HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | beedeebeedee's commentslogin

“ When Big Tech and the broligarchy are gone, entrepreneurs will finally have a chance to build new businesses whose success doesn’t rely on commodifying their users’ attention, monetizing their data, exploiting workers, enshittifying their own products, and degrading the natural environment.”

There’s a lot of reasons for this community to want consequences for the big tech oligarchs that are more than a slap on the wrist. The benefits of holding them to account are not just for environmentalists, social justice activists or rural people against data centers and inflation; the big tech oligarchs have stifled the emergence of new companies and entrepreneurs. That’s something even VC people should want to see changed.


This. They're literally attempting regulatory capture of the GLOBAL market for this stuff. It doesn't get more unfair and against the spirit of free trade and equal opportunity.

You seem to be overlooking the fact that Hegseth and other leaders in the US military and government have said that this is the end times or “armageddon”

https://www.military.com/daily-news/2026/03/06/lawmakers-wan...

(There are more instances, which you can find searching)


I can confirm this. I am not proud of it because, not only does it break Wikipedia policy but was unethical and done for an unethical person, but one of the first tasks I was given at my first salaried job was to make a wikipedia page for the boss (he said that his publicist told him to get one done). The safeguards at Wikipedia almost held, but he had me battle the editors for weeks until it finally got done. I left a couple months later because he kept doing (and asking me do) unethical things, and wish I had the wisdom and courage then to have said no and quit on day one.


You might consider revisiting this on Wikipedia. It's probably not too late to remove the boss's promotional page.


How about, instead of removing it, this primary source piece of character witness story is added :-)


Indeed, it’s always good to have unproven and unprovable anecdotes added to Wikipedia. Even better if there’s no source or names involved.


My company has an entire PR team to get our execs in 30 under 30 and 40 under 40 as well as update their wiki pages!


The only thing I’ve been watching lately are Soviet films on youtube. Mosfilms and Gorky films have their full catalogs on there. Sergei Bondarchuk’s films are deeply moving. Seventeen Moments from Spring is incredible as well- the Soviet answer to James Bond. For some reason it feels deeply refreshing to watch these films instead of what the US has been producing.


There are even callbacks to Seventeen Moments of Spring in children's cartoons like Treasure Island.


When art offers one of the only limited pressure valves for totalitarianism out gets embued with deeper meaning I suppose?


All art in the Soviet Union was state-manipulated propaganda. At least all of it that was in public venues such as theatre and television.


That is true to an extent, but Soviet films are not all the same. Great artists like Bondarchuk were able to still tell compelling stories despite the political constraints of his time. Even Seventeen Moments of Spring, which was commissioned to influence the Soviet public to have a more positive view of the KGB, managed to tell a meaningful and very human story. Tarkovsky’s Sci-Fi films are also great and can hardly be said to be state propaganda even if they were considered acceptable enough to be made public. Many Soviet films are heavy handed and wooden propaganda movies (like the ones by Ozerov), but not all.


> Great artists like Bondarchuk were able to still tell compelling stories despite the political constraints of his time

This might well be true, and it fits in with the claim that constraints or limits can lead to more creative outcomes (currently on the HN front page[1]), but everything still had to pass the state censor's approval.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50225663


[flagged]

> You do not know what you are talking about.

It breaks the site guidelines to attack others like this, regardless of how wrong they are are you feel they are. This is in the site guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html. If you could please review them and stick to the rules when posting, we'd appreciate it.


> Soviet Union was one of last countries with true art.

There was no art, only pro-government communist propaganda. In Soviet Union there was even popular saying regardless culture, that Stalin took over a Russia of Tolstoy, Dostoevsky, and Chekhov, and left it with the Union of Soviet Writers.


> There was no art, only pro-government communist propaganda

You’re conflating the Stalinist period with the whole history of the USSR.


Before there was Lenin, after there was Khrushchev, both explicitly considered art that is not pro-government communist propaganda as thing that should not exist.


By that standard, you would then need to conclude that all medieval artworks and renaissance artworks were not art but Catholic or royal propaganda.


During the medieval period and the Renaissance you totally could do art that had nothing to do with church and royals. In the Soviet Union you could not.

There is a famous quote of the judge on the Brodsky trial (1964): "Who have appointed you to be a Poet?". Аfter he sad that Soviet Government did no appointed him to be a Poet, he was sent in the gulag for 5 years. That is how "art" worked in the USSR.


The guilds regulated art in cities, and most of it was commissioned by the church or aristocracy. The Soviet Union might have been more severe but, like in the Soviet Union, you would have to do it privately unless you had support of the guilds, aristocracy or church. The comparison still holds.


Cash app and all of the organizations that stored but did not secure her social security number and other information should be liable, not her


Yeah, I've seen them going around. The last one I saw at Jackson Square looked like the safety driver was driving. This is probably the worse urban environment for Waymo to be. I'm not sure how they're going to handle the roads or the people dancing in the streets (as well as mules, pedicabs, wacky bikes, scooters, drunk people and all of the wonderful chaos). Not looking forward to them becoming operational here.


That’s only if you care about nation states.


Viruses and bacteria don't care about nation states


One silver-lining of all of these debates is that we are collectively engaging in philosophy. That is awesome and I hope this shifts our culture to start rewarding deep reflection that is not immediately marketable.


> everyone already has their own poor population to deal with

Yikes, that is quite the dehumanizing framing

Edit: A person commented "why?" before deleting their comment, which I had started responding to. I still want to give my response:

Because an enlightened government is for the people (and an unenlightened government is not worth having). The purpose of a government is to care for the welfare of the people, not to be the securer of private wealth for the wealthy. The above comment frames it as "dealing with" an undesirable population. That population is the people, and it is a perversion to think otherwise.


How? It seems realistic, not brutal (though reality is a bit brutal).

Edit: Your update seems unrelated. I can't connect it to what the parent said. They said it's hard to accept the poor of other nations when you are busy supporting your own poor, and you responded as if they said we should not support even our own poor, in favor of supporting the wealthy. There's no connection there.


> They said it's hard to accept the poor of other nations when you are busy supporting your own poor

The original comment did not say what you claim.

The original comment framed it as “dealing with” the poor population. That is bad framing. The role of government is to take care of the people, not to “deal with” them. That framing is important because the people are not a problem to be dealt with. They are to be protected and cared for. The framing is important because it dictates what is accepted and what gets done.


Poor people are a problem, they eat through resources without replenishing them, how you deal with them is another thing. Apparently you think dealing with them means something nefarious, which speaks more about you to be honest.

Poor people should be enabled to have the tools to go and have better lives, but it’s up to them, what’s better for you might not be for them, so they can only choose. It’s called free will.


> Poor people are a problem, they eat through resources without replenishing them, how you deal with them is another thing

Wow, you really doubled-down. That's a deeply anti-social way of thinking. Poor people are not a problem. An economy that creates poor people is the problem. That is a failure of government when it is captured by the wealthy and turned into a system to create private wealth rather than common wealth.

And by the way, poor people eat through resources without replenishing them? Ha, what do you think 'rich' people do?


This is HN. We are speaking objectively. Poor people are humans who deserve every ounce of respect and humanity as everybody else.

They are also, literally speaking from a logistics point of view, a problem. This is the point of view that smart problem-solvers tend to take, and is the point of view that ultimately benefits everybody the most, in practice, and in the long term. HN tends to attract this type of thinker (which is good).

You are taking a reactive point of view that over-applies hidden meanings to words (which is pretty normal for humans, and not intended as an insult).


> You are taking a reactive point of view that over-applies hidden meanings to words

You don't seem to have read the comments. There is no hidden meaning that I have over applied.

> They are also, literally speaking from a logistics point of view, a problem.

You are assuming the problem and then redirecting from its origins. The economy creates poverty. The economy is regulated by the government. Enlightened government should take care of the people and the common wealth, not be a tool for the wealthy to capture more wealth.


In a capitalistic economy you will always have poor people by definition, as poverty is a relative measure, the best you can do is having the best poor people, such a poor in your country is middle class in some other.

This applies worldwide, unless you live in a communist country, where everyone is equally poor except for the elites in power.


Besides demonstrating a naive and simplistic understanding of political economy, your statements are irrelevant to what we have been talking about.

Please explain to me how "[poor people] eat through resources without replenishing them" and how "rich people" do not? Please explain how it is good or just for a government to act as a system to secure private wealth for the wealthy and not to care for all of the people and the common wealth?


Easy, poor people don’t really contribute to the tax base, rich people pay for almost all the income tax, sales tax and property tax. Poor people are the receivers of most government benefits and programs, which make them a net expense revenue wise.

In the USA, the top 10% of all incomes account for 71% of all income tax, meaning the lower 90% only contribute 29%. Income taxes are governed by a power law (Pareto) where the very few account for most of the income.

https://usafacts.org/articles/who-pays-the-most-income-tax/

The government as it is today and in most western countries is super progressive with its taxes and benefits for its population. I don’t think it’s good nor just to charge someone more simply because they have more, that’s pretty unjust, why do they have to pick up the slack and maintain people who don’t try to get out of their situation?

I come from a 3rd world country where we now have 2/3 generations who have grown living only on government welfare instituted by the governing party to earn their votes, while the productive few are choked by taxes and forced to leave the country, how is that just?

So yes, the government should prioritize the few that actually make money and try to get more of the population that way, as they are the ones funding government.

And of course you don’t want poor people from other countries which are used to live on government welfare also to eat through your welfare without contributing back, it’s actually a requirement in order to get the greencard, which you probably have no idea what it entails as I’m guessing you are a native born bleeding heart American liberal, otherwise you would have a more realistic view of the world.


Even on your own terms, your argument fails. You claim that rich people pay for almost all the income, sales and property tax, but then only back up your claim with the federal individual income tax.

The federal individual income tax only accounts for about half of the federal government's revenue, let alone the revenue for states and localities from taxes and other fees. The payroll tax, property and sales taxes, as well as fees, are paid predominantly by the non-rich (you claim a Pareto distribution but that only holds for the individual income taxes- sales taxes are highly regressive). The top 10% receive roughly half the total income and pay roughly half the total revenue. That is not even close to "almost all" of the tax revenue for the governments in the United States.

Not only does your argument fail on its own terms, your terms are wrongheaded. I presume that you were here during covid, and must have realized that the "essential" workers were predominantly the lowest paid people in the US. That should clue you into the fact that people contribute a lot more to society than taxes!

> as I’m guessing you are a native born bleeding heart American liberal, otherwise you would have a more realistic view of the world

I am a native born American and my forefathers and foremothers fought for the prosperity and rights that you enjoy but do not appreciate. You say you are from a third world country, and that might partially explain why you are ignorant on this matter. I suggest you read the works that inspired the American Revolution and try to understand why people fought for it.


> sales taxes are highly regressive

You pay what you consume, and first need items like groceries are excluded, it's a great tax. Rich people buy more stuff than poor people, therefore they pay more sales tax than poor people (Ask WA how is it doing by imposing a millionaire's income tax, those people are leaving and they are losing sales/property tax revenue due to that). Same with property tax, to buy a bigger house you need more money, and the bigger the house the larger the property tax you pay. Don't want to pay huge property taxes? Buy smaller property. So, all in all, the logic still applies, if you consume more because you have more money, you contribute more to tax revenue.

Income tax should also be flat, as you would still pay more the more you earn.

> I presume that you were here during covid, and must have realized that the "essential" workers were predominantly the lowest paid people in the US. That should clue you into the fact that people contribute a lot more to society than taxes!

Nope, in Canada at the time, we could go out and to supermarkets for groceries. If the government hadn't imposed such strict lockdowns in some states, there would have been no need for the "essential" workers, if you mean delivery people. Otherwise, health care specialists tend to be very well paid, though covid was a shit show.

Yeah, the American revolution was based on the premise of no taxation without representation, and I know first hand how that feels as an immigrant, paying taxes and having no say on how they are used, and there are a lot of us paying a lot of taxes and having no say on them.

> prosperity and rights

Prosperity yes, rights you only get if you have a green card (and only some), if you are on a visa the second shit hits the fan you get kicked out (and even the green card may not protect you on that). You truly don't realize what a privilege you have by having citizenship. You should try being an immigrant so you get off your high horse.

It actually saddens me seeing how current politics of big government and the rise of the DSA and communism in the USA are screwing up a country which is great.


You've brushed off the failure of your arguments. That indicates that your position is not being driven by reasonable considerations.

> If the government hadn't imposed such strict lockdowns in some states, there would have been no need for the "essential" workers

That is a non sequitur. We do have essential workers whether or not they are the only workers working during a time of crisis or not.

> the American revolution was based on the premise of no taxation without representation

That is a bumper sticker level of understanding of our history. Please educate yourself on what inspired it. Read the works of Jean-Jacques Rousseau, John Locke, Thomas Paine, and Thomas Jefferson.

> get off your high horse

No. An enlightened government takes care of the people (and an unenlightened government is not worth having). Our economy creates poverty. We are in a crisis that has been growing since the 1980's and is reaching a flashpoint. You may not have been here for the 2008 financial crisis and Occupy Wall Street, so you may not have heard of Thomas Picketty's book Capital in the Twenty-First Century, but this webpage will give you a brief overview and a graph: https://www.epi.org/publication/top-1-percents-share-income-...

> DSA and communism in the USA are screwing up a country which is great

They are bringing a long overdue correction that is necessary to preserve our country. They have not even begun, so your claim that they are screwing up this country is absurd. This country is being run into the ground by the current administration and his fellow travelers.


> They are bringing a long overdue correction that is necessary to preserve our country.

Sure, communism will work this time, because it’s different! Not like the other hundred times it failed and the millions of people it killed and impoverished !

Communism is bad because it legalizes theft, if 51% of the people decide to take off the remainder 49% you have a nice recipe for disaster which has happened over and over again in the last 120 years.

But sure, your comments tell me you live in a fantasy world of books and theories instead of the real world, where reality is much simpler and crueler.

Keep on living in Disney.


Once again, you are demonstrating a naive and simplistic understanding of political economy that is irrelevant to the discussion.

> your comments tell me you live in a fantasy world of books and theories instead of the real world, where reality is much simpler and crueler. Keep on living in Disney.

No. We create our reality. I don't accept the beliefs that you advocate. I don't accept that our government shouldn't care for all of its people, regardless of what they contribute in tax revenue. I don't accept that our government regulates the economy to create poverty while redistributing wealth to the already wealthy. That is abhorrent and an unacceptable state of affairs. It directly contradicts the American Revolution and what inspired it.

Like I suggested before, please go read a book


This is a very immature, narrow, abhorrent and blinkered take. Next time your wife or mother is sick or a “burden” just take them out back and end the problem. Next time you stub your foot, just amputate it (just highlighting your mindset with an extreme take).


Sure, keep living in a fairy tale then where everyone helps each other and sings cumbaya, you represent suicidal empathy at its finest (taking your approach at an extreme take as you did mine).


Everyone helping each other isn't kumbaya - it's the path of tremendous effort, grit, sacrifice, pain. It is still better than the alternative which looks rational and perhaps easy, but much harder as you will eventually realize.


The parent stated a fact that is relevant in this context, and they did not use it as a shorthand for cruelty. Your reaction is unreasonable, besides breaking HN rules.


> The purpose of a government is to care for the welfare of the people

Not of the people, but of their own citizens. They owe nothing to people who are not their citizens, that’s why we have countries and not a world government, countries meddling in other countries internal politics leads to war.


I’ll jump in- why care? Because it sucks to have people taking pot shots at you. If it is just one, then sure, that isn’t so bad, but when you have a group doing it, it can become existential. You may not have seen this type of violence before but it is unsettling. A group of people can do low effort violence that feels fun and harmless to them (each taking a lazy swing at someone), but the cumulative effect can be beating up or killing someone. Getting yelled at, or having someone write threatening things to you, is not as bad as being punched or having a stone thrown, but it is still damaging to humans.


Not all hurtful and harmful behavior is violence and we need to maintain the distinction.


Don’t want to be the semantics guy but hurtful and harmful behaviour is by definition violence.


Evidently, you are in fact not "the semantics guy".


By whose definition?


The World Health Organization includes not just actual but also threatened physical force or power that results in injury, death or psychological harm


Something that causes harm is harmful; something that causes hurt is hurtful. So something that is harmful or hurtful is violence?

Or what am I missing?


Eh, when I was a kid violence was physical by definition. That distinction seems to be getting lost such that the phrase "physical violence" is no longer redundant. But the new usage is figurative.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: