HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | alephnerd's commentslogin

Pressure testing ideas and general discussion. You know - like the Socratic method.

A lot of people don't know about the Socratic method either so this is their first applied introduction to it.

As a meta-comment, this kind of reflexive dismissiveness is why HN has gone to shit. Zero curiosity, only dismissiveness.


I suppose it surprised me that either a) people didn't know what Socratic method was (I thought it was famous and well known), or b) LLMs are pretty good at doing Socratic questioning.

Additionally, I don't even know if you need a "skill" for this. If you just say use Socratic method to coach me in X, or teach me Y from first principles, it already does a pretty great job.


> I suppose it surprised me that either a) people didn't know what Socratic method was

There are always people who don't know something.

Do you know what the Harkness Table, Selectorate Theory, how to use a Taylor polynomial to do mental math, or what TEOLA is? Maybe or maybe not, but that doesn't mean you act dismissive to them.

> Additionally, I don't even know if you need a "skill" for this. If you just say use Socratic method to coach me in X, or teach me Y from first principles, it already does a pretty great job

Then go argue why or why not then, but that has already been adjudicated on here.

----

My point is, if you don't have anything constructive to say - don't say anything.

And if you do, then craft it in a way that sparks positive conversation, not an argument.

Acting dismissive only turns off people who are starting to learn about a topic, and is a major reason HN is increasingly turning into a circlejerk as younger and newer users often quit due to the toxic nature of commenters.


HN before it turned into a toxic, low signal cesspit following 2022.

They aren't.

I've had to create my own filter and HN has finally become readable again. I'm blocking/hiding around 100-200 posts a day.


This may not appear sexy but this is a huge deal. Power semiconductors are critical for most NatSec and industrial usecases.

You can likely live without a new gaming rig. You likely cannot live without replaceable parts for trucks and cars.


>You can likely live without a new gaming rig. You likely cannot live without replaceable parts for trucks and cars.

Bad logic for an argument. With this logic you can say you can live fine with your 30 year old diesel car that doesn't need these new cutting edge SiC wafer chips, and that making diesel engines is more important for national security than making chips, and so on and so forth till you reach knowing how to make fire, swords an arrows as the most important for national security.

Truth is fabbing CPUs and GPUs is miles more profitable than what Infineon and EU are fabbing, and they're just as important for national security/sovereignty if not even more:

Did Infineon's engineers use EU or US CPUs and GPUs for the complex CAD/CAE simulations needed to develop those SiC wafers? Why else do you think the US got TSMC and Samsung to make cutting edge fabs on US soil if CPUs and GPUs are not important for national security? When you need to process TB of live battlefield data in case of war, do you not need domestic CPUs and GPUs?


Ten years old CPUs are "okay" and there are fabs in Europe that could make them. Faster is better, but slower isn't entirely useless and hugely better than no CPU. Like a 100 hp heavy truck is greatly underpowered, but almost infinitely better than no truck.

>Ten years old CPUs are "okay"

Yeah but in a war, be it a trade war or kinetic one, against a power WHO HAS modern chips and can process data and intelligence faster, who has better leverage? The one with cutting edge tech, or the one with "okay" tech?

Seeing how the orange bafoon slapped the EU around with his trade war and received no retaliation that could cause even paint in return, I assume the answer is obvious.

Another point being how Ukraine can beat Russia in drone warfare simply because they have access to the superior tech of all western allied nations despite making lower numbers than Russia which makes more but can't easily get embargo chips.

>and there are fabs in Europe that could make them.

Which EU fabs make 14++nm CPUs and GPUs? Which EU domestic CPUs and GPUs IP designs are there at the moment that can be fabbed in case of emergency without parts or IP from rivals?

The truth is EU is painfully absent from this field. Sure, in theory they can duct tape together some RISC-V CPU and some ARM MALI GPU production on Dresden 16nm fabs, in case of a war, but since the EU never built and shipped a commercial domestic CPU and GPU from scratch in the last 20+ years, it's not gonna be as easy as turning a screw, as it is for nations that ship new cutting edge compute chips every year: US, Korea, Taiwan and to an extent Japan and China. When you've been out of the game for so long, you get rusty and comebacks are slow and painful. EU would take decades to catch up and rebuild this industry in case of a war cut them off from these parts. It's basically another supply chain vulnerability it failed to address.


The eu doesnt plan to go to war, so the strategy revolves around that. They just need to be thorny enough to make attacks painful and then sit behind their nuclear Shield and allies

>The eu doesnt plan to go to war, so the strategy revolves around that.

As an EUropean I'll say that's where the big problem lies with the EU's fairytale idealist pacifist strategy: that its limp-dick approach being the key to endless peace and prosperity, it only (barely) works inside Europe with pacifist liberal equal-minded nations sharing a common identity and values, but doesn't actually work in real life outside the EU in a world where you're surrounded by hyper-nationalistic predatory thugs with imperialistic tendencies who want to see you take you down so that their empire can dominate you, and it ends up affecting us anyway leading to EU being forced to make concessions to these extortionist thugs (Trump, Putin, Erdogan, Aliyev, Modi, Xi etc) who know the EU will always sacrifice the financial welfare of its own citizens in order to pay up racketeering fees to avoid any and all direct confrontations, leading to a slow but constant decline in its global influence and economic prosperity.

That's why guerilla soldiers in conflict areas around the world typically kidnap EU tourists but not American ones, because they know EU nations are so weak they'll just pay them ransom, while they're afraid the US will send some military team or a drone strike and kill them.

The only guaranteed thing in real life, is that (someone else's) war always finds you anyway, whether you want to or not (see Trump's tariffs and his conflict with Iran how much that affected EU economy and consumers). So it might as well find you well prepared for it, which the EU sadly never is, because it holds on to an outdated mindset from the peaceful period of the post-USSR collapse, that was only a once in a lifetime exception in human history, in a world slowly returning to default factory settings, which is "might makes right".

So "better to be a warrior in a garden, than a gardner in a war."

>They just need to be thorny enough to make attacks painful

How did that work against Trump's tarif war? The truth is that you're right, but the EU isn't thorny enough, and that's the problem.

>and then sit behind their nuclear Shield and allies

And what happens when your allies don't feel like being your allies anymore and instead turn into economic adversaries working to undermine your economic prosperity to further their own in a zero sum game? How does your nuclear shield help then? Is the EU gonna nuke the US over an economic trade dispute? Who do you think has more nukes and better shields?


The main reason why guerillas kidnap EU citizens is that the US have a policy of not paying ransom. Which is game-theoretically smart, but gets really bad PR the first few times, and if I knew the people sacrificed the first few times, I might have a different opinion, too.

> I might have a different opinion, too.

That also encourages everyone else to go kidnap your citizens knowing you're a free walking ransome bag waiting to be seized, thereby making the problem worse and increasing the chances that you'd be in such a position.


Obviously. But it gets a few people killed at first.

There's Intel 4 in Kildare in the Republic of Ireland.

Regarding the fabs (well... fab - not good), GlobalFoundries Dresden, and regarding IP, ARM. Or old AMD or Intel designs, because intellectual property goes right out of the window in a war.

>and regarding IP, ARM

Which was the last ARM CPU that's been full-stack designed and made in the EU, that they can pull out of the mothball and iterate on if need be?

Just because you own an ARM license and know how to make one in a lab or university research group, doesn't mean you know how to make and ship competitive chips as the nations that actually do this for a living daily.

> Or old AMD or Intel designs

Firstly, where will the EU get old Intel and AMD designs? Are the Verilog files, netlists and photomasks just floating around?

Secondly, if you need to bootleg the obsolete 20 year old designs of your adversary to fight them with, then you already lost the war before you even started. Which is why the EU lets itself bullied and pushed around by everyone. You have no sovereignty when you're at the mercy of everyone for the vital things you need.


ARM is a UK company, of course they have the IP. While their highest performance CPU cores have been designed in the US in recent years, they also have design teams in the UK and France. I don't doubt that their European part can adapt an otherwise finished design to a different process.

Intel or AMD IP would need to be stolen somehow. GlobalFoundries might still have some old AMD materials around. Yeah, this does seem really difficult - it would be easier and less risky to run x86 code on ARM if necessary.

Lastly, a factor of 5 or so in computing power does not decide a war.


>they also have design teams in the UK and France.

That's not enough. You need teams that have experience and history of shipping complex full stack designs from start to finish, because that's what the US (and China) has, but the EU does not. Thinking you can just turn a screw and have those teams get proficient and catch up with decades of lost experience in shipping complex silicon designs is wishful thinking.

At least the US had enough self reflection and foresight to realize they de-industrialized too much and so have on-shored a lot of manufacturing back, from cutting edge semi to ship building, using their Korean and Taiwanese partners. The EU has not and remains much more venerable, with its only strategy being wishful thinking, hopes and dreams that the status quo and favorable alliances last forever, which history proves they don't.

>Lastly, a factor of 5 or so in computing power does not decide a war.

What about 5x in everything else, not just compute?


Trucks and cars worked fine without them for decades

Because they did not use electric motors.

Now SiC MOSFETs are the most efficient devices for the power converters used in electric vehicles, where DC voltages of 800 V or 1000 V are used in the latest models, which require, respectively, 1200 V or 1400 V SiC MOSFETs.

GaN HEMTs (high-electron-mobility transistors) are the most efficient devices for the power supplies that are fed from mains electricity, where 650 V GaN devices are used for the universal power supplies, which must accept up to 240 V AC on input.


I'm curious about RF uses (esp phased-array radar / AESA). usually GaN is treated as the the best for power/efficiency reasons, but does SiC enter into the picture? not fast enough?

The GaN itself is grown on SiC (instead of Si) for high performance RF, so SiC production capability matters if you want a homegrown supply chain (but you won't use SiC in the signal path itself). Many fabs are on 100mm or 150mm wafers trying to jump to 200mm ASAP.

That's all motherhood and apple pie, but to the GP's remark, why is this supposedly "a huge deal"?

In my mind, it's a process improvement towards cost-effective economies of scale, not a fundamental change in the end product. The PR also mentions Infineon will be "further executing on its 200-millimeter SiC manufacturing roadmap."

I mean nice milestone accomplishment, but are SiC products a major supply chain bottleneck, or can the market reasonable expect unit costs to be chopped in half any time soon?


For now, SiC MOSFETs remain more expensive than silicon IGBTs, even if the difference is today much smaller than a few years ago.

So at any new design, one must ponder whether to use the better SiC MOSFETs or the cheaper silicon IGBTs.

Even if they are more expensive, SiC MOSFETs ensure economies elsewhere, i.e. they enable a higher energy efficiency, which reduces the operational costs for the end user, and also the use of cheaper devices in other parts of the system, which can compensate the higher cost of the SiC devices.

So now any price reduction of the SiC devices is welcome, expanding the range of products for which they will be chosen, thus their market share. The price reduction from using wafers with a double area can be very substantial, not only due to producing a double number of devices with a not much greater cost, but also by improving the yields for large-area devices, because usually the chips that are located close to the edge of the wafer have worse yields.

There already are many recent electric vehicles that use SiC MOSFETs, inclusively from Tesla and this is a market that grows quickly and SiC MOSFETs are a critical component for it, by enabling much better efficiency, size and weight of the electronics, in comparison with the old IGBTs.

I am pretty certain that the new EV chargers that can charge a vehicle in less than 10 minutes, or even in only 5 minutes, by working at voltages of up to 1 kV and currents of up to 1 kA, are made with silicon carbide MOSFET modules and it would have been difficult to make them in the past, when only IGBTs were available.


...Can't we just go back to thermionic vacuum tubes at this point? Those worked just fine at kilowatt powers and megahertz frequencies.

Vacuum tubes have huge conduction losses, i.e. the voltage drop on them is very high at high electric currents.

This is why for high-power switching they were quickly replaced by gas-filled tubes, long before WWII, e.g. with thyratrons (General Electric) and ignitrons (Westinghouse Electric).

Semiconductor devices have much lower conduction losses than even gas-filled tubes.

While conduction losses are much less a problem with semiconductor switches, many of the semiconductor switches have high switching losses, which limit their use to low switching frequencies.

Silicon carbide devices have lower switching losses than the older semiconductor devices, and gallium nitride have even lower switching losses than SiC devices, so both enable great increases in switching frequencies, which has many benefits.

As a bonus, in the future (when SiC crystals with a better quality will be available) silicon carbide devices will enable the production of high-voltage switches that require much fewer devices connected in series to reach working voltages of hundreds of kilovolt, or even of a few megavolt.

Nowadays, thermionic vacuum tubes or thyratrons remain sometime competitive in pulse switching applications, but only for very high voltages, i.e. above 50 kV. Even for such applications they have a too short lifetime, and there are better semiconductor alternatives, except that this market is too niche, so the big semiconductor device manufacturers do not bother to make such devices, which sometimes forces the use of obsolete vacuum tubes or thyratrons.

Only for the generation and amplification of electromagnetic waves in the microwave frequency range and at very high power, special vacuum tubes may remain preferable to semiconductor devices (e.g. the magnetrons of microwave ovens or the traveling-wave tubes still used in many satellites).


"Because they did not use electric motors."

Wooooo let's go back to 1827 for a moment and have a chat with Anyos Jedlik. Or maybe Andres Flocken in 1881. Let's see how they did electric vehicles.

Oh, lookie there, no SiC.


I mean sure, motor control existed before solid state switching devices, but it was also much lower efficiency and used much lower voltages. Power electronics absolutely are critical for the efficiencies and handling characteristics of modern electric propulsion.

A yes, and because the electric vehicles in 1881 were so convincing, we are all driving EVs today....wait

Point still stands - no vehicles electric or otherwise were using SiC until around the 1970s (and even then that was really niche applications) and widespread use wasn't until the 2010s.

Until then, we were predominantly using SiO2 MOSFETs and IGBTs.


You will note that timeline also maps quite well on when electric vehicles started to become viable in the market . Of course battery technology also had a lot to do with that, but efficient high voltage power electronics absolutely are an important part of the equation.

They existed.

I would not say electric cars "worked fine" until pretty recently.


The 2002 Electric Ford Explorer worked perfectly well for the USPS.

I believe the use of power semiconductors in cars and trucks began in the late 1960s with the introduction of diodes in the alternators.

Power electronics are vital for modern diesel-electric locomotives.

That's a funny way to frame things. Do you think Infineon is forced to choose between those two markets?

Yes?! Infineon's fabs and new SiC wafers aren't built for the small feature sizes of CPUs and GPUs.

Making power FETs uses different process nodes than CPUs and GPUs. All semi fabs are highly specialized: some for power ICs, some for RF, some for DRAM, some for logic, some for NAND.


Memory packaging is non-trivial and Europe currently doesn't have players in that space.

The primary players are South Korea, Taiwan, the US, and China and most of their capex in the space is in Asia and the US.


Goodram exists. Last sticks I bought were from them because they are not that expensive now.

Goodram doesnt do packaging, they do assembly.

as far as I recall it, packaging wasn't done in Europe even then

Global Foundries (fab) is in Germany and Amkor (packaging) is in Portugal

I almost forgot abuot GlobalFoundries and I wonder if they could profitably make DRAM at current prices...

Nope. They don't have the tech.

I think some packaging (not necessarily memory) goes on in Ireland

Perhaps an uninformed take, but there seems to be nothing about memory packaging that European industry would have much trouble with - except not having an already existing factory and specific know-how. Otherwise, it seems to be precision mechanics (for bonding) and chemistry (for the materials), both of which are bread and butter of European industry.

There is a lot of tribal knowledge and a huge ecosystem of vendors needed to support packaging.

Additionally, most countries in Asia as well as individual states in the US are giving massive subsidizes to help retain the existing ecosystem of vendors.

It is difficult for the EU to directly compete head on when the ecosystem has largely existed outside the EU for almost 30 years.


How much of that is just literary flourish.

Herodotus was an early kind of historian, in the context in which he was relating his histories he was as much an entertainer as much as a historian so he repeated every fun and weird story he heard. He did qualify the dog-headed men specifically as a thing he had heard in a ironic Greek tone, he was relating an entertaining tale, not trying to persuade you that dog-headed men really exist.

A human body with a canine head. My guy Herodotus wasn’t telling tall tales at all, he was merely giving accounts of some of the very first furry conventions. These “dog-headed” men were wearing fursuits!

That is not why. This is just GS cutting down on Claude Code access to non-engineers.


Welcome to the Register.

Here's the actual memo - https://www.aboutamazon.com/news/company-news/amazon-softwar...


Welcome to corporate drivel. That memo says next to nothing. I wouldn't be surprised if it had been written by some LLM. "Write it in a grand style, like Kennedy's moon speech, but don't scare the share holders."


> as well as artists, photographers, and animators I know who have had a significant drop in typical advertising work with the advent of AI...

Much of this was offshored earlier this decade independent of AI.

The sunsetting of film and art production tax credits and subsidizes in much of North America while the UK, Europe, NZ, India, and Colombia dramatically ramped theirs up meant much of the industry got offshored.

And new media has changed how advertising works. Influencer and guerrilla advertising lands better as it feels more "authentic" amongst consumers. This also reduces spend on traditional advertising and the teams needed to do so.


We are assigned a number of those in AP and honors classes, which is what most Harvard students have taken.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: