HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | antonyt's commentslogin

Being unfaithful to your spouse is categorically a failure of character.

No. Not in Japan/East Asia, or the Middle East or in many other parts of the world (specifically for men only).

And in 1939 Germany advocating and promoting the Nazi party was "not" a failure of character... /s

That's waaay out of context.

Don't compare human procreation urges with nation wide genocide.


Yeah but this is most of the world

Your parents' earnings directly impact how much college costs for you. And costs across the board have ballooned out of control for decades. To me, what you describe is a romantic ideal that's impractical and outdated, at least in the US.

https://graphics.wsj.com/marketwatch/college-debt-now-and-th...


I'm well aware of the current situation. Costs are ballooning out of control -- not because affordable options don't exist -- but primarily because children are being told to go to college, and given blank checks in the form of loans, but are not being prepared to plan their own financial future. College should not be treated as high school 2.0 with a blank check.

The average price of attendance is being inflated because the average student is picking a school first and then burdening themselves and their parents with whatever gigantic loans it takes. Kids are picking a school based on campus tours or social pressures, but on the first day of class they still couldn't tell you how much it's costing them to go there. They are underprepared to begin with.

There are affordable 4-year schools if you are prepared and shop around. The US has more scholarship opportunities than anywhere else in the world if you are prepared in advance to get them. There are expensive programs that are worth financing. And there are dirt cheap 2 year options that are still affordable today, on an hourly wage income.

But there are also plenty of stupid decisions that are possible to make when buying a higher education, and the system is not set up to prevent you from shooting yourself in the foot.

If a student can't say what they want to study, why they want to study it, and how they're going to pay for it -- they probably aren't prepared to be making the decision to attend. Unfortunately, too many parents are uncomfortable accepting this transition of responsibility in life and pressure them to "just try it". Signing the loan docs are easy enough, and that's the recipe for disaster.


I have no doubts you're right, but got any examples? Just curious to see them.


It's a wide spectrum. It absolutely can mean "if Samsung has a bad day my house becomes uninhabitable."

But speaking as somebody also using Home Assistant, I'd bet the author has everything set up without internet access, fully locally controllable, and entirely operable the old fashioned way if Home Assistant goes down.


Not OP, but it's the "as if I were an expert" part that rankles. It's fine to share your experiments and learning projects, but frame them as such. Some writers present their imperfect weekend experiments as if they're doing us a favor by giving out their genius for free.


Sometimes it's very easy to be confident about your expertise if you are not aware of all the complexities of a problem (See programmers and their assumptions about names and dates). So my point is a bit that it's very hard to judge that and I'd rather have someone share their learnings on their personal blog without hesitation and feeling the need to gate-keep blogging.


> I'd rather have someone share their learnings on their personal blog without hesitation and feeling the need to gate-keep blogging.

I understand what you're saying, but often well-written articles end up getting passed around and relied upon as if they were well supported documents. I don't know if it's as common now, but the Rails community went through waves of fads as someone wrote an article and then everyone read it, and started following what it said, when often it wasn't good advice in the first place.

It got the point where, if you looked at an old enough codebase, you could get a rough sense of how old some code was by looking at whatever fads it contained, and look back to see when that coding quirk was popular.


Nobody in this conversation is trying to discourage people from sharing their learnings. They are trying to encourage people to do it better.


By investors. OpenAI and Anthropic are not profitable (Anthropic is profitable if you allow them to invent what profitability means).


I heard someone calling the key metric in Anthropic financial reports EBBT: Earnings Before Bad Things[1] :-)

[1] Where "Bad Things" would be the typical interest, taxes, depreciation, amortisation plus the Anthropic specific employee compensation, LLM training (you know, for the LLM lab), revenue sharing agreements (which is a form of paying for infrastructure), etc.


A recent YouTube video by Patrick Boyle said the same thing. They are only profitable if you ignore all the costs that make them unprofitable such as paying employees and developing A models.


That's not how gross margin works.

For LLMs, marginal cost is just electricity


I made a statement about whether Anthropic was profitable I don't understand your reply.

Assuming you meant to reply to me and not someone else are you saying under GAAP accounting standards Anthropic is a profitable business because under GAAP accounting their only expense is electricity?

(I see what happened you skimmed the conversation and didn't follow what was being discussed.)


1. And that marginal cost is large, much larger than the marginal cost of serving a Google Search query

2. The marginal cost is electricity until the hardware overflows. So it's continuous for electricity and a step function for hardware capacity.

Plus you don't address the core point. Frontier AI is capital intensive. A lot more capital intensive than regular software. The existing clouds supporting the entire internet (!!!!) were built for a fraction of the cost of AI infrastructure, and there isn't even an end in sight to this continuous hardware investment.

Let alone hardware refresh cycles.

AI is basically investment into roads.

Software used to be a magical place, closer to selling music albums but even better.

AI is a much worse business margin wise than regular software.


There's also things like training costs, spend on AI data centres and GPUs, R&D, sales and marketing, etc. See e.g. https://www.reuters.com/business/finance/anthropics-ipo-pros....


Those are not marginal cost or unit economics


If the "fixed costs" kill you unit economics won't save you. Scare quotes because true fixed costs generally have a long shelf life. Right now AI models die every 6-9 months.


Investment is not a subsidy. Words still have meanings. Nobody in this thread has successfully answered the question: subsidized by whom?

Non-punishment is also not a subsidy; again, words have meanings. Let's use the correct words.


Indirect subsidies are an accepted economic concept and well studied. The posts you replied to are obviously talking about indirect subsidies and dismissing them because they didn't say "indirect" everywhere is just sophism.


But some investments are subsidized (tax liabilities) among all the other things.


A critique of OpenAI from an insider who worked there can only come from an insider who worked there. Nobody’s going to swear a vow of poverty and then work at one of these places.


You don't need to be an insider to make any of the author's assertions. An insider is useful if they're a whistleblower, when they're saying what everyone else is seeing and saying (and they hired a PR firm to do it) it's something else.


The number of people with PHDs longing for tenured positions comically dwarfs the number of tenured positions available.


These are not contradictory statements to me. Even if I don't anthropomorphize LLMs, the damn things anthropomorphize themselves and I have to deal with it. "Posing" is the key word.


I think this boils down to how it can be tough to tell the difference between:

1. I speak about it as if it were a person because I have embedded some beliefs and expectations which are wrong.

2. I speak about it as if it were a person just because that's just how the English language works when describing complicated things.

Similarly, the faceless mannequin in the clothing store "poses" as a person, and even "beckons" customers with an outstretched arm, yet nobody on the sidewalk is confused or falls in love [0] with the mannequin.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mannequin_(1987_film)


These are students aged 12-18. Even if we ignore all the other negative externalities of AI and assume it will be ubiquitous and cheap, kids need repetition and exercises to make inferences and develop intuition.

Sure - you can ask AI to, for instance, calculate how much money you'll have given a fixed principal and a compounding interest rate. But we need to get a kid to the point where they even understand what the question to be answered is. If they're using AI all along the way, they are developing less understanding of what fractions and exponential growth are.

Will it stop the really smart and motivated kids? Of course not. But at population scale there will be big consequences.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: