HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | allenrb's commentslogin

Seriously. I was imagining well under 20kft from the tone of the headline. But I guess the need to climb from FL320 to FL380 in 2kft increments fails to grab the eyeballs.

Sigh.


I’ve been a huge SpaceX fan since back when they were failing to reach orbit with Falcon 1. That said, we (the US, the planet) need more than one successful launch provider. Even Elon (of whom I’m not such a fan) has said things along these lines.

ULA went conservative with the Vulcan design before it was entirely obvious how good Falcon 9 would end up being. And then they’re having awful teething problems anyway. I also wonder if we’re seeing the beginning of the end for them. It’s clear imho that Boeing & Lockheed don’t want to make the kind of investment that would put them back in the front row.

If this is a BE-4 issue, ouch. Really hoping it’s something else in the system if it does turn out to be a booster stage issue.


A first stage issue is bad for Blue Origin since they supply the BE4s and have been having their own problems with their variants. But a second stage issue is bad for NASA’s Artemis plans since they just announced an expanded Centaur for missions after Artemis 4. So it’s a disaster either way.

The issue happened after successful separation, which would exclude BE-4 engines from the issue.

I wouldn't rule it out. First stage underperformance could lead to a second stage issue.

This is my suspicion right now. Booster engine cut off was 40 seconds late relative to timelines and stage separate happened lower and at a slower speed than expected.

The timeline was identical to that of the last LEO flight on Atlas Centaur. Which while possible seems suspicious to me. So I would take the timeline with a grain of salt.

Atlas centaur is a completely direct rocket with different first stage propellants.

I know which is why I say its suspicious that the timeline was identical to the last Atlas Centuar LEO launch.

I don't see the same thing on the timeline.

Vulcan Leo 1: BECO at 4:57.1. https://www.ulalaunch.com/missions/next-launch/vulcan-leo-1

Atlas V Leo 8: BECO at 4:21.9. https://www.ulalaunch.com/missions/next-launch/atlas-v-amazo...

Which timeline are you looking at?


they must have fixed it

I think you mean 40 seconds late :-). 40 minutes late would be very impressive!

Oops--you're right, of course. Fixed!

Ok, but all that really means is that Vulcan can't lift a 23 ton payload yet, which is not too surprising, really.

ULA tried to do too many different things simultaneously while filling their backpack up to the brim.


If it didn’t do its job pushing it fast enough Centaur might not have been able to make up for it. So just because it didn’t go boom on BE-4 doesn’t mean BE-4 worked flawlessly.

[flagged]

Agree and disagree. Without getting too deeply into politics (hat tip to Hacker News), let’s just say that while some of Elon’s nature is essential to the success of SpaceX, some of it very much is not.

I used to be a big Elon fan, I assure you.


It was essential, maybe not so anymore. Leadership team is strong.

I don't buy that all his politics are necessary for his success as a fundraiser and risk taking businessman.

I think the left started him into politics with all the threats against him, he kind of had no chance after that

The left doesn’t go after rich people merely for being rich. (You never saw Warren Buffett being hounded.) They go after them for saying awful things.

I seem to remember a fall out with the Democrats when Biden had some get together for US EV companies and Tesla wasn't invited as it wasn't unionised.

That "get together" was hosted in part by the UAW, and Musk's heel turn happened long before Biden was in office; he endorsed Kanye West in 2020. https://www.vanityfair.com/style/2020/07/elon-musk-kanye-wes...

Yes, being a Nazi is clearly the logical outcome of getting some flack from Democrats.

it's amazing how tech-bros and their fans just can't take responsibility, ever. so what you're saying is that Elon had no choice but to fund MAGA, support the AfD in germany, be active in DOGE and dismantle parts of the gov, roman saluting on a stage and other interesting actions because "The Left" was mean to him?

Very well put.

I can see points at which he was likely frustrated by how his companies were treated, and quite reasonably, considering how the success of his companies should have been seen as a positive for America.

This might in turn have resulted in support for the republicans.

But it absolutely doesn’t justify the frankly insane shift to where he appears to be now, in the areas you list. Is it just ego + a bad entourage + drugs?


power corrupts, and he's the richest person the world has ever seen. he's chronically online and wants to be liked. and he's a businessman who wants to be succesful without having to adhere to rules or regulations. (also feels to me like he's not quite neurotypical, which isn't a bad thing per se, just doesn't seem to help him navigate life).

all of this probably results in the unhinged behaviour we now are familiar with. i get the being a businessman who doesn't give a fuck about anything other than himself and his business, that's to be expected of an egocentric rich guy doing business. but the optional political stuff makes him so unbearable to me, i don't care what he has to say, sit your ass down and reflect about the mayhem you cause on a global scale you absolute imbecile. add to this his cultish fans who think he's a superhero in human form and the most intelligent person on earth, just writing or thinking about this guy pisses me off. can't we hype up people who do actual good instead of someone announcing the next vaporware idea cooked up during a ketamine session, ffs.

inb4 "oh so nothing SpaceX or Tesla does matters?", again, the cult-like behaviour pisses me off. of course hes not stupid but to suggest that he's more than a nerdy CEO with some understanding of what his engineers do, ugh...

that got a bit out of hand, sry.


> (also feels to me like he's not quite neurotypical, which isn't a bad thing per se, just doesn't seem to help him navigate life).

Mm.

The old videos of him showed someone a lot more cautious, a lot more often.

If I were being generous, I would wonder if he took drugs for the (reported) downs of bipolar have also pushed his mania into delusion? https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/PaL38q9a4e8Bzsh3S/elon-musk-...

> add to this his cultish fans who think he's a superhero in human form and the most intelligent person on earth, just writing or thinking about this guy pisses me off.

I wish people who are disappointed that he isn't Iron Man would look at how much of a dick the character portrayed by Robert Downy Jr was.


I turned on Elon when he accused the rescue diver of being a pedophile when the guy said Elon's PR stunt submarine wouldn't work.

He said on national TV Elon could shove it where the sun doesn't shine. Why is Elon not allowed a riposte?

A riposte isn't what's being criticised here.

Calling someone a pedo, repeatedly and after being asked to withdraw that claim, is not OK.

People get lynched for such words.


I'm not sympathetic to a man who, on national TV, tells another to stick things up his ass, and then complains about being insulted in return.

People get lynched for the words Musk chose to use.

As in, dead. Actually dead, not just metaphorically.

Ultimately, in court, Musk did apologise. Still didn't pay compensation, but did apologise… while also deflecting blame to an investigator Musk had hired to look into his victim as Musk's justification for emailing BuzzFeed with:

  But in a series of emails to BuzzFeed News, Musk repeated his original attacks on Unsworth — and made new and specific claims, lambasting the rescuer as a “child rapist” who had moved to the Southeast Asian country to take a child bride. Unsworth denied Musk's accusations through his attorney.
- https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/ryanmac/elon-musk-thai-...

If you're the kind of person who does that in response to being told to stick it where the sun don't shine, your culture is utterly alien to the one I grew up in and also the one I live in now.


Both Biden and Trump are regularly called pedophiles. Nothing comes of it.

If the diver had just ignored the jibe, it would have gone nowhere.

Musk gets called pretty vicious names constantly.

He has claimed that calling someone a pedo was a common schoolyard insult in S Africa.


> Both Biden and Trump are regularly called pedophiles. Nothing comes of it.

They have a secret service backing them up because of all the threats against them, and how many gunmen has Trump had get close so far? Three? One of whom shot him.

Do you want your taxes to need to be spent funding life-long police protection for that guy?

> He has claimed that calling someone a pedo was a common schoolyard insult in S Africa.

Read what I quoted and ask yourself if that response holds water.


> Would you do that with your $200m fortune? Not me.

To build rockets? Absolutely. To build electric cars? Probably not.


Eh, great man theory has been argued fairly strongly on either side with plenty of concrete examples. I don’t know if he’s even the strongest example.

Glazing a trillionaire for free is hilarious. He doesn't live in a trailer, he owns MULTIPLE million dollar properties. He isn't some humble down to earth person.

> You don't get one without the other.

Sure you do. Ask a Yankees fans what they think of Steinbrener.


He doesn't live in a trailer

Oh please. He’s rich beyond failure, something pedestrians will never understand. There’s no such thing as bankruptcy when you’re that rich.

Ahistorical nonsense


The wealth came after the doing. Not before.

A space industry wasn't and isn't a place with guaranteed success.

Look up " Tesla deathwatch" for the relevance of that post


I understand it completely - I wasn't going to reply to this because you're...very sure of your perception of what's in my and other's heads, and I've learned to avoid that as I've aged.

My peer reply is concise and elegant and avoids that tarpit.

n.b. it's fine to have opinion X and then peruse sources X, Y, and Z and form opinion ~X. It doesn't imply everyone who peruses X, Y, and Z will agree on ~X. Perhaps sources A, B, and C will have you on opinion (~~X && ~X). Better to engage with people and thoughts where they are than decide what they're thinking and have seen - in a word, humility.


And now that he's got that wealth, "He’s rich beyond failure".

[flagged]

His billionaire parents?

The fact is that failures exist for everyone.

It's part of human existence.

So is success. Small and large.

You may not even have more success than failure.

But if your successes are significant, they overshadow your L's

Crawl back into a hole.

Yes, it's ahistorical for an individual to make money in the launch industry. Peter Beck is a similar anomaly.

See Paul Allen and Jeff Bezos.

Now you can claim he's reached escape velocity if you will (I've seen someone go from $4B to 0 in 2008).

But this is a result of success, not the reason for it.


The real question is how do you build an enduring organization doing complex technical work “at the front row” while not being a cult of personality?

I am not sure if you do, tbh. I’d like to think it’s possible. Having a charismatic focal point sure seems to make it easier, based on observation of the world around us.

Regardless, you need someone to own the vision in its totality for the organization to be effective. Visionary leadership is critical for organizations like this. You can't do vision by committee.

Humans naturally form cults of personality around strong visionary leaders. It is downstream of the necessity of organizing endeavors in this way.


You can have someone smart and competent run a company without needing the cult bit.

Maybe Bell Labs?

Sun Microsystems

In the Gemini-Apollo programs, who would you say had the role of the center of a cult of personality?

It was a bit before my time, but I don't recall or recall reading about any such behavior on those teams. (Serious question)


Werner von Braun?

Arguably JFK.

That's an easy one, it was the Cold War. A race against a time. An external threat is as good a motivator (though I guess not enough for ULA :/ with SpaceX racing past it?)

How about "cult of the vision" or "cult of the mission"?

More doing complex technical work, less bemoaning cults of personality?

Or accepting that cults of personality are necessary, you may never be at the center of one and that is OK?

Because in reality, if you look at any of those soberly, that seems a pretty shitty role to play even if the media circle jerks them its because they use it to brag and that bragging is rooted in trying to make themselves feel better about the low-quality reptile they actually are and know they are. That is not something I envy at least.


> while not being a cult of personality?

Lots of other symbol systems. Nationalism. Us-versus-them.

Good leaders create cults around them. Great leaders build something that outlasts them.


We, all humans, don't need launch provider. We need useful payloads in space and we are awfully lacking in that department. There are plenty of upstart rocketry companies, and every one of them is a viable candidate to become super big and successful with enough funding and hiring deriving from that. The problem is that they have "nothing" to launch for profit.

We, all humans, are still mentally in the age of crafting custom unique hardware made out unobtanium and HP printer ink and manually crafted by the most expensive and rare engineers on the planet. Hell, the "copy" of Curiosity was a decade late and cost more than the first "original" made from scratch. Countless examples like that.

Until the situation persists, it doesn't matter how many struggling "launch providers" are there on the market.


As chance would have it, I know the author personally. It is virtually certain that he has read all 30 cover to cover. It is nearly as likely that he’s read many more in order to pick out his highlights.

And on CLRS, since GP brought it up specifically, that was one of the two textbooks for the algorithms course (which was really algorithms and theory of computation at that time) back when he was a GT undergrad. So he's had a long time to read them, though he probably didn't take all of the last 26 or 27 years to finish it.

You’re right, of course, but I share parent’s concern. Really looking forward to this launch!

With enough inflation, you and I might be worth hundreds of trillions. See: Zimbabwe.


Well sure..., but what might be less obvious is that a can of beans, a tank of gas, a wig and a chair can all inflate at 2% a year while stocks and land inflate much faster.

The way we measure inflation is focused on consumption goods that everyone depends on. It doesn't take into account the stock market.

In other words we could stay around 3% in measured inflation but see ~30% annual equity inflation...

So my point is that the most valuable companies in 20 years could be worth hundreds of trillions while the cost of a can of beans is like $5, not $200.

Zimbabwe type inflation happens when the economy doesn't get more efficient at producing stuff as fast as the government prints money. If the economy increases efficiency very quickly and the government prints money to peg at 2% inflation, the products we consume only increase a little bit while scarce assets increase a lot.

This is why in the time I took a can of beans to increase in price 3x a house increased 20x.


Something tells me not all of that debt is going to turn out quite as high quality as it appeared at the time of issuance.

The mere success of “AI” won’t be sufficient to repay those loans. Many of them only make sense in a world where AI is wildly transformative and profitably successful.


For the magnificent seven, no they're fully capable of absorbing their debt load with their current businesses.


i think it will be


It sounds like you don’t understand the problem very well. Forgive me if that’s an incorrect interpretation.

One way to prevent this type of crime is to ensure that it is never profitable. The downside is that there will be losses until the message is thoroughly communicated.


And a new method is invented in about 24 hrs.

Who cares if criminals have nice things, Id rather innocent people dont die. Most criminals tend to find ways to ruin their own lives at some point anyways. Peoples lives > pieces of paper.

Its like you're proposing a trolly problem where you choose the 5 people on a track to die because you don't want the single guy on a track to have nice clothes.


"Criminals having vacations and nice things" wasn't a great framing, "criminal enterprises continue to have revenue to reinvest in more crimes" is the better one.


> Id rather innocent people dont die

that is one of reasons why ransomware should be being eliminated


Seriously. It’s pretty clear that the new Roadster is not intended to be a practical car for the masses. And that’s Ok. There’s room for a “halo” product in any lineup.


It’s interesting and valuable, imho, to consider that people have always tended to think things are falling apart, and that perhaps now is no different.

That said, all societies rise and all appear to eventually fall. It’s equally reasonable to consider that the US/Western Civilization/humanity might actually be nearing a fall.


I guess if you take a wide enough lens, the west lives in the civilization founded in Rome. There's no political continuity, but there's a reasonably coherent cultural trajectory going back a few thousand years.

Do we think that there is going to be a major break from that?


Something more dramatic than the fall of the Roman Empire then? I doubt it. But we definitely have a potent cocktail on our hands.

The scariest ingredient as I see it is AI. Overproduction of elites is always a destabilizing factor, and much of the well educated workforce may now turn out to be overproduction.


You doubt it based on what?

Civilizational collapse occurs when society runs afoul of its basic contract and cannot provide its foundational services anymore. That can mean starvation, it also is given e.g. in the situation of elites running low on trust. Leading to social unrest spinning out of control, or former allies refusing to play along with political shenanigans.

In order to evade catastrophic civilizational collapse, you need viable and timely avenues for course-correction or adaptation. Those are presently being blocked by the very elites profiting from the system they bleed dry.


I believe it is the ratio of people who collectively do constructive things vs those who don't. Constructive deeds require things like vision, planning, curiosity, knowledge, experience, networking, tools, resources and empathy too

People who lack enough of those req will actively get in the way.

Things like building a house for little Jimmy in it self isn't hard at all. You can also give him some [digital] textbooks, answer his questions and create a position as an apprentice wizard. There is nothing hard about doing that.

Sure, some people will try to get in the way but one unmotivated saboteur vs an army of millions isn't going to change anything.

Sometimes constructive is to preserve and protect. Don't argue with those trying to stop sensible efforts and don't pay them to get out of the way. You put them in cages or otherwise ruin their everything until they get out of the way.

But if you fail to do that and their numbers grow there is no alternative but to wait until they've destroyed enough of the good stuff for them to become miserable enough to change sides. It might take a thousand years but we will build a new glorious civilization and it will sit there waiting for people to stop caring again.

We are of course far over that hill already but destroying everything takes quite a bit of time.


I think breaking the social contract is a symptom. One that produces destructive effects, but not a root cause. It's been a couple decades since I read Tainter's Collapse of Complex Societies, but my recollection of his thesis is societies collapse because the cost of continuing to operate (resolve challenges, keep the various internal processes going) is too high; i.e. either you pay (in resources) more than you get back/save, or the cost of fixing systems it impossible to avoid collapse.


Assuming that you mean dramatic in the sense of a sudden, singular event in time which many societies and value systems were upended, why do you think that was the case for the Roman Empire?


Elite overproduction I think refers to the unemployment rate of people who graduated from elite universities. I think that rate is probably still not high enough to be concerning for now.


Turchin doesn’t restrict his ”elite” to graduates of elite universities.


But unemployment is a more easily measurable metric.

Let me put the question to you: what metrics do you use to verify whether elite overproduction is happening or not?


My point is that any such metric may turn out to have been wildly off in a post-ASI world. Ten years ago or even today it may have seemed fine to educate a large part of the population for ”elite” jobs, but after ASI that may instead be looked at as a massive overproduction of ”elites”.


> Overproduction of elites is always a destabilizing factor, and much of the well educated workforce may now turn out to be overproduction.

If society decides that it doesn't want science, disease control, or software engineering, and gets rid of the jobs those people were doing up until two years ago, and then calls them "overproduced elites" and tells them to get "real jobs" (when many of their jobs weren't even automated, just abandoned at the cost of their output), that is a political decision.


> that is a political decision

But not necessarily an explicit one. It may turn out to be the natural path forward and the political decision is then to not do anything to prevent it.


How exactly is the US a continuation of Rome?


Other than the senate, eagle statues, architecture, philosophical/intellectual tradition?

Not as much of a parallel as people tend to think, but the Roman empire fell apart partly because it was based on the theory of constant outward expansion. If your model, say economic, is based on infinite expansion in a finite arena you'll have trouble.


The European colonies in eastern North America were started by the successor states of the Roman provinces of Gaul, Hispania, Batavia and Britannia. Two of these spoke Latin derived languages, and the other two spoke languages heavily indebted to Romance languages. (Much of English core vocabulary is either French or Latin in origin — 60% according to one estimate.)

Other Roman influences on the USA include Christianity and to a lesser extent Judaism (since the major US versions come out of post-Roman Judaism.)


Are you actually saying that a particular aspect of the Roman economy/society is applicable to something entirely different and completely irrelevant in the modern day?


Western Civilization saw its start in Rome, and continued through the rise and fall of the Roman Empire when it contracted. The core of Western Civilization reemerged in England in the 15th century and expanded again, with the core moving to France in the early 19th century, before moving again to Germany in the middle of the 20th century. Post-WWII the core moved once again, this time to the United States, and after the expansion of the US Empire, we now see Western Civilization faltering and contracting under unpopular wars driven by a long series of self-serving poloticians. Whether Western Civilization can reorganize and expand (with the core migrating once again) or wither and die under the expansion and invasion by other civilizations remains the great question of the present day.


Agree but “reemerge” implies it may have disappeared; of course it never truly died.

Taking a semi-opinionated swag, the core went from Rome to Constantinople, then Venice, then London.


That's fair, but I would argue that Constantinople and the Byzantine Empire was the genesis of the Eastern Orthodox Civilization, with the core now in St. Petersburg (or maybe Moscow.)


If you go that way, then there is definitely a civilizational split between Protestants and Catholics, as well as between Europe and America.

Looking from a Finnish perspective, Sweden and Estonia are culturally closest to us, but Russia is also pretty close. Britain and France already feel less familiar, not to speak of something like Italy or the US.


The USA is the product of the British empire which consciously modelled itself on Rome. It was influenced by various European countries, including England and France, which mostly developed in the Roman Empire's former territories.

The European Renaissance and the Enlightenment both used Roman and Greek ideas as inspiration. You can see this in early US architecture, and the models for some institutions such as the Senate. Some of this was ironically as a revolt against English institutions (even though England and Wales were successors of a Roman province).

The early USA's language(s) and Judaeo-Christian heritage are partly products of the Roman Empire. (Spanish most definitely is, and French is. English is heavily influenced by French and Latin.)


> The USA is the product of the British empire which consciously modelled itself on Rome

By this logic, Turkey is a continuation of the Roman Empire too. See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ottoman_claim_to_Roman_success...

At what point does something stop being a continuation of something else?


Turkey is an inheritor of the Eastern Roman Empire tradition/influences. So is Russia. It depends on your historical influences and political role models.


When it fundamentally changes? It's hard to imagine something else while living in this. The Chinese formula might be different enough since so few in the west can even superficially understand what they are doing. Over there wealth and power are trying to be two separate things.


There was a prophecy in the Koran that Islam would conquer the Romans and Muslims see the capture of Byzantium/Constantinople as its fulfilment.

Byzantium was certainly a continuation of Rome and its subjects called themselves Romans. It all depends on whether you consider the Ottoman Empire to be a continuation of Byzantium or not (there are arguments both ways).


Ancient Greece then?


You are hedging all outcomes


It is absolutely true.

It's also true that as the scope of power humanity has over itself and its environment, it equally manages to create ever larger crises, and it seems like we truly are reaching the ecological and environmental limits of what the planet's life support systems can give us before breaking down.


I personally disagree , humans have for Millenia ruined eco systems, made things go extinct etc.

Fires majorly destructive for example. Humans did a lot of environmental damage with that over the years


Earth is finite. Scale matters.

Present levels of environmental degradation due to human actions far exceed Earth's capacity to self-heal.

People struggle with judging that, after all, at best you get a bunch of numbers and the claim, they would show this (or not). Without actual scientific background, what are you supposed to do?

Human society is based on trust. You depend on "experts" on a given subject to give truthful accounts of things. When you don't have that, society breaks down sooner or later: nobody adapts anymore to reality.

That's where we're at.


We also have efforts to save the environment too though. So I agree it's grim, but it's not all grim.


I don't think there is an obvious contradiction between what you're saying and what the post you're responding to is saying.


> people have always tended to think things are falling apart, and that perhaps now is no different.

What is interesting or valuable about that? I don't think it's even true, but at best, you offer "perhaps". Great. Perhaps, perhaps not.

It's reasonable to consider that you are simply complacent.


There are a few ways to disable/hide shorts. One day I said to a friend, “man I wish I could block these things, they’re insulting to my intelligence and just encourage clicking around” and my friend said “I’ve been blocking them for a while, just do this.” And while I can’t remember what “this” was, it’s worth a quick google.

Shorts are like the video equivalent of snacking on Doritos all day long.


I know how to disable them on my PC. How do I disable them on Roku?


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: