HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | aaroninsf's commentslogin

a) this is not known, there is no reliable data on either the FAA or new bank issue; and the information forthcoming from Microsoft may obscure primary causation

b) there is also a risk of sophistry and language games obscuring common sense truth

In the world where a state actor is engaging in active sabotage as part of a cyberwarfare effort, there is one shared cause.

Which exploits are responsible in each case may differ. Still one cause.

Do I think it's Iran?

No idea.

But the point is, none of us here have any idea at present.


My case:

With a very large dataset of totally unnormalized data, semantic folding is a silver bullet.


Could someone explain to me what this is for and when it comes up?

Opposite of snark: active curiosity :)


It's realy the idea that Flat 3D object <-> Image, you can get a look at what the "founders" of geometry images said about that,

and how they apply it to simplify some mesh pipelines (hope it will feed your active curiosity !): https://hhoppe.com/proj/gim/

What I bring upon geometry images with my project, is the same idea for point clouds.

replace point[42] (index = 42) with point[row, col] (row, col of a learned matrix structure that store the points. Thus, the point cloud is stored as an image, and the pixels are the points).

Promising application is point cloud compression, but I can think of others: matrix storage is maybe not as accurate as e.g. kdtree storage, but very convenient to use, eg for neighbor querys, convolution...


Possibly UV mapping to draw a texture map?

Ah so as to "paint" an asset that's been scanned perhaps?

False, in a way that genuinely matters.

True: they are superhuman at every one of these tasks, in the boring way they are better—according to a wall clock and the coupled standard of actual results—at other things, just not in some mystical way.


The specific narrow criticisms may be entirely valid, yet the argument as a whole somewhere between weak and misleading.

CS professionals, like mathematicians—and every other one of us in our silo—are seeing one part of the elephant, and have neither context nor standing to critique the domain as a whole.

Given that limitation the toxic cynicism of posts like this actively harmful.

The are great at rage baiting, actively impede meaningful discourse.

Counterpoint: https://www.astralcodexten.com/p/ai-safety-is-not-a-corporat...


Every technology revolution needs its John Henry, I guess.


> Knowing these models’ decision making is inconsistently aligned with human preferences tells us we can’t just trust their decisions out of the box.

I'm not sure this is true.

What is the "human preference," in this assertion?

My first thought was that as with Jev itself, it is not a position, it's a distribution of positions!

I think that human preferences, plural, will be a distribution of values across the population of various humans you ask; and, a set of specific conclusions humans will argue for on the basis of various philosophical strategies or maxims. Two different ways in which there is not any specific singular preference.

(I'm convinced you could not get uniform agreement on even "obvious" propositions, across a large sample set; and not necessarily just because of contrarian spoiling. Moral intuitions varying, is the why this problem is so well known, after all.)

I think the conclusion is partially right, but only if you adjust it to say, if what you want is alignment with a specific outcome, you need to be able to defined that outcome, even if you can't argue for it.

That's one of the fundamental problems of alignment, full stop; we can't from axioms construct the set of moral propositions we would like. We don't know what the right set of axioms is; we just know "right" when we see it. (And our neighbor may or may not see the same.)


> The bad news about modern neural networks is that they're enormous. The good news is that the enormity helps...

I always catch on misuse of enormity

It's now so widespread the misuse has gained despairing acceptance, as with "infer" for "imply"... but that doesn't make it any less wince-inducing.


This usage is etymological. So its fine. I don't like it when we trash and etymology, but in this case we're restoring it, or at least not making it worse.

("ex normal" doesn't clearly mean "evil"/"sinful", and Latin already had it as "big".)


that's just how language works.. do you think that in your day to day life, you have never used a single word differently than how it was conceived of being used 10, 50, or 100 years ago?


Can you explain for the rest of us the problem with this usage?

I think neural networks are enormous, why is that misuse?


Merriam Webster:

"""

The original meanings that enormity carried related to great wickedness, and some assert that enormity should today only be used with such meanings, and that enormousness is the proper word to use to mean "large size." Despite these claims, enormity frequently refers to large size, either literal or figurative, though it usually suggests something so large as to seem overwhelming.

"""


Enormity has two meanings:

- great magnitude/size/scale of something - wickedness, evil, atrocity

Purists insist on the second meaning only, and will perhaps suggest you swap with ‘enormousness’ instead.


Wow, insisting on archaic definitions of words for pedantic reasons sounds exhausting.


Never meta.

Do not run, do not support, do not use.


I wonder if all the AI companies are making dossiers on their users.

I would say meta and google definitely are. xAI? Probaly. The others? Perhaps. Perhaps Anthropic less than the others?


It appears to already be far beyond that, they are working with each other[0]:

>ChatGPT, Claude, Grok, DeepSeek, Perplexity, Gemini, Copilot, Le Chat de Mistral and Meta AI filter your data to Google, Meta, and several of the main data brokers.

[0] https://jorgegarciaherrero.com/en/prompt-like-a-butterfly-st...

https://jorgegarciaherrero.com/wp-content/interactivos/20260... [PDF]


Hot take: the problem here is not the one implied or AFAICT assumed by the author.

The problem is not that LLM or, say, generative AI tools such as Midjourney, "have no imagination" and collapse upon the same solution. Anyone who has spent any serious time exploring what was originally called the "latent space" Midjourney provided a view into, is aware that the combinatorics around what these systems have ingested is inconceivably large and full of wonders and surprises... what we might well describe as unexpected, novel, dare I say creative, imagery [etc.]

The problem AFAICT is asking for examples of something without providing any process or instruction.

Vibe-coded single-shot prompts are inevitably (unless this is patched) going to converge on statistically-likely or contextually hinted examplars.

And this is true all the way down. It's true of secondary and tertiary features (what camera angle do we have on the pelican? Is it a juvenile or injured? Is it riding to the left or right? etc.)

The fact that humans are a heterogeneous pool with different experiences and capabilities, means if you sample humans, you get high variability. If you ask contemporary LLM, they are converging, indeed, but not in the way implied; they are converging because the corpus they are trained on is comprehensive and coextensive.

What you get is the centroids in the space.

Until you simply ask for something else.

If you want more "creative" examples, of pelicans or anything else, it's more or less trivial to get them. And if you detect durable secondary or tertiary qualities you want to see varied, you ask.

More seriously,

if what you want is to interact with large capable models/systems which by default exhibit variability , you do the (minimal) work to make that happen.

Midjourney has from very early on exposed explicit dials to turn in exactly this way.

I am surprised the author does not know this.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: