HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | OakNinja's commentslogin

English has been the high level language for programming since Common Business-Oriented Language - COBOL.

Programming has always been defining the problem you have. Nothing has changed from that perspective. Sometimes that problem is recreating something that already exists :)


This problem is not new. The new thing is that anyone can understand the core problem they’re trying to solve without involving a dev team by quick ideation and rapid prototyping.

Just as always, it’s then up to the company to prioritize what to focus on - Just like how it’s always been.

* Don't hold onto an idea or prompt output just because you spent time on it.

* Writing code is easy. Maintaining it is hard.

* If it doesn’t save time or generate revenue, it’s just an expense.

* Output does not equal value.


It's also worth pointing out how many businesses have always had a dev team that can rapidly prototype regardless of AI usage.

They tend to be the largest businesses (outside of SV) that employ the majority of people in the USA. They are also the least likely to really use AI for much other than copilot in MS Teams.


I have spent the better part of the last decade of my career being approached by executives asking me how to optimize or automate away services that I felt had reached a local optimum. Each time this was the case I would gently express that our options were to commodify, by offering a kind of template, the service or optimize the process and way we gathered information from clients. Without fail, they hated the latter option. It was hard to do, and it implied that any number of people needed to do a lot better at their job in seemingly abstract ways. No, they’d always go for the template, then be dissatisfied by the fact that it’s, well, a template! Finally, they’d go back to begging me for alternatives.

This feels like them doubling down yet again. It’s like looking at your personal finances and trying to optimize it by canceling Netflix instead of acknowledging that you eat out 7 days a week.


Spot on. Generative AI is an amplifier of your current trajectory, and a good side effect of that is that it exposes inefficient internal processes. As a company, it will be increasingly hard to go for the naïve and easy solution (the template) when the blockers are clearly visible.

One of my mantras is:

Automate governance first, creation second. Streamline code reviews and compliance before content generation, or you'll drown in manual oversight.

And this is not what people want to hear, because generating content is easy and automating governance (code reviews, build the domain knowledge into skills and automated processes) is a _real_ and hard engineering problem.


Thank you for your reply.

Yes, we could all work a bit more effectively cross-team. It's missing the point to focus on the "what" and the "doing" instead of the "why" and the "planning".

If there are some people who need AI training wheels to help plan, I think that strongly signals some kind of dysfunction. They are rehearsing how to talk to another team? Sounds unprofessional and inexperienced.

LLMs actually raise the bar and resulting demand for experienced workers. Most programmers with more than about 5 years are not the bottleneck. It's all the auxiliary people that are supposed to be coordinating, but don't know their ass from their elbow.


From what I’ve heard, this is actually a problem with the exposed OS level api’s provided by Apple. Other manufacturers have solved this with on device workarounds. Doesn’t make it better though. I resorted to only the system only notifications (Phone, Texts).


As an end user, all I really care about is that the watch doesn't buzz every single time my long-winded colleague hits on slack, but that I do see slack notifications when I'm able to look at my phone. And I always want to see my wife's texts on my wrist...

Whether that filtering is in the app, in the OS, or on the watch is not important to me.


I think the way to do this is in iOS itself. I would be shocked if Coros has better notifications tech than Garmin; it’s a way smaller company. I don’t even remember touching notifications when I set up my Coros watch. I think it is just governed by my iOS settings.

iOS has a lot of power to finely control notifications. For example for Slack I just have app badges, while iMessage buzzes. In Mail, only people I’ve added to a small “VIP” list cause a buzz. Otherwise I just look at the Mail app badge to see how many emails have come in.

It takes time to tune it, but it is a very good investment IMO.


A bad analogy is like a leaking screwdriver…


Kent Beck is smart because he proposes fixes that work in real life, as in environments with dumb code and undisciplined people.

I can very much recommend his latest book ”Tidy first?”. It’s extremely short and concise, and is perfect for a very light book club within any tech team.


I agree, both with your analysis of him and your review of "Tidy first?". We read and discussed it at work, and I enjoyed it a lot.


I enjoyed the last (and theoretical) part of "Tidy first?" as I was already doing the recommended practices in the first two. But yes, very pragmatic advice and easy to apply to get your own corner of peace in a somewhat chaotic codebase.

One term I can use is "defensive programming" (not sure if the term has been used before). People are going to do awful stuff with their code, it's up to you to draw boundary of correctness to stop it from spilling on the part that you're responsible for. It should be automated (with tests and static analysis) as well as documented. I think of those boundary as hazmat suits and I take extra care of maintaining their integrity.


I assure you, there is no such thing as a book club at my job, especially not one focused on technical writing :)


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: