Government investigations move even slower than corporate investigations. One assumes (hopes) the about to be installed new majorities will do their jobs when it comes to investigating and pursuing the punishment of the various corruption that has existed in this admin.
Yeah and that has nothing to do with Lutnick actually being removed or being investigated for crimes. His boss is the criminal in charge. A move to investigate Lutnick is more plausibly what forces Trump to remove him.
They're both criminals. "Just following orders" is not an excuse.
The point is we don't need a full-blown criminal investigation to remove Lutnick. It's a single man's call in the executive. Or a majority in the House and supermajority in the Senate.
The US Government has become so sprawling and is intentionally layered with so many laws and regulations that the forward path in the US is extreme corruption through the state. It's the absolute easiest path to outsized thefting. Trump is merely a health indicator for the system of what's possible and what's to come. And Trump is a lightweight, a performative clown that doesn't understand the levers of power, he doesn't really know how the US Government functions. There are far more dangerous, far smarter people that do and will use those levers of power more effectively for horrific things. We're lucky the Trump Admin/s have been so chaotic, so undisciplined, filled with so many political weaklings.
The partisan idiot show in the US would have you believe Trump is somewhere between a dictator and the devil. He's nothing compared to real authoritarianism. Trump is gone in two years, the system that made his behavior possible will only get far, far worse. The culture that made him possible will get worse.
The far left and far right will rock the US apart, back and forth. Each side will get more aggressive and more authoritarian as it happens. Their positions will get more extreme. That will continue until one side de facto 'wins' and then proceeds to wipe out the other side politically (acquire enough power to cripple the other side).
The left looks at the levers of power and says: oh but I'll use them for good.
And the next NixonTrumpBush? You only have one choice: leave the levers of power in place and understand what's inevitable to come from it. Or strip the power that shouldn't exist in the first place (eg executive orders as they exist today). If you don't do that, you will get something worse than Trump, far worse, it's only a matter of a short time.
The left is like Gandalf talking about how he would seek to use the ring of power for good. The ring has something else in mind.
> The partisan idiot show in the US would have you believe Trump is somewhere between a dictator and the devil. He's nothing compared to real authoritarianism.
Trump is absolutely this bad and my non-partisan take is so are most other presidents. We kill people around the world en mass and at-will. We killed over a million people in Iraq, two million in Vietnam. It’s easy to claim our leaders “aren’t that bad” when we’re not the people they’re killing. Of course we also have the largest prison population in the world, so in that sense this is directed domestically as well.
You're confusing that I said they're nowhere close to real authoritarianism, and that I said they weren't bad. I never said any of them weren't bad.
They're nowhere close to real authoritarianism. And you're seemingly confusing what authoritarianism is and somehow relating that to having anything to do with launching wars.
A non-authoritarian, democratically elected President can launch a war.
No, we live in a global world. Where the killing happens doesn’t matter. We literally are complicit in genocide. We need updated terms, because our pre-industrial, pre-information age, pre-globalism vocabulary is allowing atrocities to go mislabeled.
There were three really hard parts to creating software for other people.
1) Knowing what to build, keeping the design appropriate, not over-engineering the spec, not prematurely optimizing, et al. Note that this is different from just having an idea about a product.
2) Making it.
3) Getting people to use it. Nobody gives a shit about your software. Getting them to even try it is extraordinarily difficult in most cases. Selling is hard work. This will get a lot more difficult.
#2 has had the difficulty dialed back in many cases. In exchange #3 will increase drastically.
Absolutely nothing has gotten easier net. If anything the total will become harder net, the difficulty of acquiring users will get harder beyond the extent to which making it gets easier - users will trust software even less in the future, and the popular AI systems (personal agents or whatever they end up being called) will reduce the amount of software the typical user ever needs across a lifetime (narrowing the market).
It's profitable if you pay for the rockets. Starlink is a massive business now and it keeps getting larger, and it has good margins. It can trivially pay for the rocket business over time.
... if it pays for the launches, it has negative margins. I'm not sure what's hard to understand here.
It might be the case that once you get enough satellites up and replace them consistently enough that margins go positive, and then you can start paying back the cost of "the rocket business" (i.e. more than the marginal cost of launch) but... it's not at all clear that's even theoretically possible. At least not without launch costs coming down significantly from where they are today, which Starship is not clearly en route to achieving.
Unless I’m misunderstanding something OP is saying that the only reason Starlink is profitable is because they don’t pay for the rocket launches. But the rocket launches still cost money, it’s just that SpaceX pays for it. But given they’re part of the same overall organization it just seems like an accounting trick.
This is correct. I’m not an accountant so not qualified to say the degree to which it’s tricky, but it does add an addendum to “Starlink is profitable [if you completely exclude the primary source of variable cost by burying it into a different business segment].”
The entire "space launch" segment in the red by $1.1bn. Primary driver being the $3.2bn spent on Starship R&D.
How are they "burying it into a different business segment", pray tell me?
If you remove Starship, Falcon launches and Starlink are both independently profitable. And Starship wasn't even used for Starlink until the one test launch this year.
I account for the ingredients as depreciating assets over a 100 year lifespan
It now costs me $5 in labor and $0.20 in ingredients
My margin is now ~75%
For SpaceX, we know they are accounting for Starlink launch as depreciation. We do not know the numerator (the $20) or the depreciation period (the 100 years). Accordingly neither of us know whether Starlink is a viable business.
You are inventing more and more elaborate ways for "this is how Starlink is secretly unprofitable" while we knew it was printing money since 2024.
You can drop SpaceX's launch revenue to zero, fund all of it with Starlink revenue, and the sum is still profitable.
We know "whether Starlink is a viable business": it is. End of story. You better start pivoting towards "but what if future competition" or "the revenue growth is uncertain", because your attempts to wiggle your way out of admitting that Starlink is a money printer now are weak at best.
I have literally been describing the exact same mechanism, which is the actual mechanism that you can actually read about in their financial statements, since this conversation started.
And what is that "mechanism", pray tell? I don't think you have one. Or ever had one, for that matter.
You can't just say "they're hiding the launch costs" and expect it to magically make Starlink unprofitable. Starlink has been bearing launch costs for its entire existence, and if anything, the advent of Starship is likely to make them lower, not higher.
Are you serious? Good lord. Take this article. Go take SpaceX's filings. Ask an LLM to explain how Starlink is accounted for and what the effects of that accounting method are.
It's the "we've got a bunch of rockets lying around... sometimes other folks in the company use them when they're not working for space lift clients..." view.
The fuel would have to be expensed, but generally speaking its impossible to say how unprofitable Starlink is because they don't account for it that way or break those costs out.
When they swallow Tesla it'll be more of the same, and thats the point. Musk is trying to obfuscate the (poor) performance of his businesses so he can maintain delusional market valuations based of vague promises.
"Exodus Communications Inc., which never made a profit since it went public in March 1998, filed for bankruptcy protection after losing customers in the collapsing Internet economy."
"Exodus, which runs 44 Internet data centers on four continents, listed $5.98 billion in assets and $4.44 billion in debts in Chapter 11 papers filed Wednesday in U.S. Bankruptcy Court in Delaware. The company operates so-called server farms that provide Web site services for businesses."
"The Santa Clara, Calif.-based company’s losses increased more than tenfold in the second quarter, and it fired workers as it failed to win new contracts fast enough to replace those it lost. Exodus counted Yahoo Inc. and AMR Corp.’s American Airlines among its customers."
"Trading in Exodus shares was halted before the markets opened Wednesday. The shares fell 33 cents to 17 cents Tuesday and have plunged 99% from a record $89.81 in March 2000."
"Analysts say Exodus, with eight different junk bond offerings totaling about $3.4 billion, ran up more debt than it could handle."
“We sacrificed profitability in exchange for growth and market share, over-expanding in some areas in advance of demand, not anticipating the decline as the dot-com bubble burst and the economy weakened,” Krause said.
"Exodus’ second-quarter loss grew on acquisition and restructuring costs to $583.4 million, or $1.05 a share, from $51.8 million, or 13 cents, a year earlier. Sales rose 79% to $318.7 million but missed analyst estimates. The company lost $256 million on sales of $818.4 million in 2000."
Ten median US software developers cost about $1.5 - $1.7 million per year - including all benefits - as of a couple of years ago.
A frontier AI is at least as capable as ten median human software developers. It's likely well beyond that now. Over the course of a year, would you have to spend $1.5 million to get the output of those ten median humans? No chance in hell. You'd have to spend less than 10% of that.
Then on top of that: the AI is improving rapidly; the humans go on vacation, the humans decline, the humans get old, the humans get sick, the humans take parental leave, the human struggle to adapt, the humans are resistant to change, the humans riot, the humans protest, the humans need healthcare, the humans want paid more, the humans can only work for 4-6 hours at peak while writing software (slowly).
Do you know any humans that are experts at a dozen programming languages? That human does not exist. The frontier AI are omnimaths.
What's my cost as a business to utilize the latest cutting edge Chinese model, renting its usage from the cloud? Whatever the Chinese cost (on their side), I'm never going to suffer even a tiny fraction of that pass-along cost no matter what. We can all appreciate the subsidization going on.
Or to grab a bunch of $200 per month accounts from OpenAI or Anthropic for a team to use?
The calculations is: I'm in the US, if I have ten median software developers, what's my cost? Then versus using AI instead.
The human labor can't keep up. Even if we freeze things right here, and then hyper optimize Fable 5.2 by etching it straight to silicon, the human developers are obsolete. And the future isn't going to stop coming.
I like their angle though - from a societal perspective of allocated resources, how long until we've paid off the cost of building these LLMs? Imagine instead the entire supply chain was Stalinistically tuned towards finding bugs in Linux. Training rare earth mineral miners how to code level or whatever. I think as a thought experiment it's interesting, the answers could translate to an organizational level about comparing labor cost against token cost. What's a good breakdown of token spend vs hiring some new juniors to train up?
HN has become so miserable over the past ~12-24 months because it's a site filled full of highly paid techies living in the deepest pit of denial that has ever existed.
It's all going away. Here's a prediction: HN will effectively die with the software developer.
Is it that dependent on the software developer segment? Why do you expect it to die rather than just shift more towards... I don't know, startup business droids?
No.
It's the American people. They are the problem, they are responsible.
It's many decades of culture rot coming home to roost. The American people are responsible for the culture of the nation. The buck stops with them.
It's going to get a lot worse. Buckle up.
reply