HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | anonymous_sorry's commentslogin

As a humanist I abscribe all those important qualities you list to a person's humanity.

On the other hand, the word "person" is somewhat diminished by the existence of the term "legal person", which may include abstract entities with inhuman qualities.


It is a rather odd control. Is it just to confirm that Claude isn't reading the sequence off disk?

Perhaps. They explain why:

> Shuffling keeps the letters and destroys their order, so the difference in accuracy measures what the model knows about the sequence itself.

So by analogy, if you know a word in English starts with 'Q', you could reasonably predict the next letter would be 'u'. By shuffling, you might encounter the letter Q later on, and not successfully predict a 'u'.

Put another way, the shuffled sequences can only use frequency analysis for prediction, while the unshuffled ones have local and global order signals.


Yes but what is the source of truth for the next element of a shuffled sequence?

For a natural sequence, the observed molecule in nature is the source of truth.


We are definitely going beyond the borders of my understanding of sequences here, but I would guess the source of truth is just the expected frequency distribution of amino acids? So 'G' (glycine) is most frequent, and something like 'W' (tryptophan) is least frequent (dependent on organism?).

However I thought the point was that the _difference_ between the shuffled prediction and the unshuffled is the measure here. So shuffled is the baseline, and the gap above that is how good the prediction is.


Prion "replication" seems rather different from self-replicating RNA.

Isn't the building block that a prion requires to create a copy of itself essentially a chemically almost-identical protein that is just folded differently?

How about an alternative analogy of the prion folding pattern spreading through chemically-similar molecules like a meme through a population of similarly conditioned brains?


Yes, I agree and that is why I mentioned that there are limitations. It really depends how one interprets "replication" and that the ingredients needed to self-propagate are to be considered valid building blocks for the beginning of life or not. As far as I know, RNA would use nucleotides and prions similar already existing complex proteins. It seems that the RNA hypothesis is more plausible. However, I just found out that there's some that actually believe that life started with prions and not RNA since proteins are more stable. Although

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K0K-pMPFzGY

I like your analogy memes and prions need an already existing condition and then twist them into something else. If we are allowed to enter the philosophical domain, it's like the devil's work twisting the mind of the righteous or the Sith turning the force-sensitive beings :-)

Sorry, I went off the rails.


It looks like low earth orbit is a limited resource. Is it?

If so, do Starlink and others pay rent? Should they (to ensure efficient use of the resource)?


LEO will be worthless soon enough.

https://outerspaceinstitute.ca/crashclock/


Technically it is a limited resource, since there is only a finite volume. But we're nowhere near close to any notion of it being "full." Efficient rent would be approximately zero.


Full no it's far from that but because these things are going criss cross with kinetic energy it's like a cross fire. The bullets don't occupy a significant amount of space but you won't find anyone happy to walk through it.


To whom would they pay 'rent'? What would be done with the money?

Don't go there, it leads to nothing but more waste, abuse and corruption. If it becomes necessary there can be some form of arbitrage in how LEO is used, we're not there yet though. Maybe something like the auctions for bandwidth for mobile operators but again, where does the money go? If institutionalised it will just turn into another slush fund for whatever interests, many of them corrupt or nonsensical, to drain.


> like the auctions for bandwidth for mobile operators but again, where does the money go?

Doesn't matter. The entire point is price discovery and fair allocation. Once the resource has initially been allocated, you can allow resales, but without an auction, how would you determine the initial price?


> Doesn't matter

That's how you end up with the untold amount of waste and fraud in government everywhere. It does matter where the money ends up because otherwise it will be wasted and/or swindled away.

As said we're not there yet w.r.t. the need for such measures, the interesting photo notwithstanding. There is time enough to prepare for the eventuality that such measures are needed which also gives time to define a price point based on e.g. the revenues and profits achieved by those using LEO for their operations. The same was done for bandwidth auctions - and I have no idea where that money goes - so it can be done again here if and when needed.


If the primary purpose of the auction is to make sure the resource gets allocated to the entity that sees the most value in it, this mechanism still works regardless of whether the money goes to the most evil person/entity you can imagine or to the charity of your choice.

Of course I'd rather it go to something useful to society too, but I hope it's clear how that's a different conversation.


Man, the '75 hit just grabs me from the very first note. The funky rhythm, those fun synthy parps... everything is just so much more compelling, more human, more catchy. Apart from anything else, the Mars-Gaga thing sounds mushy in comparison.


The policy part is already in place

> Please don't put generated text in HN posts. Write your text yourself—HN is for sharing between humans. For the same reason, please don't automate posting.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html


Perhaps LLM users who are open and happy to enable reader choice could label AI-assisted writing as such.


> IBM is now just a consultancy.

Except that they own Red Hat


You may be weak in the face of marketing claims if you're exhausted, tired, distracted, or have insufficient understanding to question them. You fall back on a subconscious availability heuristic - "I'm always hearing about this thing, that has to be some kind of social proof that it's good".

You have the strength to resist misleading marketing if you have sufficient resources, experience, learning, energy and/or spare mental cycles.

I know my decision-making capacity is certainly affected by things like this. Sometimes I have limited capacity and I reasonably prioritise other concerns.


I do mostly agree with you, but...

> Creating new humans is easy

If you did a survey I suspect agreement with this statement would be rather bimodal.


That's fair. It starts easy, then gets difficult.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: