HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | adamnemecek's commentslogin

Also that compute is fast enough to make split second decisions.

Types and zero cost avstractions.


React is kinda shit.


Legit the only sensible person in AI.


This is not something you can hide like that, people notice cameras being installed.


The widespread opposition to flock is unfortunately an aberration. The average person is largely indifferent to mass surveillance, and I think a rebrand has a good chance of working. They'll give it a try either way.


> The average person is largely indifferent to mass surveillance

I think you would be surprised. Now, whether or not the average local politician is indifferent is not the same as the average person.


In a poll of "do you want to be surveilled", "do you think mass surveillance is good", sure. But in terms of revealed preferences, people will happily give up privacy for mild convenience.


"Revealed preferences" are bullshit.

What's really true is that people are, 99% of the time, not actually given that choice. For "revealed preferences theory" to work, the people involved would need to consistently have a free choice between two options. And for people who have had their finances gradually stretched and stretched over the past 40 years of growing inequality, "cheaper but worse" is not a free choice.


People can choose Facebook or to get in contact with people individually via phone, email or visits, but they prefer Facebook because it's more convenient to put a message there and count as maintenance of a group of relationships. People can choose between accepting the cameras or participating in the democracy they belong in and protest and pressure their representatives, but it's more convenient to accept.

It's true there are people without choice, but most people aren't without choice, and they choose convenience.


This is a specious argument because it neglects to take into account information asymmetries and change over time. When Facebook was first launched, there wasn't any widespread understanding of the breadth/intensity of their data collection and its downstream implications.

People initially chose Facebook because it truly offered a novel and improved service, and the true cost users would pay for it wasn't obvious to anyone yet. The "wall", chronological friends-only feeds, etc. provided genuine value, and at that point the public at large were almost completely oblivious to how much personal data was being collected from them (and even less as to how it might be used in ways counter to their own interests). Once they'd fully captured the vast majority of user share, Facebook clawed back value by deprecating the chronological feed, serving ads and "high-engagement" posts in place of friend submissions, and generally ramped up their data harvesting significantly further since.

Most people would agree that the service is far worse than what they initially signed up for, but feel like there's no longer a viable alternative that would allow them to maintain the same level of communication with the people they care about.

Facebook users are not "choosing convenience" by staying on the only platform that all of their friends and family use exclusively. They're effectively held hostage by network effects that were intentionally planned and designed around producing that lock-in effect and guaranteeing that all potential alternatives either withered on the vine or were absorbed (e.g. Instagram). To the extent there's a "choice," it's a coerced choice on purpose.


> When Facebook was first launched, there wasn't any widespread understanding of the breadth/intensity of their data collection

Come on, you're trying to tell me that people didn't understand that when they give someone a thing, that someone has the thing they gave them?

> provided genuine value

Yes, the convenience.

> how much personal data was being collected from them

"They collected it; I didn't give it to them."

> but feel like there's no longer a viable alternative that would allow them to maintain the same level of communication with the people they care about.

Yes, "the pesky convenience is forcing me."

> Facebook users are not "choosing convenience" by staying on the only platform that all of their friends and family use exclusively.

"My friends and family are forcing me."

Despite my comments, I'm not totally against the use of Facebook, but I am against the surrender of personal agency and blame-shifting these comments are demonstrating.


> Come on, you're trying to tell me that people didn't understand that when they give someone a thing, that someone has the thing they gave them?

This is a bad faith argument, because Facebook collects far, far more than "the thing they gave them".


It's true they collect more, but I wouldn't say "far, far more". They get the most from what you provide yourself. That's unless you have relationships that share too much about you.


Did they stop tracking people through their like buttons by now? If not, there's no argument - they're literally tracking non-users on every site they can! Besides Google, what company is doing as much tracking as much as Facebook?

Wasn't it just last year that it became known how Facebook and Instagram apps track your browsing through WebRTC? That alone is far far more than people knowingly give them.


Learning about their tracking web browsing through WebRTC ports from the apps, you have a point on users not knowingly providing that. Still, if you dissociate from Facebook (not having their apps, not being logged on, etc.) then that tracking would've been ineffective. The rest of my comment stands on their being able to leave it.


Why would the tracking be ineffective? How do you know?


De facto no choice is still no choice. A captured market isn't the same as people choosing convenience.


The world when Facebook was introduced: "Oh well, I guess I have no choice. There's nothing like Facebook, so I'm forced to upload my family photos to these people. I'm not responsible for doing that. Let me just find somebody to blame, maybe the family that's already using it? Nevermind that there are alternatives for keeping in touch. We don't talk about that. They're just not as convenient, so they're obsolete."


You do know that there were over a dozen social media networks that facebook bought over and effectively extinguished or merged into their behemoth right ? They deliberately ensured that choices were extremely limited. Any "alternative" that got popular and not under control of another behemoth was effectively taken over or killed. So your "use an alternative" logic just does not compute.


>> alternatives for keeping in touch

Phone calls, knocks on doors, emails, regular meetups at places.


What's typical is saying "I have nothing to hide" or valuing a bit of convenience over privacy and other principles.


You could be right regarding the reaction but how do you know that? What would be the counterexample?


The median internet user doesn't even block ads (and associated surveillance). Facebook has 2bn DAU. And so on.


Eh I think it depends on the country a lot too. The average UK citizen? Probably. Even as someone from abroad, I know the British are widely stereotyped as having cameras everywhere.

But Americans are raised from birth with the idea of “freedom” and a camera pointed at you recording your every move is antithetical to that. They somewhat tolerate it in private establishments like malls and restaurants but not in public spaces.


Axon, formerly known as TASER did a reputational name change. Worth mentioning that they are also a flock competitor, but they are not in the headlines anymore.


They did such an amazingly bad job on their PR. Their best known products literally exist to keep police from killing people or violating their rights undetected, and instead of meeting the moment and explaining why their products should become mandatory, always-on, permanent replacements for firearms or ADVOKATE-style sworn statements they just kind of... pretended that misuse of their products was WAI and ate the consequences of that.


Well put, they had a delicate line.

Those departments buy their products. If they took that angle publicly I bet many departments would suddenly been much less interested in buying/renewing. Accountability seems to be super unpopular (which says A LOT) with their customers.


I get it, but I also just don't understand why they couldn't effectively explain to the police that they were a for-profit company. The police definitely understand that!

Like, when the police were saying "we can't turn on body cameras all the time because it might violate victims rights" the correct response from axon was "we also happen to sell a very expensive victim redaction software on a separate SKU, until you buy that probably just want to let your officers use discretion wink-nod."

(I am maybe unfairly assuming here that their actual intent was to make money rather than protect the public from police abuses. I'd love to hear from folks at Axon if that isn't true!)


They could have just talked out of both sides of their mouths. Tell the public it’s to curb abuse, tell the police in private “we all know what it’s really for” wink-wink-nudge-nudge.

Maybe offer up a few token cases where they caught abuse and the cop got in trouble or something changed as proof.

Nope. You’re right, they ran right into that wall.


WAI?


Working As Intended


There have been news stories of localities canceling their Flock contracts and quietly switching to Axon.


I think word is spreading about Axon as well, I'm heartened by the amount of pushback surveillance and abuses of privacy are getting.


I think that's why they are going to create many subsidiaries with a lot of different brand names. Until those names can't "spread" anymore, because it's too many different names and they often change.


Some of their customers have even asked them to redesign their cameras so they don't look like Flock cameras.


No they don't. That's why nobody noticed the Motorola cameras going up in places where Flock cameras came down.


Sure, but they might tell people: no, it's not Flock, it's something much safer, not such a privacy invading AI camera like Flock.


Looking at things like this

```

let result = try await Subprocess.run(

  .name("ls"),

  arguments: ["-la"],

  output: .string(limit: 4096)
)

print(result.standardOutput)`

```

reminds me that macOS could really use something like powershell (I know you can run powershell on macOS) where you pass around structured data, rather than the endless parsing and reparsing. This is mostly a feature of the shell but you do need some language infrastructure to accomplish it.


To me the secret sauce behind powershell is the .NET infrastructure, which allows much more runtime introspection than the usual compiled programming languages, allowing a lot of flexibility without being too wonky. Unfortunately the Windows team seemed to not be on board with this vision, and thus it cannot achieve its full potential. The objective-c runtime may have been a good alternative here too, but I don't think Apple is encouraging its use anymore (and Objective-C is not the right language for that, neither is AppleScript imo).


You can also access COM from PowerShell, which basically opens up a lot of the Windows world to it.

And both .NET and COM and the object-oriented history of Windows is probably also why PowerShell will never really feel "at home" on UNIX platforms, for better or worse.


They should adopt Nushell! It would be seen as very "Apple"- a brave great somewhat non interoperable user experience upgrade


I was a big fan of Nushell for some time but has the same problems as unix shells. I have this CLI tool that manages a lot of things for me (a big one is downloading and cataloging arxiv papers, it downloads them and tags them with metadata and gives each PDF a proper filename based on the author's name and publication year). I tried building this in Nushell but it became eventually so painful.


I'm sorry, what are the same problems you're referring to? I ended up leaving because:

- it was unstable and kept changing (less of an issue now)

- I still need to know bash due to its ubiquity

- it was worse than python for data crunching scripts (ide tooling + my familiarity)

This was several years ago so I'm curious about a more recent perspective


There is some unstability yes.

For me the larger problems were the lack of types which in practice meant that I was running into the same problems as with bash.



Support for custom types is not there.


So you mean the ability to run a shell from code And receive structured data back?


Something like that yes. The endless parsing and reparsing that you need to do in the unix shells is such a pain.


It's both curse and blessing. Of course it gives you ultimate freedom, but like with programming languages, I personally prefer the guardrails that a type system provides.


We are on the same page then.


It's easy to be dismissive when it's this early.


Dude the writing is on the wall, git had a good run but it's time for something else. Lore is also solid.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: