HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | c16's commentslogin

Happened to me once, my computer had Little Snitch block fortinet. Got a nice message to look into why. Suddenly started calling home.

For companies with ISO-27001, Web Filtering is a control recently introduced. Protective DNS can tick few boxes and genuinely keep your network a little bit more secure (and ad free).

As an employee I'd be against it, but company device so what can you do. As the one managing the security and ISO process, it made my life a lot easier from both auditing and "why is my computer acting funny lately" perspectives. Showing my own user account having triggered an ad-based block, and the company-wide malware block rate was enough to satisfy the auditor that we has appropriate controls in place for a small company and move on to the next item.

Provided you take the stance of everyone is trusted to do their jobs, so we only need to block ads, piracy and malware lists and don't retain logging except where a block has occurred for auditing, I think it strikes a reasonable middle ground.


How did every supermarket chain around the world not jump at this and investigate?


Probably most of them had exactly zero inhouse expertise in cybersec and just pretended there’s nothing to worry about because having to worry would be inconvenient. Maybe some of them made a call to their cold chain supplier and were told that there’s nothing to worry about.


I wonder how many people working in any given supermarket chain actually know that their fridges are connected to a network at all.


Not many, probably, but their cold chain people definitely would have known. Instrumented and remote monitored cold chains are standard these days because keeping stuff refridgerated end to end is a pretty big deal.


cold chains were already standard before connected fridges, one doesn't mandate the other. The issue is most of all not remote monitoring but remote management.

I don't know what "cold chain people" are, at the scale of supermarkets you permanently have refridgeration for different groups of consumables.

I'm not aware of a scenario where e.g. fish is being shipped, and the originating logistics remotely sets the temperature of a fridge at the destination.


I bet most managers don't even know you can even connect a fridge to the internet.


have you seen how big enterprises operate? It would generally take much longer from a decision to do something to any action happening, budget approvals etc.

And for anything infosec, unfortunately people who know a lot about infosec have a habit of 'crying wolf' and talking about infosec as some kind of absolute rule that everything has to bow down to with no willingness to balance against other business risks, so probably leadership is used to ignoring the people who knew that this was a big deal and were calling for action.


Their cybersecurity departments (next to fresh produce) are all over this.

Snark aside, supermarkets are not in the tech business. The extent of their involvement is ringing their IT vendor to complain about it.


Depends. Lidl wants to be a tech company.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schwarz_Digits


It really depends on the grocery. Kroger gets a big chunk of their profits from their data stack.


I wouldn't be surprised if its their own agencies hacking these systems preemptively in order to force the issue and increase robustness against a larger multi-pronged attack.


Because most of these chaps do not read daily news related to their profession.

I’m still trying to figure out why these freezers are connected to the Internet in the first place…


Monitoring, alerting, remote diagnostics and trouble shooting.

Commercial cold chains are expensive, high value collections of equipment that even small errors at the edges can cause huge monetary losses. And grocery stores are in an extremely low margin business.


Monitoring should be in a DNZ that can talk to the otherwise “airgapped” network and push metrics out to the SaaS platform or whatever. Send a technician if something needs to be adjusted, or (only if some kind of remote access super critical) give the customer the ability to grant temp access to technicians for remote troubleshooting (but require someone to be in the facility).

None of this requires the customer to be technical, the ORM could ship the equipment with the network setup, and installation would just be connecting the DMZ device to the Internet.


The question wasn’t why these systems are setup insecurely (which has an obvious answer about cost prioritization).

Of course there are ways to setup these things securely, same with smart tvs and doorbell cameras and whatever else is getting hacked. People just have a bad time figuring out the cost benefit of all of this. And frankly we don’t know if that cost benefit has even been crossed yet, perhaps this doesn’t rate.

You yourself are engaging in cost prioritizing without adequate information. Sending a technician on site may be extremely expensive (opportunity costs and inventory risk on cold chains are wild).


> The question wasn’t why these systems are setup insecurely (which has an obvious answer about cost prioritization).

It’s not obvious to me that the secure approach is measurably more work than the insecure approach. Someone had to go out of their way to add support for remote temperature control.

> Of course there are ways to setup these things securely, same with smart tvs and doorbell cameras and whatever else is getting hacked.

No one expects a $20 IoT light switch to ship with its own network equipment, but a $600,000 to $1.5M fleet of freezers for a single grocery store can ship with its own network equipment without increasing the cost a single percentage point.

> You yourself are engaging in cost prioritizing without adequate information

I had hoped that was obvious from the question mark in my original post :) I’m asking what information reconciles this “it feels like they went out of their way to make this insecure” security posture. Responding with “they must have information you don’t have or else they wouldn’t have done it that way” is neither helpful nor logical.


I'm a bit shocked about all the uninformed arguments in the comments. Maybe I shouldn't be, because apparently basic infosec is a foreign language even to large supermarket chains and commercial freezer manufacturers. It's 2026, why the hell would you have critical systems exposed to the internet? In.. "normal" industries this wouldn't just be reasons for immediate termination, this would be a civil lawsuit for recklessly endangering company assets. I'm genuinely flabbergasted. And then it happened, AND IT HAPPENED AGAIN AFTER THREE WEEKS. Why did they not pull the plug at the very second they learned about the first incident?

I'm not happy about the attacks, but it sure seems like someone needed a wakeup call.


Those are read-only. None of those things require the ability to heat up a fridge remotely.


Diagnostics and troubleshooting are not necessarily read only. Some of these systems have temperature controls that are centrally managed for operations centers for instance.


On the other hand, 4 is a convincing back door.


Some countries are good with military hardware, and some are good with military software. e.g: Stuxnet.


> The Netherlands won't do it. Personally I think it shouldn't, as it'd set a sort of precedent that would be easy to abuse in the future

Would you stand by this statement if we did s/Netherlands/United States/g ?

It's not about the governments of today, but those of the future.


Yes.

There is imho very little to gain from such a move, and potentially a lot to lose. Disconnecting a whole society in such a way would make the total government control even easier.

Edit: typo


The USA has gone ahead and done it anyway. We shouldn't trust any government with that much power.


Can't wait for the following HN post:

> Withering, an open source Withings app written in Rust.



I guess this will lead to more companies relying on strong crypto to maintain control over their devices rather than relying on the amount of work required to reverse engineering them.



You forgot Jev. Or is that fad already over?


On web, likely. If it's in app mobile then no. Run a DNS ad blocker.


I was firmly wanting to move towards local llm, and since the Sonnet 5.5 and recent Opus speed increases, I'm putting that on hold until local inference speeds can be improved. Not sure how much juice there is to squeeze there, but I'm hopeful.


Sometimes the winning move is to not play at all. He's finding out what happens when people stop playing his game.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: