HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | Robotbeat's commentslogin

Imagine a civil engineer that refuses to use a computer of any kind for his work. How much do you trust scribbled long division?

Edit: what about a civil engineer that refuses to use steel. Or Arabic numerals. Or a construction worker that refuses to use power equipment. A delivery man who swears off wheels.


mattw2121's hypothetical is about timelines and quality. As long as said Civil Engineer can deliver quality work within our allocated timeline, he can do long division in binary scribbled in sand for all I care.


Another moron with AI Delusion Syndrome. Comparing LLMs to steel, numbers, and wheels is fucking hilarious.

Yes, power equipment is better, but still barely the same thing.

You're one dumb motherfucker, aren't you?


That would be impressive.


Only if you believe this to be representative of a road legal car. I find it easier to believe that it's a purpose-built stunt prototype, otherwise they couldn't stop talking about how clever they were solving the seemingly infinite list of engineering challenges and contradictions that make it an actual car that actual people can drive on an actual road.


? Do you think a Lambo is a particularly practical car? Obviously it’s a stunt car. It’s doing stunts! And no, it’s not legal to drive around shooting huge supersonic jets around the car; that’s hardly a criticism.


You’d want to dry the water beforehand, like is usually done in such things.


I think you meant air instead of water


Then don’t make the deposit?


Yeah, you can sell fighter jets to private US citizens, if the guns and stuff are removed.


Yep. A friend own and regularly flies a Mig 29 in California. It’s faster than anything the US military has (not that he’s taken it that fast yet)


A MiG-29 has a lower top speed than an F-15 which the US military still operates.


MiG-29's top speed is 2450kph.. the F-14 is faster (2485kph) as is the F-15 (2655kph) you mentioned.

But then we get into the performance group.. SR-71 Blackbirds (3530kph), X-43A Scramjets (10870kph). Strange inaccurate brag.


Hydrogen is 1/14th the density of air.


It had 4700kg of downforce. It would’ve been quite a feat to make a vehicle (or prop, call it whatever you like) like that less than 1 tonne.


How do you know it had that much downforce?


This isn’t accurate. 20-30% larger diameter with a constant density would mean about 20-30% greater escape velocity (mass is radius cubed but gravity is inverse radius squared, etc). So instead of 11km/s escape, it’d be 13-14km/s. And instead of ~9km/s to reach LEO, it’d be about 11km/s. This is not at all a showstopper. Even in the 60s and 70s, we built rockets with enough stages to go land on the moon and return to Earth, which is a round-trip delta-v of like 14-15km/s, and the Soviets did this mostly with low Isp hypergolic propellants, not even hydrolox let alone an exotic propellant like nuclear thermal hydrogen or electric thrusters. We often just launch stuff directly to GTO or GSO instead of bothering with electric propulsion, so even today’s rockets (many of which also have high enough thrust to weight ratio, like an Atlas V 551) you could do it (and then probably rely more heavily on electric thrusters). Even with higher gravity losses.

It’d be more expensive, sure, but the idea that it’d be almost impossible is just not true at all. It’s a very common thing that even a lot of fairly smart people often say, though.


https://arxiv.org/html/1804.04727v2

A larger earth with the same average density of Earth that has 1.3 Gs of surface gravity would need around twice the fuel to escape into space and a system that could handle that extra fuel and longer burn without self-destructing.

The fuel itself would weigh more, and thus require more fuel to lift. The fuel to lift that fuel would also weigh more and would also require more fuel, etc, and the radius of gravity to escape would also be larger even though it would also be mediated somewhat by the inverse square rule.

I actually wouldn't be surprised if you needed more than twice the rocket fuel to leave a 1.3 G super earth that is 1.3 times it's diameter.

Not impossible, but definitely more difficult.


Not to mention other technologies like balloons that actually make climbing through the (denser) atmosphere easier on denser planets.


I think it was just a matter of speech. 20-30% doesn’t matter because such a planet doesn’t exist. It’s probably bigger, and so OP has a point


There are a bunch of exoplanets in that size range, and we could probably contrive chemical rockets with over 20km/s delta-v if necessary. Nuclear rockets 30km/s.


"Because such a planet doesn't exist" bruuuh do you know how many planets there probably are?


How many in Goldilocks zones with stable orbits for billions of years? With non-toxic soils and atmospheres? With water at the surface and in significant amounts?

Now, how many can humanity reach in the life time of frozen embryos?

And if it's more than 30% bigger then escape velocity is likely beyond the practical limits of science.


That is a totally different topic. We’re talking about a hypothetical, where Earth is 20-30% larger, not whether an identical copy of Earth but 20-30% larger actually exists nearby. We know such roughly similar exoplanets are common, though. In that size range and in habitable zone.

And again, 30% greater escape velocity just isn’t a challenge. Existing rockets could be used to reach LEO, like Atlas 551 (well, probably want 552 to reduce the gravity losses). And then you can use electric thrusters (which don’t have a hard Isp limit) to reach wherever.

Heck, we could probably reach LEO even if escape velocity was twice what it is. Even 3 times, if you include more exotic propulsion methods that we’ve done some testing for (nuclear thermal, etc). With staging, etc, it’s just a matter of a worse and worse mass fraction, not really whether it’s possible or not. And once you get to low orbit, electric propulsion allows much better scaling as you can adjust Isp higher (although reduces thrust and means it takes longer to do your mission).


They're also useful for analytical purposes.

It's possible to do this with digital methods, too, but the lower spatial resolution of most digital LCDs and most digital camera sensors (compared to film) limits it somewhat. But I think it'd be more practical than the analog film based analytical holograms.


I don’t blame OpenAI for that. There’s a ton of weirdly politically motivated denial of AI being useful for solving problems that require new answers. This is one of the very few possible ways to objectively prove that AI can do that.


What's more, it's quite possibly one of the best ways to improve AI, as math provides both a large corpus of training data and an objective way to measure capability. IMO this is likely why the AI companies are working on this, with improvement in math reasoning bleeding over into improvement in general reasoning.

Really, mathematicians should be thrilled about this, as this could be the biggest practical payoff of thousands of years of investment in math, bigger even than all the preceding science and engineering payoffs. We're told one of the benefits of a math education is learning how to think; was it really so unpredictable if that also applied to machines? This sort of payoff would justify wide open checkbooks for more math research, even by humans.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: