With maths, we can prove things with 100% certainty given then axioms. The axioms are not there to be proved or disproved; they are what _define the system_. We can choose different axioms, and have a different system.
With science, we can't prove anything 100% because it is based on observation, not axioms.
The axioms are not there to be proved or disproved; they are what _define the system_.
This is not correct. We have a notion of the natural numbers in our minds but axiomatizing this notion is elusive and impossible if one insists on a nice set of axioms.
Consider this. I claim it is not possible to prove that addition of natural numbers is commutative. I claim this because any system of axioms one proposes to use as the axioms for the natural numbers that does not prove that addition is commutative would be rejected. What this shows is that we believe addition is commutative regardless of what axioms we use.
The axioms do not define the system. Axioms are found to be acceptable if they describe the system accurately enough.
You are talking about mathematical models to things. Math itself, on the other hand, have a meaning outside of any models, and that part is build to be provable, from axioms that indeed define the roots
A situation kind of like this happened to a relative in England; their international flight was diverted (I think due to weather) to a domestic-only airport; due to lack of immigration & customs facilities, everyone had to remain on the plane until it could take off again (presumably after being refueled) to get to an international airport
That is the hope; although we'll end up with either companies doubling down on cryptography to prevent this (though they will inevitably leave some holes), or changing business models, where the hardware loss leader -> subscription is no longer a thing, so hardware costs go up
On the flip side, there are companies going the other way and just dumping the hardware on the market expecting the community to vibecode up the firmware. We had open hardware like this before but it was not practical for anyone to actually do anything with it unless there was a massive community maintaining firmwares.
Behringer just announced they will be releasing an all in one DJ deck with no software but the freedom to install whatever you want on it, for a tiny fraction of the price of the existing options. There's https://thefirmwarehub.com/ with a whole load of custom firmwares for a $60~ synth. And the whole industry of retro emulator handheld consoles coming out of China where the first thing you do after unboxing is replacing the stock OS with a custom one from github.
Most of them aren’t well known legacy companies, but rather random Chinese hardware manufacturers. The synth music world is currently going through a big shift with several new cheap open-firmware options, and none of them are produced by a company anyone would recognise.
> Most of them aren’t well known legacy companies, but rather random Chinese hardware manufacturers. The synth music world is currently going through a big shift with several new cheap open-firmware options, and none of them are produced by a company anyone would recognise.
Maybe to an outsider it seems like none is being made by companies you recognize, but to us in music, lots of big brands are changing tune. Erica Synths (big in both desktop gear and modular synths), Polyend, Akai/MPC, Moog and more.
Sadly, Elektron is not yet on the wagon of change, but surely they'll find their ways soon too I hope.
But to say none of them are "well known" is very far from the truth, Moog is probably as "legacy" as any brand can get and still sell hardware today.
> changing business models, where the hardware loss leader -> subscription is no longer a thing, so hardware costs go up
I pray for the day! This business model is a fingernail's thickness away from lying. It's outright lying when applied retroactively to products that used to not need a subscription.
A tip I recently learnt: if lining a cake tin or similar with baking paper, scrunch it up really tight, then flatten, and it will fit to the tin very really
A tradie doing some welding in the kitchen I was working in some years back told me this as he disabled the smoke alarm (to prevent a false alert while he was welding): "if you set off a false alert on the fire alarm, quickly set fire to the wastepaper bin - it saves you from paying the false alert fee"
With maths, we can prove things with 100% certainty given then axioms. The axioms are not there to be proved or disproved; they are what _define the system_. We can choose different axioms, and have a different system.
With science, we can't prove anything 100% because it is based on observation, not axioms.
reply