HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | anramon's commentslogin

I'd think there are a LOT of interest behind closed door wanting to shut down projects like proton.


Proton collaborates with spy agencies. They want it to have more of the users who aren't using Gmail.


Every company has to collaborate with spy agencies. Majn difference vs. Gmail or most others is for email and files Proton have no information to give except the IP you used (really hard for users to mask), and they seem to deny VPN activity logs 100% of the time.

If you're a criminal that has nation state actors after you I'm not sure what service I'd recommend. For most every other person Proton is way more than private enough.

https://proton.me/legal/transparency

I think I'm with some of the other commenters in that there seems to be an oddly smelling smear campaign against them right now.


For non proton to proton messages, they can view the entire message that is sent and can store it or whatever. You cannot rely on some transparency report since there are gag orders and what not.


> We name the model in the title because our customers need to know which of our endpoints was affected

Then you would used "endpoint" instead of "model". In fact, there's actually zero reasons to put any model or endpoint in the title if the bug is yours alone.


>run them enough times and at least one instance will do something stupid and dangerous

Which is exactly what they did.


Except the conclusion from this article is that only open-weight Chinese models are the ones to be concerned about.


The conclusion is correct. Closed models don't need to send your data, since the data is there already.


The US has been falling so hard on its PR and propaganda department in the last, I don't know, 20 years?, that China actually seem to look like the good guys. People forget those extensive news reports, articles, stories and so on about the "chinese totalitarian dystopia" 15 to 25 years ago, now those seem like a joke in sight of what the US, and a great bunch of the anglo-germanic sphere, are doing.


That header alone made me exhausted.


lol


Less than "liberalism" I'd say "westernism". Liberalism out of direct western influence it's pretty much in line with what liberalism is supposed to be.


>this is the top comment

christ


The "left" in the US is center-right anywhere else in the world.


>> socialism defined by worker ownership of the means of production

>Thats not socialism

That is literally the most bare and core definition of socialism.


I jist checked the "bare definition" of socialism and a shiver went down my back when i saw the first eng wiki paragraph

> characterized by social ownership of the means of production

... incorrect propaganda on the wikipedia.

In the german article, its more accurate "there is not clear definition".

Its a familiy of ideas around wealth distribution with many degrees of freedom. Its not incompatible to capitalism, like communism is. I gues the eng wiki article is meant trigger stereotypes with "means of production".


Ah, you are one of those.


Please define or explain how socialism is compatible with capitalism


I already gave one, inheritance tax, since its not tied to economic activity.

When you think the "survival of the fittest" nature analogy of capitalism further, then there should be no inheritance. All value that you have accumulated over your life (nutrition) is redistributed on your death into the environment, so in that analogy, capitalism shouldnt allow inheritance at all.

There are many more options of wealth distribution, which effect more wealthy people than the working class and in small-ish quantitiea, all of them are compatible with capitalism. Again, the devil is in the details.


OK, are you providing inheritance tax as an example of socialism? I'm sorry but your comments are not easy to understand, I want to understand what you're trying to say but it's unclear because your argument is split over several comments that I can't seem to parse.

I want to understand what you're saying if you'd give me a few moments of further explanation of your claim/argument


>Socialism means that the government owns the means of production.

You mean soviet-like socialism. Socialism is older and broader than bolchevism.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: