HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | a57721's commentslogin

> sweeping dictionary between algebra and geometry that allowed mathematicians to do geometry over arbitrary rings, with arithmetic and infinitesimal data built in from the start.

That made me laugh, I wasn't expecting grothendieckian geometry to be described in LLM speak. What a time to be alive.


> What a time to be alive.

That's way more infuriating than hackneyed AI copy.


Not sure if you know what you are talking about? Most users of Java don't pay anything to Oracle. Many things have changed in the Java world. Kubernetes doesn't have any special relation to Java.

> Not sure if you know what you are talking about? Most users of Java don't pay anything to Oracle.

Congratulations Java Fan on missing BOTH the smily-face at the end of the first phrase AND the "More seriously though" at the start of the second.

I'm glad someone still loves Java though. ;)

P.S. The kubernetes reference was – since that one appears to have gone over the top of your head too – that in todays world Kubernetes is extraordinarily popular and therefore it is likely most people now hide the complexities of Java deployment into a container that is magically generated and deployed through CI/CD. Hence I was inferring that life is probably "easier" today with Java because you just deploy the magical container.


Congratulations for posting your humorous hot takes on something you haven't touched in 10-15 years.

> suggestions for ingredient substitutions (if they’re good, which is the crucial part!) would be a really useful feature for me

Can't they implement this feature without any gen AI? OK, the answer is that they don't want to pay someone for making a list of substitutions, but at least they can generate it and make a human cook revise the results. There is no need for calling gen AI APIs when the app is running.

People are shoving gen AI everywhere out of the hype, including tasks that have better, more reliable solutions with traditional approaches.


While there are professors who use students to ghostwrite books or force them to submit papers in co-autorship, that's definitely not common, and practically impossible outside of graduate school. Your average professor/TA is underpaid and struggles to teach basic stuff to the undergrads, that is totally unrelated to their scientific interests and "hobbies".


They should be underpaid (I think they should be paid even less), since they earn money from the government and don't facilitate any trade or provide value to end-users. A lot of them think their job is to weed students out instead of educating them. If you read through published research you can see how they stroke their own egos for their useless discoveries. There is zero market feedback for their work so the entire system becomes a circle jerk and full of suck ups.

The people building houses, ensure sanitation systems work, plan logistics to get food to supermarkets etc. should earn triple the amount academics earn.


That's what I am doing for my classes, just provide useful feedback and mark the homework as submitted. The university wants points, but for me any submission is 100% points, even if there are errors and omissions.

However, now there are students that just copy the output of LLMs without even caring to understand terminology and notation. Should that count as a completed assignment? In some egregious and too obvious cases I ask them simple questions about what they wrote and don't give them marks/points if they have no clue.

Using LLMs as assistants for homework is one thing, and there's no way to prevent it. But students who just copy characters from the screen without caring to understand what is going on are on another level. Above all, they are wasting their time.

Regarding giving or not giving scores, that's a complicated issue. Scores provide a "negative incentive" for learning. A positive incentive would be some pat on the back for doing the assignments. However, our brains are not wired by the evolution to do things only for positive incentives when there are no grades/deadlines/etc.

In my experience, being lenient works great with graduate students, and undergrads won't do and won't understand anything in the course if there are no grades. I learned that the hard way.


It only remains to explain this to the management... That does not work with code, engages with AI only in the form of chatbots, but demands everything to be "AI native" and won't be there to deal with the consequences.


I majored in mathematics and I learned category theory before touching any serious Haskell, and I still found most of the "monad tutorials" kind of opaque and handwavy, and I think there are inherently non-trivial details unrelated to the notion of functor etc.


No there are no trivial details, and you don't need a mathematics major or category theory to understand what a functor is.

It's a pair of a type constructor F(a) and a map operation a -> b to get an F(b).

The two "non-trivial" details are the fact that the map operation has to respect identity, map(id) = id, and function composition: map(g ∘ f) = map(g) ∘ map(f)

None of those concepts is any difficult, nor requires any "math major" or non-trivial details, because the are not there.


When there are 100 explanations of some topic, maybe it's not so trivial, after all, even when the bare axioms seem trivial.


Most of the stuff you just explained is absent from your explanation of monads. So it turns out monads are not so simple after all for people who don't already understand functors...


I see increasing amounts of code merged to the codebase that is sometimes wrong, sometimes too brittle, sometimes fixes the symptom without addressing the bug. Two years ago the same code would be criticized harshly and reworked before being accepted.

Also, now people who used to manage the development but not write any code also feel their superpowers to merge LLM slop in humongous amounts. It feels like a ticking time bomb, but I am afraid of calling it out and rain on their parade of 10x productivity (or often AI psychosis). Leaving the team doesn't feel like a good decision because what I hear from many colleagues is much worse. Ah what a time to be alive...


Its the same as with luddites / textiles, people proved they were willing to accept far worse quality because "automation". People have a strange cognitive bias it seems. When they know a person has done something, the scrutinize and correct. When its a machine / automated, or the price is low enough, it gets hand-wavy.

People here often say "we can't set rules, because imagine how hard it would be to follow them at scale". That same strange cognitive bias applies here. Somehow the "push a magic button and it works" and "of course it can't do it just as well as a person every time" kind of take over.

Imagine if many tech issues like access to pornography, corporate ad tech, violent/racist material, AI slop, etc. were all just armies of people doing it (like google / X actually just had a person curate your results really fast for every search). Of course people would be outraged at the quality, but its "automated" so no one questions.

Similarly, if AI was just a giant outsourced coding firm with 10M programmers that could write you a slop app in an afternoon for $1, people would be complaining at how idiotic it is, and how inferior to regular devs. But instead, the "machine bias" takes over and people try to forgive the shortcomings.

there is something in the human psyche that badly wants to replace itself with a machine, despite it spelling our own undoing, and often resulting in worse outcomes along the way. I suppose the whole "make a tool" drive has been wildly successful overall, but this is probably the required downside to such an innate drive.

Like have you seen the 3d printed houses? They are the uggliest, shittiest houses in the world, but somehow the lure of "yes but we can build them in 24 hours" seems to somehow get people interested. If a human made one of those dung heaps they would be pillaried as a village idiot, and rightly mocked, but somehow because "machine do thing", we should get excited about excreted dung beehive houses...


Mathematicians care a lot about the exposition of their ideas, invest a lot of time in giving talks, writing, and don't publish too frequently, compared to other sciences.

They normally don't feel like they are in some kind of race to publish the results ASAP and claim priority. Cases like that are very rare (but they get media coverage because they are so unusual).

OpenAI did a publicity stunt, their motivation is not to make a good contribution to the field, which has very different standards and culture, compared to the AI labs.


What kind of prestige? Peer review is anonymous unpaid work.

A good review does not merely check the correctness of logical arguments, it gives suggestions for the exposition, citing the correct references, putting everything in the right context, etc.


> What kind of prestige? Peer review is anonymous unpaid work.

Prestige to the reviewed, not to the reviewer.


All of the reasons you listed for peer review are valid. The broader point is that peer review can happen outside of academic journals, and nobody has an incentive to submit to them who isn't trying to play the academic prestige game. For a significant example, see the history of Perelman's proof of the Poincaré conjecture.


> journals are not the arbiter of truth and getting published in them is something only academics have an incentive to do

Good, I just wanted to point out that peer review isn't primarily an arbitrage of truth, it is also to make sure the exposition is nice to read. When you get a reviewer who actually cares, you receive lots of feedback that isn't related to the correctness of Lemma 3.14.15 and stuff like that.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: