Because they have an unelected government with no limits to the power of its leaders.
I don't particularly like Trump but I've just witnessed the American public exercise controls that limit his power via the mid-term elections.
I have no such hope that anyone can limit what Xi does, or even publicly declare that they dislike any of his policies.
I might revise my view when I see newspapers in China say they've had enough of Xi's rule. Or when some branch of government in China blocks one of his edicts. Or when some rival is able to peacefully force him to step down ignoring his chosen line of succession. I wouldn't hold my breath waiting for it though.
I am of course concerned about mining user data for the above reasons (and that's in partly why I don't use social media and neither should you - have you deleted your account yet?) but with TikTok specifically the concern is that algorithms and content can be used either overtly or covertly to influence opinion in a way that harms our national interest and our democracy (2016, 2022, Woke, BLM, MAGA, DSA, COVID-19/anti-vax) and we know that this is true and a real concern because China has themselves banned foreign companies from being able to operate unfettered in the same way in their country. If for no other reason than it's not fair we should not (and we don't anymore because we forced the sale) let TikTok operate in our country while they ban our social media platforms. Fair is fair.
If Americans decide that an American company has done something bad we just go shut the company down, arrest whoever we decide to arrest, and that's that. We can require that the American company follow certain rules or legislation, and we can take other action as we see fit. We can't do the same with a company that's not based in the United States nor necessarily bound by our laws or inspectable to the same extent.
I'm not sure why folks keep rehashing and misconstruing this. Even this example of Mining user data... is inaccurate and misses the point.
> If Americans decide that an American company has done something bad we just go shut the company down, arrest whoever we decide to arrest, and that's that.
Sounds fantastical. Some Enron guys went to jail 30 years ago, not a whole lot since.
It's not fantastical - we just have decided for one reason or another not to do anything about "whatever" since then. But if we decide we want to, then we'll do something.
The alternative viewpoint which is that our ability to do so is fantastical just strips away your own agency and in which case well there's nothing for me to do or care about since you've told me that having power or our society "doing something" is just a fantasy.
Ehm sorry, who is "we"? Are we talking about Germans or Austrians? No I can assure you mining data always has been seen very negatively in the German post war history. Are we talking about EU? According to HN GDPR always be a pain in the ass destroying the chance of data mining start ups in the EU.
But my guess: post is from USAian who somehow assumes the USA is the "normal" and Germany or the EU are basically the same. Quiet ironic then to complain about orientalism.
Honestly for CAM you absolutely need deterministic output (Speaking from experience, I built automated CAD to CAM pipelines in the past using Python+Siemens NX). IMO the true innovation is the algorithm that they must have built that turns a target voxel into a 5+-axis machining toopath, but that's good old fashioned algorithms, and also getting to a 100% automated CAM generation. Achieving 95% automation is easy, 100% is very hard
There are a couple of mentions of "machine learning", in the parts about generating the toolpaths and connecting the toolpath segments into a continuous path, but I'm still not sure I'd call it teaching robots
The debate will quickly change when we have 8ft tall humanoid robots marching through the streets.
In fact, if anyone wants the debate to change, they should probably build these robots and take them for a walk through the park/shopping mall in various places.
They're already making those, but in the shape of a dog, which has better mechanics. Some of them get beta-tested in... places you can't say here. Boston Dynamics is a military contractor.
I am surprised that no one is concerned with the fact that there is no PC release, and the game targets 30 FPS on consoles. Do they have some sort of financial incentive to not release on PC?
Yes, historically Rockstar has received payouts from Sony and MS to delay release on PC (18 months is the historical average). As to the 30 FPS that was clearly a technical limitation since they committed to releasing on base PS5 and XboxS. With the amount of non graphics workload plus pushing those console’s rendering hardware as hard as possible there was zero chance 60 was ever going to be a possibility. 60 on PC will most likely be an option, but I would expect for 30 to be the default.
I am not a frame rate dependent gamer, but I know my kid is a firm believer in 120 minimum for both League and hero shooters.
For GTA6 I’m realistically expecting a 5090 required to get to 60 at 4K. Rockstar seems to have been targeting 30 fps from early in the dev cycle so I’m hoping they went ahead and attempted to balance out controls and input response to help eliminate the lag higher frame rate gamers find objectionable.
I'm hoping once the dust has settled after the release, they spend some time optimising their engine. The graphics just don't seem complex enough to need a 5090 to render at 60fps.
Even if they don't have time and energy, they could probably dramatically improve performance by just pointing opus at their engine and asking it to profile and optimise. I've gotten great results out of doing this recently - 1000x or better performance in some cases with the right prompt. (Recently claude optimised some well code that took 170 days of CPU time down to ~5 seconds).
> The graphics just don't seem complex enough to need a 5090 to render at 60fps.
I don't want to be too simplistic here bit they do seem like quite good graphics. Raytracing/modern lighting and extremely detailed models are not particularly cheap.
If you look at other triple AAA titles with similiar graphics than 4k@60fps doesn't seem unusual, exempting very optimized/older engines like cp2077.
There's more to an engine than just throwing graphics on screen. I have no inside knowledge but Digital Foundry claims they are CPU bound due to the size and scope of their world simulation so it's not 30 fps because of the GPU or the graphics.
They have likely spent the last six months optimising their engine already. They're most likely still working on optimising it right now. MW4 came out four weeks ago and we were working on optimisations for at least six months before that and still working on optimisations and bug fixes now.
I don't feel a huge difference between 144 and 60, but between 30 and 60 yes, I think everyone feels it, 60 I way, way more comfortable, especially with modern graphics.
And if you're a competitive guy (SC2, CS or even league, probably others) you feel less input lag with 144 (graphically though I don't see a huge difference, but that might be because I play older games)
You’d be surprised. I’m not one of the people complaining it’s not 60, although I would certainly prefer it.
But you can absolutely feel the difference between 30, 60, and 120.
I seem to have a hard time seeing 120. It’s not anywhere near as obvious to me as 30 versus 60, but that may be because I’ve played so few games in it. But there’s no question, I can tell the difference in responsiveness.
Buy a 60 hertz monitor and a 144 hertz monitor, connect them to your PC, and move your cursor around on the 60 hertz monitor. Then, move your cursor to the 144 hertz monitor and move it around. I can guarantee that you will be able to see the difference, and it will be nontrivial.
GTA has followed this formula of selling the game as many console generations as possible. So they target end of life of one generation. Release the same game again for the next generation of consoles and PC. So fans buy it 3 or even more times to play GTA.
PC is usually the final release of the game. They expect it to be modded and pirated.
30 FPS is reasonable for a game like this if the frame times are constant. The Digital Foundry review showed the PS5 pro has essentially 0% variance. I think this is the only console I would consider purchasing / playing on. The base PS5 looks like it runs how people fear 30fps games would run by comparison.
reply