HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | baoooooooooooo's commentslogin

This comment always comes up but isn’t this literally irreducibly complex in the sense of Kolmogorov complexity?

I’m out of my depth here but it does seem prompts have a “smell” to their complexity that means we can use a classifier to mate them to a model with better success than random noise, but still don’t essentially all of the savings associated with systems like this just come because there is some “complexity arbitrage” where there is enough of a token cost differential between models that you always save money by trying the cheap model first and then trying a hard model if it turns out to be hard?


I’m also not an expert but that sounds a lot like the toilet seat problem. Mathematically it’s preferable to just always leave the seat as you used it, instead of using effort to return it to some desired state. This minimises effort in aggregate for all parties. I think it’s possible that routing every request through a simpler model first ends up more expensive in the long run, depending on the cost of that simple model. And if it’s too simple, the routing inefficiencies and mistakes will produce worse results.

I think one of the more difficult problems with this is that the complexity is often unclear at first. It’s not until some thinking and analysis that the complexity emerges. It’s just not possible for a simple model to deduce this, and we don’t want a dumb model investigating a complex issue.

I think in the medium term we end up with large models which are efficient with simple queries. Meaning very few tokens used to answer simple queries, keeping costs low. So one just uses this large model for everything.

Longer term I think LLMs move closer to the structure of the brain, whereby different regions/models have specialised functionality, and they communicate and coordinate depending on the task. For example, telemetry doesn’t need to pass through the prefrontal cortex. It just goes straight to the telemetry model which is super simple and cheap.


> Mathematically it’s preferable to just always leave the seat as you used it

Ah, but the consequences of a female type partner encountering an up seat in the middle of the night far outweigh my consequences of having to raise the seat during the day.


This is a good point. If your partner is blind and disabled the extra effort may be warranted.

She is not. But I do afford that 2am bathroom calls (normally not ones I myself answer) approximate the state.

Everyone seems quite upset/perplexed by the Gemini naming scheme but I quite like it. And hey, if you find yourself lost, the periodic table is probably the most ubiquitous ordered list in the world and serves to clear things up pretty fast. This will likely not be strictly true as models release over time, but is a good rough indication of what the team thinks we should expect of the models, in the same way the other labs run their naming.

I also like the personalities implied by these, with Anthropic saying “human literary achievement is neat”, OpenAI saying “space is neat” and Google being like “science is neat”.

Edit: I was coming back to say “I wish we could talk about stuff more substantive than the naming scheme” but (1) my comment may be objectively incorrect, and (2) I have to apologize that I haven’t helped the situation by… commenting on the naming scheme.


They are not following the periodic table in any discernible way though.

They're in alphabetical order, almost like Ubuntu release names. There was a leak about a Gemini Oxygen model, which would further support alphabetical order -- skipping names they don't want to use.

So, names don't align with capability but instead "release freshness". This is unlike every other provider but it is what Google does (did?) with Android releases I believe (dessert names).


They went form A to N in 4 releases. Initially maybe they planned to follow the alphabet, but I think that went out the window

I suspect the missing letters are internal models or checkpoints that were not released (e.g. Barium), although the jump from Carbon to Hydrogen and Neon is quite large

> And hey, if you find yourself lost, the periodic table is probably the most ubiquitous ordered list in the world and serves to clear things up pretty fast.

But the way google ranks the models by capability doesn't follow periodic table order.

Hydrogen - 1

Carbon - 6

Neon - 10

Argon - 18

It could very well be based on their density (g/cm^3 in standard conditions):

Hydrogen - 0.0000899

Neon - 0.000900

Argon - 0.001784

Carbon - 2.267

This would make more sense than assuming it is based on their periodic table order as it more accurately maps to how Google markets their capabilities, but is too esoteric to really be useful for clearing up confusion for normal users, IMO.


I think it's more vibes-based. The different periodic groups have different meaning.

Neon and Argon are descending down the noble gases, I'd expect their successors are Krypton, Xenon, Radon.

They skipped Helium and went straight to Neon, which makes me think they've reserved Helium as a lightweight element, and are going to follow the lightest elements for the cheapest models. Hydrogen, Helium, Lithium, and so on.

Carbon reads more as a "foundation of life" kind of metaphorical choice, and they have some choices in the periodic groups nearby to keep that sort of metaphor for a while. My guess is they move horizontally - Nitrogen, Oxygen - then on to Silicon when they hit something appropriately transformative with the model.

I'd expect the most experimental or fastest models to eventually release on highly reactive groups - Fluorine, Sodium, etc. - and that they're leaving the metallic elements in the middle for differentiation in industry-specific fine-tuned models.


The periodic table isn't really helping. Hydrogen is the lightest, that much makes sense. Beyond that it doesn't seem to work. The elemental ordering is H C Ne Ar. The cost ordering is H Ne Ar C (with Ar and C being the same per token but I gather that C thinks more and thus costs more). The capability ordering seems to be H Ar C Ne. Argon is the highest on the table but is neither the most expensive nor the smartest.

Lmao no. The most ubiquitous ordered list is... numbers. Or the alphabet.

And your first?

Not the parent, but participation in a criminal scheme to circumvent export controls seems like a pretty good reason to oust a CEO, no?

I mean NVIDIA recently was >8% of the S&P500 so it’s actually not a silly statement

Other stocks were up, so the index itself didn’t really fall that much.

That capital flows into other companies...

What will actually "hurt retirements" (delay them) is if this bubble bursts like the dotcom one did. Which seems strictly less likely without the most valuable company in the world relentlessly increasing leverage on its single investment thesis.


My qualitative take to support this is that Gemini seems to have the strongest spatial reasoning that translates nicely into CAD and engineering domain challenges. Less clear, but I also suspect a better world understanding of materials and their interactions in an intuitive way. I have this sense that Claude can tell me everything there is to know about how to spec a gasket, but it’s like Gemini actually knows what a gasket feels like and can intuit what it’s going to do.

My partner runs an internal computational mechanics benchmark that hasn’t tracked progress with model advancements (flat/no progress since early 2026) until suddenly saturating from argon and carbon. My take is that it’s due to spatial reasoning (most of the challenges are programming that require a lot of shape rotation type thinking), but we don’t know just yet why Gemini is doing so much better.


4.5 hours on battery surprised me - cool that it's built in, but yeah these things are power hungry. 25-35W kinda surprised me.

I guess it makes sense, space is a long way away after all...


4.5 hours for any terrestrial based satcom solution is insane. At this point, the battery tech alone with these power requirements is stuff that Garmin, Viasat and Honeywell could only dream of obtaining in the same quantities.

Distance alone isn’t the real issue (newer Pixel phones can talk to GEO, which is 100 times farther out than Starlink in LEO!), data rate over distance is.

It's not inherently because of space, it's because phased array antennas are just very power hungry. Most of the link budget is coming from the satellites huge antenna, the mini has a comparatively tiny aperture

Are the satellites dealing with the same power hungriness or is there an asymmetric nature to phased array tech?

They have to be able to actively melt snow too, which makes the draw much higher.

That part is almost certainly optional on the Mini.

wow this would be a neat twist if true - we all defaulted to the negative explanation of having killed them all where a much more positive explanation might be that we're no longer luring them to their deaths at the leading edge of automobiles?

I guess it is most likely some combination of the above, but if there's any evidence it would be a neat reframing


Colorado: "Insect biomass declined by ∼47% and abundance declined by ∼61.5% over the last 35 years." https://esajournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/ecs2...

Germany: "More than 75 percent decline over 27 years in total flying insect biomass in protected areas" https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal...

Puerto Rico: "dry weight biomass of arthropods captured in sweep samples had declined 4 to 8 times, and 30 to 60 times in sticky traps." https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.1722477115


The mass insect-death on windshield issue was as much a daytime issue and nighttime one.


Are you sure about that?


I am not making any claims about the relative prevalence of insects day vs. night.

I can say with absolute and total confidence that the phenomenon of insect splatter was a common - if not frequent - daytime experience. I've not experienced this phenomenon in decades.


Yes. The daytime crop was always greater than at night


The McFlies don't think very much


It’s effectively crowdsourcing urban planning, I’m in support.

I honestly think if we invited this type of empowerment/interaction in the physical world a bit more it would probably be good for spurring creativity in society (I think we do a pretty good job of it in software). It’s just a nice reminder that everything is just made up by someone else, likely no smarter than you.

Also I can’t believe this was 10 years ago, I remember being super involved in SPUR in SF (and getting coffee there almost every day) and going to talks about this kind of thing


It's admittedly appealing because it feels far closer to ordinary citizens having an influence, but I can't help feel like this is a failure on the part of the professionals whose responsibility the planning and implementation of this is.

Have we really gotten to the point where we can't trust public infrastructure to be properly implemented, and so the only solution is to take it into our own hands? What are the tax dollars paying for then?


I think in many places we have gotten to the point where the planning, processes, and public approval process for some of these simple projects is more costly in time and money than just building it as a temporary experiment and revisiting it in a year or two to measure the outcome.

Not that there shouldn't still be some kind of standards and community approval, but I think we can afford to set that at a lower bar for certain categories of easily reversible projects.

And hopefully incorporating more of these ideas can teach us to be more efficient on transit infrastructure projects in general, where the US often significantly trails other countries on cost and implementation time.


Changes are stymied by bureaucracy put in place due to fear of litigation. The primary reason that things are studied, studied again, given community input, and checked for environmental impact is that if a city or municipality gets sued due to a road change, the onus is on them to demonstrate that they didn't create an unsafe condition. For example in cases where cars crash and are liable for property damage, car owners try to sue the city to claim that the area was unsafe. Pointing to a massive paper trail like this removes liability from a set of city or municipal concerns.


Nah, that's just the bullshit they tell you.

A municipal or state government will not be held liable for the consequences of shitty infrastructure unless there's like 9/11 levels of "the system was blinking red and you ignored it" and even then it's coin toss at best. Like maybe if they kill a ton of people there might be a lawsuit that sticks that's sooooo unlikely for the scope of the kind of thing we're talking about here.

The bureaucracy is put in place because none of the people putting it in place are paying for it, headcount is power, control over resources is power, etc, etc, and all the other perverse incentives you see in government workplaces. And of course once the gravy train is running all these parties have an incentive to keep it running.


> Nah, that's just the bullshit they tell you.

I mean, this is the "bullshit" that our DOT told us when talking about guerilla urbanism at a real city meeting. I agree that it's frustrating, but it is what we were told. I don't know how to "disprove" a defensive posture. And yes, our city goverment has been sued in cases on the grounds of poor street design (though they've only had to pay out once in 20 years.)

> The bureaucracy is put in place because none of the people putting it in place are paying for it, headcount is power, control over resources is power, etc, etc, and all the other perverse incentives you see in government workplaces. And of course once the gravy train is running all these parties have an incentive to keep it running.

Do you have any real experience in city or local government?


>. I don't know how to "disprove" a defensive posture. And yes, our city government has been sued in cases on the grounds of poor street design (though they've only had to pay out once in 20 years.)

You ask them how much money they'd pay out to lawsuits, how much money they were paying out before adopting those policies. You ask them how much these policies cost (I bet they haven't even calculated it because they'd rather not have that number exist). Etc. Etc You make them spell out the math for you.

>And yes, our city goverment has been sued in cases on the grounds of poor street design (though they've only had to pay out once in 20 years.)

Suing the .gov is often the only way to get them to shape up and do the thing they should have in the first place. Getting sued doesn't mean much. It's all about the results.

The fear might be real in the minds of the decision makers but that doesn't mean it's well founded or the policies that arise out of it are not wasteful.

>Do you have any real experience in city or local government?

Worse, state. MIC prior to that.


> The fear might be real in the minds of the decision makers but that doesn't mean it's well founded or the policies that arise out of it are not wasteful.

I mean I 100% agree with this by the way. We tried to tell the DOT to look at its own stats. The one lawsuit they actually paid out in was from street design before the formation of the DOT itself and the fact that they fell behind on the paving schedule. If you actually amortize the payout over 30 years (I think the city has had one of these roughly every 30 years) it ends up being some minuscule part of the budget. But they still shut us down.


We kind of have reached that point. You can look at the cost overruns and public consultation before every new project as failures of the system to deliver what people want.


> a failure on the part of the professionals whose responsibility the planning and implementation of this is.

Don't forget the short-sighted NIMBYism.


I love the human sense (or vision) that we could find these in the 1750s as carbonized logs and know that we should keep and protect them - that we miiiiight be able to read them someday.


Actually, quite a few got partially destroyed while humans tried to physically unroll them.

I suppose they must have left the worse one to hope and to us


An unknown number of them were also allegedly burned for heat as they were mistaken for wood logs during early excavations


Odds those were all just yet more Epicurean philosophy though?


Come on, the (short) texts I've seen decoded were extremely exciting to me, surprising and event still relevant today. I think we have so comparatively little text from such an ancient time that every little passage we can recover is extremely valuable for preservation, historical context, or just philosophically, etc..

This is often said, but this passage could really have been written today:

"… we will inquire into something, but we

will not grasp it, if in some way we depart

from ourselves and from our own nature,

and besides, in the same way as the

remaining arts may be said to be perfected

in one respect, but to be deficient in

practical wisdom in another respect…"

From PHerc. 1667, col 17 (see Complete virtual unwrapping and reading of a rolled Herculaneum papyrus, pg 25)

Very cool stuff.


Yeah this hits the sentiment on the head, and I think shows the psychic damage of a system sliding into extreme inequality. My friend group seems to sit along this divide, and it's hard to see the impact that this sort of rumination can have on incredibly brilliant people.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: