HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | blub's commentslogin

Having a team implies that one was a manager or in a similar role.

These roles are nothing like a technical specialist. It doesn’t hurt to know a few things about the general technical details, but a manager or PO getting involved into technical decisions or being too deep in the code is generally an anti-pattern.

Not comparable with a sloperator. The sloperator is ultimately responsible for what their agents spit out. If something bad happens and the law comes looking, it’s their ass on the line. A sloperator will have to set up and manage some review or QA process by themselves. They will occasionally have to look at code, even if this goes against the entire raison d’être of the sloperator and maybe fix it or ask their minions to.

The “yer a manager Harry!” cope needs to be put to pasture. No company thinks that these people are an actual manager or actually managing anything. They’re still ICs.


The subject of the thread is a competition of skill with rules.

This is the second time that I had to read about your off-topic personal projects where it’s utterly irrelevant that you use AI or not. Add an off-topic tag to your messages at least.


Understood. No need to be rude about it. I will ensure that all my post when I try and relate are marked accordingly. VAV VGX.


This profession really needs to be shaken up by regulators.

Releasing something to customers which hasn’t been reviewed by any human is gross negligence.


You want to regulate an industry 90% of whose output is just a bunch non-critical CRUD apps? You haven’t thought out the macroeconomics of that, you’d go hungry faster than you’re being obsoleted in the age of AI


What makes you think people aren't "reviewing" what they ship to customers just because they don't read the code? If the testing goes well that may be all the "review" required.


https://i.imgur.com/HvzIZ6v.png

This is "Preview" — Apple's document viewer on macOS 27. Do you think the testing went well?


Personally if I had to look back at the rate of bugs of a similar severity my own company produced I think it was higher pre-llm coding and testing.


To be fair, while the threads don’t show it, majority of companies that survive by processing payments. Shopify, Airlines, Rental Car companies, Banks, etc. are still doing and generally can prove at anytime 2 party review is happening on any PCI related code. It’s just that many people don’t work on that, and regulating a new feature for the ESPN Fantasy Football service seems silly.


If the market falls apart there is no solution except learning another job which isn’t (yet) doable by AI.


> except learning another job which isn’t (yet) doable by AI.

Why? Why are jobs necessary? Who needs to have them? Should we pay people to be stopgaps/just in case jobs in case the machine fails (probably?) -- who organizes that? Do we have a human economy and AI economy? How to keep them decoupled? Does this mean stamping provenance (who made what onto what?) should be a core of the future? Right now? What does that look like? Are there other things we can do to ensure we get the Banks future and not a shittier one? Is the Banks future a good one? Is disempowerment a real concern? If so what do we do about it? Human reserves? Zoos?

I do not have answers, but I know the questions are vastly more interesting than "what job will the AI not be able to do" wtf PLEASE


I also tend to believe that the market for SW developers will shrink. In Europe, the AI revolution is hitting at the same time as an economic crisis triggered by expensive energy which is in turn making companies cut costs / local positions and outsource to cheap locations.

The idea that more SW will be built is likely correct, but it might not be a well-paying job or be done in Europe at all.


“ being more distrusting of browser-based apps than native binaries, especially with an undue focus on the risk of the app exfiltrating your data over the network”

Not a logical error. A notarized or app store app can be blocked from accessing the network so there is no data exfiltration happening. The malware risk is negligible thanks to Apple’s vetting.



“It's much simpler to update a webpage than force every user to update their app when something needs to change”

That much is true, but I consider this misfeature a clear disadvantage for the customers using the app, which are at the mercy of the developer. The days of updates being something positive are long gone. Nowadays they’re a mix of UI redesigns requiring relearning stuff, spyware, unwanted bloat, bugs and a couple of actually useful things thrown in.


Too many comments about AI read like inadvertent admissions of incompetence or dysfunctional projects.

Couple of WTFs that come to mind:

* How many bugs did one have per commit, that commits have to noticeably grow in order to not have those bugs in the first place?

* How does one even do software engineering if the (best) developers can’t reason about the code?


Code debt.

Software engineering is possible but largely a myth in practice.


Jesus man take some responsibility.


Lol sure dude.


The whole point of having teachers is to give intellectually developing and still vulnerable children the best possible support they could have from a human which is ideally interested in their well-being, being responsible and in doing a good job.

Replacing that with AI is the kind of SV-stupid which starts making sense after the educational system was hollowed out for profit reasons and is failing. The human in that system is just checking in and DGAF.


A little cheating here, a bit of fraud there and before one knows it, one is CEO of some AI company.

The revealing thing is how the cheating is seen as normal and how the other people are considered out of touch or wrong.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: