HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | TheAlchemist's commentslogin

The major difference is the price. IPO used to be bets that the businesses will grow quickly, and the price reflected the risks.

Looking at recent mega-IPOs - SpaceX and Anthropic, with OpenAI coming soon, the price assumes that the company will be a success and simply discounts the projected future cash flow, as it was not risky at all. Future is not certain though. It will be fun.


He apparently hired the firm managing 'this kind of cases' a year ago already. This was long time coming.

Yeah, that's my thesis since the beginning of this madness. I see it as a temporary blip (albeit it's already much much longer than I would expect !) and once the bubble pops, Nvidia will be back to their normal cruising speed. Which is a good company, making great products, but their valuation will be 1/10 of what it is now. And if the boom continues, there is no way either that their clients won't develop a product of their own. It just doesn't make sense to buy chips by the 10s of billions $ on which Nvidia makes >50% margin.

If anybody had any doubts about the morality of Silicon Valley guys...

Jensen is a fantastic founder and what he achieved is nothing short of extraordinary. He should be celebrated for that.

However, there are 2 issues.

First, everything points to the fact that he knowingly evaded sales restriction to China on products that are considered crucial to national security. That's pretty much equivalent to leaking confidential info from Los Alamos during WW2...

Second, I like to think that US, despite all its challenges recently, is still a country of law. Nvidia is a public company. With great power comes great responsibility. He failed that responsibility. I really don't see why law shouldn't apply to him.


it appears that what they did was not illegal under the current rules, which is why they are discussing changing the rules.

If this was a cut and dried evasion of export controls we would have a very different situation.

The fact is that many disagree with their decision to make the chips more available, but people’s opinions are not laws.


> That's pretty much equivalent to leaking confidential info from Los Alamos during WW2

That statement sounds totally crazy. Los Alamos was manufacturing a bomb, during a war.

GPUs are not weapons (despite what the novlang says) and there is no war going on.


I don't agree with it either, but all this AI bubble is considered top national security.

I've heard news now that no,Megaspeed was not transferring chips to China, they only rented the compute.

So right now lots of conflicting information around.


Do you have any evidence to back up "knowingly" and "evaded"? Megaspeed was not on the export control list.

Well, he slept with their CEO. Pretty sure that qualifies as knowingly.

She wasn't the CEO, and even if she was, sleeping with one doesn't mean you magically know everything their company is up to.

"Pretty sure" isn't a legal standard. In criminal cases, the standard is "beyond reasonable doubt".

There was no criminal case, yet. That may come later.

What would you expect as 'beyond reasonable doubt' here ? A written statement from Jensen saying that yes, I did know who that person is and were these chips are going ?


> That's pretty much equivalent to leaking confidential info from Los Alamos during WW2...

No it's not.


Government flip flopping on export restrictions costs him billions, of course he will try to side step them.

Also, can we please stop calling it national security? US wants to slow down Chinas AI progress, because we want the western companies to dominate the AI field.


Just like we knew for at least a year already about the sales through Singapore. A lot of people called it for what it is at the time already (see for example: https://www.ft.com/content/6b1ce190-24d4-4f39-a518-ef9dae5fa...). And yet, things unrolled very slowly, then suddenly.

My theory is that once new CEO is found, especially if he comes from the outside, he will be highly incentivized to denounce past sins and disclose as much as possible to start with a clean sheet. I would bet that this is one of the main reasons the stock is tanking. House of cards is about to collapse, and that may be the trigger.


> My theory is that once new CEO is found, especially if he comes from the outside, he will be highly incentivized to denounce past sins and disclose as much as possible to start with a clean sheet.

Very much this. If you read the article it mentions that the current acting CEO was against investing into startups and disagreed with Jensen Huang.


"Select Customers", aka Tesla influencers.

Robotaxi was supposed to cover 50% of US population by the end of 2025, how is that going ?

30k + 300/month makes absolutely no sense given that they are restricted to smallish areas of operation. Just another Tesla PR stunt.


It's really not bad when you think about it. Basically a private chauffeur around town for $30K + 300 bucks a month. If it had a steering wheel to go outside of the autonomous zone I would buy one. If I was richer I would buy one without a steering wheel as a second car so I don't have to drive for 90% of my trips.

Whats to stop Elon getting greedy and changing the price ?

Based on my experience with Starlink: nothing

Large traditional companies.

Recent trend is quite the opposite. What's Tesla without Musk selling pipe dreams ? Pretty sure there is 0 plan for replacement.


Are you suggesting that one cherry picked example proves a new trend?

Nvidia, SpaceX, Tesla - that's 3 out of 3 new companies in top 10 US.

two people

And 3 out of top 10 US companies by valuation. Sample size is obviously small. But if you look at larger picture, there is lots of them.

If the woman involved turns out to really be a Chinese spy, then it will definitely ruin his life.

AI and chips are, for better or worse, considered a national security matter.


Being a “Chinese spy” has very little to do with reality, much like being a terrorist. It’s a matter of what the State Department decides.

He is the the tech CEO most aligned with the current government’s optimism towards the AI build out and also its key orchestrator. What are the odds he will be held to any real punishment ?

I would not bet on punishment that is meaningful unless he screwed over other big capitalists. That's the one law you cannot break.

Being a state of national security, yes.

Spy is rather easy to define though, and it hardly depends on what the State Department decides (although of course, they can call anybody a spy, for political or other reasons, I agree on that).


I don't know why this is being downvoted. The federal government has never really prevented a terrorist attack that they themselves have not recruited. It is entrapment, and it is legal in most cases. I know it sounds like a conspiracy theory, but even mainstream media has covered this: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2011/nov/16/fbi-entrapment...

It is perfectly reasonable to suspect similar claims of catching "spies".


Your article doesn't support your claim that the 'federal government has never really prevented a terrorist attack'. And a lot of that was highly motivated reporting itself by people like Glenn Greenwald who was basically denying that things like ISIS were real threats at all in 2014 and then went full victim blaming for things like Charlie Hebdo the year after (it was harder after the Bataclan).

Will you next claim that the police have never really prevented a murder?


I gave a link as a reference of how the Federal government operates. I did not think that I needed a whole bibliography to prove something that is very easily verifiable.

Not only that you think the reporting is not reliable because of the reporter without pointing out what is wrong with the actual report.

But I'll humor you.

- Here is the judge calling the US government the co-conspirator in the same case: https://ny1.com/nyc/all-boroughs/news/2023/07/27/judge-quest...

- The Gretchen Whitmer kidnapping plot:

- https://www.rawstory.com/plot-to-kidnap-michigan-governor/

- https://reason.com/2022/04/08/gretchen-whitmer-kidnapping-pl...

- The liberty city seven: https://www.nbcnews.com/id/wbna22249838

- The cleveland bomb plot: https://truthout.org/articles/cleveland-anarchist-bomb-plot-...

- Sami Osmakac: https://archive.is/NINN0

---

These are all the cases that had some investigative reporter poking, or the jury/judge seeing through the bullshit. Here is initial reporting on recent cases. The "Iranian Agent" sent to "Assassinate Donald Trump"(emphasis mine):

>Asif Merchant traveled to New York in June for the purpose of meeting with men he thought he was recruiting to carry out the killings, even paying a $5,000 advance to two would-be assassins who were actually undercover law enforcement officers, federal officials said

https://www.ksat.com/news/politics/2024/08/06/pakistani-man-...

The woman arrested for "plotting to bomb the NY state capital":

>According to the criminal complaint, an FBI confidential source drove Bowie to the Home Depot in Rensselaer and gave her $200 to buy bomb parts. It’s not clear if they told her what items to buy.

https://cbs6albany.com/news/local/feds-say-capital-bombing-t...

---

This is not some fringe idea even here on HN. Here is a clear fed trying incite people to commit violence: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49629430

This common in most internet forums. It is called fedposting: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que... https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/fedpost

I hope all of these sources are of sound character by your standards. Now I would ask you; can you give me an example of the FBI catching a terrorist that:

a) They did not recruit, or b) Did not provide materials, or c) did not provide the target

AS for the police in the US, they are indeed very bad at preventing crime. Though that is due to multiple reasons, mostly policy related, rather than institutional malfeasance like the FBI.


Generally speaking, it's normal to keep it private.

Unless the CEO happens to be the CEO of what is considered one of the most important company for national security and future, and his private life involves somebody who appears to be a spy for the biggest competitor for world hegemony. Then it's kind of big deal for everybody.


>for the biggest competitor for world hegemony.

thank you for maintining the WW1->Cold War era great-game / hegemonic frame. Nation-states love you for it.


> And the data center trade has been unwound in just 2 days is a pretty violent shock.

It's very very far from being unwound. If (or when) it does, many companies in the space will be down 90-100%. Definitely not today.


> It's very very far from being unwound.

The grind-down has barely started. We were waiting for a catalyst and it was unexpected. The narrative has shifted to a widespread negative ai-vibe and is hard to counter with any amount of propaganda by the pro ai-crowd. Datacenter debt will be repriced and along with that capex-cuts. These take time and have barely started. The markets have smelt that these are around the corner.


The writing is on the wall. They lost. No amount of whining from SV people who don't go outside, who do not live in the real world, and who are high on their own supply of agents and harnesses who vibe-code all day in their small EA/rationalist bubbles and produce very little of actual economic value for normal people and who are so arrogant they are attempting to impose their dystopian will upon people will change this.

Investors are not rationalists or effective altruists. They chase the money. If the fundamentals and DD does not math to allow data centers to be profitable, and governments honor the people's will, they will jump ship and quicker than you think. And if governments do not honor the people's will (which is firmly in opposition to the odious people behind this push) then we have far bigger problems to worry about.


> And if governments do not honor the people's will... then we have far bigger problems to worry about.

Oh, yeah, sure. They'll get right on that. Patriot act is going away any day now. Climate change and healthcare and judicial / law enforcement reform going to be addressed any second.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: