HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | amoss's commentslogin

Are we doing typos in headlines now?

@dang

Silly typos shouldn't be subject to moderation imho. Let submitter fix it themselves, or live with the embarrasement.

That's some 5d chess

What an odd neologism, I thought. Con-widered, what could that mean? I'm a little disappointed all it means is that w is close to s on a keyboard.

You have to wonder if this part was approved by a qualified lawyer at all. A trade secret would describe proprietary knowledge of how to implement the technology, but would have no protection under patent law.

They also repeatedly claimed "DisplayLink is not a member of OIN" when it actually is, and later when they acquiesced to the cease and desist, one of the actual engineers from the company tried to review the PR to ask for changes. It's not clear anyone there has any clue what's going on!

You're saying I can't use a shell company acquisition as a means to shield certain technologies from my other agreements? Booo

I suspect they know that, but it reads as if they were just lazily tacking that claim on for effect. This isn't a petition to a court, this is just a demand letter. Listing out a bunch of scary damages is how demand letters often work. They don't have to go into details as to the basis of their legal claims.

This demand letter may become evidence in a future case and judges don't look kindly upon lies and deception.

Yes, but this claim is not that... It sounds like they're making an argument about trade secrets, without explicitly detailing the legal justification for it.

You definitely don't need to cite the legal justification for every demand you make in a demand letter.

You don't even need to have a valid justification to make a demand in a demand letter... it is common and normal to make arbitrary demands... they are negotiations.


Trade secrets aren't protected by law. That's why they aren't disclosed. If someone lawfully reverse engineers your trade secret, its secrecy disappears without legal recourse. Decompiling a binary for RE interop purposes is legal in the US.

That is a common misconception, but trade secrets are absolutely protected by law, in most countries around the world.

https://www.wipo.int/en/web/trade-secrets#systems

Now yes, they're fair game for reverse engineering, but that doesn't mean someone can't be mad about it and tell you not to do it.


Why would the identity of the author relate in any way to the correctness of their claims?

The claims:

* The existing exploits don't work. * Reasoning chains producing an exploit have cheated the test.

If the claims are wrong then rebutting them is easy:

* Ask an LLM to produce a real exploit. * Test it.


Humans use heuristics such as credentials to navigate an overwhelmingly complex world. They are not infallible but they are quick enough and right enough that we reach for them instinctively.


Explaining what a heuristic is does not address why one should be used in this case.


and it's often not the right thing to do. Let's say the blog post was from a top social media influencer. Would that carry more weight for you? We should look at the content of the post more than the poster.


Given the usefulness of this to anybody who knew about it between the ceremony and now - assume malice.


If I was to leak a private key for malicious use, I would leak a good key that only I know.


You have almost understood the joke.


what kind of a Culture would that lead to?


You seem to be confusing your quantifiers a little. (Not all SWEs must understand all CS) does not imply (there can exist parts of CS that no SWE understands).


> I think the next step is to demand that proofs either be human-scale or they prove that a human-scale proof is impossible and the machine proof is as good as it gets.

> I suspect that's possible without tripping over the halting problem. (But I can't prove it.)

I doubt that it is. For the language of proofs to be powerful enough to be able to express an arbitrary proof it would have be Turing Complete. Proving that a proof is the smallest proof of a given concept (i.e. there is no smaller human understandable proof) would then be proving the minimality of a program in a Turing Complete language.


oh no that sounds really "fake". nasty word. we are calling it "super intelligence" now. much better.


No it does not, but it does imply that if they broken system was willing to pursue one person to his death then it should fairly uphold the same standard for executives who are doing the same thing.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: