I don’t disagree that education has a pretty terrible history of embracing ideas before the evidence was there. Whole language is a good example. But I’m not sure how that bears on this particular article. If something Maya wrote is unsupported, point to it and we can discuss it. “Education research has been wrong before” isn’t really evidence that this piece is wrong.
I also don’t love the term gifted - kind of makes me a bit sick to my stomach - I hope the language changes - but over time I’ve found it to be a highly useful framework to identify a certain category of children whose nervous system is on high alert and brain is processing information much faster than they can articulate, often bored, depressed and even underperforming in traditional school environments. The Davidson Institute has a lot of content about these kinds of children, the different ways it manifests and how to support them. Gifted is not always the blessing it implies and we’d do well to learn more about it. Like you, I’d love some new language around it though.
This is not a handwritten piece. There are many indicators of LLM usage, more than I have time to list. The subheadings are the most egregious indicator - no natural writer composes titles that way, but Claude regularly does this.
Edit: confirmed elsewhere, several of the citations have fundamental errors that make me wonder if the author has ever read them. I encourage you to spend more time reviewing the things you publish
The author does specify that it is not a diagnosis in the article. I chose to publish the piece because I was discussing my own sensitivity around rejection to this friend and colleague and she shared this piece with me. I found it very helpful and thought some of the parents I work with would benefit from the tips. Personally, I think it’s useful to understand possible causes to my reactions beyond just being over-sensitive, and how to address them in myself and kids- as well as to understand more deeply how differently wired kids process information differently.
>There is a long works cited at end[sic] of the post
That is not a works cited section because there are no citations! It’s a list of references - and I wish there had been citations so I could test the author’s claims.
Also, no comment on whether these constitute made-up citations, but (courtesy of an LLM, each confirmed by me):
Silverman (#3): Wrong author. That essay is by Stephanie S. Tolan, written for Hoagies' Gifted Education Page in February 1999.
Dana Winkler & Alan Voight (#4): The paper is real but the authors are named Daniel Winkler and Adam Voight. This doesn’t sound like your friend actually wrote this article…
Dodson (#1): article's actual title is "Emotional Regulation and Rejection Sensitivity," Attention Magazine, October 2016.
Thank you. I also found it strange people thought that. Maya is amazing and deeply respected in the Bay area community. She did not use AI to write this.
Funny you say that! Her citations are bogus, exactly as an LLM would produce. But please just read the article, it's as redolent of LLMs as any LLM text could be.
I am sorry to bear the news that your friend did indeed use AI within the article. First of all gptzero guesses 100% AI generated.
Second of all you can sniff it out with plenty of the phrasing which is what my original comment was based on: "The correction temporarily erases the bigger picture." "Feedback on an assignment is rarely just about the assignment. It becomes a referendum on whether the child is still who they believe themselves to be." "What follows is rarely proportional: “no one likes me,” a wave of rage, or a full shutdown." "This is protective armor. Underneath it is usually plain embarrassment." "Because the identity is more invested, the shame lands harder." "That gap is where a great deal of the combustion happens." "The underlying fear in these moments is usually not “I will get in trouble.” It is closer to “I will be misunderstood, reduced to one moment, or unfairly categorized.” That distinction changes how an adult should respond."
Third of all the entire structure is a chatgpt output. Humans don't write their documents like this.
I would have compared it to some of her previous writing from six or more years ago but couldn't find any. I'm pretty certain if you found some it would not read anything like this article.
thats too bad. it reads so similar to ai generated content, that I'm (and several others) are staying away. I suggest your friend doesn't sound so robotic/AI-ish - I hope not to offend or disrespect your friend, and tbf, if you were a bot, I would be not surprised
> It is not ai-generated. It was hand-written by a friend and colleague with deep respect in the education community.
I hate to tell you that perhaps your friend has not been forthcoming. I encourage you to check the 'citations' yourself, and perhaps to do some study on what LLM texts look like.