Except, at least in America, almost all research funding comes from the Federal government, from a process of peer review, by reviewers who have no conflicts of interest, or stand to personally benefit by the applicant's success. So while I appreciate your sentiment, I don't see how it applies.
Why do they have to write all the time how it will cure cancer or make banking more secure etc then in grant applications?
At the end of the day, the grant committees, even if they are composed of peer academics, know very well what results are needed so that funding will be sustained also in the future. It's an iterated game.
That's not an answer. Academics quite unanimously report that they don't feel that they are being evaluated the right way and incentivized the right way, they have to hype up trendy topics, they have to publish or perish, they have to salami slice, they have to etc. etc. Where do you think this pressure comes from, if not from those who provide the money? How is this obtuse? Also, I'm not saying explicit pressure. I mean incentive pressures in iterated games that lead to a kind of evolution. Just like youtubers aren't explicitly told by Youtube to do something, but they converge on tactics that work on Youtube algorithm, because those who don't are eliminated.
It's obtuse because you are claiming that the academic peer reviewer's decisions on NIH study sections, for example, are driven not by the quality of the application right in front of them, but by how that application will, in the long-term, alter their own funding possibilities in the future. Maybe in the abstract they know this, but it's not a driver of individual decisions...it's analogous to theories of population level selection in genetics..yes it could happen, but it is much weaker than natural selection at the individual fitness level.
And to be clear, it's not that I am claiming that there are not bad incentive structures in science-- there are; I'm saying that peer reviewer's on grant committees/study sections are not the root of those problems...not propagating those problems with their decision making on individual level grants...it's way too cynical of a suggestion. Instead, blame the laws that govern grant funding mechanisms (we spend way too much time begging for funding instead of doing science), blame Universities for using impact factors and publication counts as proxy metric for researcher quality, etc. But peer review itself? Only if you blame scientists for eating the only food that is given to them by the system-level structures involved. So, yes, obtuse.
The author provides no empirical evidence to support their claims, providing only anecdotal evidence. Their claim might be true, might be truer in some places/departments/countries than in others, but I do happen to agree with the author...or I am concerned about the issue.
Also anecdotal, as a peer reviewer, I too often encounter shoddy, careless, or even probably fraudulent conduct papers, and it frustrates me because peer review is not cost free: Authors are asking scientists to spend their precious time to understand the author's work, and that only works under a social contract....that authors only send out manuscripts for peer review after they have tried their best to do their best science.
I hate to say it, because I know that China has great scientists, but most of the manuscripts I receive and reject due to sloppy work, or purposeful negligence in citing most directly relevant to their manuscript (often because that literature did exactly what they are trying to pass if as new), or out-right making shit up, have been manuscripts from Chinese Universities. Yes it happens from western authors as well, but what I am naming is real, and is increasingly a major burden on peer-review as a scientific institution. So much so that many have confided to me that they will refuse to serve as a reviewer of a manuscript out of China unless it is from a known lab of some standing. In science, there must be a culture motivated not by number of papers published or grants funded, but by its rigor and integrity, and like the finest craftsman who cares most cares about doing the finest of work. That matters, and that culture of integrity and personal pride, does need to be encouraged and rewarded, no matter where the lab is located.
This is all to say that I agree with the author, despite their lack of empirical evidence, that these values are under threat.
More than just hard budget caps, we need agents to be aware of those hard budget caps, and plan accordingly. Too much agent behavior is driven by the immediate proximal goal instead of long term, strategic considerations. What we have now is agents deciding to on embark on expensive, circuitous routs to a goal, perhaps with potential but not certain in any case, benefits, and intervention depends on either an attentive user or forces stop after the money pot dries up. Prior research (#?) has Dem nsttated agent behavior to adjust behavior in response to budget considerations that appeared to enable more efficient token usage, and if that means it needs to be imposed on a custom harness (and not the self interested ai provider), so be it.
> "Through three cheese trees, three free fleas flew. While these fleas flew, freezy breeze blew. Freezy breeze made these three trees freeze. Freezy trees made these trees' cheese freeze. That's what made these three free fleas sneeze."
Fox in Socks. Magnificent for all time.
But my favorite are the tweetle beetles with their puddle battles.
Chess...I'm in the top 1 percent among regular players on chess.com/lichess, yet impossibly far away from Master/GrandMaster level as to be impossible; their minds are completely alien to me.
I lost most of the interest I had in chess as a child when I found out that the way to get better at chess boils down to rote memorization of positions. That's not fun.
Becoming such is not my goal; I have too many other interests. It was more commentary about how one might be good, but no where even near competitive, and the journey, even if mentally capable, of improving further would take years and year of full time dedication...because chess is that deep, and because "good" is always context dependent.
I was in the tens of thousands of points on Stack Overflow, over a hundred badges, into the millions of “people reached”, learning things just to be able to answer, things I have found now in search results and been surprised that it was my answer, and yet so far from being a top contributor it may as well be the Moon.
And haven’t been back there for years. Reinstate Monica. And shame on the licensing grab.
Thank you so much. Whatever the motivation, contributions like yours are what helped hobbyists like me decide that whatever ambition I had was in fact a possible outcome, when I otherwise was hitting infinite walls of my own. And I'm sure for those who turned that hobby into their career, you've helped advance countless improvements to everyone's standard of living.
Sure some advancements suck, but that's not on you. Answering the questions publicly for all to see enables everyone, and it's up to them to use it for better or worse.
Thank you; I hope it’s been mildly useful to some people. It sometimes feels like a volunteering effort that I can do, which is slightly unusual and most people can’t do.
Unlike HN and Reddit “discussions” which bring out the snark and ackchually in me far too often, and rarely seem a good way to “discuss” anything, focused questions and answers can potentially add a small value to the world.
I believe there is a type of anticheat to help detect ai usage, there are probably ways to circumvent it but id imagine most of the top players are legit.
Or another way of saying it, when the default no-thinking baseline strategy can win frequently enough by chance that it becomes difficult to learn from a single game. In this case, just 'buy silver, then gold, then provinces) can win too often just by chance.
Yeah, but that's what makes it such a good game, in my opinion. Ten or so years ago I played a lot with / against two friends. With other "deep"(-ish) games someone who's never played before never has even a remote chance against experienced players - we had other games we'd never pull out with a n00b at the table - but with Dominion you can give them that strategy, plus a few tips, like "trashing cards is really helpful", and they know enough to hang. They'll lose, mostly, but they won't be immediately crushed, and they'll want to play again.
Anyway, the main fun is trying to get an approach working with unfamiliar card combinations - and yes, we owned all the expansions, thank you for asking. :-)
There's a level of play in Dominion where it feels like there's two turns. One starts before the first card is played where you devise a strategy given the board. The second is just playing it out. Dominion leaves very little room for strategy switching - if you devise a second rate strategy, there's no realistic way to catch up. Very little of a player's choices depend on the actions opponents have taken. Short of a stack running out, curses, and a few others, you're mostly playing solo. That lack of being able to adapt is why I can't, even after hundreds of games, I can't bring myself to play it anymore.
That's a fair point. Fortunately, most games are short enough that you don't lose a lot of time when that happens. Mostly, though, I see a way I could have tweaked my card mix a bit to have made it work, so I want to play the same board again.
But, sure, if you're looking for a game with a lot of player interaction then Dominion isn't for you.