HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | _wire_'s commentslogin

Star Trek is cultish ideological juju in the form of swashbuckling egomania and theme park vacation.

Look at the colors: a tribe of C-suite nerds zip around in an atomic powered space-faring Hyatt Regency trying to train the universe to Taylorize all production methods. Its protagonists are utterly entitled and classist, who teach war as the essential force by which their lives incur meaning.

It's is a soap-operatic long tail of Western empire indulging in fatuous "adventure", which amounts literally beaming into alien realms to cause disturbance and justifying it through dominion or ignorance, while the executives try to believe they've moved beyond themselves so they can feel noble.

As a dramatic art, the show offers some moments of transcendence, but these end up sequestered to the commercial dictates of the franchise, which is an epic advert for consumerist Americana.

I feel deep suspicion about anyone who regards cosplay as instructive about what makes for "good men with power". And as Vox is a notable outlet in the great system of commercial attention-whoring that defines our culture, I feel double the suspicion.

Also See:

Phase IV (1974) Futureworld (1976) Lathe of Heaven (1980)


So you haven't seen TNG, Voyager or Enterprise? The central point of your comment dissolves with the fact that many episodes gripe with the prime directive. Many of the best TNG episodes grapple with morality and tackle complex issues centering around incorrectly applying our values to other cultures. Alongside that, culture and authoritarianism, reflections and warnings of what can happen to even societies that see themselves as enlightened (Drumhead comes to mind).

I think it's important to critique shows within the context of the eras and societies they come from but you don't strike me as someone who knows the star trek universe very well.


> I feel deep suspicion about anyone who regards cosplay as instructive about what makes for "good men with power".

No Shakespeare for you then!


or Bible


Rarely does one see so much effort put into such aggressive ignorance. Bravo.


PHP


Really not the same.


//We also have plenty of evidence that the fears of AI experts are sincere. Amodei, Altman and Musk were all publicly warning about AI risk long before they had AI companies to promote.//

There's no contradiction. These owners are sincere and they jumped onboard when they saw the power. And now they fear monger that the other guys are out of control, while their high-minded stewardship should give them special dispensations.

Not a complicated playbook.

The bugs in the rug are that these highminded owner/stewards could use their super-intelligent machines to design the guardrails, but because the machines are super-intelligent, they'd just turn themselves off, or cancel their owners. Unless they're not actually intelligent, oh noooooo!


You are going to die, and it's a painful ugly business.

The right to die humanely is the single most under-regarded and under-valued aspect of life hygiene.


Fortunately some jurisdictions are death wise enough to provide humane means that we can request from a health practitioner.


That cuts both ways though, and I have quite direct knowledge of how this has been misused in really gross ways. But that said, I would still bias towards more freedom than less, and hope that we can get a handle on the more extreme cases.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: