Mate, I’d go back and re-read the (updated) S-1 more thoroughly if I were you. (That is, if you’re thinking about getting in on the IPO based on your current understanding of the financials.) please take this as well-intentioned advice; you’ll find many of the future expenses are obfuscated, e.g., omitted from the overviews and disclosed in the ‘fine print’ instead…
That’s not true. Wolves are incredibly smart animals and will find and exploit weak points in otherwise expensive fencing systems. They also jump surprisingly high. Moreover, once they manage to cross a fence they do not kill to feed. Instead, they slaughter entire herds of sheep for the sport of it. I personally think wolves are incredible animals, but their sudden reintroduction in the Netherlands feels ill thought out.
“In a paper published in 2016, “The first proof of the recent presence of Wolves in the Netherlands,” authors wrote:
“In light of the expansion of wolves from the Polish border to the northwest of Germany and the sightings in Denmark, the appearance of the wolf in the Netherlands was no surprise to most experts. In March 2015, this expectation was fulfilled when, after generations without resident wolves, a single wolf wandered through the Dutch provinces of Drenthe and Groningen in broad daylight. From 7 to 10 March 2015, the Netherlands witnessed the comeback of an iconic species.”
Since 2019, the country has once again become home to its first pack of wolves with young pups after 150 years. Genetic sampling revealed the Netherlands wolves came from an Alpine population and Central European populations (i.e. Germany)“
> That’s not true. Wolves are incredibly smart animals and will find and exploit weak points in otherwise expensive fencing systems.
Pair the sheep and goat herds with one or two decent sheepdogs - Kangals/Karabaş, Ovcharka (in Slavic languages, ovce means sheep, so their purpose is literally their name) or similar large breeds. That is usually enough to drive off wolves to feed off of deer instead that are a true scourge for forestry when the hunters don't keep up.
Yes they can sometimes learn to jump high fences. And that particular incident could have been prevented if people were employing early warning detection systems.
Wolves don’t just encounter a farm and instantly jump over the fences. They would have been around for a significant period of time before doing that. And during that period they could have been detected and that attack prevented in all likelihood. This of course needs proper research but wolves are very cautious.
The wolf attack in question where a wolf jumped a fence 20 times could have been detected or cut short if an electronic detection system had been employed.
These systems have the potential to make a positive difference.
But these ways are not really being tried yet, 10 years later. We are not as adaptive as wolves it seems. Maybe that can change soon though.
I know, because I have developed such a system and studied a pack with it in Belgium the past year.
I captured wolves on video more than 60 times during that period. And in that period only 2x times were the wolves hanging around the farmers field which had horses (rather than simply passing by). I called the farmer and the wolves dispersed. The videos of this are also online.
The system uses thermal imaging and the University of Helsinki have incorporated the images into a thermally trained AI model. PIR sensors can detect wolves a relatively short distance away. But this system can detect wolves and label them as such at 50m or more.
Describing the slaughter as sport would not be accurate. The situation is an unnatural situation as the sheep have no way to escape. In a natural situation the prey would have had the opportunity to disperse.
If you try to break up a fight between domesticated dogs you would also note that they enter a different state of mind during such an attack. In these cases the trapped sheep just make the situation worse.
The fence however serves a very good purpose which in most cases would do its job. And in this particular case it’s also useful, it serves as a natural barrier to allow time for a detection system to detect the wolf and potentially invoke a response system. But it’s quite clear we need to adapt a little quicker ourselves, indeed our response was ill thought out.
Love how the 5 PCBs slot into each other to form the final shape.
With respect to the assembly: do yourself a massive favor and let the PCB fab also assemble the LEDs. With a simple bill of materials like this it will add very little cost, it saves you a _lot_ of time, and it might also reduce the chance of component damage from adding too much heat or from accidental ESD strikes. (I don’t know how much these Neopixels can handle, though.)
I'll bet there's some creative board layout so that the relevant controller IC and supporting passives can be soldered onto the back of one of the 5, then have solder jumpers or some such to actually connect it into the circuit. That way, you're not adding miles of unused trace to an active bus.
Of course, having a 5x PCB fab, but 4x+1 assembly would probably double the cost for a single turn of the device.
I would love to hear more about the process of making 5-fold symmetry work for board layout. That sounds maddening to get right.
As long as you can design the outline as a vector file somewhere else, it's easy enough to import as a board outline and then lay out on top of it. I also get the lure of assembly these days, but I would hand-solder a board like this for a one-off art project. Call me old fashioned, but I'm confident enough with soldering that I'd estimate a couple of hours to assemble and I like buying domestic which is less economical than the JLPCB special. If people started to ask for kits though...
I think your idea is pretty sound if you connect all but one of the boards in a ring and use a jumper for the control section.
I could go either way on hand-soldering a single assembly. But doing this more than once would be torturous.
I can only go so many days carefully monitoring diet and minimizing stimulant intake to minimize associated tremors. And I don't have rework microscope, so my eyes would definitely suffer.
“Some exhibited “haunted” behavior, seemingly jumping to random sections of the mcu program code, outputting messages on the display that made no sense given the context.
One of them appeared to work in slow motion, with LED blinking and display updates noticeably more sluggish than normal,”
my first thought was that it smelled like a clock issue.
Some of the nastier issues I have had the pleasure to debug included (a) traces that had microcracks which affected analog readings when the PCB heated up after prolonged usage (QC issue from the PCB fab) and (b) a (suspected) ESD strike that gradually took out several components in the weeks following as I was investigating the device while new problems kept popping up. Marginally stable composite amplifiers have also caused some headaches over the years.
As someone who does both hardware design (mostly high precision analog electronics) and software engineering, the difference between both fields in AI capability is striking. Models like Fable and Astra can provide lots of interesting insights into the design of specialty electronics when prompted correctly. Yet they can hardly put that knowledge to work if instructed to generate a schematic or lay out a PCB.
Of course, for readers here with a solid grasp on how LLM's operate it's not exactly surprising. Still, I feel this is exactly the kind of thing that drives home that the way we reason about (general) intelligence does not map cleanly to LLM operation, no matter how advanced the current models are.
If anything, it is surprising that the LLM is so bad at stealing a ready-made RP2350 design! There are plenty of easy-to-find tutorials like [0] and [1] that handhold you through the entire design process, and a simple search will give you dozens of design files for open-source boards.
At this level of board complexity you almost have to try to make it completely non-functional, so although it is nice to see it in practice I am not exactly surprised that a LLM with a decent bunch of assistance managed to do it. But there's quite a gap between the equivalent of poorly copying a "Hello World" from StackOverflow and making actual production-ready boards.
It’s the training data. Finished work isn’t training data because parts are sooooo different, but maybe if the finished designs were properly labeled into the training pipeline it might work? Or the iterative work itself might need to be the training corpus.
No worries, Astra already shows signs of improvement which should make you happy for the short time before you realize why they’re making it better at this and CAD in general
I just started using opus 4.8 and it's still trash at very domain specific stuff and debugging. It went down a rabbit hole trying to coerce the algorithm to work for 1 data point, which dramatically overfit the code. Later it did 11 experiments to try and figure out how to do the math, each one yielding an accuracy no better than a coin flip and each one it asserted beforehand that it had it this time, 100% accuracy.
That's last gen though. I agree it's mediocre. Try Astra. It's significantly better than Opus and even Fable. I'm not sure about earlier OpenAI models.
I didn't say it was AGI, I just said it wasn't trash and that it's significantly better than it used to be.
Anyway just because AI sales people continually jump the gun doesn't mean AGI is never going to happen. It just means you just have to try the models yourself to see how good they really are, which I have done. Astra is really freaking good. (If you aren't paying.)
I suggest you give it a try and base your opinion on that.
Yeah maybe. I dunno though, I'm using it in obscure SystemVerilog stuff. AI used to absolutely suck at that very recently but now it seems to have no problem.
I think the key is that you give it all of the info - put all the docs, the LRM, tool manuals, etc. in a directory so it can read it if it wants (it really really wants).
I used them a bunch just for the component shopping, I can route PCBs just fine, that's not a throttling factor in any project, but ability to "send it shopping" and not only get the price/availablity for the options but look thru datasheet for quirks and parameters is very useful.
Here’s one crucial difference: there’s overwhelming evidence that human emissions have an effect on our climate. The mechanisms are generally well-understood and the research is widely disseminated and easily available to anyone that’s interested.
With the ‘dangers’ touted by these insiders, it’s all “trust me bro”, hyperbole, and very little hard evidence. As such, a skeptical mind would question their motives.
You're simultaneously overestimating what was observable in the 70s climate research, and ignoring all the actual research and evaluation test results for AI today.
I don't expect people to be familiar with more than "trust me bro", but it's all right there for you to find with a search engine of choice.
And, indeed, available for the LLMs themselves to explain to you in interrogative conversation.
Who should I be more scared of? China, which has been doubling down on open transparent research, or the secretive US companies who are in bed with the most unhinged administration we've ever had and has been actively starting wars?
They're not proposing anything concrete, and when they do, what do you think the proposal will be? Will OpenAI and Anthropic open themselves for inspection so we can verify they really have stopped developing these "world ending" technologies? Or are their proposals going to be aimed at everyone running open Chinese models?
And if a threat to the human race does come from AI, it's going to come from OpenAI/Anthropic. Hypercapitalist, secretive, in bed with the government, plus multiple real documented hackings of open source infrastructure already.
We're a hell of a lot safer with China doing the same research out in the open and making it available to anyone. The choice might well be: one or two superintelligent autonomous AIs at OpenAI/Anthropic - or a lot of smaller ones, unable to be controlled but also coming out of a diverse set of environments.
One of those leads to a stable ecosystem where we can all coexist, the other is genuinely terrifying. But make no mistake, from OpenAI/Anthropic this is all motivated by their stock price - when you're in the silicon valley mindset, it distorts your reality. They've convinced themselves that everyone's safer if they stay on top and in control, conveniently ignoring how that benefits them, and I don't believe them for a minute.
Boredom may cause teenagers to commit acts of vandalism; it’s not a typical cause for revolution. (That would be things like famine, gross inequality, severe injustices and so on.)
From the article: “For well over a decade, the reliability data that exists (and I think this is backed up by the anecdotal experience that mechanics who work on Volvos have) is that Volvo reliability is mediocre to poor, but of course Volvo forums are full of people who insist that Volvos are among the most reliable cars and that the data are all wrong.”
The author mentions one explanation, which is that most people driving a Volvo won’t experience a breakdown (and then generalize from that). Another one is of a very different kind known as post-purchase cognitive dissonance (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cognitive_dissonance#Consumer_...).
A mistake that both Dan and the forum users made, was to discuss averages instead of reliability for certain platforms and/or engine types. Most manufacturers have models with wildly different reliability.
There is a confounding variable, however -- the person is most likely a good dev. It stands to reason that they've had a decent career at least since then.
reply