HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | bonoboTP's commentslogin

Only if you subscribe to all of them. Most people have one paid AI subscription with one provider so they have to learn ~four names for the models. Four is not good-lord-tier for the amount of value it brings. The thinking effort names are just regular English words.

Would you say the same about gadgets like oh my god I have to remember iPhone, iPad, iMac, MacBook pro and Air and Samsung Galaxy etc, or with gpus or with CPUs or with car brands or literally anything??


If you're ambitious enough, there is still plenty to think about. Design, tradeoffs, what to measure, how to express your goals, what you value and want to spend more time going deep on, what counts as good enough, etc. A lot of decisions but they are of the sort where you also need to be given enough agency and decision by your company. The type of job where you're given a spec and you just code it up is indeed going away.

Maybe at some point AI will do this better too, and at some point they will just mind read you as to what you're trying to build so you don't even have to be able to verbalize it any more, but we are far from thatm


A junior is unlikely to become a senior in your company so that argument doesn't bite. We are not 30-40 years ago when people stayed at one place for a decade or even their whole careers.

> when people stayed at one place for a decade or even their whole careers.

It sounds like you, like me and probably a lot of us here, are in startup world, but even here I would say the average career is something like four or five years. Most of my peers outside of startup world have worked at the same company the last decade.

I think we're probably the exception still.


I'm going on 11 years at a robotics entity (minus a 2 year flyer at a FAANG for better lunches and stock) because I really love the work. I interview elsewhere a couple times a year to practice talking about myself and see if the grass is really greener, but if you like what you do and you're good at it, stopping the churn is pretty refreshing.

I hope you never complain about fake job postings with no real intention to hire, given that you do fake applications with no real intention to get hired.

It is up to the interviews and interviewers to convince good candidates to join. Especially those who are in work and satisfied with their current position.

Nothing fake about these applicants, they’re just hard to convince.


People are afraid of whatever they are told to be afraid of in the media. It's not about numbers and probabilities.

Yes, you don't even have to go to the more remote or significantly developmentally behind countries. In Hungary (in Budapest, not some remote rural place), we didn't have a landline phone up until the mid-to-late 90s. It was not unheard of, just difficult to get, you'd be on the wait list for long. There were street payphones though, so we could call relatives who got theirs earlier. We went from getting our first landline to getting broadband Internet within a single decade (mid 1990s to mid 2000s).

The really interesting thing is that the big push to reduce the landline backlog in the mid-to-late 90s happened at the same time as GSM was getting popular. Lots of people in Hungary ended up getting mobile phones before they ever got off that landline waitlist!

(Also, I remember that, in the 80s and early 90s at least, the wait to get a phone installed was much shorter in many smaller towns and villages than it was in Budapest. The same sort of thing happened later with the advent of broadband. As I recall, I had 100Mbps service in a small village in the south of Hungary before it was available in Budapest - and I could only get 20Mbps at the time in the USA!)


Yes though some of the social consequences mentioned in the article did reach people who didn't have a home landline through other means, like workplace phones, payphones, phones at various establishments etc.

You're speaking in such shorthand that I have no idea how to untangle what you're actually trying to say/propose. I suppose you're saying that attested code can still be malware because malicious actors can also go through the attestation process?

Yeah, this check basically just proves that you hosted your source code on a big platform and then built the pypi package with their CI. This is not particularly strong as a trust signal. Especially since it doesn't particularly protect against compromise of access to the code repository. I worry that this is going to distract from better approaches (like reproducable builds and/or distributed review).

Is it about MBA mantras or simply folks never sticking around in one spot to have long term consequences affect them and their reputations?

Nice obituary, would have been cool if Guido had stood up for him when he was witch hunted by Python leadership...

https://chrismcdonough.substack.com/p/the-shameful-defenestr...

And after that three months suspension BS drama Tim just got back to work on Python. Saintly.

btw. made me stop having a favourite programming language.


I sometimes wonder if people-who-think-of-solving-problems-not-creating-them-defensively should secede from the rest of the Internet.

They can keep the tools & remix new ones with LLMs. The rest of us can hang out in some tiny corner talking civilly.


Post-George Floyd up until Donald Trump was elected, which is when this happened, was peak of this performative bullshit. Like renaming master to main or changing the the name of blacklists and whitelists would end racism, when all this language policing did was make people quietly resentful and was one factor in the backlash that followed.

And when Donald Trump was elected, a lot of the engine of that performative BS switched sides without missing a beat, and we went from corporate pinkwashing to corporate stinkwashing.

I was not aware of this, but I had an experience at PyCon 2022 in Utah where I realized how bad the Python community had gotten and turned me off them. I came to attend PyCon from India, I land up there with vaccination certificates and everything and they would not let me attend. Apparently, two vaccinations and a booster were not sufficient because the booster was 15 days past the 6 month mark. Also, they did not have Covishield (Astrazeneca in India) on their list. While I was rtying to explain this to them beside a wall with some 35 pronoun stickers to label yourself with, the guy would shush me if my mask even slipped a mm below the nose. While at the exact same venue, within the same lobby space, some gymnastics convention for high schoolers was going on and they had no masking nothing at all. It could not be more performative than this. I did manage to get in, but lost half a day.

I came to quote this very article. This raised my eyebrows a lot when I originally read it. I always thought that DEVELOPING A DAMN PROGRAMMING LANGUAGE is inherently apolitical and strongly meritocratic endeavor. Boy, how naive I was...

Their is a lot of sociology and other research that suggests that ironically these attempts at stricter social/etc codes mostly arise in communities that don't really need them. this happens for various reasons, but it makes intutive sense if you think about it - thoughtful, well-run communities tend to think about stuff like this. but they also, because of that, mostly don’t need it. that doesn’t mean that that it is true in every case, of course.

As someone formally trained in many forms of dispute resolution, I'll also offer many of these have a significantly misguided view of effective dispute resolution. They often think some neutral and objective group of people evaluating a situation is an effective way to resolve code of conduct disputes, in part out of a desire to be fair and objective. But these are social disputes and not contract or other legal disputes. Applying mechanisms meant for one to the other does not make a ton of sense


> They often think some neutral and objective group of people evaluating a situation is an effective way to resolve code of conduct disputes, in part out of a desire to be fair and objective.

This claim is increasingly difficult to reconcile with an awareness of who gets chosen to evaluate situations, what reasoning they present as "neutral/fair and objective", and how they go about their resolutions.


We are naive when we think, as we all do at times, that humans in our differ from the others - that we have no politics or biases and aren't affected by those things, and we form some just, meritocratic ideal.

When we find ourselvees thinking that, then we are part of the status quo - the system is designed to suit us. It's very easy to think that status quo is the entire universe; just keep doing what you're doing. Instead, to avoid perpetuating the bad aspects of the system, it's essential to curiously and closely look for its boundaries, look outside it, notice the humans out there who are not being served, who may express unhappiness.

Take them at their word; they may seem absurd, but that's your human response to someone violating norms - the norms being the status quo. Their expression may include being disruptive or unpleasant. 'Disrupt' means 'violate the status quo'; it shows you the status quo's limitations.


No, it's just entryism. It's not inevitable. Long march. I was naive once, too.

That isn’t a fair statement to make

How so? Did he stand up for him?

The 2 posting you made lead with that the sanctioning was an unfair process never explaining why

Unless you are an insider to those discussions you’d not know what was said by whom

Implications that someone should interfere with a process publicly seems wrong as well


You people seems to care a lot more than about this event that Tim Peters ever did.

It looks like you (plural) bring it up only to push your political agenda against Woke or whatever.. while people are mourning and I find it frankly distasteful and an insult to his memory.


What's distasteful is your gaslighting attempt. It's pretty clear from Tim's own writing that he did care.

> While I've since adopted a tedious posting style to avoid triggering newer people, I haven't really changed. I'm not a grim person, and still find humor (sometimes dark) in almost everything. I just keep all sense of joy bottled up now. "Joy is not professional, supportive, welcoming, or inclusive - unless it's joy at the humiliation of perceived enemies of our new Mandatory Utopia" ;-) [..] > I would like an apology from the PSF, but don't expect one, and don't insist on one. What I demand is that they improve the broken _processes_ that led to this. My case wasn't the first one of trumped-up fantasy charges, and won't be the last


Stop this "us vs. them" nonsense. This is about basic human decency, which traditionally the moderate left was supposed to have. Now in the U.S. both extremists from the left and right are horrible human beings and corporate ladder climbers.

They are not woke in the first place. The "old white men" keep their corporate positions that they pretend belong to the underprivileged. David Mertz pointed that out and was swiftly disappeared by the Python Gestapo.


I'm accustomed to seeing that the unwritten ground rules in places that would criticize me for taking Tim's side, include an absolute prohibition on the use of the phrase "you people" in any context, for any reason, because it is apparently a racist dogwhistle or something. So it's rather galling to see it used by a critic.

We are talking about a political system which seeks to introduce or apply rules that are obviously unfair on their face, justified by inconsistent theories that constantly make hypocrites of their proponents. It is bizarre and unreasonable to call opposition to this a "political agenda".

As one of the people directly involved in the situation, let me tell you: defending my friend's legacy is part of the mourning. His treatment was clearly unjust on its face and now the people who were responsible and/or supported it or advocated it are trying to blend in and pretend nothing happened, while showing no remorse whatsoever. While I'm sure the benedictions they offer now are sincere, I find it mind-boggling that it seemingly gives them no pause to consider what happened. Especially considering the timing (dying around the second anniversary of the original tension, and this being discovered around the time of his reinstatement).

Tim made an entire separate blog site to plead his case, largely motivated by my own posts[0][1]. His "mea culpa"[2] ceded only a tiny bit of ground, and even that was frankly unreasonable. (In the post[3] where he accepted blame, he was explicitly calling out an oppressive power structure, just apparently not the right one.) Not to mention that he was very clearly being "tone policed" by people acting on behalf of the very movement that popularized the term to try to shield themselves.

The insulting thing is to pretend that any reasonable person could ever have seen any merit in the claims against him after any honest inspection of the evidence (to the extent that evidence was presented: the nature of the claims made it clear what public events were being alluded to, while nothing private was ever asserted to exist).

[0]: https://zahlman.github.io/posts/an-open-letter-to-the-psf-co...

[1]: https://zahlman.github.io/posts/open-letter-psf-coc-wg-adden...

[2]: https://tim-one.github.io/psf/meaculpa

[3]: https://discuss.python.org/t/for-your-consideration-proposed...


Doesn't take a lot of care to post a one sentence comment. But I get it, it would be preferable to "you people" (to point your phrase back at you) to memory-hole those times.

I don't know.

This whole episode certainly reflects very badly on PSF SC. But it is not a very glorious event of Peters' life either, and it feels better to just not uselessly stir the pot in a way that makes Peters not look good.

(and again, to be clear, PSF SC looks even worse, but of course the point is to remember Peters for what he was, not to profit of his passing to score points against PSF SC)


Python leadership threw him under the bus and now it's all nice obituaries pretending nothing happened.

I understand people have strong feeling about that. But I think that the situation is described in a more balanced way in LWN, and, as said on https://tim-one.github.io/psf, I quote, "LWN’s account of Tim’s ban; by far the best “news” article I’ve seen, finding fault on all sides". Peters also produced https://tim-one.github.io/psf/meaculpa where he says he does not recognize the charge against him, but understands why the situation went this way and that it was partially his fault.

So, the situation is more "grey" than Peters being the victim, and I don't think it is a good idea to highlight this in a time where we should focus on Peters. It feels like stirring the pot is just instrumentalizing the event to attack the PSF SC because of unresolved feelings.

Not that this event should be forgotten or forgiven, just that it is not true that it is a mistake it was not mentioned in article talking about Peters' passing. It feels like the idea is that some people don't mention it because they know the PSF SC made a mistake but they want to hide it. But it looks to me that they don't mention it because it makes Peters not look very good on that circumstance.


> where he says he does not recognize the charge against him, but understands why the situation went this way and that it was partially his fault. So, the situation is more "grey" than Peters being the victim

Not in any meaningful sense. The post you cite basically talks about Tim's historical posting style, and then suggests that newcomers to the community might not have been exposed to it, and therefore interpreted https://discuss.python.org/t/for-your-consideration-proposed... as somehow objectionable.

But here's the thing: I first interacted with the guy in 2014 (as far as I can tell) and wasn't part of the Python Usenet/mailing list culture. I didn't really have that exposure either. And yet it was still extremely obvious to me that the post was calling out injustice and not saying anything that any reasonable person could object to. The central argument is that it's unpleasant to be repeatedly subject to training that assumes you need training to behave yourself and not engage in criminal activity, while the wealthy and powerful get away with those crimes. And people who claim to be on the side of "social justice" take offense to that.

If there's some legitimate reason why a morally good person could object to that post, I never heard it floated the entire time, nor in any of the ensuing discussion anywhere on the Internet (and people have accused me before of being unreasonably interested in that discussion). I have only heard people expect me to take it for granted that this, and similar posts, somehow reflect unreasonable behaviour. And because I legitimately can't think of any charitable way to interpret the argument, I don't speculate.

Tim looks just fine "on that circumstance". It is his interlocutors who look completely unreasonable.


> Not in any meaningful sense.

This is a very unfair way of treating the situation. What I had in mind was basically what you say after: Peters understands why the situation went this way (because newcomers were not used to his writing style) and acknowledge responsibility in not realising that earlier. His post is literally called "mea culpa". It is very very unfair to pretend that Peters does not recognise some part of responsibility in a post which contains so much language sending explicitly that message.

> But here's the thing: I first interacted ...

Well, what you say is not surprising and does not prove anything. In 99% of situations were people take offence or disagree, there are also people who are fine with it and don't understand why someone would take offence. And it would have been totally unrealistic to pretend that a style that people understood in a given period was misunderstood by 100% of the people just few years later. You were just part of the people who interpreted it as Peters intended. But I'm pretty sure that you interpreted things differently in other circumstances (after all, you were quite unfair in your interpretation of my comment).

> If there's some legitimate reason why a morally good person could object to that post, I never heard it floated the entire time

Well, in Peters post, he says "So too many now read one of my typically part-joking posts, and think I’m making fun of the topic being discussed, or belittling them. Wholly unintended, but understandable, and I first realized that yesterday. Now it makes some sense to me how someone could take offense at my message about sexual harassment."

I think that the situation is simple and that Peters understands it while you don't. The message was incorrectly interpreted. Peters says here that in this case, the reaction was understandable and make some sense. Peters ended up understanding the whole mess that was basically just miscommunication, and acknowledge that this misunderstanding was possible.

On the opposite, in your message, you are basically saying that you cannot understand that someone would misunderstand. That's your opinion, and, after all, why not. But other people have other opinion (including Peters, like it or not). I hope you don't take offence of that :)

> (and people have accused me before of being unreasonably interested in that discussion)

Hm, do you think that it is not highlighting that what "looks just fine" according to you may not be an universal truth?

> Tim looks just fine "on that circumstance". It is his interlocutors who look completely unreasonable.

As I've said, his interlocutors look very bad. You may think Peters looks "just fine", but that does not mean Peters looks just fine. You are just one person. And, I know, "everyone who disagree on this is a social justice warrior and is wrong", but you cannot force other persons who wrote articles on Peters' passing to be bad or misguided because they don't agree with you on this detail.


> Peters understands why the situation went this way (because newcomers were not used to his writing style) and acknowledge responsibility in not realising that earlier.

Well no, that isn't "basically what I said", at all. I think he conceded something that didn't make any sense to concede, because he has too much sympathy for a worldview that makes no sense on its face.

> His post is literally called "mea culpa". It is very very unfair to pretend that Peters does not recognise some part of responsibility in a post which contains so much language sending explicitly that message. … [quote of Tim's analysis]

There's no pretending involved. His post actually contains barely any language that could be characterized as "sending explicitly that message". Most of it is dedicated to describing a context that has nothing to do with blameworthiness. He makes one speculative attempt at steelmanning a position that I am beyond exhausted with. It's just that this time, none of the people supposedly holding that position appear to have tried to connect the dots themselves.

More to the point, I think the steelman is still unworkable. Tim does nothing to establish why it the misinterpretation should be reasonable except to say that people might not be used to his rhetorical style. But the post actually presented a very clear message that I think any reasonable person ought to be able to understand without needing to account for a rhetorical style that I barely even noticed. Further, that message is one that, in my understanding, broadly aligns with what the offended parties claim to believe. It's just that, after 15 or so years of dealing with people presenting similar worldviews, I can no longer take at face value that these claimed beliefs are sincere and in good faith.

Tim was accused of:

> Making light of sensitive topics like workplace sexual harassment, which could be interpreted as harassment or creating an unwelcoming environment.

"Workplace sexual harassment" is not at all the same thing as workplace sexual harassment training. There shouldn't be anything wrong with questioning the implementation of that training, and there is just objectively nothing wrong with pointing out the oddity of referring to "X training" which is about not doing X. But even if it were anything like that, it was clearly not directed at anyone, so "could be interpreted as harassment" is nonsensical.

> As I've said, his interlocutors look very bad. You may think Peters looks "just fine", but that does not mean Peters looks just fine.

No; this is objectively zero-sum because it is a direct conflict. Tim could only have possibly been wrong to the extent that people claiming him to be wrong were justified, and they were not even the tiniest bit justified.

As far as I can tell, the logical implication of seeing those words as "making light" of the training, is that one is offended by the notion that a man objects to being constantly subjected to it. To which I say: imagine if the same variety of "training" were directed at a group not deemed "privileged".


> I think he conceded something that didn't make any sense to concede

Wait, are you saying that you blame me for saying what Peters did instead of saying what you have in your mind.

You explained, and we understand, what you think. But this is NOT the reality, this is just your opinion.

We perfectly understand that, according to you, there are the "good guy" and the "bad guy" and that of course, according to you, nothing is the responsibility of the good guy. We understand that. But just grow up: people may don't agree with that. These people are not idiots, or bad guys, or whatever. It's just you being one of those idiots on the internet pretending that they have the Truth and everyone who doesn't agree (including Peters) are bad people.

> His post actually contains barely any language

FFS, the post itself is called "mea culpa". If you are just denying this reality, then there is no way that we have a conversation. What next? Will you say "in his article, Peters explain that the Great Mighty Turtle is his lord and saviour"?

> No; this is objectively zero-sum because it is a direct conflict

Usually, "seeing things in all black and white" is a sign of stupidity and people don't really argue that it's exactly what they do. Are you really pretending that "if there is a direct conflict, than one person is 100% guilty and one person is 100% innocent". Facts and facts and facts demonstrate that this is just plain wrong. A lot of conflits are just lose-lose scenarios, so they are not zero-sum. Just grow up.

I'm stopping there. You are just butthurt about this situation and got into a crusade. Good for you, but you should accept that people don't care about your rambling.


(I said you people because I replied to your comment but I was responding to multiple people at once who said similar thing)

Regardless of who was wrong or right, is it the way you would like to be eulogy written about you? bonoboTP was such a nice person and helped so many person and here is a myriad of example to prove how. All that said, I will remind everyone he had a fight a few years ago with some people he worked with and there were not very nice to him. It is just but a pebble in a long fruitful life, but it is really important I mention it here to remind everyone CoC = bad


I guess it's indeed awkward. I simply feel an annoying discrepancy. Tim was never properly rehabilitated or apologized to while alive. And now it's just like it never happened.

> to remind everyone CoC = bad

I know you're exaggerating but that's not what they were saying. You're jumping to conclusions. Ironically, it was the incorrect and bad faith interpretations that were also part of the whole saga but I think mostly how the steering council handled everything.


The 200 dollar plan weekly limit runs out in like half a day or a day if you use it heavily with subagents. The 20 dollar plan is a blip.

You can build a lot of stuff this way. You can also waste it. You need good people who will use it well and usefully.


What are you doing with your subagents? I find that as long as I use Opus at the top level and Sonnet/Haiku for subagents I generally don't run into usage limits.

We never risk using Sonnet or Haiku. Too many mistakes. The cost is worth it to always use Opus 5.5 even in the subagents.

Huh, makes you wonder why this isn't available overboard via expensive matchmaking. And if it is why doesn't he use it.

A plausible reason would be that he was not looking to have an affair but rather was actively seduced. Someone not looking to have an affair would not use a matchmaking service.

Been there done that.

lol I am not the richest man, not even close and nothing physical happened. But I once got into a parasocial relationship after decades of monogamy and no dalliances. Never planned for it, and in hindsight years later don't know what happened. And it was so cathartic.


Were you an Onlyfans whale?

No. Never spent money on these sites. Public website/app. You could read any comments publicly too. Never even DMed, until ... Some things just happen, quite randomly. No more details.

I wasn't judging, I wanted to understand how it happened, and the added context is appreciated.

I don't know of that was your case, but many times, its a series of small, seemingly justifiable yet ill-advised, boundary-pushing (yet thrilling!) decisions that lead to somewhere messy.


Sure. I understand. My comment was meant to indicate that I never thought I would get where I did. Clean until you are not. Yes. Small small things becoming an obsession.

Remember that in the above scenario the seducer is an agent for hire (or she's doing it for patriotic or other reasons), not genuinely in love with the rich exec. Honest matchmaking can't guarantee the same experience in every instance.

Obviously the exec could have paid for the same service himself, but that wouldn't be called matchmaking (and it's not what most people seek).


Good points. It's a one sided match that's in part due to acting. And person often isn't actively seeking it out consciously.

They don't go out and find your perfect match, they get someone that works for them to act like your perfect match.

This does exist as a service and is considered by many to be the oldest profession in the world.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: