HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | appreciatorBus's commentslogin

I disagree.

Dressing up every day makes you feel great. I recommend it to everyone.

I had a job where dress clothes were expected and I miss it dearly.


Nobody is stopping you from dressing up, we're just mad you want to force your opinion on everyone else. I had a friend who wore a suit every day to his casual workplace and looked like a boss, still didn't want to do it myself.

I've been at jobs that made me dress up every day. For years. Never again. It's a horrible waste of time and achieves nothing.

I don't disagree with you. It does make me feel great. But I also work at sporadic hours. It doesn't make sense for me to dress up, go to my home office, check dashboards, fire prompts, etc, then undress.

My point is that the concept of work has changed so much yet we're still bound by the 9-5 rules. Core hours during which teammates must all be available makes sense, but absent that, it's all just arbitrary and cultural.


Wow. So we must not ask if any govt interventions work for fear that the wrong answer will empower political groups disfavoured by the govt and govt staff?

We should not cherry pick interventions that don't work and misleadingly show that interventions meant for one purpose did not work for another purpose in order to advance a narrative that no interventions work.

Please save your woke moralizing for Bluesky. People like what they like, engineers & non-engineers alike.

You can like Elon or hate him but reusable rockets are cool AF. I would watch them all day, with out giving 2 shits whether they were making Elon richer or poorer.


I agree that reusable rockets are cool as hell and that the landing of the boosters from the first falcon heavy flight is one of the things that just sticks in my memory.

What I don't agree with is the idea that someone being aware of the greater social, economic and environmental impact of engineering efforts should be derided as "woke" or something negative. It is very short sighted and unworthy of someone who would claim the title of engineer.


Yes.

If something is overvalued then a process that devalues it should be welcomed.


May I refer you to the rule you have quoted in your own profile?


Thanks for saying the quiet part out loud, glad some of you people are finally courageous enough to own your beliefs.


Shitting on someone else’s carpet is absolutely hurting someone.

A better example:

You prefer to shit in your own toilet but someone else prefers to shit on their own carpet.


There are whole disciplines whose telos is now activism rather than knowledge production.

https://cdn.vanderbilt.edu/vu-wpfsx/wp-content/uploads/sites...


You linked a pdf but I'm not going to scroll 30 pages on a phone to figure out your cryptic statement


There are whole companies whose only goal is to make money for shareholders! Most people on HN work for them!


And those companies make money from government sponsored R&D. and educational pipelines.


Yes.

People working hard on problems that other people are willing to freely compensate them for is a good thing.

Activism disguised as research is a bad thing.



Since most people aren't gonna have context on this part of the literature.

This paper is heavily rejected by mainstream criminologists. It relies on victim memorial lists for a count of victims and it relies on a database made by an anti-Trans group for the perpetrator count. This leads to both a significant undercount of victims and overcount of perpetrators.

The ONS has come out against it and said that official homicide data does not track transgender status so there is no official data to back this research up on.

None of this has stopped rightwingers from heavily circulating this paper of course. Somehow I doubt science is the goal here.


Idk about the paper but I know a lot of trans women and I don't think any of them haven't been stabbed/assaulted for being trans at least once.


Trans people are also statistically overrepresented in houseless populations in the US which makes statistics like these particularly challenging to investigate


Why is the paper not available?


The behavior that leads to the issue is individual consumers driving cars. Outlawing this would nuke demand for fossil fuels which encourages risky well drilling. But since 99% of Americans drive they tend to get very unhappy about the prospect of banning the vroom vroom. This is a real and challenging political problem. We can't get around it by pretending that corporations drill for fun.


There is no oil drilling off the Santa Barbara coast. There is plenty of oil there, they just care about different things. I agree it would be good to get rid gas cars, but you can't just outlaw them-- for practical and legal reasons. Maybe have the price of every environmental harm added to each gallon and let people adjust their habits accordingly?


> Maybe have the price of every environmental harm added to each gallon and let people adjust their habits accordingly?

So the people living outside of cities that commute because they can't afford to live there, will now pay that additional tax.


So can I work from home then instead?


I’d take it a step further. Most people don’t drive by choice, but because of the zoning and regulations that create sprawling suburbs meaning almost no one can live without a car. Can’t get to work, can’t get groceries, can’t get the kids to day care without a car.

Edit: want to add the sprawl also makes efficient mass public transportation nearly impossible.


In places with absolutely no zoning whatsoever, people still drive cars, motorcycles, mopeds, etc.

People like fast, on-demand transportation they're in control of. The answer is electric vehicles.


Cars make themselves not-fast by their sheer inefficiency unless huge amounts of taxpayer money is continually poured to the infrastructure. What’s incredible is that cars have been getting even larger, an example of astonishingly perverse incentive structures.


From my experience in the third world with quite poor infrastructure (e.g. unpaved roads, lack of traffic control devices anyone respects etc.), cars and motorcycles are still everywhere.

Some places like Ethiopia have simply switched to EVs by encouraging their import and discouraging import of non-EVs. Now, most vehicles there are EVs.


Yes. Which is exactly the problem. If cars cause traffic jams - never mind their other externalities only some of which are fixed by EVs - then that just means cars are too cheap and their true costs aren't reflected in their price. Cars are a classic tragedy of the commons, everyone in traffic would prefer that there be less traffic so they could get to places faster.


Describe how you think these “true costs” should be imposed. In the third world, infrastructure isn’t generally subsidised. People have to pay for everything. Yet cars, trucks, and motorbikes are still preferred - including EVs.

It is often a huge increase in a family’s quality of life once one of them saves enough to get a motorbike or ebike.


People nowhere pay for the full external and opportunity costs of cars, particularly ICE cars, in the purchase price (or even in fuel price), including carbon emissions, particulate emissions, noise, waste of space, perceived and actual safety, and so on.

Cars are literally an econ 101 textbook example of negative externalities.

Two-wheel vehicles are much more reasonable in all ways, I’m not arguing against them (although two-stroke ICEs are definitely terrible things).


Looks bad

> while Japan shows the highest immigration levels among respondents, this is almost certainly due to the survey failing to reach the native Japanese population more than to any real demographic trend.

So we are admitting that the result is useless?

> despite being known as “a nation of immigrants”, only 17% of respondents from the U.S. have immigrant roots, versus 22% overall.

What was he expecting? 100%? From what I can find, US first born immigrant % is about 16%, so basically within the massive margins of error this thing has, this is a non result.

I don't think this thing is designed to elicit anything useful except vibes & giving the author a platform to pontificate.


Author here, I appreciate the feedback but I feel like there's a falacy here. If we asked respondents if they liked ice cream, and it turned out 95% of survey respondents hate it, would you say the rest of the data is not valid because the survey is clearly not representative of the general population?

The fact that the survey may not be representative on things like immigration or its Japanese audience has no relation to the data's validity on completely unrelated questions such as developer's outlook on AI.


Are you saying that sampling bias is a fallacy?


I'm saying it's a fallacy is you use sampling bias on one factor to discredit another unrelated factor.

If you pick a sample to test a new painkiller, you should include an equal amount of men and women, old and young people, people of different ethnic backgrounds, etc. to have a balanced sample.

On the other hand, you do not need to have equal shares of people whose favorite color is blue, red, green, etc. because that clearly has no relation with how people would react to medicine.


Pragmatism could just as easily be a decision by the public collectively to have more babies. There’s nothing about immigration that makes it inherently pragmatic. It could be, with the agreement of the electorate, away to compensate for the electorates decisions to have fewer babies. But it’s not up for us outside of Japan to lecture them on whether or not they are being consistent on this.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: