HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | aflinik's commentslogin

Does that imply that with enough effort spent on fine-tuning the configuration, other LLM runners can achieve similar results?


Yes.


Can you give me some examples of an actual creative output from a human that wasn't coached into it or random juxtaposition?


Was the creation of writing as such coached into humans or a random juxtaposition? Could all human inventions just be coached into humans (who coached?) or be random juxtapositions?


Special relativity?


People are always using this example because of the "LLMs can't jump paper". Suffice to say - it's not that simple, and special relativity was definitely an incremental improvement to well-studied theory that was being developed by dozens of the leading physicists of the day.


I’ve never heard of that paper - I went to that example because it’s an example of creativity that most people agree required both a deep understanding of a complex and abstract concept, and unusual and creative thought.

Perhaps I don’t understand relativity and its precursors well enough to see how it was incremental, but either way i’ve yet to see anything remotely like relativity, or even anything like more traditional examples of creativity like picasso or van gogh, come out of an llm


Michelson Morley experiment 1887 confirmed that we could not observe frame dependent speed of light (a suggested consequence of Maxwell's equations 1865). Time dilation and length contraction were well developed as explanations for this experiment by 1892 (FitzGerald, Lorentz, Larmor, Poincare).

Einstein contributed an argument (relativity) in 1905 for why this should be the case, which lead him to make important inferences such as mass energy equivalence. i.e. he took existing maths (derived from experiments) and was able to extrapolate it to other cases.

General relativity 1915 is similar. Starting from general covariance (the equations should look the same in all frames, even if the numbers/coefficients change) and his equivalence principle (acceleration indistinguishable from gravity) there are only so many places in the equations where a simple formula for gravity can fit (and there were sound reasons to expect the formula is simple). Einstein (and others) developed several of the possibilities before he settled on the famous field equations.

I say all this because once you realize each of these ideas was built up incrementally by dozens of people over the course of years/decades and was deeply rooted in experimental observations, then it's harder to believe that it is beyond the capacity of AI. In fact, AI is contributing to cutting edge understanding of gravity https://bigthink.com/starts-with-a-bang/ai-first-breakthroug...



Looks like a juxtaposition to me.


yes but not random


sure. but to be fair, I don't see a reason why AI couldn't generate a non-random juxtaposition


How? Either you prompt it with “make me a ____” or you prompt it with “Generate a non-random juxtaposition”

In the first case you are directing the creativity, in the second you can ask for non-random all you want but the output will be definitionally random based on the training weights and the temperature setting of the prompt.


How so? Does repeated input give the same output?


yep


Can you post some links to other similar projects you've seen? I'd love to compare different approaches


I've been working in this space, though with a different goal (deterministic watercolour + ink houseplants in svg) - https://github.com/orta/plants / https://plants-production-71e6.up.railway.app


It seems pretty novel so I'm guessing they only read the title?

People have done plenty with SVGs but it's rare to see human-in-the-loop approaches


Not sure about the exact same active substance, but Amanita muscaria is the obvious candidate. It's also commonly shown as part of the imagery in stories involving tiny people: the Smurfs, Super Mario (it's the power-up that makes Mario bigger/smaller), Fantasia, Alice in Wonderland, and so on.


Amanita muscaria is iconic because it's the shroomiest looking shroom that ever shroomed, but by all accounts A. muscaria intoxication is not particularly pleasant:

> effects can range from mild nausea and twitching to drowsiness, cholinergic crisis-like effects (low blood pressure, sweating and salivation), auditory and visual distortions, mood changes, euphoria, relaxation, ataxia, and loss of equilibrium (like with tetanus)

> In cases of serious poisoning the mushroom causes delirium, somewhat similar in effect to anticholinergic poisoning (such as that caused by Datura stramonium), characterised by bouts of marked agitation with confusion, hallucinations, and irritability followed by periods of central nervous system depression. Seizures and coma may also occur in severe poisonings.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amanita_muscaria#Symptoms


But it has been used for ritual purposes.

In Russia, it's instantly recognizable as a poisonous mushroom - it's a symbol of "danger" that's as obvious as a skull-and-crossbones. Here, in America, most people I've talked to don't even know what it is.


Depends on how is prepared. If you heat it and prep it the right away it makes a fantastic sleep med. If you don't prep it right you get delirious and people can hurt themselves. You also can't take too much or that can also become delerious. I think that's why it never caught on even though it's far more effective than any other over the counter sleep inducing herb or supplement(in my experience)


It's quite beautiful, but also a bit scary that it can pop up all over urban areas on the west coast of Canada/U.S in Autumn, as well as in the forest. I'm not sure if it's common enough knowledge for people to teach their kids not to mess with them.


It triggers for me on trains too, so I think it's just accelerometer + location


I would assume the acceleration pattern of being in a vehicle is somewhat distinct.

I'd be curious what happens when you are in a vehicle that drives completely steady (no turns/acceleration/deceleration) - would it eventually turn off? I guess you wouldn't get motion sick in that case either way.


I've used it on trains a bit and it does turn off when the train is going straight ahead. You might be going 200km/h, but if the speed isn't changing and you're always going forward you don't really feel any force, and neither does the phone, so the dots don't need to be there any more.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: