This is a misconception of what is being said in GEB.
Gödel's Incompleteness, very roughly, says that not every true statement (in a formal system) can be proven. In particular, it says that for a logic equipped with arithmetic the statement holds; how you get to security I do not follow.
The idea is that since you can make every security program turing complete, I thiiiiink?, then you can have it be a formal system. So, you can then get the code, in very tortured ways, to execute a paradox, thereby breaking it. Likely in enough ways to let you gain access, though not always.
I mean this in the nicest way, but I would never have dreamt to relate Gödel's incompleteness to this topic.
I think perhaps where I would diverge is that we should separate the language from the program. Generally, we say that a programming language is Turing complete.
Gödel's incompleteness is analogous to a paradox, e.g the Liar paradox, that is one useful way to understand the statement. But it seems as if you're saying it's a Contradiction (from where we can derive anything) something like EFQ:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principle_of_explosion
That does not follow, not all paradoxes are contradictions. For instance, just because Gödel's incompleteness pertains to first-order Logic does not mean that we can derive anything in first-order logic.
I think it’s even simpler, I think it’s just folks so excited about what they’re building that they forget that no-one else is spending 16 hours a day thinking about it, and it just gets missed.
Those profits are fake. It's the government printing money and inflating the numbers, but no consumable wealth was created, so there is nothing to distribute.
Nonsense. If you have a bag with 10 diamonds, and you sell 1, you find the richest person willing to buy one, so if he pays you 1 million, it is guessed that the 10 diamonds are worth 10 million. But the 10 million dont even exist. If you try to sell the second diamond. The richest one doesnt want it or wants to pay less. So the second richest wants to pay half a million. If you sell it, now the diamonds lost half his value. And if you try to sell the third diamond, nobody wants it, now the diamonds are worth zero.
where did the wealth gone? Nowhere. It never existed. The 10 million were just a guess
Actually, I believe the reason is that this post was heavily "flagged". For the first few hours (1-7hrs) this post had essentially the same amount of points and comments as https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50208960
While this one was on page 3-4 and the other post is (stilL) on the first page.
> Unions represent the interest of a large group of people, they arrive at policy through debate and consensus.
Well, in this case, how come preventing access to healthcare to NYS residents is in the interest of the teachers? And, why would teachers think that they are the only ones who deserve good health care?
Unless… the unions have no feedback mechanism to ensure that they operate the way you think they operate, and they do what any other politician does — they want to stay in power I exchange for keeping just enough of the voting base like you more than the next guy. So, in this case, it’s perfectly reasonable for a union leadership to fight this law — it simply a preservation of power thing.
>Well, in this case, how come preventing access to healthcare to NYS residents is in the interest of the teachers? And, why would teachers think that they are the only ones who deserve good health care?
I am not familiar with the particulars, but I am sure there is information published by the union explaining their position in more detail.
I reject your suggestion that I am ignorant how unions operate. I have been a member of a union for many years. Larger decisions are decided by voting.
Like democracy, unions are not perfect. But historically unions have been effective at negotiating rights for workers (weekends, 8hour workdays etc.)
I would argue they are one of the few ways labour has been able to impact policy and law.
> I reject your suggestion that I am ignorant how unions operate. I have been a member of a union for many years.
I was a member of a union as well.
> Larger decisions are decided by voting.
After they went through the filter of the leadership, either via the “bargaining committee” or any other form of delegation, selection to which can be based on votes or appointments.
You can Google yourself how teacher unions opposed NYS health care bill, and why they deemed it necessary to justify their position with “protecting the fought for benefits” among other things.
It is worth noting that, per the Piketty, Saez, and Zucman data, the tax rates of the top 0.1 and 0.01 percent of taxpayers have dropped substantially since the 1950s. The average tax rate on the 0.1 percent highest-income Americans was 50.6 percent in the 1950s, compared to 39.8 percent today. The average tax rate on the top 0.01 percent was 55.3 percent in the 1950s, compared to 40.8 percent today.
Note that those percentages include Federal, state, and local taxes.
I did not say "effective tax" you are moving the goal post.
It is no surprise to me that an organization originally founded by the chairman of General Motors, the president of Standard Oil and their like [0] is able to conclude:
>"The top 1 percent of Americans today do not face an unusually low tax burden, by historical standards."
Which is a wild claim to make.
Nice that you find the somewhat honest footnote, but you're citing what is essentially an opinion piece from a conservative think tank.
They're quoting a paper by respected economists, but feel free to discard it because it doesn't fit your priors.
And no, you didn't specifically say effective tax rate, but you did say that western countries effectively had a cap on how much you could earn (presumably that's what you meant, even though we're talking about a wealth tax here, not an income tax, but I digress), given a top marginal rate near 100%, but that's simply false, given that the effective tax rate even for the absolute most wealthy Americans was closer to 50%.
It's a little like complaining that university has gotten so expensive by just looking at the sticker price, while ignoring the fact that few people actually pay that, and the median price actually paid is much lower. That doesn't mean the effective price is where it should be either, but you do your position no favors with falsehoods.
My statement is corroborated by the source I linked. If you found it ambiguous, the precise statement I am referring to is illustrated in Figure 2 of my source.
You called the fact I raised a "tired talking point" and referenced a contentious source. While they do cite serious academics, they seem to draw their own conclusions in the text; unburdened by their references.
The law that requires allowing alternative browsers, the DMA, applies to the entire EU.
But I believe there are still zero third party browsers, to publish their browser in the EU Mozilla need an EU development team because developers outside the EU are unable to install it, and Mozilla cannot publish it as their existing app. Enforcement is taking years.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Worse_is_better
reply