VARA’s developer released a new version 4.9.1 which had a logic bomb that completely breaks compatibility with all prior versions starting on 1 Jan 2027. Coincidentally this was released shortly after Xara (an open source AI-assisted reimplementation of VARA that was fully compatible with VARA over the air) was published. It was the work of a few minutes with an LLM to extract the new tables and constants from the new binary, so he failed to prevent interoperability with open source implementations but succeeded in doing significant damage to interoperability in the community as hams don’t always update components like this in a timely fashion. Poor judgement at best and bad faith at worst.
It’s definitely time for the amateur radio and emcomm communities to move on.
I have a fork of the now-pulled Xara repo. As of this writing it hasn’t been taken down yet but several other forks were so time will tell: https://github.com/anelson/xara
Mercury is promising. There’s also Data2G and I and others are working on our own modem projects as well. It’s an exciting time to be working with digital modes on amateur radio.
>It was the work of a few minutes with an LLM to extract the new tables and constants from the new binary, so he failed to prevent interoperability with open source implementations but succeeded in doing significant damage to interoperability in the community as hams don’t always update components like this in a timely fashion.
In case people outside of amateur radio aren't aware of how weird this is: as far as I can understand, modes like these used for amateur radio transmissions are legally required by the FCC to have complete, publicly available documentation sufficient to understand them. VARA doesn't, the developer seems to actively work against the ability to have independent implementations, and there are reverse engineering projects which, from a legal perspective, seem like they shouldn't need to exist.
And as far as I can tell, no one with any power around US amateur radio cares. Beyond the FCC never doing anything, if I remember correctly, there are even questions on the FCC's ham radio exams that are essentially advertisements for VARA.
> VARA’s developer released a new version 4.9.1 which had a logic bomb that completely breaks compatibility with all prior versions starting on 1 Jan 2027.
Is there more coverage? That sounds downright evil.
I participated in some discussion on a private discord where the claim was made that the developer did this. I reversed the binary with an LLM and confirmed it myself. I’m aware of at least one ham radio YouTuber who has posted a video about this.
I presume it will get more coverage as more people learn about the new release and the compatibility break.
I was very excited to try the new GPT-6 Luna on our internal evals for a cybersecurity application. The 50% cost savings over 5.6-Luna sounded like an easy win.
Unfortunately in our benchmarks 6-Luna uses way more tokens to produce the same result at a given thinking effort, and takes longer to do so. The additional tokens wipe out the cost savings for us. Has anyone else seen this?
VARA’s developer released a new version 4.9.1 which had a logic bomb that completely breaks compatibility with all prior versions starting on 1 Jan 2027. Coincidentally this was released shortly after Xara (an open source AI-assisted reimplementation of VARA that was fully compatible with VARA over the air) was published. It was the work of a few minutes with an LLM to extract the new tables and constants from the new binary, so he failed to prevent interoperability with open source implementations but succeeded in doing significant damage to interoperability in the community as hams don’t always update components like this in a timely fashion. Poor judgement at best and bad faith at worst.
It’s definitely time for the amateur radio and emcomm communities to move on.
I have a fork of the now-pulled Xara repo. As of this writing it hasn’t been taken down yet but several other forks were so time will tell: https://github.com/anelson/xara
Mercury is promising. There’s also Data2G and I and others are working on our own modem projects as well. It’s an exciting time to be working with digital modes on amateur radio.
reply