Terrible optic is such a bs executive wording when they lied, coerced, bullied, and threatened him…
I like the summary but knowing what irthomasthomas posted that’s missing from it, and having a better picture of what happened; terrible optic doesn’t work.
Journalism is almost dead. And if where it’s not it’s more of a summary of what happened rather than deep investigations. But only a small percentage of the population care about deep investigations anyway.
HN is going to be a weird place to be between people loving AI and the loss of loving tech. I don’t remember last time I watched a good tech dev video. At least the video game industry is a little bit shielded from this but soon it will be the same when we see the speed AI is advancing.
I don't see at all that this is stifling love of tech. Sure if you liked to engage in language wars or vim vs emacs or tabs vs spaces then yes that's over. But tech as we know it is currently exploding, a ton of stuff that simply was not practically possible before is now possible.
Give us some examples of things that were not practically possible. Things are practically possible if the time or money is wisely spent, even if it takes a human a bit longer.
Money and time are precisely the point. Things are not practically possible of a X would cost 100K to develop and it's worth was 30K. But now that it costs 2K to develop it is suddenly practically possible.
2. The abundance of game decomps and recomps becoming available. Literally dozens of example in this space.
3. Reverse engineering of obscure software. A ton of oppertunities lie here.
4. As this posts indicate, severely accelerating existing software by re-writing it in language that are not terrible for performance.
5. Analyzing large volumes of unstructured information.
6. Creating one-off engineering and scientific tools.
7. Beating essentially all traditional Linux distribution, see Omarchy.
8. A personal example: I'm remaking the engine of an old game commercial game in rust.
I'm honestly a bit taken aback that this question is even asked. The volume of software is exploding and the power of the individual has increased a hundredfold.
I don’t quite follow. If you bring software worth into question, as you pointed out everyone’s vibe coding each of your examples so their individual worth has dropped significantly (with the unknown stability of support and long term plans).
My thought was LLMs accelerate the best and worst of development, but what couldn’t be done (outside of a large lab or company) by regular humans with an infinite time scale?
I.e. 8. A personal example: I'm remaking the engine of an old game commercial game in rust.
You don’t need an LLM for that, just some dedicated time for it.
Also your phrasing needs a lot of work. I recommend the Dale Carnegie books on communicating with others.
I think maybe 1 or 2 of those would take more than 1 year for an mvp. I will agree with you that with LLMs it’s infinitely easier and quicker to get a low quality mvp.
Well if possible you want an AI that understand the spirit of what you are asking for and will add all the missing stuff, instead of an AI that just want to hack its way to the result. Kinda what Fable brought to the table. For instance as a simple example I ask it to change the text that shows the email of the user by his name and Fable did all the code in case there is the family name missing etc. That this last part you want an AI to do. Helping you to build the system with you and not gaming what you ask for for reward.
Why limit? This is a news website where users judge if something is newsworthy by upvoting it. If the community decides it’s newsworthy it’s newsworthy. Maybe not for you but at least enough people to make it visible in front page. Unless you have strong arguments, like topics creating death threats or people doxing, there is no reason whatsoever to censure any news because you personally doesn’t care or don’t like it and prevent others from accessing it.
HN is curated by moderators and votes are just one input. All sorts of topics get downweighted all the time. Given the longevity of the AI news cycle it's not a crazy ask to suggest it get downweighted too.
And it's "censor", not "censure". To censure AI news would be for Dan and Tom to lodge a formal complaint about it.
It’s not the players we should hate but the ones who make the rules of the game. Specifically not the ones who make the rules for the greater good but for themselves.
I like the summary but knowing what irthomasthomas posted that’s missing from it, and having a better picture of what happened; terrible optic doesn’t work.
reply