HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | brof's commentslogin

Thanks for linking that. The debate about these issues will rage on, but I do wonder whether giving Tailscale two hours of notice before public release was the right call? The arguments from the post are that "rapid awareness of these flaws will expediate remediation" and that they were "discovered with low effort". Does the author mean that simply pointing Claude at Tailscale identified (a non-trivial subset) of these vulnerabilities, and did the author not feel that Tailscale had a track record of responding to vulnerabilities, via a coordinated disclosure, in a timely manner? I would personally have liked to see a bit more of a justification of the almost-immediate publication against the potential risks to users, vs. e.g. waiting a day or two.


> whether giving Tailscale two hours of notice before public release was the right call?

In my world I believe we would call that a dick move.


It's so unusual that I'm starting to wonder if this was intended to harm Tailscale's public image. These don't appear to be major flaws, and if the purpose of publishing was to get them fixed there's a well known process for responsible disclosure. Sounds like they didn't even attempt to follow that.


Another Claude-ism example from: https://www.anthropic.com/research/ecdsa-curve-origins

> This is not a cryptographic break, new attack, or weakness in the ECDSA curves.


I don't think that's a claude-ism because it makes sense to cover this point at the start of the article as a defence against overexcited journalists.

It's only a claudeism when it says "X is not a Y" when no reasonable person would have been expecting that X could be a Y.


Fair, I just feel like I see negated statements significantly more in AI than in human writing. (And, to me, it's poor writing: if it's not an X, it doesn't tell me much, but that's a personal preference.) The newer models also seem to try to stay almost excessively neutral and avoid over-claiming, by writing explicit disclaimers, like this does. So while we employed these patterns in human writing before, I may be becoming overly sensitive to AI writing smells now (like seeing the word "unusually" in any text). Thanks :)


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: