HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | anotherpaul's commentslogin

Best public restroom density I've ever had was in Japan. Every corner you can find a toilet. So relaxing when you are traveling.


So there's also all the stuff about the wonders of Japanese toilets with heated seats and bidets etc. and I was amazed at how many of what are really low budget toilets in like mid-tier shopping malls, fast food restaurants and rural train stations had the full deal. And how clean they were. Toilets in those kinds of places here are often a mess and it's not uncommon to find the toilet seat missing entirely, so nobody's installing a expensive fancy seat in a public bathroom.

The flip side is if you go off more rural, you can run into the type of toilet that Japanese people consider a "Japanese toilet". Complete opposite of the tech wonders that the rest of the world pictures when they hear Japanese toilet. Because they're pretty much relegated to toilets without much investment at this point, they're also usually much less maintained than other toilets too.


For a glimpse into public toilets in Japan, do yourself a favour and watch ‘Perfect Days’.


Great film with great acting and great music. If you feel you lost the connection to your own life, it might be worth a watch.


And right here (U.S.): https://youtu.be/aRwug4G8JjI


Thanks! I was scrolling for this helpful comment with the link!


Correct order is:

1. Watch Perfect Days 2. Go to Japan 3. Do the The Tokyo Toilet [1] _tour_

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Tokyo_Toilet


My favorite movie of all time. First thing I thought of when I saw this.


Perfect Days is in my top 10 movies of all times - a must watch for everyone.

ps - I learned the beautiful word / concept komorebi from the film: "dappled, shimmering light and shadow created when sunlight filters through the leaves of trees"


Some of the most beautiful English-language writing I've read is describing the interplay of light and shadow under a canopy. This is an area where I think having a single word description is a linguistic loss.


I find having the word "komorebi" to be a conceptual gain. I can more-readily notice this beautiful occurrence because I have this easy-to-grasp concept in my mind.

ps - the existence of this word does not prevent authors from using more words to describe the situation ;)


I dunno, it could be evocative like something like "petrichor" is in English.


Petrichor isn't very evocative though? It sounds more like it should be a description of a scab or something than a smell, and I guess maybe it rains too much where I live but the smell of rain isn't something I have a strong feeling about, it's just a warning to get inside.


Yet no trash cans. It's a frustrating trade off, especially with all the vending machines. If you don't have a backpack, you're stuck carrying trash. If you do, it gets messy.

Also, this does not hold in Hokkaido. I taught English in Obihiro (well, Makubetsu) and you had to plan your trash and restroom breaks.


[flagged]

No one else in the world does that. Nobody.


Most of Australia does that, TBF.

Yes, there's litter in Australia of course, but most Australians are taught from a young age to leave nothing but footprints and trek out whatever they bring with them when moving about a city, a park, wild areas.

Relative lack of litter and glares from Australians when tossing stuff on ground as a tourist is apparently enough to make a number of those daft "10 things about Australia ..." videos and listicles.


You assume we just throw trash on the ground in cities or parks? If I’m camping I leave no trace and pack all the trash out if they don’t have a bear proof dumpster or trash can.

Every single other place I go has trash cans. Youth sport league parks, small local city, shopping areas, offices, and downtown urban environments all have trash cans. Especially if it’s an area people walk around.


Assume?

I made no assumption, I took you at your own word as per your GP comment in which you were quite emphatic.


[flagged]

And I was taught to put it in a public trash receptacle. There is a middle ground here between tossing it on the ground and lugging it with you for hours.


[flagged]

A trash can.


[flagged]

Nobody here advocated littering. What’s wrong with having trash cans, and why are you moralizing it?


> Just the worst people

What?

> Carry your trash with you.

What do you think I did with it? I don't litter.

It's just not at all enjoyable carrying two empty bottles for miles with just my hands while I have other things to carry.


No trashcans anywhere though :)


They're in the konbinis.

Technically you're supposed to wait around and consume your product at the shop where you've bought it, but I didn't have any objections to doing one-in one-out, so as long as I bought a new drink I just dropped the refuse from the last one at the store where I bought the next one.


When I was in Tokyo last year I had cashiers almost mob me for my refuse when they noticed me carrying some from another shop a couple of times.


Many drink vending machines also have a place to deposit empty bottles for recycling.


and yet there’s no trash and the streets are clean.


Patently not true - there are rubbish bins and recycling bins all over the place in Japan.


IDK man, I was just there for 2 weeks in Kobe, Osaka, Kyoto, and Tokyo, and there were so few publicly accessible trashcans that I started considering photographing the handful I saw (2-3 next to drink vending machines, and one (1) large one in Shinjuku's main luxury-tourism thoroughfare) for their shiny rarity. At one point we were joined by our third member, and we warned them first thing "there are no trash cans in Japan!" and sure enough, about 2 hours later, they were clutching an empty beverage, looking around futilely for somewhere to throw it out...


I was there for a month, a year ago, but this is all just anecdata.

It's well known there isn't an abundance of public rubbish bins, but there are plenty that are adjacent to where you are likely generating rubbish (or recycling) - eg. konbibis.

I suspect spending all your time in the frustratingly tourist-dense triad likely skews your experiences of the country. I haven't been to Kobe, but it's doubtless similarly afflicted, and presumably has responded in a similar way.


> this is all just anecdata.

The absence is well-known and described in places like Wikipedia. Also, how many major capital cities in Japan should I spend time in before it's not 'anecdata'? Should I get a sample of another 10 or 20 Tokyos before you're satisfied?

FWIW, I did a LLM research report about numbers, and they pulled up some interesting cites: https://gwern.net/doc/japan/2026-11-03-gpt6astra-japansmissi... Places like Osaka have deliberately removed their city trashcans (from 5000 to zero since 2007, while Kyoto apparently got rid of 500 recently), and the vending machine trashcans are inadequate because they're only supposed to be for bottles but of course pick up a lot of other trash because what other option is there, while konbinis report problems with people using their tiny little trashcans a lot. There's also some interesting dynamics here where the overuse of trashcans becomes the justification for removing them, thereby externalizing all the costs onto people (especially tourists, according to the Japan Tourism Agency's regular large-scale surveys, where a shockingly large percentage single out trash cans as a problem in their visit).

> but there are plenty that are adjacent to where you are likely generating rubbish (or recycling) - eg. konbibis.

As already noted, I didn't see many adjacent to konbinis. (Inside them, sure, but that is definitionally not a 'public rubbish bin'. That's a private one, and we felt awkward just going into stores to use their trash. Similar to using a store's restroom without any intent of shopping there. Some "plenty"!)

> I suspect spending all your time in the frustratingly tourist-dense triad likely skews your experiences of the country

Yes, I expect it skews my trash bin prevalence too high. Because tourist-heavy places should have more, not less.


Sorry, when I said 'adjacent to where you're generating waste - eg a konbini' - I meant the konbini bin itself. So, adjacent to _you_ (and your new rubbish) - not adjacent to the store. I could perhaps have used the word proximal.

AIUI the history is a bit murky, and it's mostly fiscal, but with some terrorism response - the sarin gas, and then other cities having attacks, and bins being seen as a safety risk.

Here in AU we had a famous (because they're so rare) bombing in the 1980's (the Hilton bombing, for the Commonwealth Heads of Government meeting) - about which much has been written. I think about 20 years ago, give or take quite a few, there's been a move to transparent public rubbish bins, and I'm sure the placement, shape, etc of those has been considered by planners with those risks in mind.

A related domestic anecdote - from the same era - one of our more interesting politicians in Sydney set about removing public bins, on the premise that their presence increased street litter (you see people put rubbish on top of a full bin, and it's blown away a few moments later).

Back to Japan - it seems to have been mostly a response to citizens avoiding rubbish collection fees at home by taking household waste to public bins. I don't know if that can be correlated tidily to higher density ~= higher tourism areas?

In any case, while we travelled there, it was rare that we had a problem with rubbish, but we were prepared -- we either followed the locals' habit (eat/drink where you buy and immediately ditch in their bin) and/or we were invariably carrying daypacks so we could take waste back to our hotel.

> Yes, I expect it skews my trash bin prevalence too high. Because tourist-heavy places should have more, not less.

I understand why you might think that, but I would suggest that it's not a universally agreed argument.


> So, adjacent to _you_ (and your new rubbish) - not adjacent to the store.

Yes, I figured that is what you meant, which is why I then explained why it still sucks. What if I don't want to eat something entirely then and there in the konbini I bought it...? What if I have trash from some other source?

> it seems to have been mostly a response to citizens avoiding rubbish collection fees at home by taking household waste to public bins.

Yes, that was highlighted in the LLM report. And is an example of the perverse dynamics and poverty mindset, where an entire society is distorted in the name of conservation, where the high usage of trash cans becomes a reason to not have them. (I am still thinking about the multiple 3/4-star luxury hotels I stayed in which provided some of the lowest-quality gas-station-tier toilet paper I have ever used - a false economy all the more unjustifiable given how little toilet paper a guest would use thanks to the wonderful bidets!)

> but we were prepared

Precisely. I was confused for the first week: "how does this work? How are the locals throwing their trash away away? Surely they don't just reorganize their lives around this limitation, and tolerate things that few other societies tolerate, and let an obsession with litter and recycling run their lives and dictate when and where they can eat or even just drink some water on a hot humid day? There must be some trick or convention I am not getting, maybe some trash cans hidden away somewhere under an unfamiliar appearance." And then I realized, "oh. They do. That's how it works." And I too reorganized my life to submit to the trash planners.


The answer to your first question is 'day pack or pocket'.

I find LLMs pay a lot more attention to speculative blog posts about these things, as they out-number actual policy rationale - in the case of the North Sydney (AU) removal of bins, there's surprisingly few resources still surviving (or at least indexed) outside of newspaper interviews, and so I'm not convinced we have access to the full set of motivations and results analysis.

I suspect the Japanese motivation is cleaner, as I noted, and you have also concluded.

I spent a fair bit of time on /r/JapanTravelTips as part of our planning - it's probably the third or fouth most talked about topic there, after 'where to eat in Tokyo' (sigh), and how to use a fast train.

In any case, daypacks are the answer to many challenges, including this one.


Personal anecdote, but I lived in Okinawa for two years, and can state that I _never_ saw a single trash can in the street. Inside buildings, sure, but not outside.


So the claim 'no trashcans anywhere' was patently wrong?


Im always afraid of Japanese toilets, will I sit on it as the robot uprising starts?


I think they don't have enough mechanical degrees of freedom to hurt you. The nozzle can only move forward / back. The seat and hot air blower could overheat and set your house on fire, but nothing could keep you on the toilet while they do that.


March 2025?


On my phone I can't scroll there. I left again


Me too, I just want to read my emails sometimes. And it works.


Actually aging research is probably really well funded in comparison. Loads of billionaires are investing. So at least money is not the issue. Morals and time. Sure, and then regulators.

One big thing with aging research is though that it just needs time. No shortcuts really. You don't know it works until the first people love another few years.


Neither is open access. A sad state of affair in 2026



StreetComplete is great. For me it made Openstreetmap much more approachable and now thanks to me there are a few more public toilets and one small road in osm. Especially with the road it was really interesting to see how quickly Google maps also took in this path. But they still also have the old road in the app. So it's linked but not 100%


I gave up pandas in favor of polars after someone at work did the same and I am very happy with it. Pandas API is just so much worse and much slower.


Have Polars' inconsistent versioning policy caused you any problems?


What's inconsistent about their versioning?


totally agree, businesses that only have Facebook or Instagram are basically hidden from me. I can not see their opening hours, nor the menue, if it is a restaurant. I understand why the businesses use facebook, its easy, but its also a bit sad.


This content is geo/IP fenced


Hope this helps:

https://archive.ph/SQQ97


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: