HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | bluealienpie's commentslogin

Reading the comments I hear about disagreements with science. Headline and articles. I don’t hear any objections the facts or refutations. You don’t have to like Science, but stop claiming that Scientific America isn’t using it unless you have proof.


My first computer science professor claimed women could not have been the first programmers because they were physically incapable of learning something this complex. Sadly this is exactly what I expect here.


My mum (who started programming mainframes in assembler at 17, was a very early adopter of PL/1 and was expert enough that IBM purchased her annotated copy of one of their manuals for quite a sum of money back in the 70s) says many of the earliest programmers were women because programming was viewed as secretarial work. It only became more male-dominated after it started being prestigious and highly paid.


You are quoting it out of context. The article made reference to endurance events prior to this as well. Also, it’s extremely relevant to idea that Neanderthal have similar wear patterns on the bones. This article is in reference to hunter gatherer theory. Our modern concepts of male/female physical characteristics may make our judgments of prior humans inaccurate.

“ Inequity between male and female athletes is a result not of inherent biological differences between the sexes but of biases in how they are treated in sports. As an example, some endurance-running events allow the use of professional runners called pacesetters to help competitors perform their best. Men are not permitted to act as pacesetters in many women's events because of the belief that they will make the women "artificially faster," as though women were not actually doing the running themselves.”


As other people are pointing out, we are going to great rhetorical lengths to avoid the empirical fact that in almost every major event based on physical strength or endurance, men outperform women. Are suggesting that every data point from every cultural, ethnic, national background in the world is contaminated by sexist bias?


> Inequity between male and female athletes is a result not of inherent biological differences between the sexes but of biases in how they are treated in sports.

But that's obvious nonsense. It doesn't even pass a sniff test, if you know even the first thing about running. We're talking about many, many data points, all pointing in the same direction: in practice, men outperform women in distance sports [1].

To even begin to argue against this mountain of evidence, you have to resort to slippery rhetorical tactics, like this:

> As an example, some endurance-running events allow the use of professional runners called pacesetters to help competitors perform their best. Men are not permitted to act as pacesetters in many women's events because of the belief that they will make the women "artificially faster," as though women were not actually doing the running themselves.”

So, the argument being implied here (but not actually made!) is that the performance difference we see throughout the history of the marathon is due to...pace setters?

Y'all realize that the competitors can run faster than the pace setters, right?

This reminds me of the old expression: "Keep an open mind, but not so open that your brains fall out."

[1] I'm talking about distributions here. Obviously, there are going to be many women who outperform many men on an individual basis.


> men outperform women in distance sports

Boy, you sure picked the wrong category. It's women who are better at endurance events.† Men have an advantage in power events.

† Here's just 2 recent ones off the top of my head:

https://www.cnn.com/2026/07/05/us/american-solo-rowing-hawai...

https://www.womenshealthmag.com/fitness/a74192266/catherine-...


That's interesting! At the same time, your two linked articles:

> Pfendler ... after nearly a month and a half at sea ... appears to have broken both the previous women’s speed record as well as the men’s speed record

Would you say hunters keep running for 1 month to catch an antelope?

And:

> Catherine Breed, 33, didn’t look terribly exhausted ... swimming for more than 100 days ... the entire 900-mile length of the California coast

It makes sense if in ultra-ultra marathons, rowing, swimming, there's advantages to having more body fat and other female traits.

But hunting is shorter and quicker:

"Hunter-gatherers (such as the San people of the Kalahari Desert) typically pursue an antelope or kudu for 4 to 8 hours, covering a distance of roughly 10 to 30 kilometers (about 6 to 19 miles) before the animal collapses from heat exhaustion", an AI said.

(And, as the sibling comment about marathons says, then men are faster.)


It helps a lot when you don't cherry-pick data that supports your pre-existing belief.

https://runninglevel.com/running-times/marathon-times

https://swimswam.com/comparing-mens-womens-records-in-swimmi...

https://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/2052-1847-6-7

https://results.nyrr.org/event/M2025/overview (pick any year you like by changing the URL)

https://www.marathon.tokyo/en/about/past/2026/ (Same)

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-026-46032-9?fromPaywa...

The overall story is one where the difference in performance decreases with distance, but is very real.


The difference doesn't just decrease, it inverts. Where that inversion threshold exists I assume varies from sport to sport and is probably worthy of a few different doctoral dissertations.


No, it doesn't. Read the links. I'm giving you papers, and you're citing anecdotes from CNN and Women's Health.


"In summary, men’s advantage in strength tends to show over short distances, while women’s endurance appears advantageous over longer distances. The extent of these differences, however, varies by sport and by course type (LCM vs. SCM vs. SCY)."

-your link

edit: Also, look at the graphs in the swim link. The trend lines clearly show there's a distance where the difference will reach 0% and guess what happens after!


Truly, you have a talent for ignoring the mountain of evidence in front of you, to fixate on the one thing that validates your biases.

The sentence you re quoting is from a site showing an across-the-board advantage for men, which gets smaller, but does not disappear, as distances increase. Literally every graph on the page shows that men are faster, in both swimming and running events, at all distances. But somehow you managed to read past all of that to find the one sentence that kinda-sorta says what you want to hear.

Impressive.

https://swimswam.com/comparing-mens-womens-records-in-swimmi...


> advantage for men, which gets smaller, but does not disappear, as distances increase.

The study below suggest otherwise (for running, which I learned about in a different HN post, I'll defer on the swimming bit that I have no idea of or thoughts about)

"[...] women become faster than men at the most extreme distances over 195 miles long."[0]

[0] https://runrepeat.com/state-of-ultra-running


Yeah, I mentioned this in another comment. There's clearly a trend toward equalization over longer distances, but even here, you see differences in performance out to 100 miles. But there are also no error bars, so we have no idea how significant these differences are.


Is a marathon a power event?


That last mile sure feels like a power event. IYKYK


Its that final .2. First 26, not a problem.


> We're talking about many, many data points

Many of those data points are contaminated by a long tradition of sex- or gender-segregated races.

Here are a couple of interesting studies, which I assume are the ones the SciAm article is referring to, but I haven't checked.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38684111/ :

> "There is a prominent sex-based difference in athletic performance such that males outperform females by 7%-14% in races from 100 m to marathon. In ultramarathons, the difference is often much smaller, leading to speculation that females are "built" for the sport. However, data are confounded by the low number of female participants; just 10%-30% in any given race. This study compared data from two ultramarathons where males and females competed in comparable numbers. [...] In conclusion, the sex-based performance discrepancy shrinks to 1%-3% in ultramarathons when males and females compete in comparable numbers."

A key point in the above quote is "data are confounded by the low number of female participants; just 10%-30% in any given race." This calls the "many, many data points" that you mentioned into question.

Another study, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12068597/, of 56 suitable races, found that "pacing was not consistently affected by sex or age."

Re keeping an open mind, the corollary is that if you're not willing to ever question your assumptions - a.k.a. biases - you're not going to be able to update your understanding based on the facts.


There are literally thousands of female participants in marathons around the world every year, and you have to be in denial to ignore the obvious sex-based difference in performance.

For ultramarathons, in particular, the performance difference is smaller, but it still exists. The most you can claim is that at ~200 miles there's a slight average performance advantage in pace for women in specific studies.

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-026-46032-9?fromPaywa...

https://trainright.com/women-faster-than-men-ultramarathon/

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3870311/


“Y'all realize that the competitors can run faster than the pace setters, right?“

Generally they can’t - the pace setters run at a pace above typical max for the distance (but within max for the shorter distance they are running), sheltering the people they’re pacemaking for.

You want to believe things are simple, but they’re not.


> Generally they can’t - the pace setters run at a pace above typical max for the distance (but within max for the shorter distance they are running), sheltering the people they’re pacemaking for.

Come on. Think things through to the end. If it were actually true that the pace-setters could run faster than the competitors for the full marathon, then the pace-setters would win the event.

What you want to say is that the pace-setters are capable of running a faster pace than the competitors for a shorter distance. Maybe that's true (I doubt it), but it's not responsive. Pace setters are there to set a pace, like a metronome. If the competitors feel this pace is inadequate, there's absolutely nothing stopping them from running faster, or demanding a faster pace-setter.


Where did I say “for the whole marathon”? The point of pace setters is that they run shorter distances faster and then drop out. They’re given a tempo to run by the lead group, yes, and they enable that lead group to run faster by providing shelter. This is true from the 1500 upwards; look at Josh Kerr’s recent mile record, the Breaking 2 project, etc.


> Where did I say “for the whole marathon”?

You didn't, which is exactly the point. It's a critical piece of information for evaluating the truth and relevance of your argument.


It was screamingly obvious from what I wrote.


You've been posting one bad take after another and you clearly know nothing whatsoever about distance running.


> You've been posting one bad take after another and you clearly know nothing whatsoever about distance running.

I was a distance runner.


> It doesn't even pass a sniff test, if you know even the first thing about running.

And yet, it seems you do not know that the gap between men and women shrinks the longer the distances get? Also, as you are saying yourself: this is about distributions, not necessarily about the top 0.1% of the world. The article makes the claim that on average, women would perform better in ultra-endurance events, supporting their thesis that women actually did the hunting back then. You might disagree with this, but the article is more nuanced, and reducing it to the rage-bait comment above does not do it justice at all.


> And yet, it seems you do not know that the gap between men and women shrinks the longer the distances get?

So what? The gap exists. Saying that it diminishes with distance is interesting, certainly, but it's a far cry from evidence that the gender gap is due to something other than biology.

> The article makes the claim that on average, women would perform better in ultra-endurance events, supporting their thesis that women actually did the hunting back then.

This is sophistry. In reality, even on average, men are faster than women.


This far less popular than United 24 which is a propaganda outlet disguised as a news site. People believe what they want to hear.


> This far less popular than United 24 which is a propaganda outlet disguised as a news site.

What are smoking? If you bother to check, United24 clearly describes itself as "The official fundraising platform for collecting donations to support Ukraine."


And do most Americans who leave the US condemn American soldiers for murdering a million Iraqis and continuing to colonize their country? At a certain point just not engaging in these pointless wars should be enough.


Most are probably too busy dissing the health care situation


What millions bro? It's arabs killing each other that raised the death count. You guys are brain broken


Lots of Americans were against the Iraq war, and I'd think expats were particularly likely to be (and the US did not kill a million Iraqis).


It’s not high security if everyone is mandated to do it. Power consumption, energy sources, water usage for coolant, waste water treatment plan, etc.

I think the disinformation is people thinking that data centers directly use vast quantities of water. What happens is the power use stresses water supplies in local areas.

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2026/jun/08/datacenter-a...


My lobster is too buttery and delicious as well.


He also promotes transphobia. Chomsky was friends with Epstein and acquaintance of Steve Bannon. I don’t think that discredits his entire body of work, but I think we should stop promoting him when there are sources that are less problematic.


You are mixing Chomsky (the subreddit) up with Norm (the book author). Norm was friends with Chomsky but not Epstein or Bannon. I'm unaware of him having transphobic views.


Like bombing innocent people in boats for a crime that would require a trial and not be illegible for death sentence?


Eligible: qualified for

Illegible: unreadable


Which innocent people are you talking about exactly?


Were they charged and convicted with a crime? Maybe they should have been...but we'll never know now.


I think that illegally crossing a country's border, especially as part of a drug cartel's narcotics operations, tends to carry some risk


What specific border are you talking about?


Any country


Presumably they're referring to stuff like this: https://www.hrw.org/report/2026/07/21/a-dangerous-partnershi...


> documents three incidents that saw ordinary people subjected to abuses, including drone strikes, torture, and arbitrary detention. In a fourth case, a fishing boat and most of its crew went missing amid signs of another attack.

That is unfortunate.

Are you going to bother to mention the millions who have been affected by imported drugs?


Oh no drugs, good thing drug crimes come with a death sentence! Even better when it is an extrajudicial death sentence!


If you want to live somewhere suspected drug dealers get summary execution in the streets and death sentences, move to the Philippines or China. Don't try to bring that nonsense here.


If you want to live somewhere South Sudanese get about in shopping centres with machetes, car jacking, and stabbing people on the streets… Maybe don’t come to Australia.

Sooner or later, the West needs to wake up and realise that empathy for the offenders over empathy for the victims, hasn’t worked.

And that includes meth and heroin dealers.

Marijuana, meh, stupid drug anyway. But I know too many people who used weed long term and now have chronic psychosis, so yeah that ain’t great.


That's a problem with your local law enforcement failing to enforce the law. Crime has been dropping where I live almost every year I've been alive, and that's all about opportunity and jobs rather than jackbooted thugs delivering vigilante justice.


Is there any evidence they are not just blowing up random people?

Edit: i have zero faith that the us government is can, let alone is willing to, control the drug trade. This seems to be an excuse to exercise violent control of the americas as an end unto itself. This is in line with our intervention in venezuela, our bullying cuba, our constant abuse of the phrase "monroe doctrine".


You, knowing absolutely nothing about the inner workings of the counter-narcotics operations, assert that there is no evidence that those people are drug runners, based only on ignorance of the facts, yet you are also apparently perfectly content to not provide any evidence to the contrary (that they are indeed systematically killing "random people"), despite the fact that such a claim is completely absurd, and you don't see any contradiction?


> knowing absolutely nothing about the inner workings of the counter-narcotics operations, assert that there is no evidence that those people are drug runners

Well, he's correct that there is no evidence known to him, so there IS no evidence known to him.

To my knowledge, the administration has not released any evidence, only claims: "We know they are drug smugglers and we have evidence that we will not show you."


So there are drug smugglers, but the US isn't targeting them, they're targeting random boats, and the US is doing this for some reason which is apparently clear to OP but hasn't been made clear to us, and that somehow is the simplest explanation for what's going on, despite being entirely absurd?


Drug smugglers.

We’ve devolved from the proverbial slap on the wrist to the practice of a pat on the back and we’ll wishes.

Anything short of that is viewed as a a crime against humanity.


I think it's a reference to the US bombing small boats in the caribbean and eastern pacific with claims that they were drug smugglers.


Legal definition reminder:

Innocent until proven guilty.

Relevance:

Legal protection in place to protect innocent people. Like you and your family.


The issue is that the US perceives poverty as personal issue rather than public issue. If my neighbor has no housing their likelihood of becoming addicted is way higher than if we simply gave them a house to live in, and far cheaper than constantly policing them.


I think is a very unfair allegation to make against homeless people. Most are not drug addicts.

Drug addicts, however, have a hard time holding on to a house, apartment, etc and will often decide to exchange a stable living situation for another drug fix.

Giving houses to drug addicts means: - a non drug addict doesn’t get to get that house - the drug addict now has a house to use drugs in, not take care of, and generally destroy

The answer is for drug addicts to be placed in a rehab program until they aren’t an addict anymore.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: