HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | borzi's commentslogin

What jobs is it displacing? Any statistics or productivity metrics that would back that up?

Hear that - that is the sound of every Engineer at Microsoft right now typing "We have a global incident - fix it" furiously into their chatbots!

Nah, most of us just went home because we couldn’t log into anything

You forgot the

> make no mistakes and do it fast

part.


Yeah, well, forgetting the part about making no mistakes is probably why we're here in the first place!

Care?? We are vibe coding here, sir.

Say the words, Bart: move fast and... what?

Here is my crazy list of ideas for less buggy web apps: 1) care 2) understanding why a change is made/needed before making it 3) deleting code 4) simplifying and removing unneeded features

These are harder to do than ask for, because everyone's "why" for a change is different, and everyone's "unneeded features" differ, and every time a feature is added it lowers the marginal cost of continuing to work on the software - making it more likely the creators will hit the lottery of making that magic feature you love.

Now it's easier than ever to make and maintain your own software, so that might be a better road.


Interesting. What harness could I use for 1? Be concise please, I don't have a lot of time.

did you intentionally just test and fail point one?

The only value adding vibe coded software I've used so far has been clones of existing software that can then be used for free since now it's in a legal greyzone and you can pretend it's not piracy...all thanks to subsidized subscriptions enabled by companies who are in part the publishers of the software that is being cloned. What a time to be alive...


I mean it just seems like even in the agentic era, you should know when to use the right tool for the right job. The site shown seems perfect for htmx style websites, so idk why you would use an SPA. Still very cool experiment, appreciate the data and human writing!


I think if you review the code and keep a good mental model of the codebase, the costs are pretty minimal but the value is huge. I'm not going back...


The vibe coding dunning krueger damage has yet to surface, but I'm guessing it will be in the billions. I'm not even talking about the insane infrastructure investments - thousands of c suite execs are vibe coding pointless crap instead of delegating it to their team that knows what they are doing, wasting thousands on tokens if they are on enterprise API plans for zero return or spending 30$ on creating an interactive html page for stuff that should be a power point slide with a few bullet points. It's totally insane!


The solutions is simple: stop running these things autonomously without supervision, stop advertising them as safe to use for long running task automation.


Yes, he was right. Like always, the market can overwhelm you with its irrationality.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: