HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | ProfessorLayton's commentslogin

>I know quite a few skinny people who have struggled every single day with food noise, overeating, and self control. They simply got through it with a lot of struggle, habits, and discipline.

You're right, but the charitable interpretation of GP's comment is that people that were always skinny don't feel hunger, which clearly isn't true in a strict sense, but not totally untrue either, it just isn't as often.

What you're talking about seems to be people that worked their way to being skinny, or those that have such low body fat that they have visible abs, which even 'naturally skinny' people would struggle to maintain.

As someone skinny enough to have visible abs (But not washboard abs either), I don't try particularly hard to maintain my weight, it's mostly just avoiding obvious things like having fast food all the time (I still do eat it) and working out. Food isn't something I think about unless I'm hungry, and despite working in offices stocked full with candy/snacks, it hasn't resulted in weight gain over my tech career. I've been told directly by people in my circle (Not in tech) that they would really struggle with working in an environment like that.

I know a few folks on GLP-1s, and they operate on a completely different wavelength in regards to food than I do, and it's been great to see them reach their body goals.


It would be nice indeed, but it's a bit like wanting to share a gym subscription when you're not using it. The economics would fall apart if everyone used 100% of their subscription, unless sharing was priced in from the beginning.

The city transport system where I live has a subscription pass you can buy that is normally tied to a single person. However, if you pay a little bit extra you make the ticket transferable, and even let someone else travel with you for free on weekends and in the evenings. Like you say, they've presumably priced in the extra usage there that comes from it being transferable, or from the extra travellers, but also put limits on how much leeway you have to abuse the system.

I'm imagining rate limits that would prevent the user from making many more API calls than they would have made searches anyway. If you want unlimited 24/7 searches, you can pay for the credits directly, but if you just want to partially replace your existing search habits with e.g. interactive agent sessions, then that would be fine.

A more specific example would be how Anthropic allow certain Claude subscriptions to get free API credits, with some restrictions on the age of the account and with the number of credits being limited.

I think there is a workable solution here, although I can imagine that figuring out the details (how many credits to offer, what sort of limits, how to price the whole thing, etc) is complicated enough that Kagi have decided it's not worth the effort for the small number of users for whom this feature would be useful. And generally I'm very satisfied with Kagi, so I'm not complaining here or trying to suggest that this is something that they should be expected to offer. It would just be nice!


What if the usage were shared between the two and a single API search used more of your quota than a UI search? There's no reason the economics can't line up.

e.g. if you expect the average user to use 50% of the search quota / month through the UI, but 100% through the API, then you make the quota shared between the two but double the effect of usage from the API.


That would work if the average user with Search + API used the same "amount" (Costs to Kagi) as the average account using Search only. If it nets out to a higher cost, Kagi is making less out of the same subscription amount.

Especially if the API induces demand.

(Don't shoot the messenger, just trying to explain why it makes sense that they're not doing this)


I think the only way to make it not harmful to their finances would be if they lowered the cap (even for human use) to where heavy users and API users alike ended up paying 'overages' constantly. Everybody who has studied consumer behavior generally finds that people hate overage charges to an irrational extent[1] so that would be a terrible move compared to just saying "API users, you've got to pay extra, sorry."

[1] Meaning, they are more satisfied with an 'unlimited' or just way-more-than-you'll-ever-need option, even when it costs them more when averaged over even a few months. I'm not saying this makes you an irrational person -- I have the same illogical feelings myself.


That's not really illogical, it's just because many companies use the fine print to fleece customers that are slightly above the limit. Think Ryanair. Or mobile roaming.

This is why unlimited or at least a service stop instead of overage is highly preferable. It's the reason I only use prepaid mobile plans too so they can never overcharge me (and it's cheaper than a contract too)


No, unless it's data center owners trying to ban new data centers, it's not the same at all.

Not at all. I gave houses as an example, but I hypothetically also don't want bus or rail stops anywhere near me. Or shops. Or bars. I guess it's not nimbyism since I don't own a bus stop or a shop.

Well now you're conflating NIMBYism with just voting for your preferences. "FU, got mine" is the key component of what makes NIMBYism, NIMBYism.

It is the same. Do you think those people who voted against data centers aren't using Cloud services, AI, services hosted on AWS, etc.

They want the data centers, just NIMBY.


>Do you think those people who voted against data centers aren't using Cloud services, AI, services hosted on AWS, etc.

https://i.kym-cdn.com/entries/icons/original/000/036/647/Scr...

>They want the data centers, just NIMBY.

Perhaps it's just you, because the votes say otherwise. Housing NIMBYism is people who already have homes preventing new ones from being built, for their own benefit (Price increases on existing stock). That's not what's happening with data centers.


NIMBYism covers far more than just building homes, and covers more than just homeowners. Instead, it covers when residents oppose things like schools, public transit, electricity generation, infrastructure, etc: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NIMBY

The person I initially responded to was specifically talking about housing NIMBYism, not NIMBYs in general. I pointed out how homeowners are typically the ones opposing new housing, which is not the case with data centers.

You responded with “NIMBYism covers far more than just building homes” which is true but not what was being responded to.


By the same logic, you obviously won't mind if there are open-cut-mines; a sewage plant; a tannery; a telecommunications rocket launch facility and a container shipping terminal next to your backyard.

I won't mind a shipping terminal. The rest have some pollution issues so probably should be some distance from residences. Data centers have no pollution issues and I won't mind living next door to one either. I never had problems with seeing industry, I like seeing industry, its a great sign of progress and technology.

Data centres causes noise pollution which has health impacts. Similarly, a shipping terminal, will generate particulate pollution (until they move to EV and/or trains), noise pollution and perhaps light pollution (if it's a 24/7 port).

But as you've (rightfully) indicated, not all pollution is offensive to all. You might even be able to benefit from that, I imagine housing near industrial areas might be cheaper. And we do need mines; sewage system; leather; satellites...and even data centres.

By no means am I suggesting that polluting industries should be completely banned. I believe there's a middle ground between carte blanche and a complete ban. The backlash against data centres isn't just because they are data centres. It's because they are often located in residential areas and are taking advantage of previous investments by the residents in power/water infrastructure. If they located data centres in industrial (or commercial) zones and invested to upgrade the power/water infrastructure, there'd be significantly less backlash.

Lastly, my reply was primarily directly at parineum's comment which contemptuously rejected people's legitimate concerns as if they lost all rights to democratically lobby for sensible regulation simply because something has a legitimate use in society.


Yes, personally its not just about money for me, a shipping port is scenic to me and if I could, I won't mind at all living near one.

Its because the current movement is insane and absurd made from completely imaginary flat earth level reasons, many of these protestors won't be happy with any dc at all even if they made it 10000 miles from their house. I am okay with reasonable dialog and compromise. I feel these people aren't. This is a uniquely strange phenomenon, I am not wholly ruling out the opinion of some who think this might be amplified ad sabotage by foreign powers, but then again one should never underestimate the native stupidity of americans. They elected trump twice after all.


>Data centres causes noise pollution which has health impacts

This is just false and I would have hoped people would have realised that when it was tried against wind turbines.


I live near a sewage plant. One or two days a year when I am cycling past the fence on my commute, I might get a whiff of something. People really overestimate the problem.

Collossus 2's pollution from on site power generation is well documented. There's also noise; depending on the design you could have a 24/7 hum plus infrasound. These things can be unbelievable nuisances if they are built without caring, near residences.

Even if they do use AI and are happy with it, and I'd be willing to bet that isn't always the case, the services they use today clearly don't depend on data centers that haven't even been built yet. Maybe some are happy with the current shitty AI that's a fun toy to play with, but don't want new data centers built and used to train an improved AI that will make them unemployable.

Yes, I want the datacenter just not in my backyard. Of all buildings, a datacenter is the most amenable to being put somewhere else. Maybe we can have it nearby if the corp is bringing something to the table. What's the problem?

And yeah I use cloud services. They aren't charities, I pay for those.


Or put another way, NIMBY is used as a slur but not every NIMBY position is unreasonable.

We need landfills but I don’t want to live next to a landfill. Maybe we could come to a compromise where you build the thing in a way that doesn’t negatively impact me.


There's only one way to handle slurs. I'm a NIMBY with a hard Y.

It's really great for getting past click-bait titles[1] and seeing what the actual topic is, and if it's worth watching.

[1] Unfortunately the even good creators use click-bait to increase their stats.


Use the DeArrow extension by the SponsorBlock creator that replaces titles and thumbnails with crowdsourced anti-clickbait ones.


apple literally uses batteries as thermal mass.


no, fuck that, they charge a cleaning fee.


I wish they put this level of care into their software. It's pretty shocking how nice their hardware has remained, while basic apps like Music/Photos etc. continue to decay.


The incredible engineering in the hardware is prized above software quality.

For most companies I'd say this is a natural tradeoff, but Apple has so much money that they can actually afford to be world class in both. Or at least, you'd expect they could. Maybe being world class in software would require delays to the hardware side of the business?

Regardless, it's definitely a weakness of the culture and I'd venture that weakness is why Apple has essentially failed at AI.


Having recently worked at Apple on the software side, my general experience was that it was fiefdom driven, there is no internal standardization on quality or process. Low level teams compete on ideas and careful politicking usually wins over quality or merit.

For AI, there were top down directives to find new ways to experiment with and incorporate into core products and processes, but as you went down the management chain, management became more conservative. First and second line managers were strongly incentivized to keep their products, roadmaps, and interfaces stable and predictable by similarly conservative stakeholders. And as such, they were generally unwilling to officially dedicate much effort to AI other than the minimum “look at how much we’re using Claude”.

In particular due to the lack of central tooling, any team trying to do much with AI essentially had to reinvent much of the stack themselves. So even small projects were largely untenable due to inevitable required scope creep.


> Having recently worked at Apple on the software side, my general experience was that it was fiefdom driven, there is no internal standardization on quality or process. Low level teams compete on ideas and careful politicking usually wins over quality or merit.

This 100% describes my experience working there in the core teams of iOS 10+ years ago.


> Apple has so much money that they can actually afford to be world class in both

This is what gets me. Think about only bugs, not a single wishlist feature, just bugs. Limit to obvious-to-normies defects: so, UI bugs (ultra-low contrast oddity with certain backgrounds while scrolling lock screen notification center) or popular-feature bugs (AirDrop demands “everyone“ to receive from people in contacts, apparently in at least a couple cases).

At least in the case of UI bugs, no secret sauce seems to be required to resolve them. No particularly special feats of engineering. It seems simply dollars can fix them: QA & engineering. When I discover these obvious defects, update iOS multiple times over the course of months, and continue to experience them, I can only assume Apple prioritized having cash on hand over investing in my (our) experience.


My macbook updated to Golden Gate, and upon reboot, a bunch of stuff was mysteriously not working. Couldn't access my NAS. couldn't reach my home assistant dashboard... I could still SSH into the devices, just couldn't reach them via firefox, or chrome, or a few other apps. So it wasn't my networking being out...

Turns out "forgot to ask for local network access and since the prompt was never allowed, default to denied" is a known bug, and since it never asked, there is no way to toggle either. It was just a bullet point in the reddit thread of networking things that broke in macos 27. It had a solution. Somehow my terminal had known to ask for permission, so it got it, but all my UI apps didn't.

I had to sudo a change to remove my local network from the local network list, and then it worked.

I would think that "suddenly all my local services stopped working" is a noticeable to normies bug. Most normies won't have a ton of local services, but normies that live with techies probably will have a few.


> normies

The tinfoil hat explanation for this is that everyone at Apple is using iCloud for everything, and thus would never encounter a bug with locally-hosted services.


The number of incredibly obvious bugs in Screen Time that make it frequently useless just boggles my mind. It has never worked for us at anything like 100%, it is hit or miss and frequently just does randomly stupid things. Settings reverting on their own, new app categories appearing out of thin air, etc.

Just one more thing that sours me on their stuff when I'm otherwise inclined to like it.


You can’t even block YouTube on your kids devices because Screen Time doesn’t see that YT is installed.

A known bug for years now.

Then good luck getting the time limits to work. It’ll tell the kids “5 minutes left!” then just let them keep going.


And then Google intentionally makes it hard to filter their stuff, too. I can ostensibly enforce YouTube limits on my Firewalla, but if I try to do that, it basically ends up blocking Google altogether. Because Google serves up some YouTube assets from google.com. I doubt very much this is by accident.


That’s odd as I do that quite successfully with my kids.

Parental controls are far superior to Microsoft and epic.


Our family has struggled with Screen Time a lot. I have come to the conclusion that it's actually beneficial for Apple to keep Screen Time as crappy as it is. That allows kids to use their iPhones more. That's good viral marketing in a very lucrative demographic and it drives up AppStore sales, micro transactions and engagement rate.


It's a dangerous game to play, though. The more it frustrates me, the more likely I am to consider alternatives when I want a new phone. They might well score a tactical win but a strategic failure.


Screen Time has had many improvements recently; I'd suggest giving it another shot with iOS 27.

No one, probably not even Facebook, intentionally ships crappy software to farm engagement numbers with kids at this point. That's a good way to get hauled up in front of congress and yelled at in a bipartisan fashion, which no company wants.


I've used 3 Apple products for more than chance interactions. A MacSE for 5 years in school, a 2015 Mac desktop for 6 months in a printshop, and an iPad for the past 2 years at work.

The SE and desktop felt like modern machines, clicks and key presses had predictable results, applications did what you told them too. On par with the Win95 and Win 7/8 I was used to at the time.

Jesus Christ, that iPad on the other hand, feels like janky Windows Vista tech rammed together by an intern. Weird UI artifacts, making the same gesture can have unpredictable results, the only function that everyone in the shop found without failure was 'undo' because it is triggered by violent shaking.

Even simple tasks like sharing a photo saved from a website is bizarrely broken. Depending on whether you saved it as a file or 'to your photos' dictates which applications can then open/share the image. And I know Android is full of it's own foibles but they took a few months to internalize. I'm going on 2 years of 'features' breaking workflow, and pixel perfect taps to activate input elements that are 5% of the screen width.

/rant


Maybe you are right, but Apple is selling hundreds of millions of iPads per year, so just maybe most people are content with the hard- and software and will just adapt to some quirks.

I am personally not always happy with the gestures, but some can be disabled. I don't have much use for my iPad apart from watching some videos, for everything that requires concentration, I will fallback to my laptop. I still think it is a marvelous machine how the hardware and iPadOS play together.


Yes. People have gotten used to rebooting every device in their house, and anything with a screen running like a piece of shit.


Yeah the iPad suffers from trying to live on the OS made for phones. I have an iPad but rarely use it any more, and then only for viewing content. It would be far more useful if I could use it with something closer to MacOS.


> Apple has so much money that they can actually afford to be world class in both > This is what gets me. Think about only bugs, not a single wishlist feature, just bugs. Limit to obvious-to-normies defects: so, UI bugs (ultra-low contrast oddity with certain backgrounds while scrolling lock screen notification center) or popular-feature bugs (AirDrop demands “everyone“ to receive from people in contacts, apparently in at least a couple cases).

I’m hopeful Ternus can turn this around. They can be top notch in both being all vertically integrated and demanding the best in both. Let’s see.


And now they only need to take their backlog tickets and throw tokens at them.


And the worst part is how you eventually just get used to these things


Minimizing shipped defects is qualitatively simpler in physical engineering because the set of possible defects you have to account for is astronomically smaller.

I am a physical engineer by background but have also spent much of my career in high-reliability software systems. The problems of reliability in software systems make physical systems look like child’s play. The levels of effort are on different scales.

An important difference is that software correctness is mostly binary. In physical engineering you can usually spend a bit more money to over-engineer a component if you have any doubts or are lazy, and that works. Effort does not scale nearly as well when it comes to reliable software.


There is also a much closer defined "completion" state in hardware, with responsibility also more distributed across suppliers.

You have a committed spec of one component, connected to the committed spec of another component, with committed maximum deviations.

All that is fixed, so you engineer for possible permutations and mass-production. (it's still a massive feat, I'm not downplaying it. But it has a defined completed controlled state)

In software this is much more fluent. You may have a spec of a library and the APIs you use, and your app might otherwise be static.

But you're handing alot of what you do to an OS, which juggles everything and continues to change over time. That API you're calling may not even have full control over the modules its interacting with.


And there’s an enormous amount of good engineering effort Apple does put into both quality and crazy cool shit that gets done. People just don’t appreciate it because it’s invisible when it works and it’s not as cool as “ran a graphite heat pipe through the fold” which is probably one of the easier things they did for the fold.


Ask any giant company that's been disrupted by a startup: money does not buy taste, or quality, or core competence. It can help, if leaders understand those things.

Apple is ultimately a hardware company that's so good they can monetize software and services. But they are not really a software company, or a services company. I think Ternus' promotion recognizes that: software and services are worth a lot of money, but they're value adds to hardware.


Big E Engineering vs little e engineering.

IMO the barriers to entry are just much different, and it’s reflecting in the workforce. There’s cultural differences too, but I think the education differences is the biggest cause.


Nah. That’s not it. Software is just legitimately harder than most physical engineering (notice I didn’t say all).

How often do skyscrapers fall over, or bridges collapse, or your CPUs fail unexpectedly, or submarines implode. Rarely. In fact, I bet most people reading this thought of the same few examples.

Then look at software. When is the last time you encountered a bug? Have you ever heard of bug free software? Even at the elite, smartest, most educated levels of software, there are still bugs everywhere. Humans are essentially incapable of writing bug free software. And it isn’t because a bunch of uneducated dummies that didn’t get degrees are the ones writing it (as you arrogantly implied). It’s because it’s way fucking harder to do perfectly or near perfectly.

That doesn’t mean there isn’t incredibly hard physical engineering. Obviously there is insanely difficult engineering in nearly any variety. But if you ask a civil engineer to design you a perfect bridge, they probably will. Ask a software engineer with all the experience and education in the world to build you a perfect podcasting app, it simply isn’t happening.


You're literally the first person I've ever seen suggesting this, I actually thought you were being sarcastic!

My POV (and most people's, I think) is that software is buggier because software people are wildly unserious compared to hardware people (and other engineering disciplines like civil engineering). Which is an alright trade-off in the very large majority of cases, as software is rarely very important and is easy to update, whereas hardware and bridges are very high-stake and extremely costly to update.

> if you ask a civil engineer to design you a perfect bridge, they probably will. Ask a software engineer with all the experience and education in the world to build you a perfect podcasting app, it simply isn’t happening

The civil engineer gets to rely on extremely high-quality very-serious civil engineering work, built over millenia. The software engineer relies on shaky (ie buggy) work from past nowhere-as-serious software engineering work, built over ~70y.

The fact that the software engineer can do anything at all on such small and buggy past work shows how easy it is compared to civil engineering.

In my mind, saying "software engineering is shown to be harder by the presence of bugs" is akin to saying "LEGO building is harder, people build stuff that collapses all the time"


I think the essence of what OP is saying is that software has a much broader search space of possible behaviors than physical engineering does.


> The civil engineer gets to rely on extremely high-quality very-serious civil engineering work, built over millenia.

Yes, exactly? That's what makes it easier.

Software engineering has been a thing for, if you squint, 70 years? Comparing that to thousands of years of humans trying to pile up rocks in various ways to make houses is unserious.

Moreover, there are only so many rocks you can pile up on top of each other. Software can be infinitely complex.

How often is the civil engineer asked to add major features to his 80% finished pile of rocks? Or to move the whole pile by 50m? How long is he expected to continue feature development on it after it's been built?

> extremely high-quality very-serious civil engineering work, built over millenia

Translation: When randomly piled up rocks resulted in many dead humans we dutifully wrote down not to do that particular thing again. Repeat for a couple thousands of years and you get your very serious civil engineering work.


How often do skyscrapers fall over, or bridges collapse

When skyscrapers fall or bridges collapse, the negligent engineers who knowingly signed off on them go to jail. When was the last time a software developer or manager went to jail over a known bug?


People going to jail for such failures are actually quite rarer than you imply. And generally software bugs rarely cause similar damage either in lives or money lost.


A better comparison to software bugs is, say, early fatigue cracking in a structure that requires retrofits to fix.

Regardless, the simple fact is that software just matters less in almost every case, so no one gets held accountable. It lets the culture of unaccountability breed within IT / software eng, and here we are.


None of that invalidates my point.

Civil Engineers (the ones building bridges and skyscrapers) have a culture of institutional accountability. They are certified members of a professional organization and when they sign off on a project, they do so by affixing their personal seal to it. This is their binding endorsement of the soundness of the architectural drawings. The presence of that seal can be used as evidence in court against them (criminal or civil).

It’s also possible for engineers to be stripped of their seal by the organization for failures far less severe than a bridge collapsing, such as conflicts of interest.

There isn’t anything like that in software, even though the stakes are much lower. Far more common is a total disclaimer of warranty whatsoever.


> There isn’t anything like that in software, even though the stakes are much lower.

What? That's backwards.

I guess you think that this "culture" is somehow made up and not an inherent part of the job or something?

It's straightforward: building collapses, people die => someone needs to be held accountable. Otherwise we'd be having people die all over. So there HAS to be something like this in place. It's not a choice, it's not a "culture". It's an inherent property of the universe we live in.

In that same way, this responsibility also inherently means an engineer can flag something as unsafe and he's legally protected. It can't be any other way, or nobody would want to do the job.

Also, signing off on a project is quite a bit easier when it comes down to pulling up some tables and calculating some structural loads according to well known formulas. Add some safety factor and voila - it's safe! Impossible for software.


I don't think it's whether one is harder than the other, it's about constraints or in software, lack of. Hardware is constrained by the physical world while software has much fewer constraints leading to a huge number of permutations.


lol no. This is just a sort of learned helplessness that is endemic in the industry. A way to protect your ego: nobody could have avoided shipping that critical bug to production, so it's not your incompetence that led you to do it!

You want a podcast app, I will give you a formally verified podcasting app with zero bugs. I will engineer the shit out of it. Just give me a year and $500,000. Oh, you don't want to? And that right there is why we have bugs. Not because it is hard, but because nobody gives a shit. Even though companies lose way, way more than what it would cost to prevent severe bugs from happening, some things you literally cannot prevent without government regulation, as engineering itself went through after a period of nobody giving a shit and a lot of people dying as a result.


The reason is people don't want to specify the full set of requirements to that podcast app ahead of time. You can spend your year and $500,000 and then the users will play around with it for ten minutes and then tell you it needs to do this and that as well. And one of those features requires you to go back and make fundamental changes to your architecture making you redo a lot of your subsequent work, including a lot of the formal verification.

So it is harder because there is so much freedom in terms of what features a program can have and what the set of requirements can be. And that's just for getting to version 1.0. Software is expected to change much more than hardware is and if the requirements for version 1.7 can only be met by a severe change to the architecture or an ugly hack, the ugly hack will look very tempting.

Having said all that, I'm not sure I disagree all that much with you. A lot of this could be improved with more big E Engineering in the software world.

One way could be with some kind of professional engineer certification. It should be reasonably easy to get the first time by passing a test on some hard and concrete software engineering principles. But if you are ever found to break them, you lose the license and will have to go through a lot to get it back. That of course only works if companies care about people having this certification.

Which leads (as you mention) to government regulation. As someone who works with medical device software I can see that it actually works. The regulations succeed in forcing us to figure out a reasonably complete set of requirements early, but it is an ordeal. For a recent project we had working prototypes for basically all functionality and still we spent four calendar months doing nothing but requirements before we started developing the actual product.

And yet medical devices still have software bugs. There are 24 software related recalls in the FDA medical device recall database just this year so far: https://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/cdrh/cfdocs/cfRes/res...


> submarines implode

Fantastic analogy, and I assume you already know where I'm going with this.

The Titan submersible [0] implosion was by all accounts due to studiously ignoring best practices and test results. They shipped fast.

In contrast, James Cameron's Deepsea Challenger [1] was a slow and methodical build, and has heavily redundant backup systems for everything. For example, the ballast release system operates by demagnetizing coils that hold the ballast; that way if they have a system failure or power loss, it fails open, and they ascent. If that somehow fails, the supports for the ballast will corrode from sea water before the oxygen runs out, so in the worst case, it's sitting in the dark for a few hours before heading back up.

Or, let's look at the U.S. Navy submarine program. I was a propulsion plant operator (reactor operator + throttleman) on a Virginia-class sub. Though I can't go into specifics, "redundant" doesn't begin to describe it. FFS, the San Francisco (688-class sub) ran into an underwater mountain at flank [2] and survived. The SUBSAFE program [3] was a direct result of the loss of the Thresher [4], and to date, no SUBSAFE-certified submarine has been lost.

> Then look at software. When is the last time you encountered a bug? Have you ever heard of bug free software?

You're conflating "free of defects" with "capable of gracefully handling defects." NASA writes as close to bug-free as I think you'll find, but even theirs isn't perfect [5]. The difference is the ability for the software to work through or around those problems. Submarine / submersible design and construction is the same. Are the engineers, welders, machinists, electricians, etc. attempting to do perfect work? Of course. They also are aware that perfection is impossible, and so the design accounts for that.

0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Titan_(submersible)

1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deepsea_Challenger

2: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USS_San_Francisco_(SSN-711)#Gr...

3: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SUBSAFE

4: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USS_Thresher_(SSN-593)#Disaste...

5: https://space.stackexchange.com/a/37694


The Face ID bug that caused a reboot on iPhone 18 pros was a clear example that they put little quality control into software.


World class in comparison to their present competition in hardware and software? Google, Microsoft, Qualcomm, Meta, Intel, AMD, Nvidia...


I feel like this might be inherent to software and hardware development.

With hardware you pretty much get to restart on every product you make. Sure, you have many of the same (types) of components, but with every iteration, you move them around and pretty much have to rethink how every part fits together and interacts. And it has to work when devices get to consumers, because you can't visit everyone to solder on a wire you forgot. (You can always tell people they're holding the phone wrong though.)

With software you have this continuous blob that you keep adding features to. You never really get to rethink how it all goes together from the ground up when the design changes, you just slap a transparent UI on top of you existing code and call it a day. If it turns out there are bugs, not a problem, you just push an update and hope that fixes more than it breaks.


> The incredible engineering in the hardware is prized above software quality.

then let me root and customize the software to my liking


When I was very young, a wise adult once advised me about a class project: "it doesn't have to be good, it just has to be the best".

I'm afraid that's exactly what Apple's software is. The market, much like my school teacher, rewards the best -- no matter how good or bad it is.


That's an amazing phrase.


Yeah my brain went 'oh...' then some pausing


‘just works’, my ass.

I agree that as a power user I might tend to notice bugs more often, but when there is no relevant error message for the normies, to even bother looking up; it takes a really deep breath for me to remind myself why android ain’t a thing I would want to go back to. I guess, I got into the ecosystem a bit later than its prime time where things apparently had better software quality in the walled swamp.


I really don’t understand the criticism of Apple’s software.

I think we need to keep in mind a couple of things:

1. It’s software designed for the masses. It’s not intended to be a power user’s playground.

2. There’s no such thing as perfect software. If you really look hard for alternatives to the Music or Photos app (to use your examples), it’s actually extremely difficult to find anything that is without compromise, bugs, or other downsides.

As someone who has moved off of many of Apple’s apps, like my move from iCloud Photos to Ente, I’m really still accepting a decent amount of compromises. It’s better in some ways, worse in others.

And then there’s some other apps where I just can’t find a good alternative. I’d love something like Apple Notes but is cross-platform with a Linux app specifically. There’s just basically nothing like that out there, certainly not at a good price, and most of them end up over-complicated or with a strange UI.[1]

And when we step back and look at how many apps Apple makes it’s mind-boggling, and really, most of them are at least a mild “good.”

[1] Closest I’ve found are Craft and Zoho Notebook. Zoho gets the price right, it’s dirt cheap, and has a Linux app (though it’s basically a web app). Zoho bothers me for being ugly though. Craft is slick on iOS with a web app only on desktop, but it’s pricey if you leave the free tier. For my criteria it’s important that the apps support sharing, collaboration, and notifications when the other person updates a note. I’m honestly not sure if these two alternatives hit every requirement because I gave on both pretty quick and accepted being stuck in Apple Notes for now. Going to iCloud.com on my Linux system isn’t horrible.


I disagree. They deserve the criticism. Among things software is one of the few things we should get correct.

I don’t think anyone is asking for the world I just want software that dosent crash and makes sense to use.

Just a couple weeks ago Apple Music was leaking GBs of memory.


I just don’t really agree with the idea that Apple’s apps are crashing and memory leaking all over the place, and if they are, not more than the median application.

For one thing, the power user crowd tends to babysit their activity monitor and get massively upset when an electron app dares to consume memory.

In my mind, the only thing that matters for non-server apps is whether or not the user experience is good. Memory consumption is just a number. Apple doesn’t even advertise how much memory many of their products have on them. They expect that their users don’t have to think about that, and as long as that remains true, I really don’t mind if Apple Music is eating up 2GB of RAM behind the scenes.


I don’t really think it’s something to agree or not agree on. This is the experience I’ve had as an Apple user. I use their products extensively and like them quite a bit. The issues I’ve seen I deem unacceptable for a company of this caliber. I’m not talking about .6 seconds of load time or absolute customization. I’m talking about FaceTime actually switching when I click the button. Apple Music not leaking memory. Basic usability not niche items.

Now unfortunately apples stuff is usually a cut above other software I’ve used but in my opinion is nowhere near as good as it should be.


I guess I’m not understanding the standard here. You’re saying they’re usually a cut above other software but simultaneously their software quality is unacceptable.

I don’t even really disagree with the negative experiences you’ve had, I’m just more saying that those experiences are inevitable in software. Being above average is about as good as Apple has ever been.

And I think that standard is also true with hardware. A lot of their hardware is supremely overrated. The MacBook Pro has a sharp edge that cuts into your wrist and has a gigantic notch on the screen.


1. Much of the software I interact with is bad.

2. I’ve had better luck with Apple software but I’d still categorize it as “bad” relative to the good software I’ve interacted with.

This is a form for software engineers. In the 90’s users accepted things like applications crashing due to lack of memory protection in the OS. We know to expect better.

Again I’m not asking for some alternate reality version of software. I’m asking them to fix clear issues that they do not seem to care about.

Not to mention Apple is a large engineering organization with plenty of talent. The software dosent need to be bug free but I shouldn’t run into as many issues as I do.

Some other fun ones: Finder locking up and refusing to minimize

FaceTime putting me in a call with “testing” when I switch devices

Safari’s extension icon flashing on and off on iOS

Stalling on the lock screen despite me looking directly at the phone to unlock it

To me these are issues that should not make it past the engineers and layers of testing.

I don’t think this is unreasonable do you?


Sounds like you need to switch/try the Microsoft ecosystem or maybe the Linux ecosystem good luck.


If I'm understanding you:

- Apple's software is better than most

- Apple's software is still imperfect, often in dumb ways

- Apple should be able to be dramatically more perfect than anyone else in software has managed to be


not quite, you're missing some crucial points. "Apple should be able to be dramatically more perfect than anyone else in software has managed to be" is off by a lot


The problem as I see it is not crashes and leaks. It’s that basic features are barely functional and the UI is not very usable.

Stupid examples from recently:

- The iOS 27 Preview app’s search feature appears to be present while in markup mode but missing while not in markup mode (this is quite reproducible for me).

- Mobile Safari regularly gets into a state where the overlay showing the current website domain gets stuck obscuring an important part of the site.

- On MacOS if you accidentally switch desktops you cannot switch back until the animation from the first switch finishes.

- Spotlight is still hilariously bad.

- The MacOS Music app’s AirPlay controls are barely functional.

- If you have an excessive number of desktop apps open, finding the one you want is gratuitously difficult. Sure, the bottom dock widget is pretty, but that doesn’t make it efficient.

- While typing this message, multiple different glitchy UI elements have appeared and disappeared.

- On iOS, if the keyboard is showing and you don’t want it, tough luck.


> Spotlight is still hilariously bad.

Fwiw, Alfred is still being sold.


imovie is one software that does not work for the common man. you need to be a pro to even make a basic video.


> I just don’t really agree with the idea that Apple’s apps are crashing and memory leaking all over the place, and if they are, not more than the median application.

Apple has some amazing engineering in the basic OS layer and the UI kit, but everything on top of it is just bad. E.g. it now takes about 5 seconds to "Privacy & Security" in the system settings, and I can see a visible delay when switching between sections (e.g. to "Screen Time").

Network settings are just embarrassing at this point - you can't sort the WiFi networks by name when looking at the saved settings!

Time Machine has been a disaster zone for the last 20 years. The keyboard navigation experience in macOS is a disgrace, worse than Win3.11 The virtualization experience of macOS sucks, and there is no support for containers (even Windows has them!).

I can continue for a long time.


>E.g. it now takes about 5 seconds to "Privacy & Security" in the system settings

It's instant for me on a six year old base level Mini.


Just upgrade to macOS 27.


> "and if they are, not more than the median application."

Comparing against the median means you've already thoroughly missed the point.


How much better is Apple hardware compared to the median? I don’t really think the iPhone is better than most Chinese brand phones. It charges slower and doesn’t have the latest battery technology. Most of what it makes it better than the competition is the software.

This angel’s halo around Apple was always a marketing illusion. They make above average hardware and above average software. Nothing more, nothing less.


Is that why the Chinese phones have a 7000ah-9000ah battery? and most of Apple’s phones have a 4900ah-5400ah battery?


> and if they are, not more than the median application

What point is there in paying the premium Apple luxury tax if it's as crap as the median?


Apple used to have maintenance releases. They used to be known for their taste.

They should absolutely cop the criticism. It’s not like they don’t have the resources to make their software better.


iOS 27 was a maintenance release that focused on performance and improved it significantly, particularly on older phones.

They blasted out a marketing video where they bragged about apps launching faster and the WiFi/cellular connection handing off more cleanly.

My feeling is that there’s just always a group of people who complains no matter what.


>My feeling is that there’s just always a group of people who complains no matter what.

There is a religious zeal to some of the criticism.


Those of us who used Macs in the late PPC and early Intel days know what Apple is capable of. This current trend where your only fix is to reboot/reformat/reset preferences, or suffer, is trash. People these days are just used to everything being trash, so Apples current software quality seems OK to them.


Apple used to be a company whose public image was intrinsically inseparable from the intergalactic ego of its chief executive. Now it's just your typical slop company run by slop executives looking to maximize next quarter's share price before they exit through the revolving door, on their way to the next company in line to harvest.


From an Apple employee culture perspective, software team is second or third class to the hardware group.

A friend on the App Store software team wasn't invited to a private iPhone Duo preview, because she wasn't in the hardware division. She felt so disrespected and is considering leaving.

My sister (on the hardware team) shared that its a constantly cycle of non-hardware folks getting shafted and then they complain loud enough until they get 'equal' treatment until the next unfair thing rolls out.


They could go a long way if they 1) slowed down the major OS releases (I mean, like stop them altogether, actually?) and 2) give priority to all bugs and not keep kicking bugs down the road because: we-already-shipped-with-those-bugs-so-they-must-not-be-that-big-of-a-deal.

I'd add 3), more pair-programming between senior engineers and junior engineers—to hopefully make junior engineers better engineers.

I have to say though, when I knew I was heading out of the company (Apple) within a year, I tried to be a "mentor" to the junior engineers at Apple. And they wouldn't have me. I suppose I was too old… To be sure, they knew Swift better than I did, ha ha.

(Oh well, I tried. I did push back very publicly against management during some of the team meetings—I was told by a few of the junior engineers as I was retiring that they appreciated that example.)


As a user, I'm much closer to 'the masses' than to the power users and still I have to say that Apple's software keeps getting worse.


The common complaint is that Apple made better versions of their software and then downgraded them. Especially iTunes.


Dude, my M5 MacBook Pro gets too hot to touch while idling, and it's all background system processes. You don't understand the criticism of their software because instead of listening to the criticism, you've dismissed it as power user fantasy without even understanding the problems.

And friend, I didn't pay for an eight thousand dollar machine for software "designed for the masses" instead of serious professionals and computer enthusiasts. "The masses" are not spending eight thousand dollars on a premium laptop marketed towards professionals. This is an expensive machine and I should be in the driver's seat, not Apple. It should not take arcane, brittle incantations to turn off Siri and dozens of background "AI" services that melt my computer and literally burn my fingertips in exchange for recommending filenames in Pages.

And that's not even mentioning the multitudes of extremely serious system and driver bugs piling up over the last several major versions, nor the grotesque and inconsistent Liquid Glass malarkey.


These kind of comments are just firmly in the “I don’t believe you territory.”

And I’m not trying to defend Apple at all, I don’t even have a MacBook anymore. I’m more opposed to these extreme tech opinions that seem more emotional than objective.


What is emotional about my comment? Everything I said was objective, including that extra premium hardware should at least come with software that doesn't give it a negative value. As in, given the choice, you could not pay me $8000 to use macOS over Linux... once Asahi/Gravity are up to par I won't look back.

What am I not believing? I'm responding to your comment which was dismissive about real, serious concerns that people have surfaced about the sliding quality of Apple software. You seem to be the one not believing things might not be how you perceive them.


My main problem with modern Apple software is I feel the design has been on a near constant gradual decline trend overall (except for the huge dip with Liquid Ass of course) and it has gotten buggier too. I'm just never going to update my iPad because I updated my other Apple devices and I deeply regret it.

I actually have felt this way for a fairly long time but Apple always baits me. Like the twelve or fifteen different times Apple OSes have finally supported some parts of WebM on certain devices sometimes when it works. Oh my god, I gotta update so I can have another couple WebMs load successfully only in Safari and not in any other app that doesn't decode it itself. Or back when I used an iPhone, third party keyboards - I use a lot of jailbreak tweaks but I gotta give that up so I can upgrade for third-party keyboard support that is so ass that nobody would ever use it. Heck, I wish I had updated my iPad even less. One fewer major version and I could've made use of the virtualization support that was dormant - but Apple fixed the glitch that let you use it on Apple Silicon iPads, so now you can't. Thanks! This is important to do because it helps... Uhh, security, probably? Something like that.

Since Snow Leopard or so, most of my Apple software upgrades have been bitter sweet at best, but usually just bitter, like I've been baited into having a worse experience.

Of course, it is probably apparent that I simply don't like Apple very much, especially not anymore. And I hate to have to justify myself by doing this, but we lack the maturity needed for me to avoid it, so... I am going to point out the obvious that this is hardly limited to Apple. GNOME 3 may be the single biggest downgrade any desktop system I've ever used has been. It has improved over time, but GNOME 3 has never been even close to as relatively good for its time as GNOME 2 was. Same for KDE 3 -> KDE 4 although I think as a rare standout KDE Plasma 6 is genuinely getting better continuously over time and remains one of the things I am excited to update. Windows 10 -> Windows 11 was so bad that it seemingly durably made several of my friends switch to Linux full time and just simply give up on things that absolutely can't be made to work on Linux - that is a powerful statement, and months later it seems they were indeed not fucking around. Android has been enshittifying at an alarming pace, too, although I don't feel like the Android experience from a software perspective is degrading or getting worse, but Google really knows how to blow their own leg off and by god they're going to do everything they can to make sure that all of the advantages they have over Apple are rendered meaningless so they can drag themselves kicking and screaming out of accidentally having succeeded at something.

I don't feel like it should be necessary for me to justify this, because Apple's recent growing incompetence in shipping working software and release engineering stands on its own regardless of industry trends. I'd SSH into my Mac Mini, but I can't. I have to go reset it, because it's been on for 60 days and can no longer open new network sockets. (I am not making this up. macOS genuinely has/had that bug and mine genuinely is in that state right now.) It's not that everyone else is doing great. When it comes to Linux systems it's easy to give them a lot of slack because they simply have no goddamned money, but still, things could be better. It's just that Apple is richer than ever and yet worse than ever at shipping software. I struggle to square the circle.


I’d consider this fixed thanks to agentic coding. Not fixed right now, but I trust Apple to scrap all cost saving workarounds (like Electron and its ilk) and go back to native every little thing. “Mac-assed” apps as they say.

The one thing that’s still unanswered is if and how quickly they will fix all the UX and UI mistakes left from the Alan Dye / Jony Ive era. Yes, Jony Ive - and his decision to scrap all Skeuomorphism on iOS which then was adapted for MacOS.


You mean Music/Photos on iOS or macOS? I mostly use Music on macOS. I use Photos a lot on iOS. Both work very well for me, and I've been through the iterations all the way since the early 2000s iTunes. What I don't like about Photos is that it's confusing to use sometimes (scroll up/down to find the buttons, the albums etc).


I have no idea what the Photos complaints are about. It's like iPhoto but with a few AI search features added lately.

Music on Mac has been getting bad IF you're still using a local music library carried over from iTunes, mainly cause they keep trying to shove Apple Music into it. Even in the iTunes days they kept removing nice features after v7. Moving iPhone syncing to Finder made sense at a high level, but somehow it ended up becoming super glitchy and never gets fixed, seems like not a priority.


I still use my local music library carried over from iTunes. And I often drop more MP3's and so on into it. My dad had some issues with the iTunes volume location on an external disk but I've been lucky.

Photos- interesting, I haven't seen any AI stuff on it. I'm still on Tahoe though. Is it coming in Golden gate?


It's older than Tahoe. You can search a word and it'll find pictures containing that object. Not LLM, just vision.

Music could be a lot worse. I learned what it's like playing local music on a Samsung phone recently. Had to use ADB to copy files in because Android File Transfer is deprecated. The phone has no Music equivalent, so I use VLC, which everyone swears is perfect for this but it's actually super clunky. Meanwhile I have a library on my Mac copied over from iTunes v3 with new songs being added and synced over (with issues lately). But yes it has issues with external drives.


Most people dont put the same quality in software because they think they can always fix whatever in another update.


I plugged my old iPad into iTunes, and yeah it was clunky as hell to transfer files into an app, but it did work.

Maybe some of their software clunk is a commitment to backwards compatibleness. We can't have all the nice things, we must prioritise.


Photos is fine, and it is still improving. The same cannot be said about Music, which is just garbage.


Notice how this comment has no counter examples of a quality OS + software stack? It’s because it doesn’t exist. Any example they could give there would be 20 nay sayers who disagree in the replies. Your favorite software is dog shit to someone else.


Out of curiosity, what’s wrong with photos? Do you mean the one on the Mac or the iOS version?


I find manually tagging people in photos and especially videos to be an incredibly frustrating experience on macOS (and impossible on iOS).

For as much as Apple is pushing memories in Photos it is surprising to me that the ability to specify who is in a photo/video is so overlooked.


Not who you are responding to, but common workflows like “show me the picture I just took” or “copy the damned image file elsewhere” are completely broken.

God help you if you own a camera and try to store its photos in apple photos.


what’s the problem? i keep thousands of photos from my camera on icloud and it works fine


Very confused, both these functions work fine for me. The share sheet is right there.


Just now, I kid you not:

I was in bed, a little away from my MacBook on the desk that was playing some music.

I opened Apple's official Remote app on my iPhone, that lets you control your Mac's Music app.

Both devices were on the same WiFi network and same Apple ID, but Remote was unable to find the Mac. When it did, it was unable to connect.

I opened the ChatGPT app on my iPhone. Went into Codex mode. Asked the ChatGPT running on my Mac to control the Music app to play a different playlist.

Worked within seconds.

Gosh these decrepit giants deserve the unprecedented disruption that's coming for their ass.


The Remote app has always been flaky because it relies on Bonjour, which is mDNS, which is less reliable than flipping a coin to heads.


Unprecedented disruption of something you could have asked Siri to do a decade ago?


You must have missed the news about how Siri is so shit now that it can't even set a timer on the Apple Watch because it can't find a "Clock app"

Also:

- When there's multiple Apple devices in the same room, your Siri command doesn't always get intercepted by your intended target. Have you even used Siri in these situations?

- Siri doesn't let you see all your playlists etc like the Remote app does.

- The official app meant for this exact purpose failed to work.

- Codex can remote control every fucking app, not just Music, even those without Siri "hooks"

Apple is no longer the "It just works" and hasn't been for years. Read the room and smell the discontent


> Have you even used Siri in these situations?

Yeah, I’ve got all the Apple stuff. Works fine in this situation 99% of the time. But if you have an idea about how they could make something that ambiguous 100% reliable you should write it up.


Maybe someone could use AI to better jailbreak iPhones/iPads etc and install custom operating systems


even books has somehow gotten worse. How do you regress fucking books, bro?? It's a damn shame.


It was already pretty bad last time I tried it. Part of the reason I just get a pdf instead of this epub nonsense.


If the last decade of Siri has taught us anything, they can literally ship the worst version of a thing and people will still buy an iphone. They’re just that good.


>I wish they could do something about fare evasion.

Reminder that vast majority of the fare is covered by taxes (Roughly 87%). I wish they just funded the remaining 13% instead.

It might not even cost that much more considering all of the expenses involved with hiring more staff (Salary/healthcare/pensions etc.) to collect the last 13 cents on the dollar.


This doesn't feel like the right way of thinking about it---if you went from 20% of people paying fares to 80%, that's 4x the revenue with the same fixed costs, and farebox recovery goes from 13% to 52%. Now, I don't think compliance is actually that low, but the point is that you shouldn't think of fares as collecting a fixed share of the operating costs.


The costs may be fixed but so is ~87% of the revenue via tax money.

Muni can be 100% free without increasing taxes too. The people using public land to store their private vehicles are not paying their fair share. Proper parking pricing and enforcement could easily pay for Muni’s deficit.


Yes, money is fungible. But why should it be that people who park cars on the street need to pay their fair share but people who ride Muni don't need to pay anything?


To incentivize the people taking their cars to use the bus instead!


Sure, but then it's not about a "fair share" any more; it's about incentivizing specific behaviors.


It's both. Why should the public 100% subsidize private vehicle storage in vast swaths of the city (And greatly undercharge when it's paid), but not public transit?

SF has some of the most valuable private[1] and public land in the US. Why is it so pressing to charge the last 13¢ on the dollar for a Muni rider, but not for drivers to pay for the public space they're storing their property on?

[1] Private land owners know this, which is why they charge a lot to use their parking garages/parking lots in SF.


The proposal was to charge for public street parking so we can make Muni free. That's not (at least not obviously) a "fair" allocation, it's just a transfer from one group to another. I agree that it's bad for street parking to be free, I just don't think it's necessarily the best use of funds from that to make transit free. If you're spending on transit, why not spend the money on expanding service instead?


> The proposal was to charge for public street parking so we can make Muni free.

My proposal is to make Muni free full stop. Via taxes is fine with me, I provided another way that doesn't necessitate that. We are already paying for the vast majority of each Muni trip from taxes.

>That's not (at least not obviously) a "fair" allocation, it's just a transfer from one group to another.

You're saying we're just transferring from one group to another, well SF was built for people before cars became commonplace, with excellent public transit before it was torn out for cars. I'm arguing that some of that needs to be transferred back to the people for better use (Bigger sidewalks, bike lanes, restaurant parklets etc.)

>If you're spending on transit, why not spend the money on expanding service instead?

Expanding service is great, but you'd be hard pressed to pay for it via parking meters/tickets and it costs even more to run a system on top of that, particularly the metro system.


I haven't run into this on macOS yet, but on iOS the space is not reclaimed in time to avoid running out of space even with Apple Intelligence turned off:

- Not enough space to update iOS without a computer tether, even though there would have been if that ~13GB on my phone was actually freed up. Instead I had to delete several GB on my phone.

- Recordings stopping due to lack of space, and again the 13GB LLM model on my phone was not removed before running into this.

I'm actually not where if/when I'll ever get my space back, and this is on iOS 26. It takes up even more space on iOS 27, and I don't have enough free space to waste on my 256GB phone.


Got a new LG washer, but some clothing item with a metal button got stuck between the seal and tore a bit of it off, causing leaks. A new seal from LG isn't too expensive, about ~$70, however, it requires the entire front and top of the machine to be removed, so it's not a cheap operation (When hiring someone to fix it).

I don't think I'd ever pick a top loader still, but front loading machines do seem to fail in more annoying ways.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: