HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | abracadaniel's commentslogin

YouTube itself provides ai summaries without watching the video now. Click the ai button and then click “summarize video”. You don’t need to play the video at all or sit through an ad and it doesn’t yet hide anything from the user to try to get you to watch.


That's at least better than actually watching the video there, indeed.

If there is another service between me and Google which isolates me from BigTech's trackers, that's even a lot better.


I recently walked past a destroyed cassette tape on the side of the road which was a blast from the past. I got to show my kids what they looked like and explain that you’d see them like that all the time.


I feel like we’re already surrounded by devices that do this without any security whatsoever (TVs for example). So, it’s nice to see one implementation try to do it safely. Though, I do agree that normalizing overt recording could embolden the rest.


TVs died. Not fully, but they went from the ubiquity of smartphones to the “oh yeah I’ve got one lying around” of VR. The shit they’ve been up to since is a response to trying to recover a much bigger industry’s profits by juicing a remainder that they’ve realized is so inert they’ll let you do anything to them. I really hope the resemblance to mainstream tech is minimal.


Well, the devices were doing it in the most hidden way possible. This is plain in the open and that's how that window is moved. And yes, I absolutely believe that the overt recording is the actual moment where they expect us to actually get used to it.


Hidden? Every device with a voice assistant has been advertising always-on recording for a decade plus.


We're talking about LG TV style recording.

Also, the assistants are not recording, they're analyzing sound wave for the trigger word. This isn't recording, it's been explained countless times already.

This whole conversation is about taking it to next level.


I do see your point, but what the assistants are doing is recording. It's only a second or two, on-device, and not stored, but it is already a recording. Apple is just changing the duration and retention.

I think as soon as the original capability launched the game was over. People don't understand technical distinctions like that and they've already accepted it.


If there's nothing left and it's deleted, then it's not recorded.

I am talking about the recording that lasts. Recording people's voice without their consent, on your behalf, and transcribing the text for your later use. It's not volatile 2s analyzed by the DSP, it's an actual record of conversation.

This is not the same recording.

But yes, I see your point, too, maybe back then we got used to it at an even less intrusive level. So it progresses, slowly, but surely, like a frog in a pot.


Doesn’t sound like it’s taking it to any other level, except that the wake criteria is handled a little more securely.


Vouched for your dead comment - I’m still thinking about it, don’t agree nor disagree, but prob worth engaging with instead of killin’


The fuck are you talking about? Doing it safely is extremely easy and already solved: have the user be root.

This is about remote control. People who think Apple/Google/Microsoft will just pass on the reigns of that remote control are dangerously naïve.

Apple has locked down whole classes of third-party utilities for its mobile system and Google is copying them as we speak. We are slowing progress at great cost by letting them lock-in and rent seek.


WHAT


unhinged comment lol


There's an argument to be made that progress on desktop personal computers has been faster because hackers (in the good sense) can hack around and invent new stuff in ways you really cannot on mobile/tablet locked-down hardware and software.

The commenter may have sounded unhinged but the thesis is sound.


Right, that’s why everyone I know uses Linux too, and big tech routinely make copies of Linux features…


…that’s unironically true.

Everybody you know runs Linux on their router, set-top box, etc.

Big tech has moved on from amalgamating OS and UI features to copying entire distros.


I think it would be fair to call "Windows subsystem for Linux" a Linux feature, yes.

And Android is still the biggest mobile OS.


The "fix" in the thread is just not updating ever again.


There is no fix that can be suggested in that thread. Pi LTD doesn't have the modified RAM Pis to test their firmware against nor should they be required to support modified hardware.


The fix is turning the detection of the modified ram from a boot failure into a warning and log output, then tell users asking for support that they don't have support for Pis that were modified by third parties.

Instead we get restrictions on all users because some users buy stuff from random marketplaces online?

I don't know why you're suggesting the fix is that they offer support for 3rd modded RAM.


>I don't know why you're suggesting the fix is that they offer support for 3rd modded RAM.

I'm not.


It’s an “or”. Generation, transmission, or sale. Not exclusively sale.


of electric energy to the public


It would be interesting to see someone try to tackle modern consoles like the PS5


The PS5 jailbreak scene is pretty sizable. Good chunk of money to be made if accomplished: https://bounties.fulu.org/bounties/playstation-5


I was thinking maybe reverse engineering newer Apple Silicon devices to port Linux.


Fable was able to get Linux booting on my M4 Pro mini. (Using Asahi as a base, not possible to upstream because they really don't like AI). Hardware support beyond USB 2.0 requires tracing macOS under the hypervisor, which Fable refuses to do and Opus isn't much good at. I'll try Sol at some point.


You don't have to upstream it, but if you stuck it in GitHub or whatever so everybody else could pick up the source code changes, that'd be neat.


No, the highest priority is Sonos.

Presumably the difficulty level is low and the community/societal justice extremely high.


Off topic, but only a couple of years ago the 3d printer community re-discovered these same kinds of flaws in the extruder gears that result in visible ripples in prints. When you put a gear on a stepper motor, and set it with a set screw, you’re pretty much always off center slightly.


Also, this seems exactly like what the classic web would’ve looked like if we’d had the ability to do it.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: