HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | Timon3's commentslogin

> It's because carbon reduction has not been disconnected from material impoverishment.

IMO this inverts the real chain of causality: it's because carbon reduction has been connected to material impoverishment.

There's endless propaganda blaring how only endless growth can give us prosperity. If you even think about advocating for decreased energy usage, you want to kill poor people and China to win (I've had both of these thrown at me on HN).

We have a multi-trillion industry who has been pouring billions into psychological manipulation. IMO evaluating statements like the quote in this light makes a whole lot of things make sense.


Spot on. The discourse that fossil fuels are necessary for wealth is propagated by those whose wealth is built on fossil fuels. It is entirely possible to have an even more prosperous society if all the energy sources isn't tied to the profits of the "dig up and pump fuel" concerns.

I'm always puzzled by this inevitable response. By what measure will earth be fine without us?

Life in the planet has recovered perfectly from five mass extinctions without our help. Each one of those killed from 75 to 90% of the species alive.

Why is the only relevant measure "is there any life left"?

Because that's what we mean by "Planet Earth will be fine". Earth will continue to hold the trait of being hospitable for life, in a way that we believe all the other planets in our solar system are not. Its distance from the sun, its size, density, atmosphere, water, axial tilt, magnetic field, etc. all very fine qualities in a planet for making life (as we know it) possible.

Earth was about 800 million years old when the first signs of life appeared, and it was 3 billion years old before multicellular life appeared. It took another billion years before things like animals and plants appeared (the Cambrian explosion), and since then there's only been like 500 million years of history.

Most mass extinctions have happened in the past 500 million years and have killed off huge swathes of life on the planet, but new lifeforms have come back, on a much shorter timescale than 4 billion years, because it hasn't had to start from scratch. That's what we mean by "fine", and why it would be a problem if all life (even the single celled life) were eradicated.


> Because that's what we mean by "Planet Earth will be fine".

I seriously doubt the majority of humans agrees that "planet earth will be fine" means "planet earth still has any life left", so that doesn't explain why this is the correct yardstick.


The planet has been here for 4 billion odd years and will continue to be here for billions more - this despite the extinction of dinosaurs after a massive meteorite strike, being splatted and damn near cleaved in half by a moon sized chunk .. that created the moon we have, existing for a long period of time with an atmosphere toxic to life as we know it today, and a good while with an essentially molten surface.

This third rock from the sun will happily just keep orbiting on, with or without us, regardless of how much we fart old carbon into the atmosphere.


Do you really not understand that people do not mean "the planet earth" when they refer to "the earth" in this context?

That's what I don't understand. Are you willfully misinterpreting this statement, or do you really not understand?


So without attacking you, I would agree with the other replies in this thread - there is some confusion, generally speaking, when people talk about "destroying the planet" or "destroying life on Earth".

Past changes in climate comparable to current global warming did indeed cause global mass extinctions; the most severe was the Permian-Triassic extinction (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Permian%E2%80%93Triassic_extin...). However, life did recover ... it just took millions of years to do so.

I disagree, therefore that it is 'useless pedantry' to distinguish between the ecological damage in the short-term that will definitely affect humans, and the long-term where the biosphere _should_ eventually recover. If anything, the large amount of time relative to human-scale should make it more alarming, not less.


I doubt anyone is seriously confused. There is no objective threshold for "the earth is destroyed", and the majority of people do not use the phrase to mean "the earth has become inhospitable to all life", so insisting that someone is wrong because their use doesn't align with your preferred use is useless pedantry.

All my people have a fair grasp of what "the planet earth" means.

Collectively we have a fair to bleeding edge grasp of seismology, magnetotellurics, radiometrics, Gravimetry, tidal modelling, geological time, geological strata, etc.

Are you wilfully misinterpreting these things, or do you really not understand?


What the hell are you talking about, who are "your people"? I can't remotely understand what you're trying to convey.

I didn't ask the question for fun. You seem to be deliberately misinterpreting the statement by rustcleaner. Why? Why not keep to the HN guidelines, and actually respond to their point? As a reminder:

> Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith.


> , who are "your people"?

People that study the planet, as opposed to the biosphere.


So you really are just willfully misinterpreting the initial statement, since you're well aware that GP was talking about something else.

Could you maybe not do that? It's not funny or insightful, it just sucks the air out of discussions.


You appear to be the one wilfully confusing "a house" with "it's occupants".

It is very clear, to native english speakers at least, that was exactly the distinction made above: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50515074

Could you maybe not do that? It's not funny or insightful, it just sucks the air out of discussions.


> You appear to be the one wilfully confusing "a house" with "it's occupants".

This is exactly the kind of useless pedantry I'm talking about! It's a completely normal way of speaking, which native english speakers should have encountered countless times: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metonymy

You might not like seeing this figure of speech, but can't you just pull yourself together and not post the same useless "correction" for the millionth time?


And can't you just pull yourself together and not post the same useless "correction" for the millionth time?

For a great many people, what you call "useless pedantry" is an important distinction - in the history of planet earth a number of lifeforms have come and gone.

Should humans alter the insulation factor to such a degree than they disrupt the very biosphere that supports them, that's bad for humans.

As far as planet earth goes, it's another wave of life crashing, with others to follow.


> For a great many people, what you call "useless pedantry" is an important distinction - in the history of planet earth a number of lifeforms have come and gone.

"The planet will not literally blow up" is not an important distinction for anyone.

But I've already wasted far too much time with your poor trolling attempts, please do your "I am very smart" schtick somewhere else.


You know, from my PoV, as someone who cares a great deal about AGW and planetary systems it's very much yourself that appears to be a troll here.

You asked a question, I answered in good faith, and you've done little other than sling bile since.

Here's an interesting paper: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S036031992...

it's about something that may very well help a human centric biosphere .. but, you know, it came from people that make a distinction between planetary studies and biosphere studies in order to have a better understanding.


You wrote one response in good faith, to which I responded in good faith. Since then, all your replies have been mocking and trolling: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50516056

That would be awesome! IIRC zellij supports this, but that only works as long as it intercepts all selection inputs. Having a more universal standard that terminal emulators can support would be great.

I don't really see how these terminal borders would make any of these issues worse? You can build a wasteful 144Hz TUI using only dots and spaces. There's a tiny bit of overhead for the extra commands, but everything else seems to be an implementation detail, no?

Oh not talking about this library in particular, more like a general whine.

This one in particular seems to have the terminal render the effects, so if there's blame it lies elsewhere.

Hmm relying on a terminal extension that only implemented in one terminal could also be a concern, but maybe it's time terminals evolved.


> I think the backlash was fed by insistence dwarf planets are not just a subtype of planets[...]

I'm 99.9% certain that the backlash would have been far greater if our solar system suddenly had dozens extra planets.

> But you never hear people explaining why the IAU insists "dwarf planets" aren't "planets" even when "dwarf planets" has several subcategories which don't share the "planet" moniker[...]

Because otherwise the definition would differ greatly from our historical classification. Since it is necessarily arbitrary, sticking close to our history IMO seems like the obvious choice.


The historical IAU term such bodies was already "minor planets", the public was not in backlash about it despite there being over 100,000 of them by the time the "dwarf planet" category was created. "Minor planets" was even historically a subcategory of planets for a long time.

But, as said above, it'd still have went over fine if, instead of considering dwarf planets a subcategory of planet, the IAU had just not used "planet" in the category of things they didn't want people to consider planets. E.g. like they did for breaking "small solar system bodies" out of "minor planets".


Yeah, and people clearly didn't count them as "real planets", except for Pluto. So what's the issue? How are "dwarf planets" less planet-y than "minor planets" were?

Had the IAU said "Pluto is now a minor planet, which is a type of planet different than major planets" it would have gone over really well, been clear, historically accurate, and scientifically accurate.

Had the IAU said "Pluto is now a dwarf body, which is not a type of planet" it would have still been unpopular, at least clear, no more historically inaccurate than coming up with "dwarf planet", and scientifically accurate.

What the IAU actually decided was "Pluto is now a dwarf planet, which is not a type of planet at all". Since the sole positive attribute of this is it is scientifically accurate, it will have some level of unpopularity and be the cause of endless confusion even after everyone who knew Pluto as a planet is long dead.

I'm very supportive/glad they made it so Pluto wasn't the exact same classification as the remaining 8 planets. I'm continually facepalming over the absolute insistence to name the category dwarf planets but not have it be a type of planet.


> Had the IAU said "Pluto is now a minor planet, which is a type of planet different than major planets" it would have gone over really well, been clear, historically accurate, and scientifically accurate.

I disagree on multiple levels:

1. It would still have gone over very poorly, because many people explicitly oppose the demotion of Pluto. Demoting it to a different category would not change the issue in those people's eyes.

2. I doubt that "[...] a type of planet different than major planets" would improve clarity much for the general public - if you've seen studies or similar, a reference would be appreciated. But changing the meaning of an established term would definitely be far less clear on the academic side (since every mention would be ambiguous before the publishing year and/or individual stances of the authors/journal are known).

3. "Historically accurate" depends on what type of accuracy we're talking about, because IMO this approach is less historically accurate because we'd be changing the definition of an existing term, without a meaningful difference aside from that (since both are literally named X planets).

4. I'd need an argument for why it'd be more scientifically accurate. Since we were unaware of most of the objects in our solar system when the previous classifications were created, it's again IMO much more scientifically accurate to create a new classification.

> Had the IAU said "Pluto is now a dwarf body, which is not a type of planet" it would have still been unpopular, at least clear, no more historically inaccurate than coming up with "dwarf planet", and scientifically accurate.

This one would have been even less popular! It's definitely historically less accurate when talking about Pluto and previous minor planets, though at least I can agree regarding the scientific accuracy.

> What the IAU actually decided was "Pluto is now a dwarf planet, which is not a type of planet at all". Since the sole positive attribute of this is it is scientifically accurate, it will have some level of unpopularity and be the cause of endless confusion even after everyone who knew Pluto as a planet is long dead.

It's definitely less unpopular than "dwarf body" and much more clear than "minor planet (no, the new one)"! And as explained, I'd argue it's historically the most accurate one.


Yeah, I know exactly what you mean! But it's important to remember that we can't presume any physical rules to apply to "before the universe". So while our reality is bound by cause and effect, it's entirely possible that the creation of the universe did not necessitate a cause.

In other words: insufficient data to provide a meaningful answer. Hopefully we'll find ways to gather more data! :)


Following this logic, a black hole with earth's mass would be a planet.

You could add a hydrostatic equilibrium requirement, which is what the IAU definition does. It doesn't really affect anything else the GP was saying.

Why did we add this requirement? To fit how you want to classify planets? That retcon was not executed well.

It shows that the line of reasoning makes no sense, because any classification is constructed to fit some of our preconceived notions. Choosing a classification that builds off our social history is perfectly fine, as long as the rules for classification are applied consistently.


Hydrostatic equilibrium is the most defensible of the requirements to be a planet.

The IAU wording is, "...has sufficient mass for its self-gravity to overcome rigid body forces so that it assumes a hydrostatic equilibrium (nearly round) shape."

In this case it just means that the planet's mass and therefore gravity is sufficient to give it a spheroidal shape. (Technically the equilibrium is with the opposing push from the planet's material, which resists gravity's attempts to compress it. The result is a sphere, made spheroidal in real planets by rotation.)

Less massive objects like asteroids can have weird shapes, like the asteroid Toutatis which has a sort of dumbbell / unshelled peanut shape. The hydrostatic equibrium requirement prevents such objects from being classified as planets, as well as small objects that just happen to be round for other reasons.

This isn't really social history but simply classifying the objects according to intrinsic properties, which seems fine to me. This classification could be applied to objects anywhere in the universe without any problem.

The other two requirements are more problematic and arbitrary. One is that it has "cleared its orbit". Earth, let alone Mercury, would be unlikely to qualify for this if it were at the same distance as Pluto, for example. Rogue planets also can't satisfy this one, and we've observed those.

The other is that it has to be in direct orbit around the Sun, not a satellite of some other object. This excludes exoplanets as well as rogue planets. The rationale for this is that they didn't have enough observational info to say much about exoplanets, but that seems like a flimsy excuse. A good definition would apply to exoplanets by virtue of being theoretically sound, and not having been tuned to fit the way they were trying to classify solar system planets.


> Less massive objects like asteroids can have weird shapes, like the asteroid Toutatis which has a sort of dumbbell / unshelled peanut shape. The hydrostatic equibrium requirement prevents such objects from being classified as planets, as well as small objects that just happen to be round for other reasons.

Okay, and how did you arrive at the hydrostatic equilibrium requirement? What law of nature told you that planets must be spheroidal?

You're only adding this requirement so the outcome fits your pre-existing desired results, since you're literally arguing for the requirement based on what objects it excludes. And what are the consequences of such arbitrary decisions, according to you? "You can't get away with that in, say, physics and still end up with useful theories[...]"

Do you get the issue with this line of critique? There is literally no useful definition of "planet" that is non-arbitrary.


> any classification is constructed to fit some of our preconceived notions

That is not the concern here. It seems to me that you're failing to account for intent. Classifications exist to serve a useful purpose. What I object to is mental gymnastics used to gerrymander a particular outcome. These things should conform to something resembling occam's razor - minimalism in pursuit of a generalized goal.


> These things should conform to something resembling occam's razor - minimalism in pursuit of a generalized goal.

That is literally what happened - a definition for "planet" that is as minimal as possible, while staying as close to our historical categorization as possible.

Now, I know you'll object to the "while staying as close to our historical categorization as possible" part, but that is literally how scientific fields always approach arbitrary classifications. Without taking our historical use into account, there is no "objective" definition you can derive.

If I'm wrong, please give me an example of what kind of definition for "planet" you'd be happy with. But remember, it must not take into account what we today consider "planets" to be.


> but that is literally how scientific fields always approach arbitrary classifications

No, not always. What you are describing there are shoddy classifications. I already addressed this exact point in my previous reply when I stated that classifications are crafted to serve a useful purpose. It is sometimes useful to hew close to the historical norm; other times it serves no purpose.

> But remember, it must not take into account what we today consider "planets" to be.

An arbitrary restriction that I do not accept.

> please give me an example of what kind of definition for "planet" you'd be happy with

I already did this in my original comment. I proposed an earth centric system that bins mass by powers of ten. My proposed range for planets was 10^23 <= x < 10^26. Hydrostatic equilibrium works well as a constraint to eliminate things that are clearly not earth like (such as black holes) but alternative formulations such as stipulating an acceptable density range are possible (such cross cutting subcategories might even be preferable).

Note that this would result in ganymede being classified as both a planet and a moon. I think that makes perfect sense given how similar in size it is to mars. In fact ganymede being excluded as a planet is precisely the sort of gerrymandering I object to.

As it turns out my proposed criteria also relegates pluto to the status of dwarf planet. I think that's sensible given that it's both smaller and lighter than the moon. However I'd be willing to entertain a set of criteria that acknowledged both pluto and the moon as proper planets - the important thing to me is consistency.


I don't see how your proposed criteria are any less of a shoddy retcon.

Then presumably you either did not read what I wrote or are otherwise not engaging in good faith. The criteria I proposed are clearly not gamed to achieve specific set membership. Ganymede should be sufficient as proof of that.

> that is literally how scientific fields always approach arbitrary classifications.

That's a big overstatement. It's how some soft science fields sometimes do it. You can't get away with that in, say, physics and still end up with useful theories, because your theories quickly break down due to inconsistencies. You can't design working scientific theories by committee, because votes don't affect fundamental physical reality.

Much of astronomy is a hard science, which is why this definition came in for pushback even from astronomers themselves. Here's astronomer Phil Plait's take:

> "For some time now I, and many others, have stated that the IAU definition is silly for many reasons, including a line that says that planets can only orbit the Sun. If that’s true, then exoplanets — worlds orbiting other stars — aren’t really planets!" -- https://www.syfy.com/syfy-wire/mea-culpa-are-exoplanets-plan...

The article goes on to clarify that the IAU explicitly limited its definition to solar system planets - in fact, the resolution is titled ""Definition of a Planet in the Solar System."

As such, it's not even a universal scientific definition for "planet".

Another quote:

> "At [the IAU] 2006 international meeting in Prague, they drafted a series of defining characteristics for planets and put it to a vote. The definition passed, and the outcome was entirely predictable: They made things a lot worse."

> "...the more proximate problem is that these definitions are, um, silly."

-- https://www.syfy.com/syfy-wire/redefining-planets-answer-sea...


> That's a big overstatement. It's how some soft science fields sometimes do it. You can't get away with that in, say, physics and still end up with useful theories,

Sorry, but this objection reveals that you either don't understand the topic of discussion at all, or you're arguing in bad faith. No theory in physics will break if you change the criteria of an arbitrary classification.

I'll pose the same challenge to you: please give me an example of what kind of definition for "planet" you'd be happy with. But remember, it must not take into account what we today consider "planets" to be.


> Sorry, but this objection reveals that you either don't understand the topic of discussion at all, or you're arguing in bad faith.

Nice false dichotomy and binary thinking.

You're right that arbitrary classifications are arbitrary, obviously. My point is that you can't get away with arbitrary classifications in the context of hard science theories.

There's an example of a definition of "planet" in one of those Plait articles I linked:

> "A planet is a sub-stellar mass body that has never undergone nuclear fusion and that has sufficient self-gravitation to assume a spheroidal shape adequately described by a triaxial ellipsoid regardless of its orbital parameters."

That comes from the following paper: https://www.hou.usra.edu/meetings/lpsc2017/pdf/1448.pdf

The Plait articles are worth reading, because they might help disabuse you of the notion that the IAU definition is a good one, and explain why it would make sense to have a better one.


> My point is that you can't get away with arbitrary classifications in the context of hard science theories.

Arbitrary classifications don't factor into hard scientific theories, so I have no idea how this is relevant. Or what "hard science theory" are you thinking of that relies on whether we classify an object as a planet?

We can modify arbitrary classifications without any theories being affected, because the theories don't rely on arbitrary classifications. We arbitrarily decided what "one meter" is, yet we use "meters" all over physics. We could change the definition of "one meter" tomorrow, and all our theories would stay valid, because they don't rely on arbitrary classifications.

> There's an example of a definition of "planet" in one of those Plait articles I linked:

>> "A planet is a sub-stellar mass body that has never undergone nuclear fusion and that has sufficient self-gravitation to assume a spheroidal shape adequately described by a triaxial ellipsoid regardless of its orbital parameters."

How does one arrive at this definition, without taking into account what we today consider "planets" to be? What principle of physics tells you that a planet must be sub-stellar mass, or that it has never undergone nuclear fusion?

You'll have to actually explain how this definition is any less arbitrary, but I don't think you'll be able to, because every useful definition falls under your objection.


A lot of comments here explicitly complain about the precise terminology of experts in technical settings.

> And know what doesn't change? People are still inputting requirements into the machine

Before LLMs, only incredibly few programs were written by "inputting requirements into the machine", most code was about inputting instructions that fulfill requirements. Usually code is/was related to the requirements, but for anything non-trivial it was almost never a direct translation of the requirements.

So as far as I can see, you're trying to gaslight here.


Given the context, there really isn't much difference between "requirements" and "instructions", per se. It's the result that matters. Flipping switches, using punch cards/tape, typing hex/alphanumeric characters or using speech with coding tools all result in code.

Few programs were written in the past because the effort required was huge. Can you imagine how long it'd take to correctly code a simple calculator using only 0's and 1's? Or even hexadecimal? And then suddenly it took just a few lines of C. The transformation scale is similar now we can use natural language instead of having to learn a programming language.


You're pretending there's not much difference between "requirements" and "instructions", but there very obviously is - it's the entire goddamn reason programmers were/are needed. If you were correct, there'd be no reason to spend so much money on people who translate requirements into instructions, but that's not how the absolute majority of our industry worked before LLMs.

> Few programs were written in the past because the effort required was huge.

What are you talking about? A lot of programs were written in the past.


I can't tell if you're being deliberately thick or are just incredibly good at missing the point. I'd think it's pretty obvious that there's little distinction in my use of "instructions" vs "requirements": whatever it is that you give a machine, which it then assembles/compiles/interprets in such a way that you can use the output for some task (really can't think of any better way to break this down). There's little distinction because that thing you give, whether it's in machine, a programming or a natural language, yields the same result per intention like "good morning", "bonjour" and "ohayo" all elicit a greeting result.

The primary reason why programmers are/were needed is because humans and machines speak different languages natively, and someone/something needs to bridge the communication gap. That bridge is done via translating instructions/requirements into the many programming languages we've developed. Now we have LLMs to also do the translation.

> A lot of programs were written in the past

Yes, comprehensively, but also only "recently" (given any 2+ slices of advancement in tools used for software development). Somehow you missed the - I think - very clear "0's and 1's"/"hexadecimal" -> "C" and "programming language" -> "natural language" references.


> I can't tell if you're being deliberately thick or are just incredibly good at missing the point. I'd think it's pretty obvious that there's little distinction in my use of "instructions" vs "requirements": whatever it is that you give a machine, which it then assembles/compiles/interprets in such a way that you can use the output for some task[...]

I understand you perfectly well, I'm just calling out your misrepresentation of these words, because they are very much distinct in our industry, even today. Trying to say differently is simply gaslighting.


It isn't a misrepresentation. At every point it was human communicating with machine. That's the context set from the very beginning. Whatever the language used in that communication, whatever the actual input provided is called, however many layers of translation between the input and the output, it's all the same result: things that map user input to machine output. And to the original point, humans are integral to the production of said things.

Nope, you can't just redefine "communication" to be equivalent to "programming" and "inputting requirements".

If programming isn't communication, then what is it?

"Communication is commonly defined as the transmission of information. [...] A common way to classify communication is by whether information is exchanged between humans, members of other species, or non-living entities such as computers." - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Communication


There are entire Wikipedia pages where you can look up questions like "what is programming": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computer_programming

How did you find the page on communication, but not the one on programming?


"Computer programming is the composition of sequences of instructions, called programs, that computers can follow to perform tasks."

What point are you trying to make?


Notice how it doesn't talk about programming being a "composition of sequences of requirements"? Or how it's not defined "as the transmission of information"?

Again, what is your point? State it clearly.

From the start, my point has been that your initial take[0] :

>> AI definitely produces bad software

> Does your IDE of choice produce bad software?

is fundamentally wrong, because your arguments rely on equivocating concepts that have well-defined qualitative differences.

[0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50464721


What concepts were wrongly equivocated and in what way?

This kind of take is so tiring. There's not even an argument, just a willful misrepresentation of the situation.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: