HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | Quarrelsome's commentslogin

Because we collectively dont care. There's more appetite electorally to oppress trans people than there is to reduce carbon footprint. Missippi just got won on the back of an ad that suggested everyone is entitled to as much beef consumption as they want.

While there are many countries who have let the world down on climate change, America is quite the outlier. Since the gatekeepers lost control of the narrative post internet, stories that highlight American failings struggled even more than before.

I think its part lf human nature that no ruling class wants to accept responsibility and privilege and would rather find reasons to consider themselves victims. Consider the wailing over gas prices every year that America never answers with "maybe we should drive more fuel efficient vehicles".


It’s the same with the national debt. A lot of people are betting that they’ll be dead before it truly gets bad, and at that point it’s another generation’s problem. Though it does surprise me how many people with actual children and grandchildren are prepared to unapologetically saddle them with that.

You should just copy and paste this every time someone mentions climate change and USA. You nailed it.

isn't the whole "we put a human into space" symbolic anyway? There's no air up there. If we had a full supply chain of robots that brought us back regolith from the moon wouldn't that be more useful than being able to send a person up there?

nah humans going is the point. the science is interesting but not of that tremendous value. we don't view archaeology as the highest human endeavor do we?

It can be both, right? Like, we can put humans there and expand the resources available to humanity immensely by sending teams of robots out to manufacture the future habitats, etc.?

Personally, I'm looking forward to joining the Elench. Humans are allowed to join the Elench aren't they?


What exactly is “the point” of humans going there, other than science? Telling a hero story that ignores the contributions of hundreds of thousands that made this possible? Gratifying a few mammoth-sized egos?

You have to start with a justification for "the point" of human life at all which is a struggle with some people who only see utility in whatever their equivalent of a quarterly balance sheet is (this includes publishing papers in academic journals).

I don’t understand why justifying human spaceflight supposedly requires grand philosophical ramblings about the meaning of life. Justifying brushing your teeth doesn’t require that either, does it?

Why humans expanding into space is important depends on being able to answer the big picture of why exist at all because they're the same answer.

If the meaning of your life to you is some short term success metric that lasts only into the immediate future there's nothing to discuss.

If you have a big picture idea of why life is important then honestly it's probably pretty likely that you already get it and we already agree. So I mention the big meaning of life stuff and if the response is "why does that matter?" it means the argument is pointless because some people have little vision beyond their own close horizons.


What is the point of humans here on Earth exactly? Some consider that humans can be replaced by AI today/in near future. Should we just give up and live space to a more advanced civilization?

innovation is about being able to reach for better solutions to problems where previously it would "take too long". e.g. DSLs.

Having watched almost everyone in my career prefer to do what they're told instead of pushing back in order to build the right thing, I kinda agree.

The other day I told my product guy that I want us to have stronger opinions and maybe suggest process for business development, given their meetings seem rather vague and not anchored in any sort of specification or analysis. He looked at me like I'd just shot his son.


its not about virtue and its not even about starving. Its about making a global economy more stable so the world is richer and the US almost always profits from that.


Do you have any evidence that is the result? Perhaps all the aid does little but prop up their criminal governments?


Commodities. They power the economy and they're worldwide. Ofc you want the free flow of goods. From the US's perspective who cares who runs what nation, as long as its not hostile and its stable then the commodities can flow from it. Then manufacturers can make whatever they want to create products to generate growth and wealth, the vast majority of which flows into the US and into their stock market.

As it stands the war in Iran is creating problematic issues with many petrochemicals and their derivative products making it harder for countries to generate wealth to invest in the US stock market.



he directed government money from strategic projects that makes the world more stable to ensure the US could waste it all fighting another dumb war. Its hard to justify, easy to criticise.


> disagree with his politics

Its the character. Buying a global media platform to "promote free speech" and then shunt the entire thing and himself behind a particular political party. This guy uses his money and his twitter account to support neo-nazi hate groups in my country (Britain First, Patriotic Alternative, Hundred Handers, Tommy Tennames). He has no self-restraint. Its abhorrent. Its not "about politics" when the politics is about racial superiority and ethnic cleansing.

> Imagine if you couldn't post a thread about Microsoft products on HN without republicans feeling the need to jump in to talk about how much they hate Bill Gates for his donations to Kamala Harris's campaign in 2024. It's really tiresome.

and if Bill Gate was literally campaigning for the Dems, getting up on stage, handing voters cheques and THEN being employed by the government to run a department then you'd have a point.

He repeatedly crosses the line of what is appropriate. People with that level of wealth should stay the fuck away from politics and respect democracy instead of using their money and business to have excessive influence on democratic outcomes. Its unseemly and disrespects the idea of everyone getting the same amount of votes. I respect that donations have similarities but there's a difference between making a donation and being excessively public.


> People with that level of wealth should stay the fuck away from politics and respect democracy instead of using their money and business to have excessive influence on democratic outcomes.

People with that level of power — because it is power — will do what they will. “The strong do what they can, and the weak suffer what they must”.

> Its unseemly and disrespects the idea of everyone getting the same amount of votes. I respect that donations have similarities but there's a difference between making a donation and being excessively public.

We have transitioned, it would seem, from the pretence of “goodness” to naked displays of power. Unseemly, definitely.

Justice. Righteousness. Old fashioned words and old fashioned ideas. Oh for a good and righteous king!


> People with that level of power — because it is power — will do what they will. “The strong do what they can, and the weak suffer what they must”.

agreed and we should hate them for it.


its cos he's a prick. The way he pretended to "fairly" sack devs at twitter when he was clearly just trying to cut costs. That he bought twitter to "defend free speech" and then started donating to the Republication party and promoting a very specific political position online. As a euro the Nazi salute alone is enough for me.

The qualifier matters, that guy has serious issues.


Tide goes in, tide goes out. Im low key of the opinion that these tools enhance existing attributes while displacing the advantages of unearned social or financial power.

So in the short term the tide might go out but then it might tsunami back.

Same goes for this terrifying political feeling around the world. Might simply be a boomer swansong and the reaction might snap back.


> displacing the advantages of unearned social or financial power

A technology that lets you directly buy intelligence with money will displace financial power?


what people consider to be "intelligence" isn't about doing l33t maths, its about self-doubt. This enables us to mitigate against our cognitive biases and instinctual impulses and accept truth, which leads to more useful outcomes.

All that buying a calculator does, is allow you to do bad sums more quickly.


> displacing the advantages of unearned social or financial power

In what way? Sure looks like pay to win to me.


if you're stupid then this technology just amplifies your stupidity which means you can fail faster. I also think the inverse is true.


Success has nothing to do with intelligence. Similarly failing has nothing to do with stupidity.


sure, but now if you're running an entire agentic run for an org, what's to stop you just replacing the org? Previously you didn't have the wadge to pay for all the devs.


I sincerely hope you are right.


It might be copium, but the only guaranteed thing that happens is change.

Remember its coming up millenilal time now and i have hope in this gen.


didnt the article say thay engineers still review change requests? They just switched from reviewing code to reviewing intent.

So "no direct human supervision" seems like a misunderstanding. Article even bigs up the purpose of engineers with a hilarious (to me at least) line about auto adversial reviews resulting in over engineered designs.


Good point, I wasn't clear enough about my thoughts here. I tried to say that in a multiple commits/s world the review might not be direct line/hunk review of the code but a more "indirect", abstracted or higher level human oversight, which is how I understand an intent review is.

I'm not saying that Anthropic here close their eyes and tell Claude to ship and that in the future there will be no code review at all, but that if we have 30K merges/day, human review seems to need to be done at some higher level, likely AI assisted like it seems to be done with their Antique code review tool mentioned in the post.


I mean i’m solodeving and on my github 30 commits a day is light green. Record probably was 280/day, but I’m not sure if every commit is merge to them. or if they just count PRs


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: