HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | Terr_'s commentslogin

Another distinction along the spectrum might be: Why an LLM system, and not just a conventional deterministic AI expert system?

I wouldn't mind "digital locks" so much if the owners actually got the keys to the things they bought.

Ideally we'd link it to a political move: "Look at how this consumer was hurt and oppressed, but with the power of access to their own damn stuff they were able to repair it to usefulness."

Ideally we'd link it to a political move, and use that for staying-power: "Look at how this consumer was hurt and oppressed, but with the power of access to their own damn stuff they were able to repair it to usefulness."

I've had a co-worker "review" my change using an LLM, and the comment concerned a pre-existing behavior... Which was introduced by the same person.

I feel this overlaps with the "Politician's Syllogism" [0]:

    1. We must do something.
    2. This is something.
    3. Therefore, we must do this.
In other words, if we start by choosing an option without trying to determine what makes it best/good/appropriate, then failing to measure results seems like a continuation of the same carelessness.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Politician%27s_syllogism


> it was always odd to me that "booking a [flight|hotel|concert tickets]" is the canonical example

Yeah, the weird part is how the people promoting the idea seem to believe the average (?) consumer will tolerate a particular risk/reward profile: It implies over-spending or cancellation fees or return-restocking fees are beyond reasonable concern, trivial compared to the minutes it saves the user who never does any verification. ("It's one banana, Michael. What could it cost, $10?")


With the caveat that I am not the average user, my most philosophically-pleasing system would be an LLM which generates and iterates "normal" search parameters. Then the user has the option to view, tweak, and and--just maybe--learn the underlying query language.

With respect to the "online" part of Sierra Online, I particularly remember "The Realm" [0] as ~1996 beta.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Realm_Online


Maybe it's the cynicism of getting older, but so many dang problems in the world seem to boil down do relationships and who has more power in them.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: