HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | _qua's commentslogin

lol the exact message that led me to ruin the family computer with Linux 20 years ago

National health reports cannot fix deep-seated cultural issues. I'm sure they'll come out with a nice report on strategies to improve men's wellbeing that won't make a lick of difference unless the world at large starts to shift.

Carney will still milk it as a way to get votes. There will be 3+ press conferences with leadership, and they will try to talk about it in ways that won't alienate the "remember École Polytechnique" crowd.

ultimately they will do nothing and pass more bills allowing big businesses to do whatever tf they want


Government reports like this sometimes motivate additional studies and think pieces, which in turn creates a framing that may be used later when society decides it's truly ready for change.

So no, they can't change the world, but sometimes they can plant a seed.


This all is just pure virtue signaling and the only beneficiary will be some NGO who gets some money and produces a report and a slide deck which only they will read. It's like the Soviet joke of "we had a 4 hour meeting about improving production in communism in the factory today and after this we will work not better and not worse than before". Until that suffering actually causes measurable damage that affects something on a grand scale that the country needs, nothing really will happen.

Nationwide change doesn't happen overnight. It involves years of unglamorous work by hundreds or even thousands people you and I don't even know about.

We live in a world that desperately needs drastic measures to change it.

But we live too comfortably for anyone to take those actions.

Like a boiling frog, ppl will wake up when its too late.


> National health reports cannot fix deep-seated cultural issues

It starts with an objective report on reality

It's like taking your blood pressure or blood sugar, it starts with data in health

This is public health and this report is the measuring instrument


This report is not an objective report on reality however (if such a thing is even possible when it comes to culture / psychology)


So it shouldn’t be reported on?

Can you expand on this? It seems to me that deep seated cultural issues are the sort of thing that therapy is supposed to address. However, I may be looking at this from the wrong angle.

The people who see issues with themselves get therapy. The ones that see no issues with themselves don't.

That is what "deep-seated cultural issues" means. Some subset of the population aren't seeing a problem with their own behavior. They see nothing that needs addressing. The rest have to learn how to put up with or avoid them.


Is efficacy not part of your calculus?

Isn't recognizing there is a problem the first step on fixing the problem?

The report gives no indication its a male problem. It’s just a survey targeting men. Maybe its a general mental health problem. We know mental health issues in women have increased over the same time period.

Okay? What's your point? That the report didn't find every problem, it just found one problem?

The claim is its a MALE mental health problem. Where is the evidence?

This report? The existence of a male mental health problem does not imply the existence or absence of a female mental health problem or any other type if mental health problem.

>The existence of a male mental health

Maybe you can you disambiguate your phrasing here. Which do you mean?

1.There is a MALE mental health problem -- some mental health problem wholly or partially unique to men

2. There is a mental health problem observed among men

If #1, where is the evidence? A men-only survey can't show it. If you surveyed left-handed people and 30% had anxiety, that doens't mean there is a left-handed anxiety problem.

If #2, we agree on what the research shows, but it brings your original point into question: "Isn't recognizing there is a problem the first step on fixing the problem?" Which problem are we recognizing? Labeling a general problem a male one assumes a diagnosis, which points the search for causes and fixes at men when nothing in this report shows that's where they are, and other available information shows worsening mental health in women as well.


My friend the only one doing assuming here is you. You've constructed this strawman argument where since this report doesn't prove X then just because it proves Y it's worthless. Proving Y has value.

My humble theory on naming: Argon-Carbon = ArC

Next: Silver, then Iodine

Slowly spelling out ARC-AGI


I don't really have the time to learn the math to really understand this stuff myself, and I'm not entirely sure I could learn it even if I had the time.

But I love to read about it and marvel that we as a species even managed to figure out this much about something so tiny and complex


You think pond water is the worst thing an $80 motel room has seen?


> Jugs of brackish water lined the walls. Buckets overflowed with hunks of marsh grass.

I don’t know, that goes a little above and beyond IMO. One typically doesn’t do science in a house-type setting, for many of the same reasons you don’t carpet a bathroom.


Probably poetic license. You can look at the pictures and see everything looks very clean.

The jugs are sealed. We can't see any "overflowing" buckets. Looking at some water samples under a microscope is not really that messy.


> for many of the same reasons you don’t carpet a bathroom.

someone should inform the orange POTUS of this: https://www.architecturaldigest.com/story/did-donald-trump-j...


> for many of the same reasons you don’t carpet a bathroom

For some reason this is a commonplace in the UK.

Yeah....


I had a colleague who walked the tiled floor in front of pissoirs in socks..


Ugh, I just realised my imagination is too good :)


Love it


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: