This argument is a tough road to hoe. The problem is that there needs to be symmetry. If one deserve the fruits of their ancestors' good works, then they also deserve the yoke of their ancestors' cruelty or exploitation.
I tend to believe that a child is not born tainted by the sins of their ancestors, so I cannot believe that a child is born meriting the success of their ancestors.
No excuses or rationalizations here, but: Do we fire people for cheating on their spouse? Seems like a private, family matter.
Of course, the spy aspect could be relevant from a professional perspective (depending on what actions he took or what he knew), but I'm guessing you're talking about him having an affair.
I think every corporate training I've ever taken has made it pretty clear if you had an affair with a vendor and gave them something in exchange you'd be fired as soon as it came to light. I've seen people, even CEOs, fired for affairs at work because of the power dynamics. So the answer is maybe, it depends.
I can't even remember how many times I read a permutation of the following in company trainings:
"Failure to adhere to this policy will result in disciplinary action, up to and including termination of employment, and may also subject the individual to civil or criminal legal proceedings."
When they are the CEO of multi-trillion dollar, geopolitically important companies, and when we are talking about spies of geopolitical adversaries? Yes, absolutely.
In fact, the affair was less important. Even if they were just a very close but unromantic professional relationship it would be a serious scandal.
Most posters in HN don't think "poor corporations are the victims when they are hacked". They think "the corporations should be liable because they did not invest enough in security". This is morally the same.
Hm sure but politicians and world leaders cheat serially on their spouses and we don’t seem to think that’s something they should be held accountable for.
Only juvenile and unserious people are focused on sex and cheating here. The problem is who he was influenced by and who he went on to influence, whether this relationship was romantic or not. This is a problem of judgement and damage control now.
It's not personal when you're in a certain role. You are not just representing your company, as a CEO you are practically embodying the company. It is the ultimate position, and it's compensated accordingly. If you want a personal life, resign from the job of CEO of the world's biggest and most strategically important company.
That is a very American take. I think there are other countries (e.g. Germany, the Netherlands) where there is a much stricter separation between the professional and private persona. Nvidia is american, and so is Jensen, so i guess it is OK to judge him by this standard. Just saying that different cultures judge this behavior differently.
Yeah you say that then your country elects a serial-cheater pedophile as president; I'm not sure you are so representative of your country customs as you think.
Espionage aside, let's not forget that he was having an affair with a customer company's executive. If that's not a massive professional fuckup I don't know what is.
To be fair he probably spends all of his "free" time working. As the founder and CEO of it there is no personal or professional life. It's all one life.
People who speed take reckless actions endangering others, therefore we should fire anybody who gets a speeding ticket. Thoughts?
Now take the same point and apply it to every other crime, misdemeanor, and breaking of rules. Should companies really operate based on that? Or should we maybe draw a boundary around professional life and only consider the professional life?
I'm not saying what I would do, just what many places think: the CEO was picked up for drink driving last night, maybe we should try hiring someone else instead.
I think the issue is normally more that these might expose you to blackmail or extortion.
But that's ironically a non issue now that's it's front page press...lol.
It's a bit like celebrities who release embarassing photos themselves, to bypass hackers leaking them. (To be clear, I don't think the photos should be out either way, your private matters should stay private, celebrity or not, and it's horrid to have it dragged out in public. But I do admire the ballsiness in just releasing it themselves. And in this post-modern era, perversely some people seem to benefit from the exposure)
> No excuses or rationalizations here, but: Do we fire people for cheating on their spouse? Seems like a private, family matter.
It is not so clear, if this is about his character and can he be trusted. This is evidence that someone is capable for lying and doing something that might not be in line with company ethics either. I don't think we can assume from humans that "he lies only in his private life, but can be totally trusted on business side".
The main issue with this analogy is that despite how similar to a human's writing its chat-based UI is, Claude is software, not a person.
Junior engineers are humans like the tech lead.
LLMs are software like a compiler, an IDE or a paint program.
So IMO comparing an LLM to a junior is dehumanizing. Comparing it to a compiler is more apt (though a better comparison is with IDEs and editors: after all you use an LLM to write the code, not compile it).
I get what you're saying and I mostly agree, but I think it's also wrong to say that the tech lead did no "actual work". It's still a valuable and necessary role, otherwise companies wouldn't have them.
I like to say that I build software with Claude. "With" does double duty here, meaning both "alongside" and "using", and it covers the range of ways I use the tools.
The objection to saying "I built this" is pedantic, but so is the insistence that one really did build it. But does it really matter? At the end of the day, there is tons of cool new software to make and play with, and it wouldn't be there without human guidance.
I can't speak for anyone else, but I don't mind at all when an open source project switches licenses or whatever. They gave away the fruit of their labor, but I am not entitled to any more of it.
What does bother me is when the projects pivot to claiming that users now have a moral obligation to financially support the project. There is a kind of dishonesty in this move.
It's not that a successful project "should be free", it's that its success depended on it being free. If they had said all along that they'd eventually ask users to pay, that would be honest... but then they wouldn't have seen much of that adoption in the first place.
In my case, I never intended on my open source project becoming popular, it just did and I had to either abandon it or make it my job. I'm not sure where that falls in your judgement.
It's your project, to the extent that you own the copyright. You are free to switch the license on your project, etc. If anyone tries to shame you for this, you should pay no mind. (Edited to add that you are also free to abandon it, and you could do that with a clear conscience.)
Likewise, users are free to continue using open source software without payment or donation, to fork the project, etc. If anyone tries to shame them for this, they should pay no mind.
Why would you have to abandon it instead of just keeping on in your preferred pace? If anybody wants more rapid development they can fork it, not your problem.
Some people also have tried the paid new feature prioritization where it later lands for everyone. I think it worked in some projects but project must have been really good otherwise.
I mean: who doesn't want to work full time on their passion project? Especially when I'd just been made redundant, I feel most people would do the same.
> I can't speak for anyone else, but I don't mind at all when an open source project switches licenses or whatever. They gave away the fruit of their labor, but I am not entitled to any more of it
It only bothers me when they try to claim their new license is open source or use misleading language when it isn't. Which seems to be what 90% companies doing that do.
People can do whatever they want with their intellectual property as long as they aren't lying about it.
That would be a completely insane thing to do. I suppose it's possible, but I really doubt it.
"Let's widely publicize a tort/crime that our computer systems did, and then cross our fingers that nobody ever sues us or does even the most basic investigation that would immediately uncover our criminal conspiracy."
In the insane corporate crimes you read about (maybe FTX, or the eBay stalking scandal), they were trying to cover things up, not heap public attention on it for months.
Huh? It's extremely common for businesses to decide that breaking the law is a cost of doing business and just do it because they figure they'll end up net positive from it, or even just to cash out in the short term.
Uber made no attempt to cover up that they were operating without licenses, and just ate it and fought it betting they'd get established before the law could catch up, and they won that bet, paying some fines and stuff but ultimately taking the market.
These LLMs are literally trained by these companies pirating literally every bit of media humanity has ever made, they made very little attempt to cover it up.
Of course they'd be willing to break the law for some PR? With a thin layer of plausible deniability "oh no, we didn't mean for it to hack stuff!" they know they'll get a slap on the wrists at worst, all while generating hype to prop up the AI bubble further by presenting the models as hypercapable.
The mindset is probably: either a) the models become capable of what we are claiming and so the companies become so huge and valuable the cost is irrelevant and we'll be to big to punish meaningfully, or b) it's a bubble and might as well push it up as big as it can go while I can make money, then by the time consequences come around I'll be long gone and who cares.
> The Right/Republicans have always touted free speech.
> The Left have always been a bit more 'censory'
Not "always", and not even now. It's always contingent and situational. Same goes for nearly every clause in the Bill of Rights.
At various points the left has been associated with the fights against obscenity laws, against Cold War loyalty oaths, against blacklisting, against bans of books.
At various points the right has been associated with the fights against desecration of the American flag, against the teaching of human evolution in schools, against depictions of sex in media, against anti-war demonstrations.
Lots of people are saying agentic cyberattacks are a marketing hoax. The argument is that either AI is not capable enough to carry out these attacks, or that it would not carrying out these attacks without nudging from the labs, or even that somebody told it to do cyberattacks and the companies are baldly lying. My question is: what evidence would cause you to change your mind about this?
I'm not even saying it's an incorrect position. But to take the claim seriously and act accordingly, it needs to be falsifiable.
AI boosters and detractors alike often hedge their claims so that whatever ends up actually happening, they can say they were right all along. When that happens, the discussion boils down to people saying "yay AI" and "boo AI" at each other without exchanging any substantive information.
I don't particularly believe this (I'm not an expert in anything computer-y, let alone security, so the only thing I know is that people who seem respected here (like simonw) point out that the sandbox from OpenAI was at least very badly designed, but who knows why that is), but here's one piece of possible evidence: if something similar causes so much damage that it ends up obviously hurting the company responsible. This could be something like targeting a big bank and causing so much disruption that the law wakes up and immediately intervenes, or it could be major damage to the company's own systems.
Of course, if that happens, this whole discussion becomes moot, and good luck to us all...
It's an open question whether geofence warrants are constitutional at all. I know that at least in the Fifth Circuit, they are not.
reply