HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | anonym29's commentslogin

I love the work Signal has done to bring E2EE to the masses. I've donated to Signal. I've evangelized for Signal. I've been an enthusiastic user since it was TextSecure and RedPhone.

But I really hope Signal knows it comes across as disingenuous and hypocritical to insist they're serious about protecting user privacy while routing every push notification through a service offered by a documented NSA partner (Google Firebase). This is a huge metadata leak to the adversary that motivated TextSecure to be created in the first place.

I appreciate the accessibility to "normie" users, but give power users the option to set up their own UnifiedPush distributor, the way Molly does.


That's why you use FLOSS and not commercial / encumbered code.

On the concern about literacy and numeracy rates declining: AI is one small factor among many larger ones. At least in the US, this decline has been occurring for decades. "No Child Left Behind", however well intentioned, ultimately resulted in coursework being gradually watered down further, and COVID causing an attendance gap was an idiosyncratic implosion of literacy rates for the generations that missed that time in classrooms: in the immediate aftermath, 8th graders averaging a 4th grade reading level. AI is, in all likelyhood, contributing, but there is no controlled study where AI was added to an environment that wasn't already in a freefall of literacy and numeracy rates to begin with, so we can't assign causation to it cleanly.

Counterpoint: if programmers wrote programs the way structural engineers designed buildings, ecommerce apps would take half a decade to build and the software industry would have just gotten around to inventing Windows Vista and jQuery in the last year or so.

Maybe that's okay.

If you're saying e-commerce would simply be consistent and secure product catalogs with fewer promotional and tracking dark patterns, web scripting would rely on a and extensible and functional library for manipulating markup documents, and a stable OS kernel with few dark patterns and no cloud accounts, many of us would be sold in a heartbeat.

I don't think you're making the counterpoint you mean to be.


Don't be naïve - the industry wouldn't be any less laden with surveillance crapitalism; the presence of that isn't a product of the pace of development, it is a product of the nature of consumers to eagerly suffer limitless abuse so long as the product "just werks", looks/feels polished, and doesn't require any kind of learning or discomfort.

Freedom from everything you enumerated already exists for anyone who cares enough to pursue it - robust ad and script blockers, operating systems with no coercion or user hostility, simple and stable scripting languages. They're not as polished as the products of manipulative and extractive abusers like Microsoft, Google, Apple, Discord, et al., and accordingly, users shun them, for the reason I explained above.


> it is a product of the nature of consumers to eagerly suffer limitless abuse

Ah, there's the victim blaming.

> Freedom from everything you enumerated already exists for anyone who cares enough to pursue it

Do you have any idea how daily life is for non-technical people? It isn't reasonable in our society to expect everyone to switch to FOSS, and blaming 60 year olds for getting their identity stolen because they weren't using a Linux phone or rolling their own self hosted matrix chat server is such a cruel and unbelievably out of touch take.


Hey, if the option is on the table for states to fight back, up and including enacting the corporate death penalty (forced dissolution) against Microsoft, Alphabet, Meta, Apple, etc, I'm all for that.

That would never happen though, the victims would plea and fight too vigorously in defense of their own abusers.

Who should be blamed for the actions of corporations ultimately subject to the society-scale approval of their consumers? No amount of misbehavior, malice, negligence, or abuse from the company can alienate the modal user of their products, they've thoroughly demonstrated this too many times to count.

It's not the doddering elderly folks I blame the most, it's everyone younger than them, the folks who grew up with the technology, aware of every abuse by these companies, who refuse to change their behavior. The ones who know better. The ones who can explain to you in great detail all about the surveillance, the dark patterns, the emotional manipulation, the extractive commercial angle, and who all refuse to adjust their behavior anyway. It's a choice, and it's one they make on a continual basis.

And to answer your question, no, I don't have much of an idea how daily life is for non-technical people besides them voluntarily suffering abuse like theft of their time (advertisements), or voluntarily paying a bribe to avoid the abuse, for no real reason other than that they don't care enough about the abuse or the bribe to spend 5 minutes learning how avoid both for free for the rest of their life.


> And to answer your question, no, I don't have much of an idea how daily life is for non-technical people

This is very clear. You're incredibly disconnected from how most people in society operate, their motives, and capacity.

And your malice and contempt is entirely misplaced.


You seem confused.

malice /măl′ĭs/ noun

1. A desire to harm others or to see others suffer; extreme ill will or spite.

2. The intent to commit an unlawful act without justification or excuse.

3. An improper motive for an action, such as desire to cause injury to another.

None of the above apply to me. I don't want to harm or injure anyone, and I don't want anyone to suffer. Consumers choose suffering and choose to voluntarily accept harm and injury, and I wish they wouldn't.

But you can't force people to not harm themselves, it's something they have to choose for themselves. Anyone who's ever lived with or loved an alcoholic or drug addict understands this. The contempt isn't for the person, it's for the theft of the person's faculties. The response to the person being unwilling to change is frustration with their choices, not contempt for the human being.


Hmmm but that software would also last a century so… your point? Moving fast and building unstable software isn’t really that great.

>I can't state my disdain enough for the rabid, careless advancement of AI, and all the bros that keep telling me to catch up or fall behind, while they are actively causing harm to the hundreds of thousands, or millions of users they have, without care or consideration.

Have you ever considered that the people who are pro-AI are not a monolith, and that it can be simultaneously true that you should absolutely be learning how to effectively and safely use LLMs in engineering workflows, while it is also true that there are people who are using them very unsafely?

Beig opposed to learning how to use AI correctly because some people use it recklessly is like being opposed to learning AWS in 2015 because some people left sensitive data in open S3 buckets.

Do not confuse negligent misuse of the tool for the value proposition of the tool itself.


Re-read my post before quoting it and getting defensive. I'm not anti-AI, I use Claude daily, partly because that's all the industry is now, partly because it can be an amazing tool.

I'm furious about slop-shovelling profit-driven development that actively causes harm to people. And the lack of care for, or outright disdain of customers, specifically fuelled by a misuse of AI, and the people telling me to get used to this, the people telling me to stop reading my own PRs, the people telling me this is just how it is now. When we all know that doesn't have to be true.


Just bide your time until there are some absolutely catastrophic breaches like what is happening in Japan right now on a daily basis, and then people and legislators will slowly start demanding accountability.

I just don't see any grassroots movement advocating for responsible software development winning out with a demographic that can't even unionize for their own self benefit.

There is no part of me that believes people will fundamentally do the right thing without an incentive to do so (money) or punishment (fines, jail). There won't be action until there is so much suffering that governments can no longer ignore it.


Yeah, makes sense.

Only counterpoint is we have very well functioning unions in Norway for engineers.

But yeah, I don't see grassroots movements winning anywhere. Not even here.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Norwegian_Society_of_Engineers...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tekna_(Norway)


>People intuitively like the idea of reducing inequality and hate the idea that the fact they make less money than the other guy might be entirely rational.

Mediocre and average employees like the idea of reducing inequality, because the mediocre employees stand to financially benefit and the average employees can expect little to no change in compensation while reaping emotional rewards.

For highly paid employees (high impact, high competence, whatever the reason), reducing inequality goes against their direct financial interests. Inequality gets reduced by dragging their compensation down, not increasing everyone else's.


> For highly paid employees (high impact, high competence, whatever the reason), reducing inequality goes against their direct financial interests. Inequality gets reduced by dragging their compensation down, not increasing everyone else's.

Speaking as someone who's been a super high performer in some roles, and a terrible performer in others, I definitely want to reduce inequality.

Like, it's entirely unfair that I (because I negotiate well) get better options than others. If you want to pay someone outside of band, give them a different title.

If someone performs unexpectedly well, give them a bonus/promotion etc.

It's deeply sad (but unsurprising) that so many people can only focus on their particular benefit (especially when the vast majority of that benefit is context dependent).

Like, if you hired John Carmack or Fabrice Bellard and just told them to take tickets, they'd probably be an average performer at best. If you told them never to take initiative, they'd perform badly. So lots of performance is dependent on context, there are very few "good" employees in a vacuum.


> it's unfair that I (because I negotiate well) get better options than others

No its not. This is a skill that is useful when exchanging value with other entities (the basis of the economy). You're being compensated for having that skill.

Would you hire a salesperson or head of procurement or media buyer with bad negotiation skills? How about a developer who can't properly negotiate with teams demanding their time to properly allocate themselves where needed?


>Speaking as someone who's been a super high performer in some roles, and a terrible performer in others, I definitely want to reduce inequality. Like, it's entirely unfair that I (because I negotiate well) get better options than others.

Then give your money to people who don't negotiate as well. In practice, you don't: your revealed preference speaks louder than your stated preference does.


Wanting to live in a better society should not preclude me from doing better in this one.

And the transaction costs on such an approach would be too large, as I'm sure that you know.

M I note that you don't address the notion of context dependent high performance.


Just because someone is 'good' at negotiating higher comp in the interview process, doesn't mean that will have an high impact on the business.

As an EM, a person's current salary is an anchor. If someone is paid at the bottom of the band, but then later the company learns about their high impact, they aren't given a raise, they are told to push harder and get promoted.

And then when they are promoted, they are probably at the bottom of the next band.

if a person threatens to leave, the EM (rarely) can magically wave a wand to increase the salary, but they can promise to put them up for promotion next cycle.


If they're truly high impact and high competence they should be able to signal that value in high impact high competence ways.

The reality is that in most industries competence and impact has very little to do with compensation. Compensation is the result of political status games, not demonstrable ability.


Neat concept, but utterly disgusting that Discord is still used as a social platform. Matrix is much less odious.


What's wrong with Discord?


Discord is the ultimate gatekeeper of information these days, and the company behind it cannot be trusted with its user data.


"ultimate gatekeeper" seems a bit strong for a niche group chat program.


200,000,000+ monthly active users is not niche at all, it is among the most widely used communications platforms on the planet. That userbase is comparable in size to Uber or Steam.


Besides being a centralized, proprietary data harvesting operation that has slowly started selectively enforcing mandatory identity verification requirements, despite their previous identity verification provider already getting hacked and leaking 70,000 people's PII?

Nothing says "hacker culture" like voluntarily submitting your photo ID and a real-time facial scan to big brother so your de-anonymized communications can be permanently logged and used against you by the state as soon as a future administration decides you're a disfavored person.


Too bad nobody actually uses Matrix. Less odious, bit you're gonna be talking to yourself.


GP isn't proposing using closed proprietary models over an API, they're proposing having local hardware serving open weight models at your house/apartment being remotely accessible through an overlay network like Tailscale. The idea being that local inference is very hungry for power and thermal budget, so you run the inference somewhere that power and thermal headroom is abundant (your house/apartment, on a tower, or dedicated unified memory boxes like DGX Spark, Strix Halo, Mac Studio, etc) and then remotely utilize that inference from a regular laptop. You still get all of the benefits of local, private AI inference, without having to expend a laptop's limited power and thermal budget on doing the inference on the laptop itself.


Thanks, I had absolutely no idea what GP was saying, it was completely incomprehensible until you published this Rosetta Stone here.


Enjoy.


star graph looks very inorganic


That's what happens when your project randomly blows up through a translated tweet haha


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: