HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | bgun's commentslogin

So.. approximately when someone at the company realized something fishy was going on with Jensen, but before they got caught? Obviously this is conjecture but your reply isn’t the slam dunk you seem to think it is.

I think it's a stretch to say 'Gets caught' was conspicuously timed with this action.

I quoted a line from an article that seemed relevant. I would appreciate you not projecting your opinion of what I thought about it onto me.


I’m a little confused by the description of that interaction - why wouldn’t you take the SD card? Did they want to charge extra for it? Seems like even a 10 year old map (plus apparently other functionality) is something you’d want.

In any case, glad it took you on the wild goose chase that led to the write up!


Because OP refused to believe that he, a technically literate person, wouldn’t be able to find the correct settings page and assumed that the previous owner was just not the brightest bulb. Which, in my opinion, is reasonable, because a reasonable person wouldn’t expect infotainment systems settings being only available with maps SD card.

This is the kind of trap that I constantly fall for no matter how much I try to avoid it. "Surely it can't work that way" and yet it does.

By this article’s definition, any editorial - including TFA itself - is “deception”.

All documentaries editorialize. Saying so is neither particularly novel or interesting. The film also doesn’t attempt to render a guilty verdict - that was already done in a court of law and EH is in prison.

It’s fine to dislike the film, but the honest thing to do would just be to say so rather than to claim some kind of moral high ground.


Yeah, because your Honda is totally using comparable technology. /s


Ioniq is not a Honda..


I do not drive a Honda. This was about something else.


Your point seems to reduce to “bad writing=bad thinking, better writing=better thinking” which to me seems to support the original point, not refute it.


I’m not going to elevate memeing to thinking, no. If that’s the bar then using ai is just as much thinking as writing and the whole “writing is thinking” meme is pointless.


What is "memeing" in this context? From what I can see, it's just someone claiming something "seems" like a meme to them because it's repeated a lot. Is the idea that getting enough sleep is healthy also a "meme"? That Alzheimer and cancer suck and have no upsides? What's the actual criticism here, feeling left behind on an insight many other people already attained?


> What's the actual criticism here

I stated this in an earlier post: "Probably what matters more is the specific process."

> Is the idea that getting enough sleep is healthy also a "meme"?

Yes actually.

> That Alzheimer and cancer suck and have no upsides?

Maybe? I don't think that qualifies, It's more like an emotional response to a disease.

> What is "memeing" in this context?

Repeating memes. In this case "writing is thinking" is a meme in the culturally transmitted idea sense. I don't think it qualifies as thinking because it's just the mechanical propagation of those memes through the culture. So if we're going to classify that and all other stuff one writes down as thought and elevate it, I don't see why prompting an AI isn't among that.


And how do memes get propagated "mechanically"? People say things like "the sky is blue" or that cancer sucks because they happen to agree, not because they heard it and just repeat whatever they heard all the time. Accusing someone of parroting something, instead of actually meaning it, is such a cop-out.

I mean sure, "writing is thinking" is shortening something, like "sharing is caring" does. Of course different things are not the same things. But it's not something people just "repeat", and when you ask them why they say it, they can't give you anything. Maybe that's why you're neither asking (why they say that, what they mean etc.) nor telling (in what way you disagree, what you think instead etc.).

> So if we're going to classify that and all other stuff one writes down as thought and elevate it, I don't see why prompting an AI isn't among that.

(IMO) of course it is, who said otherwise? Just the output isn't.


I'm reminded of that Hitchens quip about interpreting ad hominem arguments as a tacit concession that you've made a good point. If they had a more substantive rebuttal then they would have led with that instead.

The memeing accusation wasn't technically an ad hominem, but it does at least live on that side of town.


Just because something is illegal doesn’t mean it will be prosecuted, right? If I break into my friend’s house in the middle of the night and smash some stuff, and later we both acknowledge that it happened, that it was regrettable, but never press charges, then should state resources be tasked with justice?

Once companies start harming each other in undesirable ways, as opposed to proverbially toilet-papering each others’ lawns, meaningful prosecution will happen in earnest.


At least random hackers seem to have codes of ethics.


Well, they'd presumably be different hackers than the ones who work on Linux. We don't know what would motivate them. Maybe they'll do it because they consider the next stage of man's intellectual evolution to be too important to leave up to a couple of American companies and the Trump administration. Maybe they'll do it for the proverbial lulz.


“Ketchup manufacturer recommends ketchup be included in every dish, citing child safety concerns.”


If your point is that we should regulate AI as least as strictly as industrial vehicles, I agree.


Afaik anyone can buy a bulldozer. Whether or not you are licensed to operate it is a different story, but there's nothing stopping you short of your conscience.


Licensed or not, you're fully liable for any damage you do with it. And possibly go to prison. I'd like to see crime committed by AI held to the same standards as crimes committed with any other tool.


I don't think the law makes a distinction over what tool you use to commit a crime.

The problem with AI is that the AI might do something that would constitute a crime (eg. attempting to land malicious code via a PR), but the general legal standard to convict a person of a crime is malicious intent (or sometimes negligence).

If the human user instructs the AI to do X and the AI does X by committing crimes in the process, the prosecution usually has to prove the human intended this to happen (or is somehow criminally negligent). For traditional tools, the user has much greater control over the tool so the intention can be more easily deduced from the results. For AI, at least for now, results can be wild. I don't think the legal system is prepared to put people in prison because their AI randomly ran amok after being given an innocuous prompt. This is analogous to holding a driver criminally liable for harming people due to a serious malfunction of the vehicle.

If anything, I think more liability should be imposed on AI developers.


I'd assume that after some number of news stories about AI agents committing crimes, the threshold for criminal negligence should be easy to reach for anyone who doesn't take proper precautions

A lot of negligence is of the "the last 30 times nothing went wrong" type, and the dangers are increasingly well known


I generally agree. But the field is evolving too fast for the legal system.

I'd imagine regulation and enforcement will come when things are starting to settle down.

The analogies with vehicles being inherently dangerous and require extra regulation are apt, because safety measures (eg. speed limits, seat belts, comprehensive road safety rules etc.) were implemented bit by bit, but way after the cars had been invented...


> I don't think the law makes a distinction over what tool you use to commit a crime.

The law might not, but enforcement definitely does. Crimes committed through a corporation are often ignored.


Yeah. Though, this is a broader issue of capitalism giving corporations preferential treatment...


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: