I'd take these industry reports with some salt, because of what parent said:
Players (claim to) hate AI and will ruthlessly cancel developers who admit to using it. This is sure to bias developers towards not admitting they use AI regardless of whether they do.
Stadia is an inferior experience, until it becomes the only experience, at which point your choice is Stadia or nothing. Do you really think people are going to choose nothing?
I'd bet more on Steam adding nextlevel anticheat, mandatory live service components. Or AAA games no longer being a thing, just like AAA albums are not a thing.
I find it hard to imagine a world of choice between what everyone hates or nothing. That's not how gaming ever worked, or how a (relatively) free market works.
Even Steam monopoly is only possible because people always genuinely loved Steam.
GTA6 leaker promised leaks based on value of his coin. GTA5 cracker wants you to know his Monero.
Given how brazen these things are becoming, are we entering a new era of piracy where people hack, crack, rip and distribute entire franchises for free and get paid anonymously?
Can you elaborate more on what Grok Bot has (that you are emulating) that isn't available in other agents, and why you are emulating Grok Bot in particular, compared to another agent? What exactly is what "real startup teams need"?
Good question. I think the thing most worth learning from Grok Bot is how the bot interacts with people.
Compare a Claude Code connected to a gateway with Grok Bot. One is a coding agent, the other is a personal agent. When you give Claude Code an instruction, it goes and does it itself: it thinks for a while, works for a while, then gives you a big pile of text. If you say a few more things while it works, your words go into a queue. Whether they cut in or wait, in the end it's the same single agent doing the work, because it's a dev tool, not an assistant.
Grok Bot, as a personal agent, is different. The agent you talk to rarely does the work itself. It's like your assistant: most of the time it only needs to do two things well, talk with you and delegate for you. So when you talk to Grok Bot you don't wait long, you usually get an answer quickly, because the main agent is a lightweight agent tuned only for the conversation. It hands the task to a full-power subagent, keeps an eye on the work and reports back to you. So even when you have several things going and keep sending messages one after another, your messages don't cut in or wait like in a single-threaded queue. Your assistant decides for you whether this message, this task, goes to a new subagent or gets added to the one that's already on it. And you rarely see a Claude Code-sized reply in Grok Bot. Your secretary sorts things out for you. If it's a lot of information, or it needs a special kind of interaction, your secretary uses a page (a special web output), or in-app pop-ups, choice boxes, input boxes and so on. Not only text, and never a wall of text that's hard to read.
I was a long-time user and developer of OpenClaw-like apps before, so I saw right away that this is the biggest difference between a personal agent like Grok Bot and a coding agent connected to a chat app. These are the points I found most worth learning from Grok Bot, and they are the core idea I kept pushing and optimizing for the whole time I built Pots: a personal agent that works like a real coworker / secretary.
All of this is already in Pots, especially the special interactions. Pots didn't build its own app first (that's also why I say Pots cares about what real startup teams need, more on that below). It lets the agent treat each chat app as its own tool and get good at the controls each chat app already has, so inside each chat app Pots gets the same kind of special interactions as the pop-ups and choices built into the Grok Bot app. And since Pots is a local, self-hosted service, I also researched and designed how it can give people a page they can open from outside, the way Grok does: the agent uses Cloudflare and Tailscale services, so its pages can be reached from outside freely and safely.
Now the "what real startup teams need" part. Grok Bot is a separate product, a separate app. If a team wants to use it, everyone can only use it as an outside product and throw their own tasks and their own context at Grok Bot, and the company can't manage it in one place either. Pots is built on top of each team's chat tools. You don't need a separate app, you just bring Pots into your own channels: Slack, Discord, Telegram, Teams and so on. Pots gets all the context you want it to know directly, with no outside tool and nobody passing things along. If Grok Bot is a personal assistant that each person can only use on their own, from outside, then Pots is an in-house team assistant. It's simply a coworker on your team, so internal work takes fewer steps. And because it's built on the team's chat tools in the first place, you get 100% of the features right in your own channels, without a separate app.
If you go deep into the crypto world you'll find that this messaging resonates well with "degens" (as they sometimes call themselves).
They love this stuff, it signals how "pilled" you are. It may or may not have to do with a large proportion of them being high on drugs (weed, psychedelics, cocaine), in addition to obviously being terminally online and bubbled. They are also extremely anti-authority, because a lot of what they do breaks the law in bigger and lesser ways, especially tax/financial law.
And they often will drive millions and millions of dollars of crypto toward these ventures, often anonymously.
You have to read these kinds of things in the context of the target audience, which is very real.
I think "degen" for "degenerate gambler" refers specifically to those who make wild, all-in bets without any more research than a quick scan of twitter and telegram memes. Not those who would actually parse a multi-page manifesto document.
Alright we will see how long that lasts. If they want to enforce their “contracts” they will need a court (i.e. an authority) to order the opposite party to abide by their contract and if they don’t, police (i.e. an authority) will force them to court and enforce what the court says.
The idea with crypto is not to need courts, the court would be the "global computer", contracts (actual cryptocurrency term) are computer programs running in the Ethereum VM.
Bitcoin originally imposed this idea on payments, and Ethereum attempts to create this computational contract system for the non monetary consideration of contracts (the harder half of the contract).
Don't say it isn't so!? The community founded on circumventing existing financial structures are anti-authority? Next you're gonna tell me anarchists don't like individual leaders, or that socialists care about healthcare.
Source: I suppose also "made it out" although it wasn't hard, I left my job, like any other industry. Worth knowing as well that the cryptocurrency ecosystem isn't nearly as "internally" aligned as some people want you to believe, there is a large range in weirdness in the ecosystem, not just what parent above shared.
Ethereum in particular has some history with that. A long time ago they espoused this principle called "code is law", and then one time the code for something called "The DAO" did something they didn't like, so they overrode the code. To this day the Ethereum consensus rules specify that a certain hardcoded transaction ID should not do what it literally says it does.
The transition from PoW to PoS is another example, espoused the open ideals of Bitcoin mining, right up until the moment they had gathered sufficient power and members, at which time they closed the gates of ascension behind them.
I like it, literally revolutionary, to my eyes BTC owes more to PoW than Blockchain. You start seeing it everywhere, related to Taleb's skin in the game concept, or costly signaling in zoology.
Probably 0 if I had a choice. But is global warming a problem that is exclusive to bitcoin? Or does bitcoin highlight and accelerate an existing problem that is already a problem through other means, like car/plane emissions and AI datacenters.
Whatever solution we come up with, will work against all sources of warming or environmental damage. Although if one of those measures is banning Bitcoin mining, I wouldn't complain about it.
> Next you're gonna tell me anarchists don't like individual leaders, or that socialists care about healthcare.
There's an irony embedded in both positions. Everyone cares about government, anarchists care about overthrowing the existing government in order to replace it with their own version. Similarly, everyone cares about healthcare, socialists care about other people paying for their healthcare.
There's a big difference between anti-authority and a-hole, knee-jerk opposition defiance disorder, but even if you're right wouldn't the people being asked to sign this contract be the last people to do so?
Probably combination of "information laundering" and "betting market".
If you are making money (i.e. beating the "house") you are by definition laundering information, and profiting off of deniability. Everyone who isn't doing this is the sucker losing money on a betting market.
The funny thing is these companies want to be considered information laundries, because that's what serves the real customer (politicians, celebrities, etc). The people "betting" (i.e. losing) are the product.
>If you are making money (i.e. beating the "house") you are by definition laundering information, and profiting off of deniability. Everyone who isn't doing this is the sucker losing money on a betting market.
???
There's no allowance for skill? Even in financial markets, there's no reason to believe why people who continually beat the market must be insider trading. That's not the same as saying that people should be day trading, but that doesn't mean the reverse is true.
I absolutely can imagine a video game doing that, especially if there were some way to make the consumption be conspicuous.
In Tan's case, I think the "fun" thing is the right way to look at it. He gets to play at being a big shot developer and show off on Twitter, so clearly he feels he's getting some value from his spending even if no-one else does.
There is a more serious question about to what degree the AI vendors have a duty of care to prevent addicts from getting themselves into financial trouble - perhaps they might in future face the sort of regulation applied to high street bookmakers. I doubt Tan would fail any putative affordability test, though, so it would still be up to him to seek help for his problem if he feels its getting out of control.
Well, I run a number of apps that have users who appreciate them (I hope?) and they simply wouldn't exist without AI giving me the leverage to build them. So.. yes? What's a "return", anyway? It's worth it to me, obviously!
But you might have hit the nail on the head - yes, it's extremely fun and maybe that's the main reason after all. And FYI many, many people pay a lot more than $1k/m for video games.
Median average single salary in the US is ~64k a year. Spending ~19% of all income on a single hobby is completely out of the question for the vast majority of people.
If you claim it as a business/work expense (In Australia, that gives you a 47% discount), 1K is not even one day's salary for a well-paid dev and just about one day for an average paid dev.
Average base compensation for SWE is ~140k (in the US w/ the highest earning SWEs), so the average is roughly half of that. Earning ~275k is comfortably in the top 20% of all SWEs; 1k a day is easily in the top 5%.
It's even worse than that; the president has declared anyone using the term "AI" is the Enemy, and aiding the Enemy is a capital crime.
You could say the president is just joking about such things; I don't think this will actually be acted upon, but the political/legal situation is quite rough.
I hear they have great "AI" programs in El Salvador! If you say the right things you might even be selected for a free trip here. Such a bargain. And the weight loss plan their nutrition experts have put together is top tier.
Products get successful by being good, but after a certain threshold people buy a product because "nobody got fired for buying Salesforce". Which is not all that different from buying a product because "haha, fuck salesforce, they fired me".
You probably don't intend this, but the argument seems like "money talks, so why bother with ideals". How would you solve enshittification in the current market, if not introducing a bit of anarchy?
That's definitely not what I'm saying. I'm just saying build a better product and a better company that focuses on its employees. It's not that hard and there are plenty of examples all around. Also, revenge isn't exactly an ideal, it's actually quite the opposite.
Players (claim to) hate AI and will ruthlessly cancel developers who admit to using it. This is sure to bias developers towards not admitting they use AI regardless of whether they do.
reply