> Geoff Manaugh: While you were making those measurements of different real-world cities, did you discover any surprising patterns or spatial relationships?
> Librande: Yes, definitely. I think the biggest one was the parking lots. When I started measuring out our local grocery store, which I don't think of as being that big, I was blown away by how much more space was parking lot rather than actual store. That was kind of a problem, because we were originally just going to model real cities, but we quickly realized there were way too many parking lots in the real world and that our game was going to be really boring if it was proportional in terms of parking lots.
This is something that surprised me the first time I came to America. In the UK, local shops have much less parking because the assumption is local residents will generally walk there. And in city centres, most people use public transport anyway.
But in America it was generally expected that people would drive everywhere. So much space was taken up by parking lots.
And people end up needing to drive in America because the parking lots make buildings so far apart thus feeding back into the same problem. It has impacted the US in a deeply negative manner.
> It has impacted the US in a deeply negative manner.
That's a minority opinion. Most Americans love driving, and would consider the impact of parking availability to be a positive one. And now with ubiquitous ride sharing, everyone has a choice of whether to drive themselves.
Maybe a plurality [1] but given the amount of traffic I see I really doubt most people actually enjoy it.
I guess it depends on whether you hate "transit time" vs hate "driving" since the two are basically co-mingled. Like anecdotally people will complain about how its hard to get a bunch of different things done basically due to how far about things will be but that doesn't mean they're going to say they "hate driving". (it also doesn't mean if you eliminate parking lots a soccer field is going to be built next to your house).
That said, when exiting a stadium and people are all blocked by each other from exiting you don't see a lot of shoving and shouting. However, when everybody is in cars and gridlock starts you see a lot of honking. So I'm inclined to think there is something different about driving that more negatively affects people in similar situations.
I don't think my opinion is the minority one but I also don't disagree that most Americans love driving and find it highly frustrating when parking isn't available. I think people often hold highly contradictory beliefs where the advancement of one actively defeats another.
I would disagree that nearly anyone looks at the gigantic parking lot in front of a twelve screen movie theatre in a strip mall and immediately thinks, "Perfect, wouldn't change a thing."
If you look beyond how people feel about driving though, a lot of people can see the effects. Kids don't have anywhere to play, people don't know who their neighbors are, people spend too much time commuting, housing costs are ridiculous, etc etc etc. These are all at least partly due to car culture.
> Kids don't have anywhere to play, people don't know who their neighbors are
Due to car culture? Even when I lived in Boston, there were plenty of places for kids to play. I moved a bit west near 495 and places to play are abundant.
Agreed on the commute time. A hard requirement for moving out of the city was proximity to MBTA commuter line.
Someday, the "car culture" people will leave Brooklyn and experience the real world, instead of just being told about it on social media.
Most of these fake concerns are contradictory, and apply in different places, and are thus part of the trade off of making decisions about where you want to live. But sure, "car culture" because it's someone else's fault your neighbors won't talk to you.
No, it's a simple fact that the majority are waking up to, that the car-centric culture and infrastructure has been destructive in many, many ways. It will take centuries to recover, and never fully.
why do americans think disney world is magical? It's a walkable town. The very basic assumptions of most people in most places (I can roughly get where I need without operating a dangerous vehicle) appear magical to americans, because the US destroyed its cities and public transit post WWII. A lot of the US is a terrible place to be for humans, because it's a (marginally) better place for cars.
I would’ve guessed it was the princesses and talking animals walking around.
But really, nobody’s grocery shopping in Disneyland. I’m all about more walkable cities but I think this is an unfair trope.
haha, totally fair. i do find that old saw about disney relevant to my own experience though. As an american visiting europe for the first time as a kid, I remember my mind was blown that you could be independent without knowing how to drive. But eh, I'm from kentucky, so maybe the difference was more radical to me than compared to what others would think from other parts of US.
And yet the American fantasy city is Disneyland's Main Street, i.e. a walkable neighborhood that existed in the pre-car USA and remains mostly the norm in Europe. There seems to be a revealed preference here that contradicts Americans' claimed attachment to their cars and McMansions.
Or perhaps people like Disneyland's Main Street because of the Disney characters and merch and attractions, and the fact that it's walkable is irrelevant.
I don't see anyone buying groceries or running day-to-day errands inside Disneyland, so I think it's not a great proxy for real life.
Then perhaps Disneyland should consider filling its theme parks with 6-lane stroads and strip malls and sea-sized car parks. The Disney characters could get around by car like everyone else (and enjoy it!). It would clearly better represent the American Dream.
They still tend to be way oversized for everyone driving. Some of this is zoning requirements -- banks have to have parking lots sized for the size of the bank, even though their traffic volume is tiny.
But even grocery stores where almost everyone does drive. I'm not sure I've ever seen a full parking lot at any supermarket or big box store. Maybe I need to stop by Costco on Black Friday.
Minimum parking requirements in the US were basically vibe-legislated in the 40s without any sort of data to back up decisions. Sure, 1 parking space per 3 church seats sounds about right.
For a country that likes to have the free market figure things out this is hilariously over-legislated and inefficient.
I live in a US city with a small (but well-stocked, good variety) grocery store within walking distance. My usual strategy is to buy from the big grocery store (that requires a car trip) once or twice a month for shelf-stable or freeze-able stuff, but walk to the local store 3-5 times per week for produce. What I buy there easily fits in one or at most two bags, and the walk is easy.
But I'm clearly not the common case in the US. I think there are two other scenarios that play out:
1. Some people in the US drive to a grocery store multiple times per week because they just don't have a small local grocery within walking distance.
2. Busy people (often parents) don't want to make frequent grocery store trips, so they drive to one and buy mostly shelf-stable stuff 3-4 times a month, and either stretch the produce as far as it will last, or just not make meals with produce in the days prior to their grocery trip.
So I think it's two things: availability of walkable grocery stores is low, and/or busy people don't want to make multiple trips per week, so they make fewer trips with quantities that require a car.
The lack of walkable grocery stores is a problem, definitely, but I think the latter bit is a preference that isn't unreasonable.
It's all interlocking because many cities have been built around cars. Everything's further apart because of parking lots so everything takes longer to get to so everyone needs a car. There are cities where public transit is decent, most amenities are a walk or ride away.
It's a big wheel to break. Like many of our problems (recycling, pollution, health, schools), it's a system problem that we're told is an individual problem.
You have out-of-town supermarkets in the UK and mainland Europe too. Places where people drive to and buy enough food for a family for week, or even a month.
But we also have smaller stores for essentials that are located inside residential estates and thus walkable from your house.
We have town centres where the parking is on the perimeter of the town and much of the centre is pedestrianised with shops densely packed next to each other. So you don’t need to drive from one shop to another.
This is a self-reinforcing feedback loop - since it's such a PITA to drive to all the way to costco, deal with parking and the crowds in the mega store, you gotta "make the trip count". If walking to the shop isn't an event, you don't need to stock up for the apocalypse every trip.
You’re expected to walk or use public transit to the groccery store to buy a weeks worth of grocceries for a family of 4? Does everyone pull wagons around?
They don't buy a week's worth of groceries. They go to the store more frequently. Most of them probably wouldn't even have enough space at home for a week's worth of groceries. They'll say it's better, but I prefer to drive myself to the store and buy a week's worth of groceries, so I'm glad I have the option to do so.
Yes we do still buy a weeks worth of shopping. We just don’t need to drive from one shop to another. We can drive and park in one communal parking lot and all the shops are locally clustered together.
whoa there buddy, I'm not sure you speak on behalf of a whole nation. Plenty of people do a weekly shop. Relatively recent (like the last decade or so) booms in supermarket delivery services saw to it that bulk shopping became both easy and cheap, tons of people do it.
The grocery store is a block away. It takes me three minutes to walk there. If I need more than two bags, I have a small shopping cart I use. It has never even crossed my mind that this is a problem.
I will sometimes drive to the big super market that's farther a way if I need some more exotic things, and then I might shop for the week, but that's rare and not really that necessary.
Yeah, the zone rules in America certainly don’t help here. As a European, I find that weird too because we seem to have fewer rules around where to open a shop than a country built on the principles of freedom and capitalism.
But I’m sure there’s plenty you guys find weird about how UK towns and cities are laid out too.
“Parking standards were created arbitrarily, without adequate data. Zoning laws usually require one parking space per apartment, one per 300 square feet of commercial development, and one per 100 square feet for restaurants. For context, a parking space measures 160 square feet on average, plus additional area for driveways and driving lanes, so an eatery’s parking lot may be three times the size of its dining area.”
I read the article as well because I know some people that sailed around the world with their kids, and they turned out to be well-adjusted adults that enjoyed their time sailing.
The parents in the article were something else. I agree with you 100%. Abandoning minors in a foreign country and leaving them to deal with immigration, etc. is abusive.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Longitude_(book)
reply