HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | binaryturtle's commentslogin

I always found it odd that there's only one single origin of life point or even just a single common ancestor considered in history. Shouldn't entirely new life develop all the time on earth? I mean the ingredients and building blocks are still there, the environmental situation still should work out, like availability of water, temperatures, etc. We should see a constant emergence of new life all the time. Why would that process stop, just because some other life already exists? Maybe we just can't detect this, because whatever new life happens to appear —more or less— resembles life that's already there.


I'd imagine the bar for becoming new life is much higher now, because it requires finding a niche that isn't already filled by an existing organism or requires being immediately competitive with existing life.


They're pretty sure the primordial environment was a hydrothermal vent in an anoxic high phosphorus soda lake with methane, ammonia, and UV exposure. Nowadays those lakes don't have the methane and ammonia, so that environment isn't there anymore. https://www.science.org/content/article/unusual-soda-lakes-m...

The surfaces of clay particles in these lakes have been dubbed "the primordial sandwich".

The early protocells were 'alive', they were self-replicating, but they required nutrients and metabolic processes that only existed near mineral surfaces and would starve if they drifted away. They had to evolve new enzymes to become 'free-living'.

So it looks like the LUCA was one of these early protocells with an incomplete metabolism.


> Shouldn't entirely new life develop all the time on earth?

It's possible OoL requires some exponentially unlikely step. We wouldn't realize that because of observer selection: had the step not occurred, we wouldn't be here to be thinking about it. There's a huge complexity gap between the stuff produced in OoL experiments and the simplest known life.

It's also possible OoL requires conditions that no longer exist on Earth, or that only existed in the early Earth (or wherever life got started in the Solar System). For example, if it depended on the existence of short lived radioactive isotopes or free ammonia.


Because the moment life first appears, it multiplies and fills all easily available niches, and any new life is outcompeted by the more evolved pre-existing organisms.


I may be a dumb layman, but that argument seems too tidy and absolute to me - wouldn’t it suggest, for example, that viruses could never appear because they’d be outcompeted by more advanced bacteria? Earth seems to have room for an incredible diversity of types of life.


Viruses are not newly appearing forms of life, they are co-depending on the already present forms of life and they reuse some of their machinery. Viruses are the opposite of starting from zero, they start from a functional organism and stop existing if the base organism gets extinct. However, reading other answers, it seems the great oxygenation event is an even stronger argument against basic life appearing again. They would get oxidised and die.


Nope. It would suggest that new viruses could not spontaneously appear from abiotic matter, because they'd be outcompeted by existing viruses. Which may well be true.

We don't know where exactly viruses came from, but one of the leading theories is actually that they are the descendants of bacteria which outcompeted other bacteria. When a parasitic bacterium sheds more and more of its own metabolic capabilities, because it's more efficient to steal those abilities from its host cell, it evolves in a way that looks more and more like a virus.

"More evolved" or "more advanced" in this case doesn't mean "bigger" or "more complex". You can say viruses are equally evolved as bacteria, meaning they've spent equally long being optimized for their ecological niche.


>ike availability of water, temperatures, etc. We should see a constant emergence of new life all the time. Why would that process stop,

Anything that's so agreeable to abiogenesis that life might spontaneously manifest, is actually pretty tasty for things already alive. They swoop in and eat it before it gets started. So, I suspect that even what the article says isn't that they both arose in the same place, but in different places separated by distance, time, and/or environmental barriers.


But the enviroments that have the easy/free energy that would give rise to life is almost always contaminated with life competing for and consuming that chemical energy.


It has to survive though in the sense that it has to live long enough for us to see it. If we think of life as "spontaneously" (roughly speaking) emerging from the right conditions reasonably rarely, it has to outcompete other existing life for some time. And then there's the chance that we might not recognize it as "new" at all.


A step further "novel" life (hence still simpler) made from the same raw materials as existing life would look exactly like decomposing existing life and be routinely scavenged for material.


> Shouldn't entirely new life develop all the time on earth?

The fact that it doesn't is a pretty simple solution to the Fermi Paradox.


It's probably unrelated to the Fermi Paradox. Life doesn't develop all the time on Earth largely because it's already developed. The conditions for that development are largely gone now, plus existing life easily outcompetes new life in general. This tells us nothing about the probability of the development of new life in an environment that doesn't already have life.


The ingredients and building blocks aren’t there in the same way. Because life formed, those early ingredients are now transformed, as is the environment. This blocks new life of the type that formed 4 billion years ago from forming again.

Indeed, all species branch out from that one universal common ancestor that was the first free living successful cell.

Put another way: forming life isn’t easy at all. And once it forms it changes conditions to suit its continuation, not to allow new life to form.


Life is vastly faster than random chance at producing more life. So living things go fill niches faster than random chance can use those niches to produce new life.


The building blocks will be immediately consumed by existing life. And that's just one way in which the world is radically different from the one in which life arose.

And life may have arisen from a very low probability set of circumstances ... there's no reason to expect it to be happening all the time.


> Maybe we just can't detect this

Probably this. How would we know what such 'proto-life' (perhaps even just some self-replicating soup of chemicals, no cell wall) would look like? Where to find it? How rare its occurence? Etc etc.

Scientists might not even recognise it if happened right in front of them.

I'd put my money on coming up with a more general definition of "life", and then looking for short(est) pathways from "soup of random chemicals" to "something in there that replicates (parts of) itself".

Doesn't need to look like life as we know it, as long as some elements of "self-organising structures, something being replicated" are there.


Different word, same stupid concept.

Also it would be one human "species", not "race".


I personally also block access by web browsers to non-standard ports (aka not :80 or :443) via an app firewall (Little Snitch here). In this case it would have warned me when the compromised script would have called home to that endpoint on the non-standard port.

Gotta tackle such issues at different places all at once for sure. It's like wearing 5 digital condoms at once. Too bad there's still some leakage somewhere for sure. B)


I never upgraded beyond the PS2 (and I was a heavy console gamer back in the days), because all the "needs network", "needs account", "needs certificate to be valid", etc. stuff is entirely scaring me off investing my money in any of that.

Now, my motto is: if I can't run it safely in an emulator and download the files from some "abandoned wares" site then I don't care. And I have zero moral problems with that.


I never really got into the 3D pinballs, for some reason those are less fun, maybe because visually they are harder to read?

I always preferred the "2D" pinballs, with Pinball Dreams and Slam Tilt my two favourites. I still play those from time to time.


This is actually a web port of Space Cadet for Win 9x which has sort of a prerendered 3d look but is still basically a 2d table, as opposed to stuff like Pinball Arcade or the FX compilations by Zen.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Full_Tilt!_Pinball#Space_Cadet


I also liked a lot pinball illusions, it had great music, graphics and gameplay. Given that it was created by Dice, the studio that years later created the Battlefield franchise


Stupid question: wouldn't a simple comparison with the body(parts) from the inappropriate pictures sent to the girl have helped the innocent guy? I mean those thingies all look different, no, like some sort of "fingerprint"?


Any number of things could have acquitted this man, including that. His lawyer, the judge, the prosecutors, the police and anyone else involved at any stage of this case need to be looked at very carefully and hard decisions should be made about whether it's appropriate for them to be licensed to perform whatever duties they were performing in the course of it.


They should all be required to serve the sentence themselves.


More importantly all the other cases they have been involved in need to be re-examined to find out what else they fucked up.


The prosecution certainly could have done a comparison, but it seems they just went with the matching username and figured it was a slam-dunk (which it turned out to be). It's very possible the defense was never even made aware of those photos, and thus had no recourse for challenging them.


I don't think it would matter - the crime is sending images, not necessarily sending images of you. Entirely plausible a perp might use a random image they found online rather than a genuine personal photo for a multitude of reasons.

Terrible luck and a terrible legal defence. The stuff of nightmares!


Of course it would matter as it casts doubt on the evidence.


410 and a "Sec-Fetch-Mode:" string in the response body. I guess it thinks I'm a bot? Thanks!

Nothing to read, nothing to see, I move along. (Yikes, the modern web sucks!)


Real browsers send it. [1] Some of the reader apps do not. Most bots aside from those utilizing Chrome Headless do not.

People can see a few headers here [2]

[1] - https://caniuse.com/?search=sec-fetch-mode

[2] - https://nochan.net/.env


I didn't even make it that far, I got PR_END_OF_FILE_ERROR which indicates it couldn't even get past the tls handshake.


I mean that just might be the dying gasp of a puddle of scorched fibreglass and boiling copper where the server used to be.


Mostly harmless(c)

    load average: 0.00, 0.01, 0.00


There's a survey link. Not sure it works as Cloudflare blocks me from accessing it. Oh the irony, having my opinion as EU citizen about an EU issue blocked by some silly US company.

I want some birds too!


Share a screenshot of the block?


It's the typical Cloudflare error where it tells you "Your browser sucks", not sure what a screenshot would help. :)


An error that shows Cloudflare's logo might not be a Cloudflare error but a website who has configured to block you. A screenshots shows what it might be.


I may have missed one by looking at this huge dump, but NONE of the "buttons" I saw there actually looked/felt like a button. Something I can feel that I press it down and it gives proper visual feedback, like a little 3D effect.

I'm old-school. :)


You might like this: https://nielssp.dk/guis/buttons


I really enjoyed Motif and the general flat clean look that came with eg TWM and co. I do have a soft spot for the candy Mac styles, and win2k is still my favorite windows release


Ooh, nice! This very much appeals to the historian and former GUI developer in me.

Update: The Pixel Perfect checkbox makes a noticeable difference in appearance. I presume this is because older systems were developed before the advent of anti-aliasing, and were designed pixel by pixel.


Oh wow, that was so cathartic. Thank you for sharing.


A few really nice buttons there, indeed. :)


Ubuntu 2020 wins, only one dark themed


Dark themes are for people who can't lower their screen brightness.


So interesting to see the contrast between OSX and Windows in 2001.

No wonder OSX felt like the future.

I miss the future.


For me the 2001 OSX looks wishy washy and does not have a professional look.


Conversely, I want those old candy Aqua buttons back. They were kitschy, but I loved them.

I'd say the same for the scrollbars, but these days I'd settle for reverting to them being visible at all times.


I believe in the KDE / Magic User Interface way, users should decide what they want a button or a checkbox etc. to look like, and then everything should conform to that.

And if you really wanted to, maybe made some concessions, and were clever about it, you could maybe find a way so that users define shapes and functionality and a default light/dark color scheme, but applications could still use the "user style" with their own color scheme, and allow the user to switch between that and the user defined colors.

It would also have the side effect of ejecting the people who just change things to make their mark. There is no more mark to make! Except making the "style configurator" for the user better, collaborating on expanding the protocol shared between it and websites/applications. You can invent a new type of button, put it on the pile, and hope it becomes one of the higher rated ones that gets downloaded and used a lot, on any OS, in any application or website. That will be a lot less interesting for hack frauds, and software interfaces can finally become awesome and then just better from there.


For me, Windows 3.x era buttons are the pinnacle of buttons.


What, no BeOS?! :)


Does Haiku count ?


I have always felt that the button in the last couple version of Windows was a bit off. This page confirms it: Old school buttons used to stay in a "selected" state after being pressed, but that was not implemented in Windows 8's new UI.


Awesome, the Haiku one is my favorite


Indeed, 2000s are my fav globally


KDE 3.1 *chef's kiss*


GUI design, just like music and film, peaked when I was about 15.


I unironically prefer the UI of old Bootstrap:

https://getbootstrap.com/1.0.0/

They may have peaked with 2.0:

https://getbootstrap.com/2.0.2/


Wow I totally forgot how great 2 was, how did we regressed from that? The buttons are so satisfying


I want to eat those buttons.


I love those versions, they were really innovative at the time.


I see a couple that look like buttons to me, like a yellow Donate button and a green Learn More button.

I agree that most of the other ones don’t look very button like to me either. But even so I would probably understand that most of them were buttons when I saw them in context on a page.

The flat style has been around for a while now, so I’ve gotten used to it even though when I started using computers it was on Windows 95 with the grey rectangular buttons with shaded sides that give them the “3d effect”.

And even flat style buttons often have changes when you hover and click, but it seems that they didn’t copy that part on this button collection page.


They didn't copy any hold/hover states which is too bad, those are an integral part of a button IMO


Exactly, and more broadly ALL of them are a variation of bgcolor + border-radius + padding + font (type, size). No funky shape, borders, FX, 3D / relief or even shadow, pixels... Every single one is a flat, round borders.


It sounds like you're talking about the "gloss" era with "juicy" buttons, which some people are retroactively referring to as Frutiger Aero. Yes, things definitely look more 3D in that design. It's currently considered out of mainstream fashion, which explains the lack. Will it resurge?


Earlier era for me actually. I'm a 90s person. :)


Also more generally called skeuomorphism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skeuomorph


Enter "Lickable Pixels" -- the phrase that described the Aqua era.

Introducing Mac OS X's Aqua interface, Steve Jobs said at Macworld in January 2000: "We made the buttons on the screen look so good you'll want to lick them."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aqua_(user_interface)



Nice! That Windows 95/98 GUI design wasn't the most beautiful ever made, but it was quite usable. You never had trouble telling what was what.


Apple and Jony Ive killed skeuomorph design a long time ago.


Web 2.0 was fun :-)


This is a big part of why I am in love in Posthog's design (though personally I have little belief in my own current ability to replicate it)


I suspect the best buttons - like the best music - are those from one's youth


I wonder how many people may have gotten an actual heart infarct because of that. There may be a person out there that may be dead as a result.

It's entirely irresponsible of Amazon to even display such values to the user.


Reminds me of the time a Robinhood user killed themselves after Robinhood erroneously showed their account balance at -$730k.

https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-55990461


In that case, they settled with Robinhood and FINRA fined Robinhood 70 million dollars.

https://edition.cnn.com/2021/07/01/business/robinhood-lawsui...


"They" being the family; Robinhood couldn't settle with the guy who was wronged because he, ya know, killed himself first


Ah, there'll be something in the TOS absolving them of responsibility.


Maybe AWS is also “for entertainment purposes only”

https://techcrunch.com/2026/04/05/copilot-is-for-entertainme...


Well... That depends on the country jurisdiction. And any ToS is bounded by law and can be questioned.


I legit had a small panic attack due to this.

I'm not a devops but we are running some s3 buckets. When I saw the number I couldn't even comprehend and thought we had been hacked.

I feel like this is such a bad mistake from AWS and we will never be compensated for it.

Put me off having anything on AWS from now on.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: