HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | bubulux's commentslogin

I always find it fascinating to see this out in the wild. I work from coworking spaces, so I’m constantly around developers from companies of all sizes, and the difference is striking.

Some of us have moved away from IDEs and writing code entirely and work terminal-first, while others still use agents the way I did two years ago.

For example, I recently watched someone in an actual code file adding Python import statements by waiting for Copilot’s inline suggestion to kick in. It was such a bizarre thing to witness. That’s not because of the person (I don’t want to judge anyone’s way of working; if someone enjoys writing code, that’s fine by me). It’s because I remember doing exactly that years ago, and since then I’ve stopped writing code altogether.

I even remembered that I had built an extension back then, because Copilot folks never added a quick opt-out or silent mode to Copilot inline suggestions[1].

It’s strange how fast everything has changed.

[1]: https://marketplace.visualstudio.com/items?itemName=Bubulus....


And profit lines have stayed pretty much stable in the last few years for most companies.

Thats an very interesting way to think about this, never thought to invert it that way.

I allways found it interesting to look at this issue in the way the imitation game was modeled. For me I concluded, that as long as we can replicate the intution we associate with intelligence, there is not much room left to debate about "real intelligence".

The chinese room experiment I find in that sense a valuable extension, cuz the turing model more or less is a very conversational "voided of action" kind of test. The room model adds the act of translating without having the knowledge of translation.

But your take invalidates my stances here clearly. There is a possible scenario, in which we can replicate the intuition for operating a real terminal but still keeping the act of the terminal itself a "voided" sort of action by itself, cuz well, its not a real terminal, reading real files and so on...

Thank you for this, I will have to chew on that :)


And for me this is the reason we need to learn stuff several times. In layers.

The first time we both improvise and memorise. But we have no idea of the underlying complexity of the edge cases. This matches what the imitation game does.

Then we practice and practice, and we start to understand, to really understand what's going on. This is in parallel with learning to deal with the edge cases.

Then, many years later, we learn everything again, but based on an internal world model that can predict and explain just everything about what we are learning. And that's when we actually learn. After we already know it :)


thanks for the great comment! You answer is great too, I will probably think about it for the next 4 nights or more, triggering my wife's comment "why are you so weird and distant? are you cheating on me?"


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: