im really worried that amd is buying these silicon baked chip companies to kill it at worst or side car it at best. i really think these baked silicon chips will be a game changer id happily buy 100k worth of these chips if we could have one order of magnitude of upfront cost and power consumption in exchange for no ability to update the underlying model. a future where we arent rationing tokens is an interesting one.
their subscriptions aren’t subsidised. in fact its near 100% margin. you are getting the lowest priority access with no service level guarantee in the gaps in supply left over by api users, anthropic’s cost basis on hardware would be the same without subscriptions.
I don't know about near 100% margin, but definitely true on lowest priority access. Plenty of times I get model overloaded, outages, etc on my consumer subs, then switch to my work API sub and everything is perfectly fine.
what % of anthropic’s cost basis do you think is subscription power charges, keeping in mind they have a mix of triple net and and colossus which is capacity based pricing?
i gave up reporting scams to meta and google, you get the distinct impression they are in on it when you get a response saying “we looked into it and it was fine”
I know I'll get downvoted for this, but here goes. I was in a position to see some of the mythos derived results early. In my organization everyone was running around with their hair on fire. I asked whether or not any of the vulnerabilities mythos found were also found with existing static analysis tools. The result was blinkblink "what are static analysis tools?"
I'm not saying mythos didn't find anything new, but several people who should have known better were not using SAST/DAST tools to find potential vulnerabilities before pushing their code into the great unknown. One person I talked to said they didn't bother because GitHub automatically runs SAST tools against pull requests. I looked. Their CICD pipeline had no such tool configured. I'm pretty sure it's more appropriate to say GitHub CAN run SAST/DAST tools, if you configure it, but it won't run SAST/DAST tools by default.
This was a very small sample, but I wonder how common this type of confusion is.
this is the problem with prohibition we all know ai tools can be useless and amazing depending how you use them. bad actors aren’t constrained to the one way anthropic uses them or the way they will let us use them, so the good guys are at the mercy of their capabilities. i would feel a-lot safer with more access in more hands than the current climate. to your point about existing security tools, we all know tools make ai even more capable so we shouldnt be framing it as a replacement in either direction but again ai orchestration using these tools and improving them. look at anyps5 do we expect ai could do this from a cold prompt? or is it the pattern they deployed plus the ai capabilities that made it possible. cyber security with ai will follow the same patterns. bad guys have to win once and good guys have to win every time making the tool access asymmetric just makes that even harder. doing that under the guide of safety is mind boggling.
subscriptions use already paid for compute in the holes left by high paying api customers, its hardly subsidised, if you look at it objectively, subscriptions are 100% margin
what would help with this is to regulate and restrict frontier models from doing cyber work so that the good guys are defenceless against bad actors /s.
really disagree with western policy makers and ai company leaders on the path they are steering us, leaving us defenceless all for the sake of their obvious self serving attempts at regulatory capture.
human advancement is a function of population, instead of focusing on population decline to solve our resource problems we should focus on efficiency and technology. i am not rooting to revert to the dark ages i really struggle with this ideology of reduction that seems extremely popular. we really take for granted the fragility of human existence we exist in a pico second of reality and could and most likely will be snuffed out eventually, having our own species rooting for this outcome seems suicidal.
I'm a professional cynic and I spread the idea of "population decline to solve our resource problems" every time I have a chance; I even write dystopic science fiction with this theme. I do it not because I think it's the solution (yours is), but to jolt people in a reaction like yours. Let's build a bright future; just in our solar system there's easily enough matter and space for a trillion humans, each enjoying many acres of forest[^1].
you live in the time of human history that is objectively the safest and most comfortable that any population of humans have ever enjoyed, look inward if that cant make you happy or excited for the future
lvt is too ham fisted, what your really want to tax isinefficient land usage, eg your land is zoned for higher density or industrial etc and you fail to deploy it as such then you should pay a tax for that. this encourages investment and discourages land banking. moving that land into those who will deploy it and lower the overall cost of doing things overall
Your version would instead discourage zoning land for any productive use. Which is an issue in a democracy, where the same people being taxed elect the people who influence zoning
In a dictatorship your scheme would work, in a democracy it would just prevent even more economic activity
i agree with you that it wouldnt be perfect, but dont follow your logic? the gov designates zoning and collects the resulting taxes wouldnt it encourage in the worse case over zoning?
reply