HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | bdhe's commentslogin

Elaborate please? How did Bush and Obama build the foundations for Trump's castle?

Expansion of power of the executive branch at the expense of the legislative branch

Trying to engage in good faith here. What did you see in the first few weeks after your 2016 vote that were materially different from how he ran his 2016 campaign (and I mean the hits - "they're sending rapists, ...", "grab her by the pussy", ...)?

I can imagine people souring over lack of follow through on economic promises, or the naked corruption with your $coins, but from a racism/xenophobia/morals perspective, I'd feel like most of the signal was there in the 2016 campaign was it not?


For me personally it was trying to ban travel from whole countries based on race. Morally I didn't expect him to personally be a paragon of virtue. My hope was that the vile parts of his retoric were mostly campaign bluster and "locker room talk", and that he'd defer to experts once in office.

The mask-off racism was just beyond the pale, and lead me to look deeper into his past and how he was starting to govern. It became obvious that he'd mostly cheated or lucked his way into fortune and fame.


Gotcha.

> Morally I didn't expect him to personally be a paragon of virtue.

Lot of people respond with this, but honestly, that is setting up a straw man to knock down isn't it? No one claims that we should expect any politician to be a paragon of virtue but in terms of how they conduct themselves and the language they choose, there is still a reasonable bar that Trump blew past and set an awful precedent.


"Not a paragon of virtue" is an old expression that I use to mean I have low expectations of someone, not that everyone must have low expectations.

In hindsight there were signs I should have known about and some I should have taken more seriously. Which is why I suppose Jensen is on the ropes now.


In one sense, the generational label is correlated with class consciousness. The Boomer generation due to good post-WW2 conditions, relatively strong labor, and lots of red scare propaganda were immune to the chasm between the capital and labor class that has only grown since the 2000s.

Accounting for inflation, i.e., 2026 dollars, the 2000 top 10 richest individuals in the world had net worths between: - Bill Gates ($117 billion) - top - Kenneth Thompson ($31 billion) - #10

Today, those numbers are: - Elon Musk ($830 billion) - Warren Buffet ($150 billion)

There are at least 10 people today who are 50% richer than the richest person in 2000!

No wonder the people whose peak earning potential was in the 90s and 00s didn't feel the chasm between the billionaires and the working class.


>In one sense, the generational label is correlated with class consciousness. The Boomer generation due to good post-WW2 conditions, relatively strong labor, and lots of red scare propaganda were immune to the chasm between the capital and labor class that has only grown since the 2000s.

Propaganda, but also reality. What Stalin, Mao, Khmer Rouge did are real, and bad, and it influenced the thinking of a lot of people around Western supremacy. Our world of today is very different from that, and from a moral perspective it's truly questionable where the West is at this point. But back then?


Do you think the impeachment might just provide enough transparency so that there's more public pressure for accountability even if the Senate doesn't convict?

I encourage you to read this entire section of Ken Paxton dodging his securities fraud indictment using the full weight of the power of the offie of TX AG.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ken_Paxton#State_securities_fr...

Then, imagine someone spending $200 million aiming to ensure his election.

Not much you can respect in that someone doing such things.

And this is only 1 bullet out of dozens more like this in the last 8 years or so. Elon was very different in the late 2000s.


Nah, listening to the stories from his first wife, he was just better at hiding it publicly.

You really didn't know who that was, but had to look into the Wikipedia entry in detail enough to read about a jury decision and then frame it in a different way than written in Wikipedia (which rightly talks about the judicial process related to specific charges brought against Zimmerman, not an absolute statement of facts, such as "victim was not found to have been murdered").

I'm flagging that this doesn't sound like a good faith discussion. The green account raises my priors.

Note that I'm not suggesting that Apple's policy on censorship is good, quite the contrary.


The person you replied to wrote "shooter was acquitted"

Wikipedia writes in the second paragraph "...but a jury acquitted him of second-degree murder and manslaughter in July 2013"

How is that framed differently than Wikipedia did?

Or do you mean the part after "i.e.", but i.e. is literally latin for "in other words". So obviously the part after i.e. was reframed, that is what i.e. means.


You alluded to it. Murdered vs. found to have been murdered. There's a conflation going on there and its clear why.

The iOS summary says that he was murdered.

The Wikipedia entry states that a jury found that the person who killed him did not murder him. If what was done to him was not murder, then he was not murdered.

Therefore the iOS summary is wrong.


The jury found there wasn't enough evidence to find Zimmerman guilty beyond a reasonable doubt of the crime of murder in the second degree.

That is not the same thing as finding that the person did not murder him. That's why the verdicts are "'guilty' or 'not guilty'", and not "'guilty' or 'innocent'."

Take for example a hypothetical situation where I murdered someone. The prosecutor decides to prosecute me under first-degree murder, that is, premeditated murder. However, the murder was actually in a fit of passion, and the evidence for murder-1 isn't there. The jury can find me not guilty of murder-1, even if they believe I committed the murder, because the prosecution messed up and filed the wrong charge (and didn't also charge me with murder-2 or homicide as a backup). Thanks to double jeopardy, I can't then be re-charged.

Everyone can agree that I murdered that person, including me, even though I was acquitted. Jut because someone was acquitted of murder for a death they caused doesn't automatically mean the the person killed wasn't murdered.

(This is relevant to the Zimmerman's case, where you already read "The prosecution had requested that a lesser charge of third-degree felony murder, an offense that includes the commission of child abuse, be included in the jury instructions. Defense attorney Don West called the possible lesser charge "outrageous" and a "trick" by the state, because they had asked for it to be included at the last minute." That Zimmerman was acquitted of murder-2 does not mean he would have been innocent of murder-3 had the prosecution included that earlier.)

We can see that Wikipedia does not use the acquittal to determine that a killing was not a murder.

Take a look at the Wikipedia entry at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Nicole_Brown_Simpson... where it says Nicole Brown Simpson and Ron Goldman were murdered, and says that O. J. Simpson was acquitted for those murders, and it says "In 1997, the jury unanimously found Simpson responsible for the deaths of Goldman and Brown."

According to your reasoning, were Nicole Brown Simpson and Ron Goldman murdered?

Quoting now https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Coyle:

> James Edwin Coyle (March 23, 1873 – August 11, 1921) was an American Catholic priest who was murdered in Birmingham, Alabama, by a Ku Klux Klan member for performing a marriage between Pedro Gussman, a Puerto Rican Catholic, and a recent Catholic convert, Ruth Stephenson. The killer, E. R. Stephenson, was Ruth's father and opposed what he saw as an interracial union. He would ultimately be acquitted by a jury.

Was Coyle murdered? Wikipedia seems to think so, and lists him under "People murdered in 1921" at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:People_murdered_in_19... .

We know "murder" has a cultural meaning independent of specific determination of a legal charge, which is why things like "unsolved murders" and "murder–suicide" (where the murderer is dead and cannot be tried) exist. The iOS summary is not wrong, you simply disagree with it.


You accused them of arguing in bad faith, but it seems like the only issue here is that you disagree with them, not that they did anything in bad faith.

Its a reasonable view for someone to think that if a court finds a "not guilty" verdict, and there is no dispute over who the killer is, especially if one of the defenses raised is self defense or lack of intent, then the term murdered is inappropriate. It is also reasonable for someone to disagree with that position. I don't have a dog in that fight, i just object to accusing without further basis, anyone who disagrees as being in bad faith.


Did social media REQUIRE to subvert democratic norms or is it just that social media was so good/powerful that it ended up inadvertently hurting democratic norms and that social fabric?

I didn't think your Facebooks and Twitters required shady data center deals and circumvention to actually establish a viable business model.


>I didn't think your Facebooks and Twitters required shady data center

there were years of debate on whether or not a lot of the things early social media groups did constituted violations of, and not limited to : FTC Act Sect 5, the electronics communications privacy act, the CFAA, the video privacy protection act, and us state privacy laws from coast to coast.

they just did what they wanted, lawyered up, got big enough to lobby, and became legal ..

point is, these groups aren't stranger to 'shady deals'.


Fair point.

Neither. Governments and other politically aligned entities realized social media was useful and it was intentionally used to hurt democratic norms and the social fabric. It was neither an accident nor an intentional part of their business model (with Facebook being a possible exception.)

It's heresy to say here but related content algorithms aren't inherently evil.


Uff, first you're ironically doing it and then ...


Loe's Paw?


What kind of CEO, CIO/CTO?


The kind that has a strong in-group bias and likes to hire from his own ethnicity, gradually taking over departments.


There's such a kind? Got some data (not anecdotes) to support this?


I'm sorry, but this is almost a parody of the enlightened centrism meme.

The Democrats have attempted to pass several anti-gerrymandering bills. One in the Senate in 2024, one in the House in 2021. Both stonewalled by Republicans.

The Republican SCOTUS appointees allowed partisan gerrymandering, the Democratic ones were in the dissent.

California's prop 50 was IN RESPONSE to an unprecedented mid-term gerrymandering effort by Texas at the behest of Trump.

I just picked one example, but I could easily write similar responses that show very stark differences between the parties when it comes to wars, stacking the court, war with Iran, and more.


Newsome proposed a ballot measure to allow the government to draw a more Democrats friendly map. hHochul treated redistricting in New York and supported efforts to do so.

The difference in many case was that legal challenges in blue stated tended to stop the gerrymandering where courts in red states tended not to. The end result is different, the political intent was not.


And Newsome did that is response to what again? Oh right, as a threat of 'if you do it we will do it to' to try and contain unchecked Republican gerrymandering. Kind of a important detail to leave out.


No, not really. Two wrongs don't make a right. It doesn't matter who started it (especially since each party claims to be responding to the other, and the only thing they differ on is where to draw the zero point), it is still not acceptable to continue in kind.


It does matter who started it and responding meekly to being wronged just makes you a sucker. And conservative morality being what it is, suckers are going to be bullied for fun.

> Two wrongs don't make a right.

It is ok to respond to gerrymandering by gerrymandering. It is not kindergarten. The court said it is legal, GOP will continue to do it. If the other side does not engage, they will honorably loose all ability to influence politics.


I'd argue that in this case two wrongs literally do make a right, because AFAIK game theory proves tit-for-tat to be the most effective strategy in a two-player prisoner's dilemma (which this boils down to). Since the few instances able to prevent such voter repression had already proven their defection to the side trying to repress voters, Newsom's approach seems to objectively be the best one to defend democracy.


There's a nuance you're missing. These are not two comparable wrongs.

The CA proposition was put to a vote. Literally direct democracy. The TX legislature had a special session to put this in without voter input.

The CA proposition is time bounded, the TX one is not.

The CA proposition was in reaction to the TX one. If TX did not mid-cycle redistrict I am confident CA wouldn't.

Can you still really claim the two were equivalent?


I can't speak to his intent, I just know that he specifically said the state legislation should redraw California lines to favor his party.

I can't include every detail in such a format, but its worth noting that I did clearly call out the Republicans doing it first. Its not like I was saying "democrat gerrymander" out of context there.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: