HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | SecretDreams's commentslogin

Now they AI can sulk and dwell, wondering why adoption for their new architecture is low, like other, prior, new architectures after arm!

Do you have kids/regularly go to the library?

I rediscovered the library when I had kids and they aged up to reading ages. Libraries are still great. An absolutely wonderful asset to get kids reading without using screens, which is absolutely important.

The only difference is libraries do host a lot of content, so you should do some exploration of what types of books you're looking for ahead of going to the library. Or, better yet, use your local library app to browser their index at your leisure.

For young children's books, just grab stuff off the shelf that is engaging and aligns with your parenting approaches. For young kids, you're just trying to make the experience fun - including going to the library. Most libraries also should be doing activities too, which is also engaging for young kids.


Yeah we go there frequently. They also sell books very cheaply, like one buck for a book, 75 cents for a children’s.

> Edit: every time I question these crazy valuations I get down voted really quickly.

You've gotta understand there's a lot of people on HN with their wealth tied to the success of AI at this point. Every downvote on a post like this is just a lowly engineer that wants to keep having steak dinners.


People that grew up in the 90s.

It's a dying craft, sadly. Because building a PC is so fun and I will do it with my kids, if for no other reason than to show them how it comes together.


> if for no other reason than to show them how it comes together.

I am team nand2tetris for life


building a computer (as nand to tetris) is fun, building a pc - like putting a cpu, an ssd and some ram into a motherboard is not, and modding is just spending $ on vibes.

> and modding is just spending $ on vibes.

As one does


> It's a pretty depressing state of affairs where no company seems interested in the absolutely massive middle ground between malicious hacking and child pornography.

I've got to imagine you've not meant to write this in this way. Of course nobody wants the middle ground between "malicious hacking" and child pornography.. because both those things are illegal, so the middle ground will also be illegal lol.


That's fair, I phrased that extremely poorly. What I meant (and it hopefully was clear from context, albeit not actually what the words I choose directly conveyed) is that the choice seems to be either either legitimate debugging of local code is lumped in with malicious hacking, or there being no guardrails at all for anything, even child pornography. In a sane world, there would be a company that's willing to make a distinction between those.

No I understood it to be the choice between something that bans child pornography but also bans useful things under the guise that "you're trying to hack someone illegally", and something that would be useful but also allows child pornography.

The middle ground is one that allows you to do useful work without breaking the law.


> but I am not completely retarded either.

Not with that attitude!

Jokes aside, I think they need a fall guy to help deflate the AI bubble rather than pop it. We here all agree LLMs are useful, but there's obviously still a disconnect in where valuations have taken us versus revenue and ROI any time soon.


Their brain

The tools are good, but the ideas are not. These tools basically see many people building the same things independently, rapidly, and over and over again.

I'm not seeing a lot of unique applications. I am seeing some optimization, plenty of rehashing the same crap. Lots of thought outsourcing.

Honestly, I'm mixed as someone who also uses these tools. Is it really efficient for 100s of people to be spending tokens and electricity to all make, effectively, the same bad app from their shower thought/idea? I love that we've democratized coding so that it's more accessible to laypeople - but it is mostly all slop and lack of creativity being produced. And, in the rare instances where someone genuinely makes something good, 100x people will then spin their own AI to rip off the same idea.

Where does this all go at the end of the day for humanity when nothing is new or creative and we are going backwards in critical thinking along the journey? Especially since the journey IS the thing for humanity - not the end product of the journey.


> The tools are good, but the ideas are not. These tools basically see many people building the same things independently, rapidly, and over and over again.

Isn't this just every bubble technology since the 80s? I remember being at parties in the early 2010s and hearing awful web site ideas that were certainly feasible with an RoR stack but had a <1% survival rate. The only difference now is less engineers acting as gatekeepers.

I'm certain it was the same way with static HTML webstores in the 90s, social media since early blogs, and other industries that received funding spikes that eliminated financial barriers (construction, film, video games, restaurant chains, etc)

Eventually the Gartner Hype Cycle proves true and the hysteria dies down, but out of those promised elevators of progress come a few incremental steps upward.


I don't even know if it's bubble technology, but more the issue of technology making something easier, cheaper and more accessible (once called democratization), leads eventually to more crap.

When photography was on film, it was expensive, more time consuming, and harder to do, and that led to professional photographers, some advanced hobbyists, and not many cheap/easy disposable film or polaroid photos by average people. But then digital became good and cheap and sharing photos was instant and easy. Eventually smart phones overtook digital cameras and the proliferation of photography was rampant, now the public space has been changed by the number of people who are ready to record and capture everything, and if you look at the photos being taken, we have more photos taken in a day than were taken in a year 70 years ago. Of course the quality suffers. It's not dedicated users anymore, it's kids and grandmas.

Quality of a human network (of people taking photos or using any technology) will decline over time.


I don’t think there was enough money in the web in the static HTML days to have the same bubble. But I do recall domain squatting being a lot more prevalent then than it is now.

More recently was blockchain hype.


Whether great or not, it seems to follow the birth of home videos with youtube, tiktok, etc. The video industry went:

- from highly founded centralized creations (TV, movies, series),

- to highly founded centralized creations (TV, movies, series) plus public home made videos (influencers, etc.) plus private home made videos (vlog for friends, etc.).

I can imagine the same with software, where big highly funded software remain, on top of home made software. Some home made software on neglected areas might be exchanged on some social platform (for example, apps to help women track their period was neglected for a long time), and some will just be for friends and family (like a personalized educative video game with a kid's favorite plush).


This is why I feel like any AI usage is making us all crabs in a bucket when it comes to progressing as a society. Any genuine creativity or effort is immediately stolen and repackaged as someone else's, which inherently means that its incredibly difficult for the original author to get any credit and devalues any genuine progress. And most importantly, people are doing this to deny the author any profit

We seem to be in a situation where 0.1% of people are creating anything new in the programming space, which isn't a change at all, but the difference now is that there's an absolute army of people waiting in the wings for the second they finish to take credit - and profit off their work without compensation. Because apparently that's progress, according to some people

This has been happening the most in realtime with news sites, where any news they publish is fed into chatgpt and recycled to avoid giving them any clicks or advertising money. What happens when all the news sites die because chatgpt ate their ability to survive? We'll go backwards as a society because we won't have news, and then suddenly chatgpt will lose its ability to report the news. Lose lose, unless you're an extreme short termist

It extends to everything with AI, its giving us negative progress as a society, because its society eating itself in exchange for the shortest time line go up


>Any genuine creativity or effort is immediately stolen and repackaged

So pretty much how things have worked almost all the time. For example after the US violently branched off from the UK we stole every idea we could. China operates the same way. Copy and make cheaper.

>Because apparently that's progress, according to some people

According to the people in power keeping information locked up for entire lifetimes is a good idea. They love that kind of progress to stay rich forever.


AI has industrialised and automated plagiarism in a way that we've never seen before, its 3 orders of magnitude worse. These AI companies stole literally everything on the planet

What we had previously wasn't ideal, but it was nowhere near as bad


And the AI models get stolen and distilled.

At the end of the day imaginary property is just that.


Yeah sure but now cat is out of the bag and we are in a prisoners dilemma where this inevitable. You can personally not use AI and get your shit stolen in milliseconds either way

I'd rather genuinely create something than steal other people's work

What does genuinely create something mean? Is it creating if you are inspired by anything? Is it creating if you have any prior information on the topic? Is it creating if you rewrite or build upon something existing? If it creating if you take a little part of something existing and copy it I to your creation? Is it creating if you take something, but reference the author? Is it creating if you are building something with an autocomplete/line completion/statistical model? Is it creating if you have an agent that searches the internet and helps you find the little snippets or material that might help you? It is creating if your idea needs you to use an AI to make a baseline in a certain "style"?

There's a valid argument about the edge cases, but AI takes in something and replicates it wholesale. Its fully automated luxury plagiarism

This is not edge cases, this is about creating anything, where is the line? You have AI in autocomplete, in translation, in grammar correction, etc.

If you take the stance on that AI is plagiarism you should be able to define where and why it's not okay to use prior information to impute new information. If you think that grammar correction or translation is fine, it's weird why it's fine at 1 word. If you think autocomplete is fine, why is it fine at 5 words? At how many words is it suddenly plagiarism?

All of these statistical models that we have on the phone and in on the web are trained on some kind of corpus, oftenmost taken without permission.


Sure, this is why I don't use AI, that part isn't terribly complicated!

> because we won't have news

The masses will have "news" generated by LLMs and the rich will have their private information gathering that delivers actual facts. Finally we can keep the masses dumb and uninformed again, unable to mess up anyone's plans and operations. They will be kept busy fighting among each other.

Those with fuck-you money think they can afford and survive the destruction of society. I suspect we will find out ourselves how long that holds true.


Original ideas are not "allowed" in a sense that the infrastructure will fight or directly forbid you. Your original ideas will have hard time to go through Apple AppStore's review or Gooogle's Android or Chrome processing. You will have hard time getting paid for it, you will have hard time to make people hear about it because x, FB, TikTok, reddit etc all have an agenda and they don't spread things that don't fit it(AKA medium is the message).

We don't live in a free world where you can just do things anymore, you are supposed to fit the machinery that is churning hundreds of billions of dollars every year.


I blame the subsidies and free AI. Can't blame people for building dumb things when it's so cheap and disconnected from the actual costs. That demand then manufactures shortages that wouldn't otherwise exist... The public gets swamped with slop which they view as all AI can make, so they hate the technology. It's the worst of all worlds.

I don't think there is anything wrong with people being empowered to build dumb things, even lots of dumb things. Especially if we believe that there will be a market correction that will force the good things to rise to the top, and everything else to go away.

I don't disagree, but I think we got the ordering wrong. This step should've come later in its evolution.

You're still left with a filtering problem. App review, Job applications, games on steam - any huge increase in volume means it's harder to find the good stuff now.

I think friction to distribution is an interesting thing in this. Pretty unbaked thought that isn't really saying anything, so you'll forgive me: When we were getting deviantART off the ground, folks wanted the user growth to speed up, so we reduced the amount of work to upload things. Then, the quality took a dive and it became too difficult to moderate with the tools that we had, so we increased the friction a bit, over the time I worked on it, the amount and type of friction increased and decreased as we tired to dial in the right amount of growth and quality. It was also interesting what friction filtered out what type of people... add 6 screens you have to click through with drop downs etc, lazy people drop off but creative people get fatigued, add 3 screens but require a minimum of a 200 word description, creative people love it and copy/paste artists drop off, etc. The internet itself has had various versions of this in different aspects of it. I think that is also true in reverse, things can sustain mediocrity through friction. I'm sure there are loads of interesting examples of this all over! Just a thought. :)

Wow, I remember spending so much time on dA throughout the 2000s! I use it less now because I take fewer photos generally, but it still brings back a flood of good memories and still holds the bulk of my portfolio, which has now spilled somewhat over to Flickr. That's interesting to think about: I don't really remember what the upload experience was back then... I think probably a file-picker, one or two screens and then bam it was up. At my moderate volume, any friction would indeed have been a turn-off and a source of fatigue. It was a fun little friendly community to spend time in, and a great source of inspiration looking at all the crazy cool stuff people had created; I hope it still is. Thanks for your work!

> Especially if we believe that there will be a market correction that will force the good things to rise to the top, and everything else to go away.

Do we believe that, truly?


The problem is that the tool and the marketing around it make people think they can circumvent the time it takes to refine ideas into a good experience or product.

You cannot, in the end, eliminate time. There are no shortcuts. It's like Euclid said, there's no "royal road" to mathematics, nor to a good product.

LLMs can speed up several aspects of execution, but actually honing an idea, figuring out what constraints make sense, how the experience needs to be tweaked, in brief, design, will always take time. The one shot revolutionary product notion is total myth.


This really isn't limited to software. A more egregious example is music: we already had every genre, every mood, at our fingerprints practically for free. And now, we're just giving a big middle finger to human artists for no benefit whatsoever. Well, except that Spotify might be able to pay $0.0000 per stream instead of $0.0001.

On some level, I understand where the individual impulse is coming from - "I couldn't do this and now I can, it's amazing" - and I can understand why amoral VCs would throw money at these platforms. But I will never understand why so many intelligent, sensible people are cheering for this future.

Look at all the new book releases on Amazon. They are 95%+ slop, and not good slop. They're made with zero effort. Some of them sell because people judge books by the title & cover. What does this achieve? Once you eliminate all revenue for real authors, what next?


If you think we have every kind of music people want, then you lack imagination.

I for example generate catchy music that helps me remember topics. Those are hyper personalized.

Even outside of hyper personalized music, for the styles of music I like, something like 90%+ are topically centered around love/lust and I prefer more topical variety. So I make them.


Everyone makes crayon scribbles as a child. What does this achieve?

Everyone learns the same basic curriculum in school. What does this achieve?

Everyone makes mediocre attempts to play instruments/sports as an adolescent. What does this achieve?

Everyone treads the same highs and lows of friendship and romance that have been tread by billions of others. What does this achieve?

It achieves the human experience. Not everything has to be best-in-class to be meaningful, and that's a dreadful expectation to heap upon anything that doesn't strictly demand it.


"Passive income" grifters spamming amazon with books that they literally spent 0 time or creative effort on are not "achieving the human experience". There is no creative/personal satisfaction or development from this, it's just people making things worse for others trying to make a quick buck.

What percentage of art spend went to advertisement before AI?

I don't know but these are by different people, for a different purpose, pushed in different spaces than advertisements.

The things you listed are considered to be smaller version of 'proper' expression in art or mastery of some skills that humans value. Even if most people go nowhere with some of them, they're still seen as commendable things to do and parts of the universal experience.

What is AI generation a smaller version of? While you can make worse and better AI outputs, do you think the average Kindle slop author is going to one day become a proper bestselling writer? Will an average Suno music generator turn into a musician?


Difference being people did those things compared to a prompt, there’s no experience to be had from prompting “make music” in relation to trying to play an instrument or lay out a track.

Playing someone else's music doesn't teach you how to compose. Laying out a track in fruityloops doesn't teach you how to play the instruments.

Complaining about negative space is easy but not very informative because the attention doesn't go missing, it gets reallocated to something that someone found more engaging. I remember the vitriol aimed at DAWs 25 years ago, but it was obvious then and correct in hindsight that what was lost in forced mediocre specialization would be more than made up for in expanded capacity, and that anyone who wanted would still be able to drill down and master an instrument, but that they would now be in a position to determine where this would be most impactful. It's the same fight all over again.


Unpopular (and unrequested) opinion: I still think that the world's best DJ mixing music live on stage in a club is not the same class of job as an amateur pop band playing in a pub in front of family & friends. The latter being much more meaningful.

Unpopular, unrequested opinion: band kids messing around in FL studio after practice are doing something far more creatively meaningful than the activity the adults organized for them and recognize as virtuous.

Learning how to compose and play are two different skills though, they are likely to reinforce each other, whereas a prompt is just something completely disconnected. It wasn’t that long ago people were thinking prompt engineering would be a profession of the future, and now you barely need to be able to spell to get the same output.

Similar to how getting good search results used to be a skill.

What does having machines do stuff instead of Everyone making that stuff on a not-best-in-class level achieve? What is the Human Experience in that?

Apart from more wealth inequality and environmental pollution, of course, which is what we call The American Dream nowadays.


AI books on Amazon will eliminate revenue for authors in the same way that YouTube eliminated all revenue for television. Most of YouTube is absolute garbage and even the algorithm recommending content is garbage. Yet "real" video producers that make good content still make an absolute killing. You make good stuff people will be attracted to it. The much bigger threat to authors is that people just don't read anymore.

I don't mean to brush you off, you do have points. But don't you believe there is a connection between the shrinking reading habits on the one side and the constant, nonstop flood of low quality distractions from technology, of which genAI is a continuation, on the other?

Social media and AI are a big part on destroying peoples faith in the inner world, is my hypothesis.


Oh I'm 100% with you. I think tiktok and instagram are a complete blight on society. I think Hacker News isn't necessarily great either. We're all distracted by mostly useless crap all day long now. I'd say we choose it and autonomy matters but there's definitely an addictive nature to it that was engineered and fairly insidious.

But that didn't eliminate the meaningful stuff. If anything we have more of it now than ever and it's all making more money than ever. We just have to look away from our hypno-rectangles long enough to appreciate it. Unfortunately most people (especially younger ones) don't want to do that.

We already had infinite content and people spending all day scrolling so I'm not sure AI can make the problem any worse. But I could see (as happened with YouTube) people that otherwise wouldn't be able to make anything being empowered to make good stuff. AI won't ALL be bad content, and the cream that rises to the surface might actually be really interesting.

We needed to fix this distraction problem at a societal level (somehow) far before AI came along.


I'm honestly massively disappointed.

I expected tools when animator can just put a bunch of keyframes, sketch the transitions and have AI fill it in, getting all of the artistic vision with massive work saved.

Instead industry went full on dystopia "let's replace entire jobs" instead of settling on just massive efficiency improvements on top of keeping the quality and we got million slop generators and little of the actual good tooling that would change the industry, outside of coding tools.


Well, filling transitions between key frames is an entire job: inbetweener.

At the higher end, AI hallucinations don't hold up. I really do think professional artists and animation studios are using AI at least for rapid prototyping and many are building custom pipelines and constantly iterating until it's good enough for production, or using it in small areas of production (e.g. build a base and manually draw/edit imperfections)

I think if it has key frames and the sketched movement there is very good chance to get it near perfect. And any small problems still there can be fixed after.

> I expected tools when animator can just put a bunch of keyframes, sketch the transitions and have AI fill it in, getting all of the artistic vision with massive work saved.

I actually tried that multiple times for a simple b/w icon animation. All the tools of the Big AI labs gave me crap.


On my drive to work this morning I passed by a bus and it had a poster ad on the side for a new musical. Completely uninspired obvious slop. I don't understand why when in the past they would pay better artists and not settle for cheaper ones, they now settle for that gross ai "look". Maybe the average joe / new gen is fine with it? I can actually comprehend outsourcing code to ai more than I can outsourcing your branding / visual identity

Local take away restaurants in my area have full AI slop menus with digital signage. It is depressing...

>I expected tools when animator can just put a bunch of keyframes, sketch the transitions and have AI fill it in, getting all of the artistic vision with massive work saved.

You expected it to replace jobs, and you're surprised when it replaced jobs?


I'm all for replacing the boring parts of the jobs. Making a bunch of nearly-same animations in between keyframes is definition of boring.

Life has an abundance boring tedious jobs. Unfortunately the animation in between keyframes is almost more important than the keyframes themselves for making the animation flow correctly. Which is why AI animation often looks so wrong and off-putting.

Quality Control is tedious and boring, Do we want AI to take over there as well?

Actually don't answer that I already know most of the sloperators are in favor.


Sketch, make AI,fill, correct the small mistakes, repeat. Surely massive savings over current process?

We got those tools too! Not just diffusion and descedants. Cascadeur is a good example of "tasteful" application of AI, meant to help authors realize their vision, instead of replacing it or just making it as trivial as possible.

> Instead industry went full on dystopia "let's replace entire jobs" instead of settling on just massive efficiency improvements on top of keeping the quality and we got million slop generators and little of the actual good tooling that would change the industry, outside of coding tools.

You could try, collectively, uplifting the voices who saw it coming and called it out clearly in advance. They're the ones generally derided and dismissed as impractical weirdos, though, so that might be hard.

As long as we instead uplift the greedy and craven, we will see greedy and craven results from otherwise neutral technologies.


What you wanted were essentially specialized traditional models. I still have hope that when this bubble bursts and they hype dies down and people have to pay the real price of the do-everyting LLMs, the industry will pivot towards specialized traditional models, which are give much better results for far far far cheaper.

BorisFX does this great. They don’t even call things AI just ML (which is correct) and the product I use, Optics, has this insane masking model that allows you to just paint with green and red colors very crudely (and I mean that) and get almost perfect masks immediately. These kinds of tools are extremely valuable and worth paying for, compared to Photoshop who has gone all in on generative AI and it’s all terrible, slow and token based.

> Instead industry went full on dystopia "let's replace entire jobs"

That's the only thing the elites care about. They dream of not needing pesky labor anymore.


No wonder Hitler had so much support. They even called him man of the year. Then he turned on them.

He wasn't man of the year because he was so great, but because he had a significant influence on world affairs that year.

He was part of the Elite.

> I'm not seeing a lot of unique applications. I am seeing some optimization, plenty of rehashing the same crap.

http://youtube.com/watch?v=nMfHYUFeiJo


I'd prefer to hear what you have to say vs some video which I don't really have time to watch. Care to summarize?

Sure. Take a look at the current landscape. What do you see? A lot of copying. How many companies do we need building harnesses that act, look, and behave the same? How many clone apps with the same exact design and aesthetic? How many half-finished games that are just created in order to copy the success of someone on X? How many genuinely novel, quality ideas go unnoticed, unrecognized, or flat out ignored because they don't align with the consensus?

Humans are conditioned to be mimetic: seek an authority, seek someone more knowledgeable outside yourself, but never, ever, ever learn for yourself or do for yourself (especially when doing so goes against the status quo). In practice, this leads to an endless sea of copies that delude themselves into thinking they're unique ("me too" apps, etc). In other words "if they're working on this or doing it this way, it must be important/safe for us to do it this way."

Most people are terrified of being original and authentic and so default to the "short blade of grass" direction of "we'll compete on the same terms as everyone else so we can fit in."

It took me several years to fully understand this but once I did, I saw/see it everywhere. And practically nobody you share this insight with is comfortable with it which tells you it's closer to the truth than not.

Edit: thank you for showing legitimate curiosity and asking me to explain instead of treating me like an idiot.


I see it with my kids, the older one tries something, the younger one copies them because it must be good if their older sibling is doing it. Monkey see, monkey do.

I scanned the video and transcript and it argues (poorly, imo) that competition produces parity and mediocrity.

I also don’t really see how it applies here — AI in this case is removing what most people would understand to be competition. Do people driving cars still compete on running speed?


> AI in this case is removing what most people would understand to be competition. Do people driving cars still compete on running speed?

We're not talking about business competition, we're talking about human competition. Species level, subconscious, and driven to seek (perceived) safety in the hierarchy amongst other humans.


It is interesting I think a hard societal split is emerging between those who understand AI is a tool that can be used and can use it, and those who embed themselves in the view that AI itself competes with them as a person.

Just for entertainment in the last month or so we've had a Nintendo Switch 2 emulator and a Playstation 5 emulator that have grown by leaps and bounds. I'd usually put an estimate at 2 years before we'd have these things working properly now it's weeks. But the reason you're not seeing a lot of unique applications (though they are out there for sure) is because people aren't sharing them. I make a bunch of stuff that isn't good enough to distribute widely but serves my purposes just fine. Are they 'unique'? Maybe not entirely, but I haven't been able to find apps that do the same things in the same way or I would just use those. It's really nice to have software that works exactly how you want it and that you can tweak any way you want with a prompt.

If they would at least go completely open source, not just in license, but in values, we'd at least get a smaller amount of slop that iterates into something good over time. What a waste to have the same garbage churned out over and over.

> I'm not seeing a lot of unique applications. I am seeing some optimization, plenty of rehashing the same crap. Lots of thought outsourcing.

Nihil novi sub sole but at AI scale.


> many people building the same things independently, rapidly, and over and over again.

It's the Lisp curse, magnified by a million.


Or maybe the tools are not good?

I can't write more than a few prompts without the LLM (any of the latest SOTA models) starts doing complete absolute nonsense.

I do agree that the ideas are not good to be clear, but the gap between the promises of what LLMs can do and what they can actually do is huge.

Anyway, it's funny to see the insane amount of astroturfing on HackerNews and how people try at all cost to make it seem like the technology isn't the problem but humans actually are. Literally every top-level comment is about that, or downvoted.


Democratizing coding via LLMs is democratizing cooking via frozen foods. It's gonna be unhealthy to the end user despite the convenience. And the taste level will not be there. Sure, you "made" dinner just like you "made" an app.

There are startling parallels today to how news and information was 'democratized' when social media emerged in the mid to late oughties. The issue is the same: once it's cheap and easy no one seems to care about how healthy it is.

You don't get a nice juicy IPO valuation by trying to save money or be efficient with your token usage!

Common saying. I always wonder how the stock market would have priced pick sellers? Would they have baked in 10 years of continued revenue growth from the sale of picks?

Look at Cisco. Only this year did its stock return to the price it reached at its peak in 2000. Since then the amount of people on the internet has grown ten-fold.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: