At what point we just start hating LLM because it is LLM?
Honestly I do not care if article was written letter by letter by human or written by agent steered by human.
I care about knowledge and quality, it it is there then it doesn't matter how was it written. I too hate LLM slop but I understand that not everything done by LLM have to be slop.
At the moment it's a good proxy for quality and intention. IF it was mostly generated, it's probably mostly meandering bullshit which doesn't quite make sense.
Yes the style is annoying and bombastic, but the objection goes deeper than that; it's annoying to have someone generate text with an LLM from a small outline or prompt, not even edit it for sense, and dump it on readers.
>At what point we just start hating LLM because it is LLM?
At the point where you read enough LLM written text with zero substance narrating wikipedia article or heard that voice on youtube restating the same thesis over and over for 15 minutes.
The rule of thumb: if I can detect it's an LLM without trying to detects it's an LLM and the feeling doesn't go away, it's a slop.
I agree, but I don't think the article has zero substance nor it is narrating wiki article... yet top comment (at that point) was about how it reeks of LLM.
I think many people are just fed up with the specific voice LLM's tend to write in. Doesn't help many of us now live in a world where most of what we do is read LLM prose in claude code and what not
if you consider every single person that uses some LLM then sure, it is tiny percentage, but I would wage that large percentage don't write technical documentation as GP. large userbase probably don't need THE best solution for their use case and will be comfortable with A solution that is within their budget. so for them simple luna < terra < sol < astra would suffice.
but if you want to use some LLM agent for anything commercial and you want to get the best and at the same time you don't want to overpay the easiest and the surest would be to create your own benchmark for your specific use case.
The meaning you're looking for is living, enjoying life. We already have more books anyone could ever read in a lifetime. Same with movies, tv shows, documents or games. You have whole planet to travel around and explore. You have few billions of humans you can interact and socialize with...
I really do not understand why so many people are afraid of not working... meaning of my life was never to work for someone, that was always only means to finance my life.
Yeah right. Just a few hundred million dollars (that’s really not a lot!) will allow to live a joyful life! Why even spend these years working somewhere?
sorry I honestly don't understand what you meant (english is not my first language). do you imply that person needs few hundred million dollars to live? because if so I don't agree, you really don't need that much money to be happy. sure I'm living a comfortable life from money I earn, but I could live will far far less money and still be happy.
I was replying to a comment saying something like "why bother about having a job? Just read books, travel around the world, there's so much to see!"
To live such a life you need quite some money.
no, you don't. books are really cheap, libraries are everywhere. and you can also travel cheap, people backpack all around the world every day. sure you will still need some money, but certainly not "few hundred million dollars", that is way overblown...
sure, that is true, but that is what I'm saying. if AI will take over intellectual work and robots manual work (in the future) then our current system will have no other option than completely change.
"Our current system is broken and will have no other option than to completely change" is a scary future not an exciting one
There has never been a time in our history where excess labour has been treated with any grace, and I think it's rather delusional to think that will start suddenly now.
The entire debate is, how exactly can it change. Because I see zero signs pointing towards the rosy future you mentioned, rather contrary. I only see the current AI overlords hoarding power, hoarding money, and the plebs fighting more and more for scraps - against each other or/and later in uprisings against those technofeudalists and their few selected minions. And when the AI gets advanced enough, I see less future even for the minions, and also less chances of the uprising winning against a robot army. Will the humans survive? Maybe, but after a violent culling. And not even that I see guaranteed, depending on the future alignment of the AGI (or whatever it will be called). But all this bleakness is based on today's inaction of the politics/people towards the bad actors, so I really hope we can still steer it away.
revolution, that is only option. yes, it may look overly optimistic and rosy tinted but what is the other option? be overly pessimistic, concluding that the rich won and we lost and just wait for the inevitable end?
most countries around the world still have democracy, so voting the the solution. what I don't know is how to fight populism... because that is the achilles heel of democracy... for now, spreading the knowledge is probably all we can do, people have to (and will in time) learn who can be trusted and who cannot.
but honestly I don't buy into sci-fi "AI will kill us all or enslave us" premise. that is only our anthropomorphisation of the artificial intelligence. what I see as more probably that AI could rule us in stead of the human politics that rule us now. why not have LLM political parties that could be voted? each one with open weights and transparent prompts? without emotion, corruption and greed? wouldn't that be better than current situation?
AI gets so much diluted by the most important discussions about gendering the toilets and who was first in some valley, so I'm not surprised it slips by without real insight. But to answer your political party concept: the LLM learned their decisions from our flawed decisions, it learned corruption and greedy actions and wrong decisions resulted from human emotions, so I'm honestly not sure what good policy results we can expect from an uncontrollable amplifier.
There's a bit of a problem that secondhand EVs aren't on the market until a couple of years after someone has bought them new. So there's a bottleneck. In this case all the cheap leasing deals work in favor of the eventual secondhand market.
Honestly I do not care if article was written letter by letter by human or written by agent steered by human.
I care about knowledge and quality, it it is there then it doesn't matter how was it written. I too hate LLM slop but I understand that not everything done by LLM have to be slop.
reply